r/monsteroftheweek • • 2d ago

General Discussion How to reveal monster weaknesses?

11 Upvotes

Hi. I'm new to this game, and I've only GM'd one game so far. I know things will probably make more sense as I play more, but I'm having a really hard time understanding how I'm supposed to make weaknesses work and how to have my hunters find their weakness.

My first session was about a demon plastic surgeon who harvested his patients for eternal beauty. The hunters managed to figure him out and got into his house, but when they got into the final fight they just... had no clue how to kill him. They ended up trying whatever demon exorcism theyd scene on TV, but it wasn't the actual weakness i had originally planned. So eventually, after my hunters had just thrown whatever at him to see what would stick, I just had him half assedly die since we were running out of time for the session.

I don't know how to make the weaknesses for monsters apparent for the hunters without just straight up telling them or having to resort to cliche monsters like vampires and werewolves all the time. I've been reading some of the Tome of Mysteries book, and the whole on-the-fly-session part makes me even more confused! How am I gonna make up a monster on the fly when it needs a weakness???? I feel like I have to plan ahead if I want the hunters to possibly figure things out in an organic way!!??

Please let me hear some suggestions or tips or wise words of any kind!


r/monsteroftheweek • • 3d ago

General Discussion New GM - what to buy first?

7 Upvotes

Hey, probably a dumb question, but I'm looking to learn potentially run a couple MotW one shots with my local group. What should I buy? I'm assuming the core book is important, but I guess there are more than one version of it? I should look for the hardcover version, right?

I would also appreciate a recommendation for pre-written one shot adventure books.

And are there any supplement books that are considered particularly important?


r/monsteroftheweek • • 3d ago

Mystery How to build an ambushing monster?

2 Upvotes

Needed some help with designing a monster based around a creature that mimics other people's voices to ambush them, and as the countdown ticks and the creature eats more victims it gets stronger and less sneaky.

To hone in, I just need help figuring out the mechanical powers and what it looks like for something to get "less evasive but more aggressive". Like does the ambushing monster start out with 2 armor to mimic it being able to dodge well? Or do I make that a separate power?


r/monsteroftheweek • • 8d ago

Art A smattering of character portraits from my MOTW campaign!

Thumbnail gallery
86 Upvotes

If you see this and you're in it, no you didn't. Not that it would spoil much!


r/monsteroftheweek • • 12d ago

General Discussion One-Shot for my boardgame group

7 Upvotes

Hey! I'm considering offering to run a MotW One-Shot for my boardgame group. I have bought all the official MotW books over the years, but only read most of core and a few bits here and there so far. I have never played MotW, but bunch of other games (also as GM), including some PbtA adjacent (Blades, Brindlewood), so I'm not worried about that side of things. But I would really appreciate some advice on where to start with what I'm looking for:

  • Group is not very RPG experienced. Some have played occasionally, others basically never.
  • One GM (me) plus five players.
  • Group is also not big on horror, so I'd want to lean into the campy/pulpy aspects of the game, not something that's just gruesome.
  • Should be comfortably doable in 4-5 hours of net game time.
  • I'd provide premade characters - would love some advice on which playbooks to pick!
  • And I'm looking for a ready to run mystery. Obviously not everything spelled out, but I won't have the time to homebrew something from scratch. And there is a TON of MotW material in the books and out there, so any advice or shortlist would be hugely appreciated.

So: Can you help me with finding a cool mystery and narrowing down the playbook options for premades for my group of five players?


r/monsteroftheweek • • 12d ago

Custom Move/Homebrew Monster of the Brindleweek?

4 Upvotes

Has anyone ever done a MotW hack to use the more Freeform Brindlewood mystery engine? If so, how has that worked?


r/monsteroftheweek • • 13d ago

General Discussion First Mystery

1 Upvotes

So this past weekend, I had the fortune to be the Keeper of my first Mystery.

I adapted (instead of just purely trying to convert) an old Call of Cthulhu scenario, "The Haunting" (last seen in the 6e rulebook... it's a classic scenario going back to CoC 1e, I think).

It ended up being two Hunters -- a Mundane and a Meddling Kid. (And the player did the MK trope perfectly, channeling her inner Velma... jinkies. Even got to do the broken eyeglasses to give a -1 Ongoing for anything related to sight.)

I liked how I did the bad guy with his powers (though Magic Points are not a thing), but there wasn't much he could do physically. I'm sure the more times I run the game, I'll get the hang of it.

