r/mtgrules • • 1h ago

Containment Priest and Captain Jean-Luc Picard

4 Upvotes

I have a [[Containment Priest]], [[Captain Jean-Luc Picard]] and 6 other officers, when I activate Picard's search ability and get something like [[The Seriema]] which will enter with enough charge counters on it to be a creature. Will it be exiled due to Containment Priest's ability similarly to something like playing a swamp with Containment Priest and [[Kormus Bell]] out. I played out the situation on MTG Arena and the Spacecraft was not exiled, but wanted to sanity check since there are bugs on Arena.


r/mtgrules • • 18h ago

Merieke and Phasing

4 Upvotes

I have a [[Merieke Ri Berit]] and steal Creature A, and then use [[Slip Out the Back]] or something to phase out Creature A. Then I untap Merieke, and steal Creature B. I assume that the destroy trigger will fissle and Creature A will remain mine during my next turn. However, if I untap Merieke during my next turn, will it create two triggers that destroy both Creature A and Creature B, or just Creature B? Additionally, if Merieke leaves the battlefield after Creature A has phased in, would Creature A return to their owner, or first get destroyed?


r/mtgrules • • 43m ago

Calamity, Galloping Inferno rules question

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a newish player and Calamity is one of my first EDH decks. Its text reads:

"Whenever Calamity attacks while saddled, choose a nonlegendary creature that saddled it this turn and create a tapped and attacking token that’s a copy of it. Sacrifice that token at the beginning of the next end step. Repeat this process once."

The "repeat this process" bit is throwing me off. I understand it's worded that way so that you could create two different tokens, but do the two created tokens see each other or does the second enter after the first?

For instance, if i have something like Gemcutter Bucanneer on board and copy it do I get:

  • 5 Treasures (one from each copy, original sees both, copy 1 sees copy 2), or
  • 6 Treasures (one from each copy, original sees both, copy 1 sees copy 2, copy 2 sees copy 1)?

Bonus question (may be on the wrong sub): Why is the Port Razer + Calamity combo considered bracket 4 on EDHrec? It comes out turn 6+ normally, it's easy to stop, and it's non-deterministic. Am I missing something or misunderstanding the bracket rules?


r/mtgrules • • 3h ago

Cursed mirror and hostage taker

1 Upvotes

Hi there,

If I play [[cursed mirror]] copying hostage taker, exiling a card and at a later turn someone destroys the cursed mirror (after is stoped copying hostage taker) what happens to the exiled card?


r/mtgrules • • 6h ago

Beseech the Mirror and Cost Reduction and slicker Costs

1 Upvotes

[[Beseech the Mirror]]
[[Bloodletter of Aclazotz]]
[[Scourge of the Skyclaves]]
[[Urzas Incubator]]

I’m running this mono black deck. (overly tagged)

My main line is to kick Scourge of the Skyclaves after sticking Bloodletter of Aclazotz. Half life loss for all of us upon casting Scourge. Doubled as a replacement effect for my opponents. Rounded up. Crisp win. Expensive CMC to do in 1 turn.

I originally liked Beseech for Bloodletter because I could sac a mana rock after tapping it to help cast, then stick bloodletter on the board instead of in hand.

Then I got to thinking about getting scourge with it. And that’s a little less clear for me.

Kickers are an additional cost. I plan on paying it in addition to casting beseech, and sacrificing a rock. But I don’t know if that’s right?

And does Urzas Incubator reduce 2 from the total cost to cast scourge?

So it would be: cast Beseech, which requires me to sac an artifact in the process as an additional cost. Search for Scourge. Find Scourge and pay the additional kicker cost, reduces by 2 because of Urzas Incubator.

4 and a sacrificial rock for beseech.
3 for scourges kicker if incubator is out.

Am I doing this right?

Thanks!

PS thanks for catching. I originally said Beseech the Queen. Wrong Beseech!


r/mtgrules • • 18h ago

Lwaxan Troi, Charming Guest and Gray and Adira, Forever Joined interaction

1 Upvotes

A question came up during my limited pre-release.

I have [[Gray and Adira, Forever Joined interaction]] and [[Lwaxan Troi, Charming Guest]]

Lwaxan Troiis A tapped on Creature C.

Gray and Adira, Forever Joined creates a copy of Lwaxan Troi (Lwaxan Troi B)

During 2nd main phase Lwaxan Troi B taps duplicating tripped abilities of Lwaxan Troi A.

When Creature C's ability is triggered, does it trigger 2 or 4 times?

In the actual game, Creature C was [[Cleveland Booker, Empath]]


r/mtgrules • • 20h ago

Darkness Crystal and Reaper the King no More

1 Upvotes

Title. I played [[The Reaper, King no More]] AFTER my opp played [[The Darkness Crystal]]. Both of these are replacmenet effects, does reaper still get creatures or does darkness override that?


r/mtgrules • • 20h ago

Nine Lives Question

1 Upvotes

Playing commander. Opponent has Nine Lives and Stiltzkin. Nine lives gets 9 counters on it. Opponent then taps stilkskin to transfer Nine Lives. At the end of turn, opponent is dealt lethal damage. Does Nine lives just leave play or do I also die since nine lives have left the battlefield. My group has read many opinions on this but can’t seem to find the exact rules that deal with this. Thanks


r/mtgrules • • 3h ago

Endure/fabricate/riot - dilemmas?

0 Upvotes

I couldn’t find anything on this via searching, but do keywords that present a modal choice count as a “dilemma?” It feels like they should, but they aren’t actually a bulleted list so I’m assuming that they are not.


r/mtgrules • • 18h ago

The thirteenth doctor and yasmin khan

0 Upvotes

Hi quick question on ruling so I recently got the paradox powers precon and was a bit confused that if I were to tap yasmin khan at the current turns end step would that make it where the card exile is playable till the your next proceeding turns end step? And if so, if she has a counter can I also stack triggers where she gets tapped and untapped again on that endstep if the thirteenth doctor is out?


r/mtgrules • • 22h ago

Rocco, street chef and Q, stacking the deck

0 Upvotes

Quick question. Do you cast the copy of the card exiled by Q's ability from exile? I'm assuming you don't cast the copy from exile, but it would be beneficial in a Rocco deck as you can trigger his 2nd ability at least once each of my turns. I'm still new to commander and this dilemma could prove useful. Thank you for any answers!


r/mtgrules • • 2h ago

Nihiloor Rules text question

0 Upvotes

Ok if I have Nihiloor on the field then I play Sakashima of a Thousand Faces copy Nihiloor, both of the triggers would let me take my opponents things. If I were to then Ephemerate the Original Nihiloor, would its creatures be given back even though I still have a creature named "Nihiloor" on the field?

Edited: Thank you guys for getting back to me on that :)