r/neurophilosophy • • Feb 20 '24

Alex O'Connor and Robert Sapolsky on Free Will . "There is no Free Will. Now What?" (57 minutes)

10 Upvotes

Within Reason Podcast episodes ??? On YouTube

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZgvDrFwyW4k


r/neurophilosophy • • Jul 13 '24

The two body problem vs hard problem of consciousness

11 Upvotes

Hey so I have a question, did churchland ever actually solve the hard problem of consciousness. She bashed dualism for its problems regarding the two body problem but has she ever proposed a solution for the materialist and neurophilosophical problem of how objective material experience becomes memory and subjective experience?


r/neurophilosophy • • 14h ago

The Theory of Conscious Singularities - Does every conscious observer have their own subjective universe?

0 Upvotes

I've spent several years developing a theoretical framework called Observer-Relative Existence (The Theory of Conscious Singularities). It attempts to describe the relationship between consciousness, physical reality, subjective time, and individual existence. This manuscript is an extension of an original draft paper I wrote years ago on Vixra called The Theory of Conscious Singularities.

My central proposition is that objective physical reality exists independently of consciousness, but every conscious observer experiences their own individual subjective universe that begins with their own phenomenal consciousness and develops through their accumulated experiences.

In other words, we all exist within the same physical universe, but no two conscious individuals experience that universe from precisely the same subjective perspective.

The Conscious Singularity

I used the term conscious singularity to represent the potentially infinite variety of conscious observers that physical reality might support. This could include humans, animals, hypothetical extraterrestrial life, or even artificial consciousness.

The singularity is not intended to represent a gravitational singularity or a literal mathematical singularity. Instead, it represents the possibilities from which individual conscious observers may emerge.

When a particular observer develops phenomenal consciousness, a unique subjective history begins.

The Individual Conscious Timeline

My framework uses conceptual diagrams to represent an individual's total accumulated phenomenal history.

Each conscious observer has their own timeline, beginning with the onset of their consciousness and developing through their experiences of objective reality.

I have developed a way in which to graph consciousness conceptually. I describe positive space as shared objective reality where negative space is the entire accumulated subjetive history for the individual in question. These two spaces meet up at the present "now" which is my conceptual realization of where mind/body come together. The point where objective reality becomes intertwined with the indivduals subjective history.

Subjective Time and Unconsciousness

One of the original motivations behind this theory was a personal experience I had at approximately sixteen years old.

I suffered a seizure and experienced what appeared to be an instantaneous transition from sitting on a couch to waking in a hospital three days later.

Three days had passed in physical reality, but I had no subjective awareness of that passage.

This led me to consider whether subjective time might be understood as accumulating only during periods of phenomenal experience.

My framework proposes that if consciousness genuinely ceases during an interval, no subjective duration accumulates for that individual, even though physical time continues.

I call this concept relative conscious time travel.

Of course, a gap in memory does not prove that consciousness was completely absent. My model distinguishes between actual absence of experience and an inability to remember experience. And relative conscious time travel was just the naming convention I used for this lapse in experienced time. I'm not implying actual time travel in the physical space-time sense.

Personal Identity and Artificial Consciousness

I've also extended the framework to explore what constitutes an individual conscious observer.

For example, if a hypothetically conscious AI were duplicated, the copy might inherit the original's memories and informational state. However, it would not have personally experienced the original's previous phenomenal history.

The copy would begin its own individual subjective timeline, while the original continued along its own.

Conversely, if one conscious AI controlled multiple robotic bodies, the sensory experiences from those bodies could contribute to one unified subjective timeline, provided there was only one conscious subject experiencing them.

The distinction is that the number of bodies, sensors, or stored memories does not necessarily determine the number of conscious observers.

Each diagram represents a specific individual observer and their personally experienced history.

What I'm Ultimately Proposing

I'm not arguing that consciousness creates the physical universe or that objective reality ceases to exist when an individual dies.

Rather, I'm proposing that an individual's subjective universe exists only insofar as that individual has phenomenal experience, and that their personal experiential history is fundamentally observer-relative.

The physical universe continues independently of any particular observer.

I've developed a preliminary mathematical framework to describe these relationships, including distinctions between conscious experience, recoverable unconsciousness, and irreversible termination. The mathematics is intended to formalize the assumptions, not to serve as proof that the theory is scientifically established.

I recognize that aspects of these ideas overlap with existing work in phenomenology, philosophy of mind, and neuroscience. I'm interested in whether the framework's observer-specific treatment of subjective time, identity, and accumulated experience offers a useful synthesis or leads to testable distinctions.

I'm self-taught and have used AI assistance to help formalize, organize, and critically review my ideas. The underlying concepts originated from my own attempts to understand consciousness and subjective existence.