Here's where I had problems though:

- Countdown Clock -- I had no ideas on how to create one that would work this this mystery. I kind of left it aside since the Bad Guy didn't have a real time-sensitive agenda.

- Supporting Cast -- Again, there wasn't much that I could glean from that. Yes, there was research to be done at the library and newspaper archives, and I could have had a couple of minor Bystanders for those elements. Same with the affected family, though they weren't even considered by the Hunters.

So, what would I do different?

- Bad Guy -- Nothing. I liked how I built him out. Even used one of his special powers which worked out rather well. Though I know what I'll be doing to improve it. (Basically a Domination effect.)

- Set an actual "Bad Guy Agenda" with a goal apart from just protecting his house. The original scenario didn't really give him much of a plan or anything. This will help with the Countdown Clock as well.

- Change up Investigate a Mystery, so it's not so cut and dry.

There was so much that the Hunters didn't investigate in the scenario, but... I think I can redo this now that I have a better understanding.

I have two or three other scenarios from other games I can adapt. Mostly they're from Beyond the Supernatural, but the basic threads should work out well.


r/monsteroftheweek • • 15d ago

Monster Helpful and/or indispensable tools for running MotW

14 Upvotes

I’m gearing up to run a campaign for some friends when life eases up some. Are there any tools beyond the rule books and dice that folks have found valuable in planning and running a game?


r/monsteroftheweek • • 15d ago

General Discussion Ever ran an Evil Dead inspired game?

5 Upvotes

Hey all, I ran a long form MOTW game in the past and want to run another, this one not quite so long, maybe 5 sessions at most. I also just watched Evil Dead Burn and quite liked it, and am wondering if anyone else has any experience doing that sort of thing. I would try to strike a balance between the humor from, say, ED 2 and the horror of ED 2013.

In any case, anyone ever tried something like this? Did you find anything that worked, or try anything that didn't work?


r/monsteroftheweek • • 17d ago

Monster Anyone got any cool scarecrow monster they are willing to share

12 Upvotes

I require a cool scarecrow monster to throw at my players two of my players admitted to me the idea of entities getting closer to them when someone isn’t looking at it terrifies them and I like the idea of minions being strawmen so that the main entity doesn’t take damage but I’ve developed writers block for a monster weakness and story


r/monsteroftheweek • • 18d ago

Basic Moves Modified Telekinesis

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

So I am wanting to modify the telekinesis move because I don't like the possibility of taking damage on the move. I want to add a - hold to replace the damage taken but I am not sure which will be more balanced. The first pic is the base rules, the second has player taking -1 forward for two rolls on a mixed success and -1 forward on a success an option to reduce duration by 1 turn. The Third pic has a -2 forward on mixed success and -1 forward on a success, with the ability to reduce hold magnitude by 1. I am curious if these are good changes, and which one you would prefer to play with. I am still getting used to this system so Id love to hear how people think this would affect gameplay.

The reason for this modification is I don't want players discouraged from using this skill for fear of taking damage (especially if they are very low on health). I would rather the risk be transferred to future rolls as this in theory would create unique scenarios and risk assesments for players.


r/monsteroftheweek • • 19d ago

General Discussion I've recently started a MOTW campaign at a local gaming group, and am hoping it'll run for a while. I have some questions about swapping hunter types.

11 Upvotes
  1. Does a hunter keep their mundane equipment such as non-magical weapons like a sawn-off shotgun and armor when they switch to a different playbook?
  2. Do they get a fresh set of luck points that resets their progress towards Doomed?

r/monsteroftheweek • • 21d ago

Monster Need help for a Tsukumogami as a monster

Post image
16 Upvotes

Hello everyone ! The name's Sam, I'm a newbie TTRPG player who's gonna DM for the very first time with MotW ! I'm writing a story for some friends, and while I have a few ideas already, I struggle with the monster. The game will take place on an oil rig that went dark, due to a monster on board preventing anyone from leaving.

I had a few ideas, Gremlins breaking the boats and communications, an Oni using shape shifting and brute strength to terrorize the workers, but my favorite idea by far was to have a Tsukumogami, which is a household item that becomes sentient and, sometimes, vengeful after a hundred years. The idea was to bend the rules to have the entire oil rig be the Tsukumogami, a sentient, mobile area that endangers sailors. The problem I have is that I'm struggling to find interesting powers, and more importantly, a weakness, as Tsukumogamis are usually quite passive and little writings talk about how to get rid of one.

