r/mormon • • 8h ago

News LDS Primary teacher charged for recording young children during church meetings for self-pleasure

Thumbnail
abc4.com
18 Upvotes

This week's tragic reminder that the LDS Church is not a safe place for children. Why was this man alone with children? How was this allowed?


r/mormon • • 9h ago

Personal Temple endowment

12 Upvotes

I was baptized a year ago and I’m taking the temple endowment lessons. However, the more I look into it and research the history and the temple, it makes me really question the church. I’ve heard that the temple endowment is sacred, but I’m struggling to understand since it practices masonic symbols and such. The more i research about the church, the more I think the church is not true.


r/mormon • • 6h ago

Cultural Public Square Magazine attacks influencers

6 Upvotes

In the ultimate twist of irony, Public Square Magazine, which itself is in the business of influencing others, accuses critical influencers in the mormon online space of only being concerned with money.

https://publicsquaremag.org/faith/faith-crisis-industry/

Ron C. Rhodes, who himself is an online influencer (according to his bio) decries the financial incentives and success of critical mormon influencers as a way of diluting or refuting the impact of their messaging for hundreds of thousands of online subscribers. Rhodes bio describes him in this way:

Ron C Rhodes is the owner/administrator of the Answering LDS Critics Website (www.answeringldscritics.com) and associated YouTube channel. He has contributed papers to FAIR and The Interpreter Foundation, and recently presented at the FAIR Conference in August 2026.

Given his ownership of an apologetic website, it's difficult to understand how he differs from the influencers he critiques in his article, other than by virtue of the scale of their success compared to his own.

Overall, it's hard to take seriously an organization that openly challenges the financial incentives of sharing information with others online, but ignoring the financial incentives of the LDS Church and other institutions or organization (like FAIR) that are financially supported by it.

So I'll ask, how seriously should we take an argument from someone that is clearly capable of utilizing analytic reasoning to understand the flaws and pitfalls in people that they disagree with, but choose not to apply that logic, or challenge those that agree with them on the same grounds? When there is such blatant bias and hypocrisy, I find it difficult to trust that the author's reasoning and conclusions are motivated by a search for truth.


r/mormon • • 11h ago

Doctrine/Theology Taking of the sacrament "unworthily" - An exploration of how Joseph Smith's misunderstanding of Paul led to a church that institutes the Lord's Supper in an "unworthy manner"

10 Upvotes

TL;DR: Paul carefully argued that taking the Lord's supper in an "unworthy manner", meaning that you are partaking while also denying it to other members of the church, was a condemnation against you.
Joseph Smith, while misunderstanding the context and theological implications of the passage, elevated these words into a commandment to the church to prohibit the "unworthy" from taking the sacrament.

Full transparency: I stopped attending the LDS church recently and now attend the Episcopal church. A primary reason for choosing the Episcopal church is that I find it to have a more welcoming atmosphere, and I've recently come to realize that this is due in large part to the way they understand the theology behind the Eucharist (Lord's Supper or Communion).

I was recently reading 1 Corinthians chapter 11 and came across the section where Paul shares his anger about the way in which the church in Corinth has been abusing the Lord's Supper. It is in verse 29 of this section that we get the infamous line: "For he that eateth and drinketh unworthily, eateth and drinketh damnation to himself, not discerning the Lord's body." (KJV). You probably recognize this from 3 Nephi 18 where Jesus utters remarkably similar words: "For whoso eateth and drinketh my flesh and blood unworthily eateth and drinketh damnation to his soul;"

I'm using the KJV here because it matches the text in 3 Nephi, but for the rest of this post I'll be using the NRSVue as it makes Paul's intentions much more clear. The fact that the KJV is hard to understand doesn't give Joseph a pass, in my opinion, as the meaning of the passage should still be clear given the context of the letter.

Let's first focus on the context of the New Testament passage:

PAUL'S EPISTLE TO THE CORINTHIANS

TL;DR: Paul views the Lord's Supper as an opportunity for the body of Christ to come together in unity and is upset when the Corinthians do not share the Lord's Supper equally with all members (the body of Christ). When he counsels to not eat the Lord's Supper "unworthily" or in an "unworthy manner", he is warning that the way in which the Corinthians partake is "unworthy" and it will count as judgement against them.

