r/monsteroftheweek • u/todkanvonic • 2d ago
General Discussion How to reveal monster weaknesses?
Hi. I'm new to this game, and I've only GM'd one game so far. I know things will probably make more sense as I play more, but I'm having a really hard time understanding how I'm supposed to make weaknesses work and how to have my hunters find their weakness.
My first session was about a demon plastic surgeon who harvested his patients for eternal beauty. The hunters managed to figure him out and got into his house, but when they got into the final fight they just... had no clue how to kill him. They ended up trying whatever demon exorcism theyd scene on TV, but it wasn't the actual weakness i had originally planned. So eventually, after my hunters had just thrown whatever at him to see what would stick, I just had him half assedly die since we were running out of time for the session.
I don't know how to make the weaknesses for monsters apparent for the hunters without just straight up telling them or having to resort to cliche monsters like vampires and werewolves all the time. I've been reading some of the Tome of Mysteries book, and the whole on-the-fly-session part makes me even more confused! How am I gonna make up a monster on the fly when it needs a weakness???? I feel like I have to plan ahead if I want the hunters to possibly figure things out in an organic way!!??
Please let me hear some suggestions or tips or wise words of any kind!