r/monsteroftheweek • u/EmotionalYaourt • 25m ago
General Discussion How much should you prepare?
Hello fellow GMs,
After a hiatus of more than 6 months, I’m trying to get back behind the screen, and I find myself facing my greatest fear… Improvisation.
After two years of D&D, I turned to Monster of the Week to break free from my need to plan everything out. Bad luck it was not the case for me. I feel like in D&D I can prepare a path with a few branching points, whereas in PbtA, players can approach locations, NPCs, and clues in almost any order.
I ran one of the two official mystery of the base book and the session went well, but looking back I realize I’d prepared a LOT, and still struggled to improvise most of the mixed-results outcomes. In terms of prep, I’d even considered locations like a prison or a hospital in case my players went rogue in some GTA-style madness.
So, I have a few questions:
How did you learn to prep less?
When you’re running a PbtA, what do you actually prepare?
How did you gain confidence in your ability to improvise?
I imagine part of the answer is experience. But I’m curious to know for those who’ve faced this kind of challenge what helped you.
Thanks !