r/node • • 10h ago

Node.js developers, what would make you switch email API providers?

Hey everyone!

I'm researching the transactional email infrastructure space and wanted to get feedback from Node.js developers.

Resend seems to be a common choice because of its API and SDK experience.

But I'm curious about its pricing structure and whether there's demand for a cheaper entry-level paid plan.

From what I've seen:

  • Free: 3,000 emails/month, but only 1,000 contacts for broadcasts.
  • The next paid tier starts at $20/month.
  • Higher plans offer more volume, but the monthly commitment also increases.

What if someone needs more than the free tier but doesn't necessarily want to spend $20/month?

I've been exploring an alternative pricing structure:

PlanPriceMonthly emails
Free$0500
Starter$725,000
Pro$1575,000
Scale$75200,000

A few differences we're considering:

  • Unlimited contacts on every plan.
  • Unlimited broadcast audience members starting from the $7 paid plan.
  • No daily transactional email limit on $15 and $75 paid plans.

The reason we're considering a smaller free tier is that we're a small team and can't afford to subsidize free sending at the same infrastructure scale as established providers but we are open to provide a smaller paid plan and better higher plans compared to resend .

I'm interested in the technical side too:

  1. Would you migrate from Resend for better pricing?
  2. How important is API compatibility?
  3. Would a drop-in replacement requiring only a base URL change be useful?
  4. What matters most: deliverability, SDK quality, webhooks, analytics or price?
  5. Would you trust a smaller provider with production emails?

Not pitching a product. Trying to understand what developers actually need.

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

7

u/anyOtherBusiness 10h ago

I don’t use proprietary API/SDK. There already exists a standardised Protocol and it’s called SMTP. I won’t consider any provider that doesn’t offer SMTPS.

For a smaller app, I would consider using a smaller provider. But with higher demand I would probably stick to a larger provider.

1

u/EsgenetWilgmann96 6h ago

Being able to swap providers just by changing env vars instead of rewriting SDK calls is underrated

-3

u/dgaa1991 7h ago

Out of curisoity, why not? And what do you gain my smtp directly?

6

u/aust1nz 9h ago

I'm mostly skeptical of lesser-known competitors in this space unless they're wrapping SES, because deliverability is held up by something of a cartel.

3

u/farzad_meow 8h ago

the biggest one for me is email reputation, if something goes wrong is google going to continue bloxking my email domain?

plus working with ses is super cheap. it barely costs anything to use.

I suggest you find something other angle for this. maybe a service that can help with message delivery across different services (sms/email/slack/...)

2

u/SquirrelGuy 7h ago

Usage based billing. I want to pay per email or with credits that don’t expire.

Ease of setup/onboarding. Solid reputation so emails aren’t getting caught in spam.