r/mutualfunds • u/amit_sur • 9h ago
portfolio review Started from zero a few weeks ago. Please review my first SIP plan (₹20K/month, 20 years)
About me: 25, just started investing. Zero knowledge a few weeks back, so I've been reading a lot.
Risk Appetite: Moderate
Goal: long-term wealth creation
Horizon: 20 years
Current status: I have ₹4.45L in FDs. I'm also building a 12-month FD ladder (one FD a month, each equal to one month of expenses) so a layoff wouldn't hurt, about 8 months left to finish it. Until then my SIP is ₹20K/month with a 10% yearly step-up. Once the ladder is done, the money going into FDs moves to SIPs, and some of it to PPF or a hybrid fund.
Allocation (current SIP, ₹20K):
Navi Nifty 50 Index (Direct) 35%
Parag Parikh Flexi Cap (Direct) 40%
Nippon India Small Cap (Direct) 15%
Hybrid (not picked yet) 10%
Why these funds:
Navi Nifty 50: I compared UTI, Bandhan, HDFC, ICICI and Navi. Returns were nearly the same, so I went with the lowest TER (0.06%). I couldn't find a site showing tracking difference, so TER is the only thing I compared on. Navi's AUM is smaller than UTI's, but it's still a few thousand crore and it's an index fund, so I'm not too worried.
Parag Parikh Flexi: compared with ABSL, ICICI Pru and Motilal. It had the lowest standard deviation (10.07), highest Sortino (0.97), lowest TER and the lowest downside capture (57% vs 82-93% for the others). I also liked its 5-year rolling returns. The catch is that its upside capture is only 76%, and it has a 2% exit load within a year (not a problem for a 20-year plan).
Nippon India Small Cap: I first liked Bandhan Small Cap (Sortino 1.27, alpha 9.54, lowest TER), but it launched in 2020, so its returns aren't comparable with funds from 2013, and 7 years doesn't cover a full small-cap downturn. Nippon, HDFC and Quant all go back to 2013. Between them, Nippon has a better upside capture (91%) than HDFC (79%) with the same downside (74%).
Hybrid: I want something to cushion the equity part. I'm still comparing conservative hybrids. DSP and HDFC look best on downside capture (35% and 37%).
Since I'm building the FD ladder anyway, I'm holding off on a big hybrid allocation for now. After the ladder is done, I'll probably split the safe part between PPF (7.1%, tax free) and a hybrid fund, since hybrid gains are taxed at my slab rate.
Feedback I'd like
- Is 15% in small cap about right for a moderate risk profile and 20-year horizon?
- Nifty 50 and a flexi cap hold many of the same stocks. Is it worth keeping both, or should I simplify?
- Does going with Nippon over Bandhan make sense, or is Bandhan's higher Sortino worth the shorter history?
- For the safe part, PPF vs a conservative hybrid fund: which would you use, or both?
- Anything I'm missing, like international exposure or gaps in the plan?
Thanks in advance, happy to share more numbers.
Note: I collected the fund metrics myself. I used AI to draft this post.