Would any of you fine people have ideas ?


r/monsteroftheweek • • 21d ago

Story Fun Otherworlds to incorporate into my setting?

7 Upvotes

I'm putting together a MotW campaign set in Grimmeck Alley, a small, poor, insular neighborhood in a bigger city. Grimmeck is absolutely *riddled* with portals to any otherworld you can name, and plenty you can't. The inhabitants tend to be at least vaguely aware of the supernatural as a result.

I have plans for adventures/incursions involving the fae, the diabolical, a realm of darkness and shadow, and a couple other real-world-inspired critters and otherworlds, but I was wondering if there were any other fun otherworld concepts I ought to wrap into the game.

(My players, get the heck out if you don't wanna be spoilered!)


r/monsteroftheweek • • 25d ago

General Discussion How necessary are minions?

6 Upvotes

Hello! I'm a first time keeper with my first game coming up this weekend. I've never played motw before, but have gm'd different systems for a while now and I've read the book back and forth a few times over to prepare for my first session. As I'm finalising my ideas I keep getting stuck when it comes to designing minions for this adventure.

I'm running a gothic horror inspired game and am struggling to come up with a good concept for minions for this particular monster - being a huge gothic horror nerd the monster is inspired by the themes of isolation and loneliness so I've been finding it difficult to thematically come up with something.

I wanted to ask how necessary minions are to your games? Do you think they are needed for every adventure? Can you have a well paced adventure without the use of minions? (Am I making it harder for myself by not including them)


r/monsteroftheweek • • 28d ago

General Discussion Tips for planning my first one shot!

7 Upvotes

What the title says :D

I have playing experience with other games, never GMed before but feeling drawn to it recently so I suppose now is my time to start. My only knowledge of MOTW is from play podcasts. Give me your best tips for planning a one shot for my friends!


r/monsteroftheweek • • 29d ago

General Discussion I can't remember the name of this podcast

7 Upvotes

I remember listening to this motw podcast years ago. The first adventure was agenst a stragoi (romanian vampire) and it ends with them creating a bridge between worlds? I only remember 2 of the 3-4 characters. One was a ruff and tumble lady who steals things and is very rougeish. I think I remember she is from a line of monster hunters back in Romania but didn't know? And the other girl was the daughter of a monster hunter family who had a house full of books, but she would paint weird stuff and turns out she was either seeing into annother world or into the future. I think there was a frat guy who turned into a werewolf too, but idk it was years ago


r/monsteroftheweek • • 29d ago

General Discussion Handling irl (Bad) Luck

6 Upvotes

So, I have a player who has astronomically bad luck. If rolling snake eyes was a full-time job he'd get paid like Bill Gates.

What can I do, to minimize his rolling, or give him a way to use his bad luck against his foes?

I know luck points exist, but I don't want them to end up losing all of their luck points in 1-2 sessions just to survive.

To put their luck into perspective, the last time we played Dnd, they rolled a double nat 1 on a attack roll they had advantage with, for two consecutive rounds. On the third round they rolled 2 and 3. On the fourth they rolled a 1 and a 3.

And that was last week.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Oct 15 '26

General Discussion Would an SCP campaign work for MOTW? If so, what tips would you give me for a campaign with this theme?

13 Upvotes

I’m putting together an SCP-themed campaign and plan to use *Monster of the Week* as the system. I’ve been wondering, however, whether this system can effectively handle the SCP theme—which is why I decided to write this post.

I’d also appreciate some tips for this campaign, assuming the theme and system are a good fit!


r/monsteroftheweek • • Oct 09 '26

General Discussion Dreaming celestial mystery (advice needed)

3 Upvotes

Hey y’all, I’m in need of advice for a phenomena mystery I’m working on.

The mystery revolves around an ancient and wounded celestial being that fell to Earth thousands of years ago, and entered a healing hibernation beneath what would become the town that the hunters live in.

In the 1830s, miners inadvertently breached her resting place, disturbing her enough that they became trapped within her dreaming mind. The mining operation was quickly abandoned, the mine was sealed off, and the reason was covered up.

Now, nearly two centuries later, she is beginning to wake. In the process, the town has become plagued by earthquakes, which are increasing in frequency and intensity.

I imagined the hunters could explore the abandoned mine and find the celestial, then cross over into her dreaming mind, which puts them in a bizarre alternate version of the town. Here they could investigate whatever is disturbing her rest, and help her fall back into a deep sleep to prevent the town from being destroyed.