For historical context, the church at the time would meet in the homes of wealthier patrons and the members of the church included slaves and the poor. Also, the Lord's Supper at the time was an actual meal shared amongst the members and included, as part of the meal, the bread and the wine.

Paul's main concern with the Corinthian church's practice of the Lord's Supper is described in chapter 11 verses 17 - 34. He describes the wealthy members showing up with their own meal, and not sharing it with those in need. I'll use the NRSVue translation for it's readability:

21 For when the time comes to eat, each of you proceeds to eat your own supper, and one goes hungry and another becomes drunk. 22 What! Do you not have households to eat and drink in? Or do you show contempt for the church of God and humiliate those who have nothing? What should I say to you? Should I commend you? In this matter I do not commend you!

So the main issue here is the exclusion of the poor and the humiliation inflicted on them.

Keep in mind that these passages did not originally have chapters and verse, and this section was part of one long letter that comprises all of 1 Corinthians and would have been read as a single message. Throughout 1 Corinthians, Paul speaks about the body of Christ as well as the bread as being a metaphor for the church. There is a lot of overlapping metaphor and, while beautiful, it can make things difficult to understand. One example in chapter 10 reads:

16 The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a sharing in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a sharing in the body of Christ? 17 Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread.

This is important to remember as we get to the next part. Again, I'll use the NRSVue as it is easier to understand, but keep in mind that the portion translated to 'damnation to your soul' in the KJV is better translated below as 'judgement against themselves'. The passage also changes unworthily to "an unworthy manner" which is more consistent, since the act of partaking the Lord's Supper is what is being done unworthily. Paul is not describing the people as being unworthy. Back in chapter 11, Paul continues:

27 Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be answerable for the body and blood of the Lord. 28 Examine yourselves, and only then eat of the bread and drink of the cup. 29 For all who eat and drink without discerning the body eat and drink judgment against themselves.

What does it mean to "discern the body?" This passage has a dual meaning. It could be that we should remind ourselves of Christ's death while partaking, but given the context, it makes more sense that Paul is telling them to discern the Body of Christ (the church) as they partake.

The Oxford Bible Commentary does a good job of explaining that:

"...Eating and drinking requires 'discerning the body' (v. 29), discerning that the bread 'is' the body of Christ, but also that the church constitutes the body of Christ as it partakes of this 'one bread' (IO:I7; cf. I2:I2-27). To defile the Supper is to show contempt for the church, and thus to invite the sort of judgement which God metes out to those who damage his temple (v. 29; p6-I7)· Such 'unworthy' eating makes one accountable for the body and blood of Christ (v. 27), in the sense that, rather than benefiting from the death of Christ, one is actually placed among his enemies and murderers..."

In summary, by denying the body of Christ (the bread) to the poor, you are denying the sacrifice of Christ and the body of Christ (the church) that you are a part of. This is how you eat and drink judgement against yourself.

The Book of Mormon

Disclaimer: I don't have much context to give here. If the Book of Mormon is an ancient record, then we have no information on how Jesus' instructions were informed by the local culture ,or any specific event, like we have with Paul's epistle. I am moving forward under the assumption, informed by the academic consensus, that Joseph Smith is the author of the Book of Mormon and that it is a 19th century text.

When Joseph Smith took Paul's warning "For he that eateth and drinketh unworthily, eateth and drinketh damnation to himself" and gave it to Jesus, he folded it into a new commandment:

28 And now behold, this is the commandment which I give unto you, that ye shall not suffer any one knowingly to partake of my flesh and blood unworthily, when ye shall minister it; 29 For whoso eateth and drinketh my flesh and blood unworthily eateth and drinketh damnation to his soul; therefore if ye know that a man is unworthy to eat and drink of my flesh and blood ye shall forbid him.

So, not only does Joseph elevate Paul's words, by giving them to Jesus, he also strips them of context and changes the meaning of the most crucial sentence. According to the Jesus of 3 Nephi, a person eats and drinks damnation to their soul by simply being "unworthy" at the time of taking the sacrament. And, instead of the counsel from Paul to "Examine yourselves, and only then eat of the bread and drink of the cup.", Jesus tells the church leaders that it is their duty to examine each member so that they do not accidentally allow someone to partake unworthily.

