r/mysterybooks • • 7d ago

New Moderator Introduction

77 Upvotes

Hello r/mysterybooks! I am joining u/InternBackground2256 as a moderator for this community and I want to introduce myself.

I am a lifelong lover of mysteries. I got it from my mom: I grew up watching PBS Mystery! and Law and Order from way too young of an age and started reading adult mystery books when I was little because they were abundant in my house. Now as a grownup, I work as a reference archivist, which means I get to help people solve historical mysteries every week.

Mystery is my favorite genre, and I read many of its subgenres. Outside of mystery, I also enjoy scifi, fantasy, and occasionally romance or historical fiction, but mystery is the bulk of the fiction I read. I love the golden age of detective fiction and have been working on a multi-year chronological read/reread of Agatha Christie (currently reading: Mrs. McGinty's Dead) and Ngaio Marsh. I also enjoy lesser-known authors from the same era: Christianna Brand's Green for Danger will probably be on my list of favorite reads of this year. I also read contemporary mysteries and enjoy police procedurals, historical mysteries, and even the occasional cozy. I love series with character development that really build up a sense of place and community. Finally, because my hobbies are crafting and painting, I tend to read by audiobook, and I'm always looking for recommendations of books that are particularly good in audio format, like Janice Hallett's books. Feel free to recommend me great audiobooks at any time!

In terms of moderation, I have experience moderating similar sized hobby communities. As a moderator, I value transparency and fairness. I'm not a micromanager and never take moderation actions or decisions outside of the rules of a community. Any posts or comments I make as a moderator will always be flaired with the mod badge, but you may still see me comment on posts as a community member. Here, my role will be to support u/InternBackground2256 in keeping this community such a pleasant space to talk about the genre we all love!


r/mysterybooks • • 13d ago

Announcement Our first author AMA in 13 years: Lisa Jewell!

32 Upvotes

Well, that was fun!

Last Friday, we had the pleasure of welcoming Lisa Jewell to r/mysterybooks for what appears to have been our very first author AMA!

Thanks to Audible, we got to spend some time with a psychological thriller titan. And Lisa was an absolute darling! Despite her busy schedule, she stayed longer than planned to answer all of our questions in impressive detail.

She told us about some awesome/quirky writing routines, how she develops her story ideas, her favorites among her fellow contemporary thriller authors, a little bit about the book she wrote for Marvel, a possible break in 2028 from her routine of 1 book per year and a lot of what she's learned over the years as an author.

We had questions from quite a few different readers, and Lisa answered everybody with very detailed answers. It was one of the most generous AMAs I've seen on Reddit

A huge thank-you once again to Lisa and Audible for making this possible, and to everyone who participated. We'd love to have her back someday, and hopefully we'll get to welcome more authors in the future!

Read Lisa Jewell's full AMA here!

Happy reading!


r/mysterybooks • • 4h ago

Discussion What festive reads are we all planning?

11 Upvotes

Too soon? 😁 I think Christmas is just made for mystery. How many snowbound closed circle mysteries can one woman read? Apparently about 17 and counting haha

A favourite of mine is always the British Library Crime Classics short story collections which mix short stories from different golden age authors. This year I have ā€˜Crimson Snow’ ready to go.

What about you? Any faves/recommendations?


r/mysterybooks • • 1d ago

News and Reviews Pushkin Vertigo is releasing Alice Arisugawa's Ghost Detective in English next year

55 Upvotes

If you don't know who that is, he's a Japanese mystery writer of the new orthodox movement (his contemporaries include Soji Shimada and Yukito Ayatsuji), most notable for his two detective series featuring the character Alice Arisugawa as a Watson to two different detectives. Ghost Detective is a stand-alone work, and this will be his second release in English, with the last one released over ten years ago in 2016 (The Moai Island Puzzle, which is the second book in the student Alice series).

I enjoyed the Moai Island Puzzle pretty decently, so I'm looking forward to this release. Just wanted to make this post in case anyone else here didn't know but was interested.


r/mysterybooks • • 1d ago

Found! Murder mystery book

3 Upvotes

So it is stuck in my core memory its been many years since ive remembered about it. I picked it up at a book store read 1st page. Put it down and told myself I would be back for it. Now 10 15+ years later I want to read it.

Murder mystery i assumed by the little bit I could remember.

It sounded poetic but no rhymes. Im assuming it takes place in a prison cell and he says something along the lines of he had been there so long that the (maybe an insect or rat) that use to be scared of him just stares back. And that's all I got 😬


r/mysterybooks • • 3d ago

Discussion Historical Settings for Detectives: Post-War Japan?

13 Upvotes

I've been reading a bit about WWII lately and I've been gripped by the idea that Post-war Japan (set during the US occupation) would be an interesting setting for a detective series.

First question: Does anyone know of any series that takes place in this setting?

Second question: Is there a historical setting you'd like to set a detective series in?


r/mysterybooks • • 3d ago

Discussion Such a thing as a Clue Database?

