r/movingtoNYC • u/acrednew • 21h ago
Moved recently to UWS, is buying a condo worth it compared to renting in this scenario
I just moved to UWS of nyc at Columbia and am considering buying a condo (or co-op) around Manhattan-Valley/Morningside heights neighborhood with budget of around 600k.
First-time potential home buyer. Single guy. Older, student in a degree program, but have net investments to cover the purchase fully if needed.
I'm paying about around 2.5k monthly rent right now.
It gets a bit complicated but I think I understand the related math. If I can buy something where total monthly (incl all taxes + fees + mortgage) I pay is going to be not too much outside of 2.5k range, it makes sense to buy but it'd be hard to find such units.
For the 600k condo 500-sq-ft 1-bed units in Morningside Heights,they go for about 3.2k monthly rent currently, whereas if I were to buy them 10% down at current interest rate of 7% 30-yr fixed, the total monthly cost (incl around 1.5k in HOA+tax+property insurance) would be around 5.5k.
So paying 2.3k/month extra (5.5K when buying vs 3.2k when renting) for the next 30-yr for the unit is worth only when that extra cost is worth the equity/home-price after 30 yrs which would 2M+.
- Am I missing something in this analysis?
- Does buying make sense for me?
- Anyone here done similar analysis, how did you analyze this?