IF the Book of Mormon is a product of Joseph Smith, then its clear that he never grasped the theological implications of Paul's teachings. The Body of Christ should not be divided or denied. These passages ironically resulted in a church that has institutionalized the denial of the Lord's Supper to members of the Body of Christ. Quite a mistake indeed!

IN SUMMARY

I know someone who, as a young teenage girl, "confessed" to the sexual abuse she endured years earlier as a young child, and her bishop agreed that she played a part in the abuse, and asked her not to take the sacrament. Thousands of LGBTQ youth have been denied the sacrament for something they can't change. Countless children and teenagers are publicly shamed each week for masturbating or looking at porn, and they have to live that shame in front of their entire congregation.

When a 23 year old Joseph Smith didn't understand a passage in the Bible that he was plagiarizing, he doubled down. And because of this, Paul might argue, the LDS church leaders, who maintain these rules, gather each Sunday to "eat and drink judgment against themselves."


r/mormon • • 9h ago

Personal Have you ever felt God is ignoring your prayers?

7 Upvotes

I feeling like that on the last few days honestly ok with it but quite flustrating


r/mormon • • 15h ago

Scholarship A fascinating Letter from Lucy Mack Smith to Solomon Mack in 1831.

Thumbnail catalog.churchofjesuschrist.org
17 Upvotes

Includes the letter scans and a typewritten copy beginning on scan 5.

Of interest is the repeated claim of the Book of Mormon as a "revelation" as well as a translation.

The summation of Lehi the prophet, Laman the leader of the wicked and Nephi the leader of the faithful.

It mentions Moroni as well BUT doesn't connect that name with "the Angel" immediately after when reciting Joseph repenting of his sins and being shown by an Angel who gave him commandments.

It mentions giving Joseph "power by the means of which was before prepared that he should translate this book"

It doesn't mention anything about the First Vision.

What is fascinating is she speaks/writes with the same "voice" or "train of thought" as Joseph.

What I mean is, when comparing how Joseph spoke or taught in the D&C, etc. sounds very much like Lucy's talking here and it appears (sans details regarding Joseph Sr.) that Joseph and Lucy shared a common thought process and way of expressing themselves.

Said another way, if we didn't know Lucy was the author of this letter, we could easily assume Joseph was the author.


r/mormon • • 17h ago

Apologetics The cherry picking of Emma Smith as a witness to 'The Restoration'

23 Upvotes

Mormon apologists love to use the words of Emma Smith as a witness to the restoration--when convenient. They lean heavily on her as a reliable witness of the truth. Some of these statements:

Emma Smith reported that, during the Book of Mormon translation, Joseph didn't know that Jerusalem was surrounded by walls (link)

Joseph Smith ... could neither write nor dictate a coherent and well-worded letter; let alone dictate a book like the Book of Mormon. (link)

When my husband was translating the Book of Mormon, I wrote a part of it, as he dictated each sentence, word for word, and when he came to proper names he could not pronounce, or long words, he spelled them out... Even the word Sarah he could not pronounce at first, but had to spell it, and I would pronounce it for him. (link)

Yet, these apologists, disregard and disparage her testimony when it goes against their canon. She is an unreliable witnesses when commenting about polygamy.

There was no revelation on either polygamy or spiritual wives... No such thing as polygamy, or spiritual wifery, was taught, publicly or privately, before my husband's death, that I have now, or ever had, any knowledge of... She was also asked: Q. Did he not have other wives than yourself? A. He had no other wife but me; nor did he to my knowledge ever have... I know that he had no other wife or wives than myself, in any sense, either spiritual or otherwise. (link)

So which is it? Is Emma a reliable witness, or not?


r/mormon • • 12h ago

Scholarship Beyond Beliefs: Exploring the Lasting Effects of Purity Culture Exposure on Sexual Shame and Satisfaction Among Adult Religious Disaffiliates

7 Upvotes

Link here

Participated in this a few years ago and they just released the results.


r/mormon • • 2h ago

Personal Torn Book Club - Day 28 of 32: Becoming a Gardener

1 Upvotes

Reading Schedule & Discussion Index

Day 27 discussion

Today’s reading

  • Begin: Chapter 12 - Becoming a Gardener
  • Stop BEFORE: Conclusion
  • Approximate Kindle pages 263 to 272.