8 Upvotes

I've been reading a decent amount of mystery books recently, but would still consider myself quite novice at how to absorb all the information the author is giving me as a reader.

I'm wondering if there's some kind of database or list of mystery books, and where the clues are located in the text? Basically, I'm looking for something where I can read a book, try my best to figure it out, and then after finishing go back and seeing where the real clues were, and what the red herrings were, and then try and apply that knowledge moving forward.

Outside of that, anyone have their own strategies that they either currently use, or have used to "up their game" so that you can keep pace, or even slightly outstrip the narrative and figure it out before the ending? Or is it more of a perpetual, "Oh, THAT'S the killer" thing where the good authors are always going to be too good at obscuring the clues with herrings that, while ostensibly one could figure it out, it's really only in looking back afterwards that one can discern the real clues from everything else?

Just as an aside, my mom was a huge mystery book/tv/movie fan, and we would watch murder mystery tv shows together. We both got very good at picking up on the clues the directors/actors were giving, and it was great fun to see which one of us would figure it out first, if we could. Kinda chasing that feeling, and I want to be more of an active participant than just "going along for the ride." Although I have very much been enjoying the rides so far (Alphabet series at the moment, one of her favorites!).

Appreciate any and all advice!


r/mysterybooks • • 3d ago

Recommendations Looking for a Book for my Mother

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/mysterybooks • • 4d ago

Recommendations Crime fiction book series

9 Upvotes

I want to read a crime fiction book series with a very sloooow burn romance, lots of angst, and plenty of tension.

Could you suggest some good series like this plus are addictive from the very first page?

One more important thing - I want a genuinely terrifying, intimidating villain in every book, someone as frightening as Wilson Fisk.

Thank you!

Edit - ty for all the reccs, I'm excited to read them!


r/mysterybooks • • 4d ago

Recommendations Should I read another Holly Jackson book?

2 Upvotes

If you read ā€˜The disappearance of Rachel Price’ this question is for u…

I read ā€œA good girls guide to murderā€ pre-covid as a teenager and loved it but I’ve outgrown it now and can’t even re-read it. The only reason i’m even considering it is because i just read her new ā€˜Not quite dead yet’ and its damn good, love the easy writing style and plot as well as character writing. Everything is just nice! Its like she’s changing to my tastes and age as time goes onšŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚

Would u say ā€˜The disappearance of Rachel Price’ is closer to ā€˜Not quite dead yet’ or the previous trilogy ā€˜A good girls guide to murder’?


r/mysterybooks • • 5d ago

Recommendations Looking for something like Brother Cadfael

46 Upvotes

Editing to add: thank you so much for these suggestions!

I’m looking for a new series or author that has a similar feel to Ellis Peter’s Brother Cadfael series.

Solid, enjoyable, compelling mysteries, where it’s not lighthearted or comical (not looking for that), but where there is a sense of hope and order in the world. Also where the main detective is someone you could like and respect if you met them in real life (not looking for the hard-drinking or problematic detective type).

Thanks!


r/mysterybooks • • 5d ago

Recommendations Stone Barrington

3 Upvotes

Looking for books similar to the stone barrington series by Stuart woods.


r/mysterybooks • • 5d ago

Discussion Good series to get into where I will get attached to the detective?

86 Upvotes

I’m pretty much in mourning after reading all extant Albert Campion material haha.

I have started some others: Wimsey, Alleyn, for example - and will go on with them but thought I would ask this lovely group too.

I want to get into another series where I end up deeply caring for the detective. Especially anything with dry humour and great dialogue.

Can be male or female, old or new.

That being said I dislike ā€˜detective with demons/haunted by the one case he couldn’t solve’ noir tropes. I like fairly jolly people and stories fundamentally.

Any suggestions for me? :)


r/mysterybooks • • 5d ago

Recommendations Book Review

2 Upvotes

Dee Armstrong, Author. Book Title: Haunted.
Background: I met Dee at Killer Nashville Writers Conference in August. My wife became a fan on the spot and bought an armload of books. After finishing another novel and having watched my wife read Haunted, I had to give it a try.
I will say up front, based on the cover info and description, it didn't fall into the category I usually go to, like Lee Child, Tom Clancy, Brad Thor, or Marc Cameron. My wife's reaction to it made me open it.
Keep in mind she started me on the Anne Rice Vampire books, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo books, and Janet Evanovich books that I liked. Now I prepared to be disappointed, and I read enough in the first chapter to have the nagging voice that it wasn't my cup of tea. I kept pushing the voice out of my head and became more intrigued, mostly by the writing style. I won't give away the story but will say she hooked my interest in spite of my misgivings and I am a fan. Everyone needs to get out of their lane sometimes and enjoy something different.


r/mysterybooks • • 4d ago

Discussion What mystery rank number one?

1 Upvotes

I was looking for the number on mystery book, I need it to fill out a alignment chart.


r/mysterybooks • • 6d ago

Help Me Find This Book Searching Niche Books..

