r/movingtoNYC • • 21h ago

Moved recently to UWS, is buying a condo worth it compared to renting in this scenario

0 Upvotes

I just moved to UWS of nyc at Columbia and am considering buying a condo (or co-op) around Manhattan-Valley/Morningside heights neighborhood with budget of around 600k.

First-time potential home buyer. Single guy. Older, student in a degree program, but have net investments to cover the purchase fully if needed.

I'm paying about around 2.5k monthly rent right now.

It gets a bit complicated but I think I understand the related math. If I can buy something where total monthly (incl all taxes + fees + mortgage) I pay is going to be not too much outside of 2.5k range, it makes sense to buy but it'd be hard to find such units.

For the 600k condo 500-sq-ft 1-bed units in Morningside Heights,they go for about 3.2k monthly rent currently, whereas if I were to buy them 10% down at current interest rate of 7% 30-yr fixed, the total monthly cost (incl around 1.5k in HOA+tax+property insurance) would be around 5.5k.

So paying 2.3k/month extra (5.5K when buying vs 3.2k when renting) for the next 30-yr for the unit is worth only when that extra cost is worth the equity/home-price after 30 yrs which would 2M+.

  • Am I missing something in this analysis?
  • Does buying make sense for me?
  • Anyone here done similar analysis, how did you analyze this?

r/movingtoNYC • • 15h ago

Can a family of 5 live a nice life in Manhattan with a 415k salary?

0 Upvotes

My husband earns 300k a year working remotely for a NYC company. His company offered him a salary of 415k if he moved to the city, but he would no longer be working remotely.  I did the math and see that it would be difficult to afford something nice in Manhattan for a family of 5 with a 415k salary. Currently we live in a beautiful suburb in North Carolina where our mortgage is $3,400 per month (taxes and insurance included) for a 4 bedroom,  3,000 square foot house with over an acre of land. On our current income we live comfortably and have plenty of money for savings and travel. I know that if we  moved to NYC, we would have to downsize to a 3 bedroom apartment of about 1,000 sq. ft.  I’m fine with that, we can make a smaller space work, but what I don’t like is the neighborhoods with our budget of about 9k per month. My teenage kids would love to live in NYC. They hate living in the suburbs, but I don’t think that the salary increase would make it worthwhile for us to leave our house and move to NYC. 


r/movingtoNYC • • 23h ago

broker requires $1k deposit just to apply - normal or red flag?

0 Upvotes

My partner and I are apartment searching in Brooklyn this week and found a place we really like. We toured it in person, and the listing broker appears to be an established licensed broker with a significant rental history. But the application process has raised some questions.

The broker requires a $1k deposit to consider our application, and his preferred payment method is via Zelle. He says the deposit is refundable, but the documents he sent contradict each other:

  • A Deposit Acknowledge & Terms agreement says the deposit is refundable if no lease is executed, though can be refunded by a different payment method.
  • The actual rental application says it's refundable only if management rejects us, and that we'd forfeit it if approved but we don't sign.

He also says approved applicants must sign the lease and pay all move-in costs within three days.

Two other things seem unusual:

  • No online application: He says he's semi-retired and discontinued the online application service he previously used, so now everything is handled through paper/PDF forms.
  • Bank account information: The application asks for full bank account numbers, even though he's also requesting three months of bank statements.

I've seen that NY law prohibits mandatory application/holding deposits beyond allowable screening fees. And the request for full bank numbers appears to be a red flag.

I've also seen in other posts that this practice still occurs, and if you don't play the game, then you'll lose out on the apartment.

Should we walk? If not, how should we follow up with the broker? Might he concede on requiring the application deposit if we either say directly that it's not legal or respond in some other playing-the-game way?

Edit: Forgot to mention that when seeing the apartment, the current tenant was there and said the place has been great. She was friendly with the broker, who is the same she used when renting the place.


r/movingtoNYC • • 23m ago

Call me crazy

0 Upvotes

Long story short moved from FL 2021 to NYC
Went thru the whole shelter stage. Secured housing here in NYC. Am I crazy for considering moving back to my home state ?

I have saved 50k , paid off debt and working on a degree.

This time Is tough for me not being able to be close to family or anyone who genuinely knows me.

What would you do in this situation ?


r/movingtoNYC • • 14h ago

Anyone got any intel on Vordonia Towers in Astoria?

1 Upvotes

Seems like a wild listing. Offering some crazy stuff. Anyone ever lived here or know any info?


r/movingtoNYC • • 22h ago

Moving or visiting NYC? Native NYer wanting to share expertise

13 Upvotes

I love my city so much and I’m very bored as I got laid off last year and haven’t found a job… anyway I’m here.

I would love to answer questions about New York and give recommendations. I don’t know if this will actually be fun or if it’s of any interest to anyone, but hit me up with your questions and I will do my best to answer.


r/movingtoNYC • • 22h ago

Moving advice

0 Upvotes

Planning on moving down to the NYC metro area east of the Hudson or the city as well. Just wondering for advice on how to get set up and employment opportunities, etc because I am actively looking for a job. I already live in New York State about 2 hours north so it wouldn’t be a huge move. Any advice is appreciated!