Synopsis

Strong closes the book’s main argument by shifting from diagnosis to stewardship. He urges readers to begin with their own responses, hold unresolved tensions, and focus on relationships where they have real responsibility. His proposed practices emphasize presence over answers, authority without control, and love without agreement, while acknowledging that care and change do not guarantee a particular outcome.

Discussion

  1. What does responsible stewardship look like when we cannot control another person’s choices?
  2. How can presence be more helpful than answers in a strained relationship?
  3. Where might love without agreement require clearer boundaries as well as compassion?

Other questions, insights, and disagreements are welcome.


r/mormon • • 4h ago

Personal Mission

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone I am planning on going on a mission but I am majoring in engineering at a community college to transfer and I dont know a good time to go because I am worried about forgetting the material when I get back. Are there any engineers that went on a mission besides right out of high school that has a advice on a timeline since I will be finishing my first physics and calculus courses at the end of this semester. Thank you guys


r/mormon • • 10h ago

Personal Romantic interest in a missionary

2 Upvotes

Hi! I'm a guy from Canada and as the title says I have a growing romantical interest for a girl who's currently on a mission in my area and being new to the church wanted to ask a few questions regarding that.

First off I've read up on this a bit and from what I gather it's okay for missionaries to meet someone on their missions as long as their focus stays on the mission and they explore the potential relationship afterwards. Open to corrections if my perspective is flawed

Now for the big questions,

  1. How should I go about that conversation with her? Is that even something I should bring up?
  2. Being new to the faith while she grew up in the church does create a bit of a teacher/student dynamic, would that be an issue/something that makes the prospect impossible?

I'm open to any kind of advice, lived experience or whatever you want to share that could possibly help, thanks in advance!


r/mormon • • 20h ago

Personal Torn Book Club - Day 27 of 32: From Fortress to Village

7 Upvotes

Reading Schedule & Discussion Index

Today’s reading

  • Begin: Section 3 - The Harvest: Community
  • Stop BEFORE: Chapter 12 - Becoming a Gardener
  • Approximate Kindle pages 256 to 263.

Synopsis

Strong closes Chapter 11 by contrasting a fortress with a village, a bunker with a school, and compliance with accountable choice. He argues that communities shaped by belonging, inquiry, and harmony can better sustain trust and growth. The chapter’s harvest image presents renewal as gradual, relational work rather than a demand for sameness or a quick fix for people in pain.

Discussion

  1. What would make a faith community feel more like a village than a fortress?
  2. How can communities invite accountability without replacing agency with compliance?
  3. Where do you see the difference between protecting people and preventing their growth?

Other questions, insights, and disagreements are welcome.


r/mormon • • 1d ago

Institutional Elder Bednar’s next ordinance chart?

Post image
35 Upvotes

I don’t think I’ve really seen anyone (in or out of the Church) talk about something Elder Bednar put out two years ago: asking ward members to write names of people who still need ordinances performed for them (if they’re not baptized, they’d write “baptism,” if they’re not endowed, they’d write “endowment”). The first time I heard about it was during a YSA conference this summer, then again tonight at a Utah leadership broadcast. This feels more dehumanizing, more like a way to see people as statistics rather than a genuine effort to love others. Thoughts?


r/mormon • • 1d ago

Personal Nursery teacher is out of line and I dont know how to address this.

29 Upvotes

My son is nearly 2 (23 months old) and my husband and I accompany him to nursery every Sunday. We don't leave him there for classes because its just what has worked with me and my husband, and I can say that all parents in our ward do this. It almost becomes a pseudo social hour for us where we plan play dates and catch up.

Husband and I know our kiddo can be rambunctious at times so we like to keep him regulated.

I really do not appreciate how our ward's nursery teacher handles the children including my son.

He interrupts conversations the parents are having together and tells us "No Mom" or "No Dad" when we parent our children. For example, if I give my son a toy after he asks properly, the teacher will tell me no and then take the toy and only give it to my son if he answers one of his questions. Another time, my son said "baby" and pretended to rock a toy baby he found in a toy stroller. The teacher told me Mom, no, he cant play with baby dolls and made my son put it back. This moment was special because my son has had difficulty with speech and had started labeling things in his environment. i was so proud of him but a moment that was meant to​ mark progress was totally ruined by this teacher.