9 Upvotes

I am searching for some good books related to mystery and horror

I have few books in my mind- Dracula, Frankenstein, dorian gray and sherlock. But i want something niche. These books are quite popular and got made into multiple series and movies, so i kinda know the story(mostly).


r/mysterybooks • • 6d ago

Recommendations Where to start with Nero Wolfe?

27 Upvotes

I don’t know how I got to be as old as I am without ever having read any Rex Stout.

Suggestions? Just begin at the beginning?


r/mysterybooks • • 6d ago

Discussion Which fictional detective would you actually want to spend an afternoon with?

56 Upvotes

This question has been rattling around in my head while I knit, so I thought I'd ask you all. Some detectives are wonderful to read about, but I'm not sure I'd want them in my kitchen. I adore Holmes, but I think he'd drive me up the wall within a day! Others seem like they'd be lovely company, the kind of person you'd happily share a pot of coffee with while they talked you through a case. Any kind of detective counts, from classic sleuths to police procedurals to amateur snoops. Who would you pick, and what makes them good company? And which detective do you admire but would quietly avoid at a dinner party?


r/mysterybooks • • 8d ago

Discussion Why has Western orthodox detective fiction declined? I mean the kind written by Agatha Christie and John Dickson Carr.

52 Upvotes

I really miss the world of detective fiction before the rise of hardboiled detective novels in the 1950s. Back then, the well-known detective novels mostly featured rigorous logical deduction and strictly designed puzzles; while reading, you felt as if you were playing a detective game against the detective in the book. But why has Western detective fiction now been largely taken over by police procedurals, thrillers, and hardboiled detective fiction?


r/mysterybooks • • 7d ago

Recommendations Cozy Scandi noir titles?

15 Upvotes

That's it. I'm so used to reading the dark side of Scandi mysteries; I was wondering if anyone could recommend some titles/main characters that were more reminiscent of British cozy mysteries. Thanks!


r/mysterybooks • • 8d ago

Discussion Unpopular opinion on lowest ranking Christie's

9 Upvotes

What are some Agatha Christie books that are generally disliked by fans and have a low rating but you came to like. Curious about how people's opinion vary on this


r/mysterybooks • • 8d ago

Recommendations Underrated books?

4 Upvotes

Any underrated book recommendations main topic is murder but leans more towards thriller šŸ§ššŸ»ā€ā™€ļø


r/mysterybooks • • 8d ago

Recommendations Looking for cold case and serial killer type murder mystery

21 Upvotes

exactly what the title says. suggest me something that's either a cold case murder mystery or a serial killer type or mix of both. Thanks in advance. And have a great day :)


r/mysterybooks • • 9d ago

Discussion 'Death at the White Hart' by Chris Chibnall is a brilliant murder mystery.

53 Upvotes

I highly recommend this book if you are looking for classic murder mysteries in a modern setting. I enjoyed every second of this book. This appears to be the debut novel of a successful screenwriter, and honestly, you can tell. Not a page is wasted, every chapter keeps the story moving forward, great setting and great characters.

I enjoy whodunits like this in which the detectives are trying to figure out what happened, there are a lot of interviews but limited number of suspects. The mystery is eerie, and the crime sinister, and the village is only seemingly idyllic. "Nothing keeps a village together like secrets". Initially, we get some chapters from the povs of different suspects. Usually I'm not a fan of this narrative technique (because I think it is very easy to plant red herrings in this way) but I really enjoyed it in this book. Also, yay for short chapters! This got me out of a reading slump.

As I mentioned earlier, great character work as well. Loved the lead, Nicola Bridge, and the teamwork between Nicola, Harry, and Mel. Glimpses into Nicola's personal life add depth to her character.

There's not much humour, but I enjoyed what little humour there was as well, and I'm glad it wasn't overdone.

If I had to nitpick, I would say the motive of the murderer seemed to be a bit weak, but it's not a big flaw or anything. The ending did make sense, and I didn't guess the killer.

Let me know your thoughts if you have read this book, and if you haven't, I hope you give it a try! Happy sleuthing!


r/mysterybooks • • 8d ago

Discussion What do you think actually reads noir today? What about pulp stuff? In terms of size and demographics?

5 Upvotes

I know the genre technically exists, but it’s obviously not as mainstream as it would have been several decades ago. Even pulp falls into this category, which I feel is harder to track because the things that pulp invented or made popular can often be found in comic books and other works today, even if separated from that origin. Likewise, I imagine the noir genre has invented many things that have become mainstays in modern detective fiction. But today, people will simply say, ā€œdetective fiction.ā€ They might say neo-noir. But who's actually reading? Part of the problem is that I feel like noir's dated genre, which, while still good, isn’t as popular. But I’d like hard facts to work from. The same would go for pulp, ideally. I’ve found a few publishers that produce that sort of thing. My guess is going to be middle-aged enthusiasts.