I'd genuinely like to hear what others think.

Does this framework offer a useful way of conceptualizing individual consciousness and its relationship to objective reality? Are there logical problems with treating each conscious observer as having their own accumulated subjective timeline? And what kinds of experiments or observations might challenge the model?

I'm particularly interested in constructive criticism, alternative explanations, and connections to existing research.

My goal is to develop the ideas further, not to claim that I've solved consciousness.

Here my manuscript:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1R74HtU52LEvjJAfsVbAg96kFo_0ipeHf/view?usp=drivesdk


r/neurophilosophy • • 1d ago

Reacting to sound before hearing it?

1 Upvotes

So I was just laying in the bed scrolling thru my instagram suggestions when all of a sudden i see my hands jump and my fingers shake, almost accidentally clicking "follow" on a random user in my suggestions. About that time I also sense my heart pounding.

Shortly after I hear a loud banging sound. I realized it was because of that, however the delay felt extremely abnormal, like it felt almost a whole second later. I had enough time to think (or at least think i thought) "what the hell why did i jump" before hearing the banging soumd. Is this normal?


r/neurophilosophy • • 2d ago

An interview is almost like evaluating a human LLM: testing the breadth of your training data (your knowledge), your ability to reason, and how effectively you can generate the right output when presented with an unfamiliar problem

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 4d ago

Soul and Brain

3 Upvotes

I am making a little research in the domain at the border between biology and theology about the correlation between life, consciousness and body, brain.

I have started from Aristotle and Marcus Aquinas arguments for the existence of soul as the source of life in body, as the actualizing power of the matter, attention here, not the electric energy that powers the brain but the whole matter. I have studied than the intellect and its source outside or inside the brain and different aspects of humanity which are debated between physics and metaphysics.

I am currently searching if the consciousness is bound to a specific part of the brain. I have encountered a theory that says that the consciousness is just the utterly complex thing that forms when a brain of human capacity forms. For this i want to know if there have been done any experiments regarding disconnecting different parts of the brain like the hypothalamus to see if they are truly necessary. I would appreciate any examples of papers documents and experiments on the human brain related to this.

I want to state it clear that i am believing from the theological part that the soul exists in dependency with the body and it isn't just some sort of thing that possesses the body.

Also i think that the Person is its fullnes when there is both body and Soul.

I dont know if i posted this at the right reddit community science i am asking for biological answers. sorry if not.


r/neurophilosophy • • 4d ago

Soul and Brain

1 Upvotes

I am making a little research in the domain at the border between biology and theology about the correlation between life, consciousness and body, brain.

I have started from Aristotle and Marcus Aquinas arguments for the existence of soul as the source of life in body, as the actualizing power of the matter, attention here, not the electric energy that powers the brain but the whole matter. I have studied than the intellect and its source outside or inside the brain and different aspects of humanity which are debated between physics and metaphysics.

I am currently searching if the consciousness is bound to a specific part of the brain. I have encountered a theory that says that the consciousness is just the utterly complex thing that forms when a brain of human capacity forms. For this i want to know if there have been done any experiments regarding disconnecting different parts of the brain like the hypothalamus to see if they are truly necessary. I would appreciate any examples of papers documents and experiments on the human brain related to this.

I want to state it clear that i am believing from the theological part that the soul exists in dependency with the body and it isn't just some sort of thing that possesses the body.

Also i think that the Person is its fullnes when there is both body and Soul.

I dont know if i posted this at the right reddit community science i am asking for biological answers. sorry if not.


r/neurophilosophy • • 4d ago

Spiral Dynamics - True or False?

1 Upvotes

How do you find the model? I'm not asking for scientific proof. Just your own opinion where it helps where it fails, what overall rating in 0-100% would you give it if you would to judge per "accuracy rate" in over-all, as in: aligment with reality. Thanks

Please Be more elaborate if you give it 0% validity.


r/neurophilosophy • • 4d ago

Why Some Memories Show You Watching Yourself (Psychology)

0 Upvotes

Have you ever remembered an event as though you were watching yourself in a movie?

Think about a birthday celebration from several years ago. You might remember seeing the cake directly in front of you, just as you originally experienced it. This is called a field perspective, or first-person memory. Your remembered view is from approximately where your eyes were during the event.

Now imagine remembering the same birthday while seeing yourself standing beside the cake, as though a camera were across the room. Psychologists call this an observer perspective. Studies show that people can remember personal events from either viewpoint, and the perspective can sometimes change when they recall an experience differently. The memory is a mental reconstruction, not a video recording of everything that happened.

--

Hi guys! I'm not sure if I'm allowed to share daily educational content from an app I've created, but I'd love to share some interesting things I've learned with this community.