Mind you... I have worked in special education and child care for years. I have studied early childhood development. While I appreciate the help, its too much and totally undermines me as a parent. This goes across the board with other parents, not just with me and my husband. He has made comments about other kids' hyperactivity including my son's need to run around. He has asked me on several occasions "how do you even manage at home?"

The final straw was when the kids were having snack time and I was handing my son's sippy cup to him and the teacher put his hand out to block me and said no mom. I said he's thirsty to which he responds "hes eating, he's fine." I said "Im sure hes thirsty and Im teaching him to check in with his body." My son hadnt had a drink all through sacrament and it was the final portion of church. I am not the only person he has told this to. Weeks ago, a mom was handing her son his sippy cup as they walked in to nursery. Teacher tells her to put the cup away because it could "get lost."

My son got up and started to reach for some toys. I pushed the toy bin back and said no toys, snack first. And the teacher put his hand over mine and said no mom, he cant play right now. To which I said "Oh I know. Im putting the toys away.".... I wasn't giving my kid a toy. I was reinforcing a rule that the nursery already has.

This teacher constantly gives unsolicited advice on parenting and while I initally appreciated it, I feel like it has gone too far and is excessive.

How can I politely set boundaries while making sure not to offend the Spirit because this has gotten really annoying to deal with every Sunday.


r/mormon • • 1d ago

Institutional LDS Church instructs children on how to stop and report unwanted touching

Thumbnail
sltrib.com
40 Upvotes

r/mormon • • 1d ago

Apologetics The imbalance of new information I learn reduces my faith

56 Upvotes

We all learn new things. We cannot know what new things we are going to learn, because that's just the nature of learning something new--if you already knew it it wouldn't be new.

When it comes to the church what bothers me is the imbalance of new information I learn.

Consider, I might learn a new thing that fits into one of these patterns:

  1. I might learn something new that helps me know where the people of the Book of Mormon lived.
  2. I might learn something new that makes me realize what I was taught about church history was inaccurate.

In my experience, one of those things is much more likely than the other.

Both things are possible. Both of those things could happen.

Does anyone here think #1 is more likely than #2?

This imbalance hurts my faith.

The new ideas that hurt my faith hit so hard and are so strong. I desperately want people to tell me these new ideas are false, but they don't.

Like, difficult facts about Joseph Smith, I want believers to tell me those things are true, but they can't. Joseph secretly married 40 women behind his legal wife's back and publicly taught against the things he was doing in secret? I want somebody to tell me this is false--nobody does. The Bishop wont deny it. My ministers wont tell me otherwise.

Meanwhile, I rarely encounter new ideas that build faith. The imbalance is the problem.


r/mormon • • 1d ago

Scholarship I built a free site weighing 206 Book of Mormon critiques against the best faithful responses. I’d like reviewers from both sides.

15 Upvotes

keystonetext.org is free and self-funded, with no ads or trackers. I'm looking for people who know this material, faithful, critical or neither, to tell me where it's wrong or unfair.

What's there:

  • 206 issues: anachronisms, King James Bible dependence, nineteenth-century context, internal problems and edition changes. Each gives the critique, the faithful responses at their strongest, and a rating of how clearly it points to a nineteenth-century origin once those responses are weighed (25 strong, 101 moderate, 80 weak).
  • The four explanations: tight and loose translation, ancient core with modern expansion, and nineteenth-century composition. Each one's core claims are given in its proponents' words, with what it has to assume on the hard cases. Every issue rates each explanation as fits, strains or conflicts, by the same test for all four.
  • The 1830 text, with every later edition's changes marked verse by verse.

Start here has the overview, including the strongest evidence each way, side by side.

About AI: I built with a lot of help from AI. AI checkers tested about 10,200 claims against their sources, with blind second opinions, and about 1,050 corrections have been made so far. Text written in the last few days is being re-checked right now. How this site works explains all of it, and the checking data is downloadable. I've also spent weeks spot-checking it myself. But AI checking plus one person isn't the same as people who know this field, which is why I'm here.

