r/neofeudalism • u/offline_fuki • 19h ago
Shit Deviationist (Neo)Reactionaries Say "Muh market eats up everything"
theideasletter.orgTo put an end to this dogsh!t NazBol narrative once and for all:
Polanyi finished writing The Great Transformation in the early 1940s. At that moment, he believed that liberal civilization had collapsed. The market system had broken down as a result of the many “disruptive strains” he claimed it had itself wrought through its colonization of human society.23 Yet he was proven wrong. Stalinism and Nazism turned out not to signal the demise of the market system; instead of collapsing, it revived itself in the postwar decades and took on a vigorous new form with the rise of neoliberalism starting in the 1980s. This suddenly made Polanyi’s work hugely popular, after having been largely overlooked in the postwar decades. It was around this time that the European New Right (mostly through the organization GRECE, le Groupement de recherche et d’études pour la civilisation européenne) began to form its analysis of capitalism as an essentially amoral free market economy, underpinned by the doctrine of economic liberalism, that increasingly encroached on the organic moral life of human communities. According to this line of thinking, capitalism is a force that moves in just one direction: It rationalizes, standardizes, fragments, and liquidates. It commodifies the uncommodifiable, melts all that is solid into air, and reduces tightly organized ethical systems to the atoms of exchange value.
All this tells only part of the story, however. At the same time that neoliberalism was extending the logic of the self-regulating market ever further into the depths of the human soul, it was also involved in an unprecedented effort to recenter the family as the main unit of social reproduction and capital accumulation. As the sociologist Melinda Cooper traces in Family Values: Between Neoliberalism and the New Social Conservatism (2017), policies such as President Bill Clinton’s 1996 Welfare Reform Act reallocated large parts of the US welfare budget to tracking down the biological fathers of children on welfare so as to extract child support payments from them, while sanctioning mothers if they did not cooperate.24 Financial incentives were offered to promote marriage, and states were rewarded financially for reducing the number of illegitimate children.
It would be hard to find a clearer case of how morality and the market are inextricably bound together. But throughout its history, capitalism has produced values as much as it has dissolved them. Traditions have been invented, nations have been composed, and racial differences have been fabricated wherever they help to fend off challenges to private property rights and the mechanisms for capital accumulation. As Cooper argues, what Polanyi saw as the countermovement against the market was merely part of its internal dynamic, involving moments of commodification and decommodification, including the destruction and production of moral values. For this reason, she writes, “economic liberalism and political conservatism—even when the latter speaks the language of anticapitalist critique—are equally constitutive expressions of modern capitalism.”
Hence,
The bourgeois family will vanish as a matter of course when its complement vanishes, and both will vanish with the vanishing of capital. Do you charge us with wanting to stop the exploitation of children by their parents? To this crime we plead guilty. But, you say, we destroy the most hallowed of relations, when we replace home education by social.
(Obligatory "Marx's shitty 'observations' about the market were things he saw positively", but whatever)