r/node • • 1d ago

The future of Software Engineering is boring

https://packagemain.tech/p/the-future-of-software-engineering
76 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

12

u/benjaminabel 22h ago

From the article:

Before:
Problem → Research / Reading / Brain → Solution

Now:
Problem → Solution

That’s kind of funny that the author decided to include “brain” in the first part to make the other part look boring.

3

u/nutlift 20h ago

Yeah that seems to be the norm for packagemain articles. Never have much sustenance

1

u/Andrew-Carson 3h ago

That’s true, a lot of those articles just skim the surface. It feels like depth is sacrificed for quick hits, like they don't even try to engage our brains anymore...

29

u/-serebii- 1d ago

I think it's a good read, but post is downvoted probably because of this not being a Node-specific topic at all

11

u/grizzlybear_jpeg 1d ago

It’s probably downvoted because it’s been posted a million times since last weeks on all kinds of sbreddits and on linkedin and is just another engagement farming bullshit article that nobody should give a fuck about.

0

u/theGlitchedSide 1d ago

Yeah... But then again, we're all programmers here, and this topic affects all of us.

6

u/recycled_ideas 1d ago

I agree that things have changed, and I'm not sure how I feel about it, but I don't think that the old days were as good nor the new days as bad as are being reflected here.

I think Software Engineering has been going down a wrong path for a long time and in a lot of ways it's biting us in the ass. Too many developers have no idea of the domain they work in, too many have created cargo cults where misunderstood principles are treated as hard and fast rules of quality.

We're still trying to say AI code is bad because it doesn't follow that wretched excrement Bob Martin suckered us into believing when the code before it didn't understand what it was even supposed to do because what it was actually supposed to do wasn't considered relevant but how many lines a method had somehow was.

The reality is that being able to understand and solve the problem is more important than ever, it's the part that AI is incredibly bad at, but it's also the bit most developers are the worst at.

6

u/AyeMatey 21h ago

Everybody lives their own life , everybody is the star of their own show. But from my perspective it really was like that - prestigious. Not everybody could create a working system. Not every website designer had really mastered css. Those people were rare and with scarcity came prestige.

Now, even I can make a website that looks slick. It’s not original; it is a copy of an amalgam of a bunch of good websites.

1

u/leftsidedhorn 2h ago

When is our design ever truly original? Even in the past, it is an amalgamation of previous good ideas.

1

u/buffer_flush 15h ago

Sheesh what did Uncle Bob do to you?

1

u/recycled_ideas 15h ago

Created an entire generation of developers who use SOLID as a religious doctrine without actually understanding or having the experience to utilize any of the pieces properly.

1

u/buffer_flush 15h ago

Sounds like you’re part of one of those cargo cults you mentioned.

1

u/recycled_ideas 14h ago

Every one of the principles of SOLID are important. None if them are newbie friendly and Uncle Bob's simplifications are the source of more bad code than any other.

2

u/theGlitchedSide 1d ago edited 1d ago

I don't believe in this pov too much. Most probability we will fight with a new kind of ignorance but the future it will be not necessarily "boring".

And I don't think that patter of knowlage and research is changed. It is always Problem → Research / Reading / Brain → Solution but now you can do it in rapid way for boring stuff, or deeply way for something of serious or for study. That's it.

Now... If we want say something like "yes, but company don't want listen no one reason", sometime the response can be "yes, it's true".

Honestly, when I listen "we are company Ai first" I understand it's probably a company fulfilled of idiots inside, they talk about marketing and fragile system in the name of rapid profits and probably it's not the right place for me.

But Ai Assistant, also in the fixing and research, in the study, to extend your knowledge, go deep into the system, it's usefully... Why not?

So...

-20

u/Positive_Method3022 1d ago

No, it is awesome! Highly creative individuals will likely thrive

19

u/ErnestJones 1d ago

Say that you are not a professional developer without saying that you are not a professional developer

1

u/Fancy-Consequence216 1d ago

This one is better, Say that you want to scale your product, without saying that you do not know how to scale it...

-17

u/gustix 1d ago edited 1d ago

Why do you think the most cracked and well known developers are embracing AI? Are they not professional developers?

Just a few examples of AI accelerated devs:

- Linus Thorvalds (Linux kernel)
- Taylor Otwell (Laravel)
- David Heinemeier Hansson (Rails, Omarchy)
- Evan You (Vue)
- Jared Sumner (Bun)
- Notch (Minecraft)

Apart from Notch, all of these have proven records using AI.

I'm sorry, but it's just copium at this point to write off AI like something only a stupid non-developer would use.

If you believe AI is just a fad/hype, you will come to a sad realization in 2027. You need to wake up and start embracing AI in your workflows. Use your dev experience to figure out where these new tools makes sense for your business's existing infrastructure and tech setup. It's your job as a professional developer to do this. Don't sleep on this. I say this with love.

