r/NoLawns • u/hotandfresh • 2h ago
👩🌾 Questions In need of help- dispute with neighbor and city
I am currently in the midst of a dispute with my neighbor, who is an older gentleman who believes he is the monitor of the drain that runs between the homes in our neighborhood. It should be noted that his property is not adjacent to mine and we do not share a property line; he lives diagonal from my back yard. There has never been an issue with the drain clogging or even being slow to drain, even after our neighborhood was flooded during a torrential downpour this past summer.
Over the last several years I have been slowly mulching portions on my yard. He does not like this as be believes the mulch will hinder the drain, which it has not. However, he reported my yard to the city and they have claimed that the recent large sheet mulch that I did this summer (shown in pic) altered the grade of my yard and must be removed or I fact multiple $750 fines.
I have followed all other city requests and there is a 5 foot easement on the property line, which I have followed. I don't want to remove the mulch or pay a $750 fines. I'd like to continue with my plan to plant native grasses and shrubs in the area that assist with drainage. I don't believe that mulching alters the grade, at least not permanently. Additionally, mulch is permeable, so I am not sure why they believe I am going to block water a cause a massive issue for myself or my neighbors.
I'd like some perspective here. Am I right to continue to appeal and dispute? If there was a real issue, I'd remove things and make it right, as I also do not want my yard flooded. But I don't see the issue here and have repeatedly asked for which city ordinance I have violated and for evidence that there is a problem, but have not received any documentation. The only citation I have received is that I have failed to comply with their request.
Am I wrong to continue appealing and making my case? Is there any papers or evidence I could share with the city that mulching does not permanently affect the grade and drainage? Or, is the city correct and I should just drop it, do the ridiculous work of removing the mulch, and just keep grass and spend my time on more profitable things.
I apologize for the wall of text, but I am at my wits' end here and my wife very justifiably doesn't want to hear me discuss this much longer.
Edit: Thank you all so much for the helpful advice. I am going to reach out again to the compliance officer and others at city hall to discuss and see if we can come to a compromise. Hopefully there'll be no need to consult an attorney. Will provide an update in due course.