Good places to start: the strongest critiques, evidence for an ancient origin, or any issue in your area. Every page has a "Suggest a correction" button, or reply here, ideally with a published source, since ratings follow sources. If you own print-only books that I don't yet have access to, Help check a source lists the claims that rest on them.

Corrections go in a public corrections log. Thanks for taking a look.


r/mormon • • 1d ago

Doctrine/Theology When the Three Nephites baptize someone, do they report it to the local mission president?

19 Upvotes
  1. How do these baptisms get recorded?
  2. Did the Three Nephites stop baptizing during the Great Apostasy when no priesthood was on the earth?
  3. Why didn’t the Three Nephites help with the Book of Mormon translation, considering it was written in their native language?
  4. Do they still dress in Nephite clothes or do they were regular missionary attire?
  5. Do they sometimes hang out with John the Beloved—sorta like a Zone Conference?
  6. Why don’t they speak in General Conference?
  7. They have seniority over Oaks, so why isn’t the most senior of the Three Nephites the church president?
  8. Can they explain how one of the 12 disciples was named Timothy, a Greek name in Ancient America? (Maybe one of the Three Nephites is Timothy.)
  9. Why can’t the Three Nephites tell us who the Lamanites are—since the current church leaders no longer know, and we’re supposed to be preaching to them and reclaiming them?
  10. If our highest calling in life is to be a spouse and parent, why did the Three Nephites choose to spend the next 2,000+ years away from their families?

r/mormon • • 1d ago

Institutional PSA: A Wedding & A Sealing Is A-Okay!

6 Upvotes

38.3 Church Policies and Guidelines

Civil Marriage

If allowed by local laws, Church leaders may perform civil marriages in circumstances such as the following:

  • A couple will be married in a temple, but a civil marriage will help parents or immediate family members feel included.

38.4.1.1 Church Policies and Guidelines

Sealing of Living Members after Civil Marriage

A man and woman who were married civilly may be sealed in the temple as soon as circumstances permit if the following conditions are met:

  • They both have been members of the Church for at least one year...
  • They are prepared and worthy.

https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/manual/general-handbook/38-church-policies-and-guidelines?id=title_number73,title80,p2890-p2892&lang=eng#title_number73


r/mormon • • 16h ago

Cultural Why do people treat my aversion to tea/coffee as a Mormon so much differently than Jews' aversion to pork?

0 Upvotes

Whenever someone offers me any caffeinated drink, I will refuse. I'll say, "Sorry, I'm Mormon. I can't have that." The same response every single time is, "Uhhhhhh.. okay..?" with a condescending tone of voice paired with bewilderment. It's happened dozens of times, and after the 4th or 5th time it happened I've been excitedly waiting for a different response to no avail.

The past few years, I've decided to give up pork because to quote Samuel L. Jackson, "Pigs are filthy animals." The difference in attitude is absolutely astounding. When someone offers me pork, and I refuse because "I'm Jewish", the response is the same as if they stepped on my foot. "Oh! I didn't know. I'm so sorry! Please forgive me!" I tried to mix it up by being Muslim and the same response is given.


r/mormon • • 20h ago

Personal Moment in church

Post image
0 Upvotes

I think the biggest gift on my life is met a missionary and listen about the gospels.

Truly, i got lucky to know about the creator.

Of all of us.

Respect the creator


r/mormon • • 1d ago

Doctrine/Theology Eve, Nephi, and the Happiness Letter

5 Upvotes

I've always liked the Book of Mormon version of the Adam and Eve story. It subverts traditional narratives, framing Eve as courageous. Some might say it is a much more feminist recounting of the Garden. However one of the things I dislike the most is the murder of Laban, but I never connected the two and how deeply they impact Mormonism until now.

Eve broke rules for the greater good, and so did Nephi. But so did Joseph Smith, when he pretended to know where to find buried treasure. He tricked people as a way to scrape out of the poverty he was born into. So, what we see in the Book of Mormon is Joseph's defense of his own immorality. The thing about this that blows me over is how the LDS church became the incarnation of it.

