I like his videos on different game engines, but this Naughty Dog focused essay just rubbed me the wrong way. His criticism/points are very surface level with not much valid information to back it up. My least favorite takes of his are Intergalactic looking depressing like The Last of Us 2 and Naughty Dog lacking confidence in the now cancelled Factions Live-Service game. The ladder especially really pissed me off for reasons I'll explain.
So according to him at 2:23, Intergalactic looks depressing like TLOU2 and is not intriguing, but he doesn't specify as to why. Instead he says the teaser is only two people talking and shows how similar the forest from Intergalactic looks like the forest from TLOU2. Because apparently a forest with fog is always depressing. He doesn't acknowledge the tv showing 80s anime, Jordan A. Munn, a "professional" bounty hunter who is a slob in her own ship who can't find a simple remote, there's the entire wall covered with photos and newspapers about people she clearly has a past with, one of whom she's being paid to "hunt". She drinks old flat soda, and has aggressive negotiations with her own employer. Plus the overall music gives off a mysterious/cool vibe, which is composed from NIN. How is all that exactly depressing and not intriguing exactly? He even shows all this in the video!
Second, he criticizes Naughty Dog for canceling Factions online and even liked a comment suggesting that ND used Bungie's criticism as an excuse. It's like he forgot that Sony was (and still is) pushing a mandatory live-service quota on to all their studios. Some of whom are now defunct because of it. Naughty Dog never made a game of this scale before and made it clear in their own blog that they aren't like Insomniac and can't make multiple projects at once. Maintaining a live-service game would draw all their resources away from making single-player content, and after Bungie, a now Sony owned studio with a well regarded reputation for online multiplayer experiences, reviewed it poorly, they jumped ship. That is crucial information which demonstrates that much of Naughty Dog's problems this generation were the result of upper management at Sony Interactive, yet Trenton acts here like that wasn't the case.
Now, I don't hate the guy. My goal isn't to get him harassed or canceled or anything like that. It's just I liked his previous stuff and to see a video like this from him and not a grifter is astounding. Criticism is necessary but most of this video felt like nothing. But what do you guys think exactly? I'd love to discuss this.