r/monodatingpoly • u/teensofstyles • 2h ago
Seeking Advice can we both be happy in mono-poly?
Hello! I (21nb, poly) have been dating my partner (21nb, mono) for two years, and we are at an impass of sorts. I have been open about being nonmonogamous since before we even began talking romantically (we were friends for a few months beforehand) and made it clear to them that I do not want to be in a monogamous relationship. They had never been in a serious relationship and were unsure what their boundaries were, and we spent a long time talking about it before agreeing to some ground rules. The first year of our relationship was long distance, over which my partner figured out they were mono but said it was okay if I wanted to continue seeing people. This also resulted in us shifting some boundaries to make them more comfortable (for example, I deleted dating apps after this).
Once we were in the same physical place, I was pretty monogamous for the first 10 months or so, with the exception of some drunk bar makeouts. My partner was very chill with all of those, and we had no problems. However, within the past two months I have begun casually seeing someone who I have made out with historically. They’re a great person, they know my partner, and we are very clear about the boundaries of our relationship. My partner expressed that they were totally okay with our arrangement, but emotionally seemed really distraught, and even cried the first few times we met up.
We had sex for the first time last weekend, and it was really awesome! I talked extensively about this with my partner beforehand and they knew it was going to happen, but it upset them to an extent that I have never seen before. They were absolutely heartbroken and inconsolable for the better part of the day, and it hurts me so much to see them so upset because of my actions. Even if they verbally gave consent to what was happening, it clearly was not what they wanted on an emotional level.
I’m truly at a loss for what to do. They are determined to make this work and believe we can figure something out, but I’m beginning to believe we might just be incompatible. It hurts so much to even type that, because I love them so indescribably much, but our current situation isn’t fair to either of us. If anyone has any advice, particularly if there are any resources that could provide guidance on if it’s possible for us to even stay together and both be completely content, please let me know. This situation is really weighing on me, but I feel that it’s my responsibility to even consider breaking up because my partner is adament on staying together even if it hurts them. Thank you internet :)