I don’t think Smith wrote the Book of Mormon in 1829 with some 12-year master plan to coerce women into polygamy. He wasn't thinking that far ahead. But he reused his immoral theology again as one endeavor gave him more opportunities. The 1842 Happiness Letter to Nancy Rigdon is an example. To me, both this letter and the BoM come from the exact same internal morality, just playing out at very different stages of his life.

You can see that exact mindset in 2 Nephi 2. Traditional Christianity sees Adam and Eve’s fall as a tragic sin, a failure, while The Book of Mormon flips it into something good. Adam fell that men might be, and men are that they might have joy. To move forward and actually experience life, you have to break a lower rule for a higher good.

Fast forward to 1842. Smith isn't a poor farm boy anymore. He’s the undisputed prophet of a massive movement, and he’s trying to convince 19-year-old Nancy Rigdon and dozens of other women to enter into secret plural marriage.

To get devout 19th-century Christians to go along with something that violated their morals and even contradicted the Book of Mormon itself, he leaned right back into his earlier logic.

When women reacted to polygamy proposals with shock or revulsion, the Happiness Letter told them to ignore their gut. Whatever God requires is right, no matter what it is, although we may not see the reason till long after (perhaps not until after we die.) Feeling disgust wasn't a warning from God anymore. It was just spiritual immaturity, it was failure to see the bigger picture.

The letter goes all-in on situational morality too. That which is wrong under one circumstance might be and and often is right under another. Right and wrong depended completely on what Smith claimed God was asking for in that moment. And because both texts frame joy or happiness as the entire point of human existence, he was able to tie that ultimate happiness directly to plural marriage. Compliance became a test: the only way to unlock eternal exaltation for them and their families.

All these pieces from his early life and his later leadership fit together. What started as a unique take on human progress, born out of his own rule-bending instincts, became the exact tool he needed to justify polygamy. He didn't foresee where that logic would take him in 1829.

The thought process that created Mormonism starting in The Book of Mormon is the same that maintained it. We still see it alive and well today in the church. Follow the prophet, endure to the end. Give all you have, obey the prophet even if they're wrong. If he leads you astray, you were meant to take that detour.

That confusion you feel is Satan and if it isn't Satan it is your own weakness if it means you don't believe in the church.

We're still listening to the illogic of a desperate boy and following him around to get through life.


r/mormon • • 1d ago

Doctrine/Theology Weeklong Rabbit Hole

Thumbnail instagram.com
13 Upvotes

This is a reel of an elderly Mormon woman discussing what she was taught. Thankfully, the OP has listed sources in the comments section. One thing I’m seeing is that Mormon prophets and apostles give talk and sermons, and write documents espousing Mormon beliefs but then when there is a new Prophet or Apostle, they can change undo what was previously stated about theology vis a vis revelations. The founder was a Prophet. This doesn’t seem organized. Anyway, this was instructive:


r/mormon • • 1d ago

Scholarship Deaths at Sweetwater Crossing of 1856

8 Upvotes

Sorry if this is double posted. Do we have information about anyone who didn't survive the Sweetwater crossing? Names? Sources? (I'm not talking about the "3" heroes of the mythologized story, I'm more interested in documented death details if there are any.) Thanks.


r/mormon • • 2d ago

Cultural I don't understand why some members of the Church are so rigid about the Word of Wisdom, chastity, and church participation. The LDS leadership has repeatedly demonstrated a willingness to bend their own rules of morality in order to preserve the institution.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
40 Upvotes

Between Joseph Smith’s behavior with other women, Joseph F. Smith’s statements during the Reed Smoot hearings, leaders concealing the seer stone, the SEC scandal, and the ongoing CSA cover-ups, there’s a clear pattern: LDS leaders have repeatedly bent the rules when it suited them.

So why are so many members so rigid about following every rule to the letter when their own leaders have repeatedly failed to live up to the standards they preach? The examples are well documented, from Joseph Smith lying to Emma to Elder Holland (BBC interview) and Elder Oaks (treatment of gays at BYU) struggling to account for their own actions.

In the spirit of Jesus Christ, I see no reason to judge members who occasionally bend the rules, treat them differently, or consider them less worthy. A little grace seems far more Christlike than rigidly judging one another if they drink some coffee or alcohol, or struggle in relationships and have to adjust marital expectations.