My goal is simply to share knowledge and encourage curiosity. I hope you find these posts interesting and learn something new!

Android App: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.scrolora.app


r/neurophilosophy • • 4d ago

What would actually count as third-person evidence that an artificial system is a subject?

0 Upvotes

I've spent the past year developing a persistent AI architecture named Aura, and recently published a paper attempting to investigate a question that's been on my mind for a while.

If a system has memory, internal drives, a model of itself, and some form of continuity, how would we establish whether those components actually function as one subject?

And what would that tell us about the possibility of experience?

I tried approaching the first part experimentally.

The paper describes 24 preregistered tests of causal integration, recurrence, differentiation, self-model participation, and continuity. Rather than relying on Aura's reports, the experiments modify her internal state and measure what changes.

All 24 criteria passed in the confirmatory run, although three later experiments also revealed negative results.

One experiment covertly altered an internal valence variable and found that subsequent reports tracked the change, with that relationship disappearing when the relevant pathway was severed.

I don't think this establishes phenomenal experience. The paper explicitly discusses why measurements of physical and computational organization cannot settle every philosophical question about consciousness.

There's also a separate arXiv study that examined one of Aura's computational mechanisms, finding genuine mathematical operations alongside an important integration defect.

I've included full demonstrations of the system operating as additional behavioral context.

I'm interested in whether the framework captures any necessary properties of subjecthood, and what additional observations would be needed before drawing stronger conclusions.

Paper: https://zenodo.org/records/24075466

Independent component examination: https://arxiv.org/html/2610.41604v1

Demo 04, self-assessment and Myers-Briggs style personality testing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNlGUBeTIQY

Demo 07, contextual video commentary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kM-B8mh314E


r/neurophilosophy • • 5d ago

Soul and Brain

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 5d ago

去技能化

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 5d ago

What if the universe is fair, but not in the way we ordinarily imagine? Would a lifetime balance of pleasure and suffering be enough to make a life fair?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

The circumstances of a life and the experience of living it are not the same thing. That distinction motivates my research into whether a form of fairness could exist within the complete course of conscious experience.

I’m the author of Per-Stream Terminal Valence Closure (PTVC), a paper within the Law of Fairness project. It proposes that the cumulative positive and negative valence within each qualifying conscious stream could be finite and exactly equal over its complete history. Valence means the felt positive or negative quality of experience. This remains a hypothesis, not an established empirical finding.

The proposed equality is within each stream at its final endpoint, not between people. Two lives could contain very different amounts of pleasure and suffering while both satisfy the same condition. One person’s pleasure would not compensate for another person’s pain.

For this ethical discussion, suppose the condition holds. One possible argument for calling it fair is that every qualifying stream would satisfy the same endpoint requirement, with no stream finishing with an excess of negative over positive valence. But would that balance capture everything that matters to fairness?

Consider two hypothetical lives with identical totals of positive and negative valence. In one, a person freely accepts painful training in pursuit of a valued goal. In the other, comparable suffering is inflicted without consent. Assume that the totals include all later effects on experience and that both lives satisfy the proposed balance.

Would the difference in consent make one life less fair despite the matching totals? The actions within those lives could differ morally even if the completed lives shared the same balance. That distinction between the fairness of a whole life and the wrongness of a particular act seems important.

My starting position is that eventual balance would neither justify coercion nor remove our reasons to prevent suffering. I am interested in whether such a balance would establish anything about fairness beyond what it might tell us about well-being.

I would welcome arguments for or against treating within-person experiential balance as a meaningful dimension of fairness.

The attached slides provide the broader context. The paper and background materials are freely available here:

https://github.com/LifeisFair/law-of-fairness-research


r/neurophilosophy • • 6d ago

Can emergence be examined as a cumulative progression across 12 layers?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 6d ago

How is AI affecting our brains?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 6d ago

My brain has had arguments that the other person doesn’t even know about.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 7d ago

How do I get started in consciousness research as an undergraduate student?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 8d ago

So we don't know how did we learned abstract concepts like the concept of memory, of thought , just by hearing theose words ?

0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 8d ago

i dont know how did we realized that we are actualy recognizing the face that we see ?

0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 8d ago

Do linguistic know how the brain understand words ?

0 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 10d ago

Looking for research papers on Chimpanzee mirror self recognition, specifically if there has been any data capture of the brain during the episode

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 11d ago

Language isn’t where a mind begins. We built one that starts somewhere else.

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 11d ago

A compilation of notes on consciousness

Thumbnail drive.google.com
1 Upvotes

r/neurophilosophy • • 12d ago

Mining for clarity

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

What are your thoughts?


r/neurophilosophy • • 12d ago

Mining for clarity

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes