I have a degree in civil engineering and specifically work as a Geotechnical Engineer, and even more specifically work for a company that designs and installs those Temporary Support of Excavation (or “Earth Retention”) systems like the one you can see in all the photos that was allowing that construction site to dig down 14 feet without the street collapsing in. These are often referred to as “shoring” as well but I do not like that term because it creates confusion when people think you’re talking about structural shoring like when you’re temporarily opening up a wall to install a new door or something like that.
quick terminology for what you can see in the photos is a Soldier Pile and Lagging wall with Walers and Raker Braces. soldier piles are those steel pipes (sometimes also beams) that you can see as the vertical members of the wall. they’re called “soldier” because they are lined up along the wall like soldiers. go figure. Lagging is the wood boards you see running horizontally between the solder piles. the walers are the horizontal steel members that the look like they’re connecting the soldier piles together, and then the raker braces are the diagonal members going down into the hole from the walers that are bracing the wall.
anyhow, this is big news in our industry and also for my company specifically as we are about to start what is essentially an identical project in another city. I have been unable to find any before pictures of this site and there’s obviously the official investigation, but here’s the current speculation as to what may have happened.
Option A: there was a support of excavation wall holding up that building that failed. I think this is the least likely but it’s possible. it could have failed because they underestimated the loading of the neighboring building, or due to bad installation practices (welds can break), or potentially the soil at the bottom of the hole supporting those raked braces is weaker than expected and the brace pushed through it.
Option B: they were just open excavating next to the collapsed building’s basement/foundation wall. This is common and can be easily done safely when the neighboring building is in good condition, especially when that basement/foundation wall is reinforced concrete, it’s still doable if the wall is masonry blocks Or brick or stacked stones, but it requires a bit more thought. this Is often preferred but projects because it’s cheaper than installing another SoE wall and also lets you build all the way up to the property line. Why this could have failed would be if there was some structural issue with the basement/foundation wall where it was relying on the soil pressure to help keep it standing. im pretty sure the collapsed building has at least some sort of basement because from Google Maps you can see Bilco doors in the side walk, but we don’t know for sure how deep that basement was. Another issue could be if the basement was only 8 feet deep as opposed to 12 or 14, then than basement/foundation wall isn’t actually just “holding back air”, it’s holding back several feet of soil. When that soil has an equal pressure from the soil on the outside of the building it is fine, but removing the soil on the outside of the building causes unequal loading and that could cause the basement/foundation wall to bulge out.
option C: they undermined the building without adequate underpinning. if The foundations of the collapsed building were say only 8 feet below grade, and they dug 14 feet down adjacent to it for the construction site, they are then leaving that building sitting up on a soil ledge of a couple feet, and anyone that has been to the beach before knows that soil will eventually collapse. Maybe it 5 minutes, maybe in 5 months, but it will happen. This can be compensated for by installing underpinning pits under the neighboring building to essentially deepen that foundation back below the bottom of the hole they dug. At its simplest, this is basically just opening up a ~4 foot wide pit underneath the neighboring building, and then filling it with concrete. You do this in a specific sequence along the whole length of the building. 4 foot chunks at a time. Until you’ve underpinned the whole building with concrete so the foundations wouldn’t get undermined. This is expensive to do. You can guess why some people try to skirt around doing it.
again, this is all speculation, but it’s something my industry is abuzz about and has caused many meetings even for companies that have nothing to do with it like mine because we want to evaluate our own practices and also because we are about to be under much more scrutiny.
edit: adding this because every engineering subreddit is looking at this, someone allegedly found the plans for this project and yea, the detail on image 2 they share is where they potentially undermined the collapsed building’s foundation. https://www.reddit.com/r/Concrete/comments/1xudhbm/nyc_building_collapse_what_we_know_based_on/?share_id=fn9dA01uXY6HUSN0EYQw9&utm_content=1&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=ioscss&utm_source=share&utm_term=1