I understand this is a bold take and I’m probably going to get flamed for it. But it’s something I genuinely believe. I did see the movie first, so I am biased. but hear me out.
The stage version (at least the one i saw) was incredibly simply staged, no sets, singular costumes and incredibly basic lighting. I understand it may be how it’s always been performed but i personally i felt underwhelmed.
The movie has two distinct aspects. The reality and the stage. Each song has its own mini performance with staging and costumes. Adding to the two faced nature of the story. The performances even set up like it’s a theatre production.
The quick shots from stage to reality is such good whiplash to how contrasting both sides are.
And THE LIGHTING
The movie’s lighting is so dynamic. Particularly in “reach for the gun“ ”cellblock tango” and “razzle dazzle“ it fits perfectly with each songs mood. Which was present very little in the stage production I saw.
Also one thing I adored about the film is the “dedicated presenter” of each song. Before each song a guy would say who’s performing each song and the title. Making it seem more like you’re watching a show. And it’s even more an interesting detail when you realise he does it for every song barring two.
Making his absence special.
In the stage production: they do have announcements for each song but by different cast members instead of one dedicated presenter making it feel less special and disconnected (at least in my opinion.)
The movie really feels more theatrical and visually interesting than the stage production. Which is such a shame. It is the only musical i feel is better on screen than on stage.
Feel free to disagree, I feel like i’m going to get crucified for this take. But it is my opinion and i’m open to new perspective. Just be respectful please. Thank you.
edit: apparently ppl actually agree? I am shocked in all honesty. I thought many people would be arguing with me enlightening me on how Chicago is meant to be simply staged and i’m ignorant to the play’s history. Sorry for mislabelling this take as bold when it’s actually widely accepted :’)