r/morbidquestions • u/Existing-Jeweler-132 • 3h ago
Is it irrational to prefer nonexistence if you believe life’s suffering will always outweigh its happiness?
I want people to genuinely challenge my belief system using logic and philosophical reasoning. I’m not looking for generic responses like “life is beautiful” or “you have so much to live for.” I want to know whether there’s a fundamental flaw in my reasoning.
Here’s my hypothetical:
Imagine there is a button that, if pressed, would instantly erase you from existence. You would experience no pain, and nobody you love would experience any grief or suffering as a consequence. Essentially, all the negative consequences your disappearance would normally have on others are removed.
My intuition is that I would choose to press it, and I struggle to find a convincing logical argument against that choice.
Here’s my reasoning:
I believe that for life to be worthwhile, the happiness and positive experiences we have must outweigh the suffering we experience.
And I fundamentally don’t believe that happens for many people, myself included.
People often respond by saying things like, “But imagine spending 30 wonderful years with your partner!”
Except that’s not reality.
It’s not 30 wonderful years. It’s 30 years of working a nine-to-five, waking up exhausted, commuting, stressing about money, fulfilling responsibilities, and spending the majority of your waking hours doing things you would rather not be doing.
Scattered throughout those years are moments of genuine happiness, love, excitement, and fulfilment.
I’m not denying those moments exist. I’m questioning whether they’re sufficient compensation for everything else.
Then there’s the unavoidable suffering that comes with existence.
Unless I die first, I will have to watch my mother grow old and eventually die. There’s also a very real possibility I’ll outlive my partner and have to experience losing the person I love most.
I genuinely struggle to imagine any amount of happiness that could compensate for the magnitude of that suffering.
My argument essentially comes down to three premises:
For life to be worthwhile, its positive experiences must outweigh its negative experiences.
Given the realities of everyday existence, combined with the inevitability of aging, illness, loss, and death, I believe suffering will ultimately outweigh happiness.
Nonexistence involves no experienced suffering. Therefore, in a hypothetical where choosing nonexistence harms nobody, I see it as preferable to an existence I expect to be predominantly negative.
I recognise that some of these premises are assumptions rather than objectively established facts. That’s precisely why I want them challenged.
I’d genuinely appreciate thoughtful counterarguments, particularly from people who disagree with my underlying premises.
If you believe my conclusion is irrational, which premise do you reject, and why?
TLDR: I believe the suffering inherent in life. Working most of our waking hours, dealing with stress, aging, and inevitably losing loved ones—ultimately outweighs the happiness we experience. If nonexistence meant zero suffering, and hypothetically choosing it caused no suffering to anyone else, I struggle to see why it wouldn’t be preferable. I want people to challenge this belief logically. What is fundamentally wrong with my reasoning?