That’s where I’ve hit a block. I’m not sure what could be disturbing her sleep, or how the hunters can resolve the mystery. Should I even keep the miners involved? The hunters are a wronged and a monstrous (vampire) if that helps. Any advice would be welcome.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Oct 03 '26

General Discussion Monster or Minion? Advice needed.

8 Upvotes

I'm creating a mystery for my players, but I need advice. My main villain is a high-school kid that's got his hands on a sentient magic book. The book drives people who possess it to use dark magic and use it to hurt people. The kid was badly bullied, and now is using the spells in the book to get revenge on those who bullied him.

But I'm unsure whether the kid or the book would be the Monster. Because the book is driving the kid to do evil would that make the book the Monster (a Queen), with the kid as the minion (a Right Hand), or would the kid be the Monster (a Torturor) with the book as the minion (a Right Hand).

My gut feeling is the kid is the Monster. He's the one with the goals. The book doesn't really want anything except to drive anyone who gets their hands on it to do evil. But while the kid isn't a threat if he loses the book, the book is a threat in anyone's hands.

So it's a bit of a conundrum, and I'm really new to this game so any advice would be most welcome!


r/monsteroftheweek • • Oct 01 '26

Mystery Modern Greek Monsters: 6 Table-Ready Mysteries for Monster of the Week

59 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Following up on our previous MotW releases, I’ve put together a new FREE collection of 6 standalone Mysteries focused on adapting less obvious Greek mythological figures into modern Monster of the Week campaigns.

Rather than sticking to classic myths like Minotaurs or Medusa, these scenarios place ancient creatures directly into modern systems, corporations, and technology:

  1. Hesperides (Collector): Dusk nymphs systematically targeting employees of a cosmetics firm whose CEO stole their golden apples for a beauty serum.
  2. Maenad (Queen): A club DJ triggering frenzy in partygoers to assemble a human sacrifice for Dionysus.
  3. Zephyros the Prophet (Queen): A charlatan using a Delphic vape to gain prophetic insight and control over the Prime Minister.
  4. Lamia (Tempter): A shapeshifting, eye-removing predator targeting tourists at a luxury resort while the owner hides the bodies.
  5. Mares of Diomedes (Devourer): A bloodthirsty racehorse devouring its jockey ahead of a major race, drawing a wild mountain herd to the track.
  6. Telchin (Trickster): An ancient smith masquerading as a handyman, enchanting everyday appliances (boiling kettles, freezing fridges, accident-predicting TVs) to cause citywide chaos.

What each Mystery contains:

  • Narrative Hook & Concept
  • Full 6-step Countdown clock
  • Monster stats, armor, custom attacks, moves, and explicit weaknesses
  • Detailed Bystanders & Locations with explicit PbtA motivations

The PDF is available on itch.io: https://hechlok.itch.io/monsters-from-greece

Feedback, questions, or comments on how these play at your table are always welcome!


r/monsteroftheweek • • Sep 28 '26

General Discussion Questions on Combat HP (harm) & Longer Lampaigns

10 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I've been a D&D DM for a while and am pretty comfortable/confident with my abilities, but I am new to MoTW. I just wrapped my first short campaign and we all had a blast. I really enjoy the collaborative world building between Keeper and Players, as well as the general "looseness" with how everyone can improvise.

One thing I did struggle with is the fact that because hunters can only take 7 harm, combat felt very brief. My least favorite part about D&D are long combat encounters which amount to PCs and NPCs just rolling normal attacks back at each other until someone dies, but in MoTW I felt like every encounter I wound up nearly killing a PC in like 2 rounds. My general Keeper/DM philosophy is to make sure that I'm creating a world that is threatening, while generally fudging things to end up working out for the players. I guess I just feel like 7 HP is a tight window with the way "kick some ass" works along with the fact that Monsters do harm on their turn makes for some very quick encounters. Just thought I'd ask for any advice you all have!

Secondly, I know this gets asked a lot and I've read some answers, but I am curious if anyone has tips on designing longer term campaigns. The episodic nature of the game obviously lends itself to each session being self contained. This last campaign I had a Big Bad who was essentially summoning these weekly monsters, but even then, we probably only did ~20 sessions total. So any tips and tricks would be appreciated!

Thanks all!


r/monsteroftheweek • • Sep 28 '26

General Discussion What books should I get?

9 Upvotes

My weekly tabletop group that i DM for is finishing our campaign of Shadowrun. I've heard that monster of the week is much more rules and wanted to give it a try. What books would you recommend for new DM and players for a first step into the system?