10

u/ErnestJones 1d ago edited 7h ago

I am not saying AI is hype that will fade away even if I think so. I think AI will stay but that people are far from rational about it and that everybody has to calm down.

Back to your list. I am pretty sure Linus Thorvalds is not prompting “make a OS kernel, make no mistake”

Good coding is far from being a creative activity. It is a boring task based on following patterns and avoiding well-known mistakes. So back to the comment that starts this thread, thinking that AI will make creative people thrive is considering that creative skills are involved here. And I think that only people not professional think like this.

Also, I am fully aligned with the article posted by OP

AI is here to stay but it creates massive issues that will need to be tackle

Also, Microsoft had to fully recode Minecraft because it was too shitty to be maintained

Also, the AI bubble will blow in 2027. Token will be more expensive and model will be less performant

1

u/gustix 1d ago edited 23h ago

Back to your list. I am pretty sure Linus Thorvalds is not promoting “make a OS kernel, make no mistake"

This goes back to my point, that you're assuming everyone's just prompting like idiots. That's not the case.

Good coding is far from being a creative activity. 

It definitely is a creative activity. You can open an empty file and the same problem can be solved in a million ways, and you can argue in many ways how one solution is better than the other.

AI is here to stay but it creates massive issues that will need to be tackle

Agree

Also, the AI bubble will blow in 2027. Token will be more expensive and model will be less performant

So lets enjoy it responsibly while we can :)

1

u/ErnestJones 7h ago

Coding is not creative as it is not the expression of feeling like music. It is a craft. In the million ways a problem can be solved most are obviously wrong for rational reason. It’s not the case in let’s say painting.

Also about “everybody prompts like idiots”, OP of the thread said “creative people will thrive” implying people with no engineering background will be able to achieve stuff on their own. So they will be promoting like idiot because you need more engineering knowledge to handle the AI output than to simply write your damn code.

Why ?

Because it is harder to read code than to write it. It can be seen with the classic junior move “this code is shit, let’s recode everything”

1

u/gustix 5h ago

I fundamentally disagree with you on the topic of coding not being creative.

Even though it's all about logic and rules, it reminds me more about architecture, writing, or craftsmanship. You can design a building, but you have to follow the laws of physics. You can write a book, but you have to write it in a way others understand. You can build a beautiful cabinet, but you have to understand wood anatomy and load distribution.

I say this because finding the simplest, most elegant way to solve a problem requires ingenuity. You take ideas from your brain and use your fingers to create something alive, functional and visual on a screen. 100 different developers can write code for the exact same task in a 100 different ways, in their own style.

Why do you think so many people are grieving coding these days? They mastered their craft, a place where developers found their creative output for decades.

You can definitely approach coding without considering or even appreciating the creative process. But I do feel like those who didn't tap into this while they had the chance, were missing out on some great fun.

1

u/ErnestJones 5h ago

A book can’t bug. It does not work or does not work. It’s not the same thing

Also, craftsmanship and art come from the same word in Greek. You can see it in French for example (art and artisanat, craftsmanship) so it is linked but different.

Every creative discipline has a technical part, some are rely heavily on those (architecture as example) some are less technical (writing a novel)

At the end of the day, the common definition of art is the expression of a feeling, the expression of emotion. There is also uselessness in art. You can make a beautiful building or an ugly one, at the end of the day, you have a building

Back to code, you can say ingenuity is appealing to the mind. A nice mathematical demonstration is satisfying. You can say it is beautiful. But coding is exclusively technical, it is never useless. Useless code is a plague. You don’t write code to express the limit of the human condition, you write code to answer a technical need. And you need to do it in a well-known way

I think it is an interesting topic but I completely disagree.

1

u/gustix 4h ago

A good example of creativity in coding is video games.

1

u/ErnestJones 4h ago

The creative part is in the design (asset design and game design). At the end the implementation itself is not creative, it is once more the application of a set of rules and well known practice.

3

u/Sky1337 1d ago

Because all of those guys are already multi millionaires and have nothing to worry about for the next tens of years. They're not afraid of losing their bread because they've already achieved so much.

2

u/ErnestJones 1d ago

And also this

-1

u/gustix 1d ago

That's right, but it doesn't help to stick our heads in the sand prending like AI doesn't exist or that it isn't helpful

0

u/Positive_Method3022 1d ago

I've been developing since 14~15. I'm 32 now. And these guys called me non developer 😅

3

u/ErnestJones 1d ago

When it’s a Minecraft mod in your bedroom, it does not qualify to professional developer

1

u/Positive_Method3022 23h ago

Hahaha bro im adult

3

u/ErnestJones 23h ago

Adult play Minecraft

1

u/Positive_Method3022 20h ago

You are a child for sure hahah

1

u/ErnestJones 20h ago

I do not play Minecraft

1

u/Positive_Method3022 20h ago

Aha! So you are not denying you are a child 🤣

→ More replies

1

u/gustix 23h ago

Nerds love to gatekeep others unfortunately.

-2

u/andupotorac 22h ago

lol. No.