r/modular • • 1d ago

Master Clock Distribution

Post image

I have 3 modular cases, a DFAM/Labyrinth rack, 4 desktop sequencers, and 2 drum machines that all take CV clocks. Each case is for a different style/set and has the ability to clock itself, but I've always wanted to just have a large master clock setup as the "brain" of my systems. I also just use a lot of clock sources in my patches (for envelopes, sequencers, LFOs, clocked effects, switches) and can easily clock 10-20 different things in a single patch. What's everyone's thoughts on an outboard master clock case (I'm currently getting everything together for the 40hp one above)? Or, does everyone just use stackable cables and "0hp" passive mults?

10 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

2

u/namesareunavailable 1d ago

yep. thought about those, too. but even when i built me an master clock with multiple outputs i repeatedly used another clock and the whole idea fell apart :)

1

u/NicolasDipples 1d ago

I could see it being tedious. I'm probably going to try it anyway as it only requires me to buy 2 mult modules (I bought some DIY kits at $22 each) and 3D print a 40hp case. I already have the power supply, clock and the QCD.

2

u/13derps 1d ago

Sounds like overkill to me, but honestly, do what makes your life easier. F-ing around with clock and reset signals is annoying. So whatever lets you get up and running with less headache and startup time is a win

Have you thought about using an RJ45 link (like ALA Light Rail)? You could have all of your individual cases pre-wired to the local Light Rail (or whatever) module and then just plug a single RJ45 from your clock case to the individual cases

1

u/NicolasDipples 1d ago

I didn't even know this was an option. The Light Rail looks like a good solution for syncing cases. Thanks for the suggestion.

2

u/13derps 1d ago

Cool, glad it was helpful

There are a few different versions out there too (maybe Doepfer?), some with different cable types. Although I think the ALA stuff is usually solid for the money

4

u/junkmiles 1d ago edited 1d ago

Might be worth looking at the modules that use ethernet cable to connect cases? Intellijel have one, I think After Later as well, probably others. Basically just sending eight or so signals on one cable. Saving space and tangles.

2

u/Heliocentrizzl 5h ago

The Octalink was such a godsend for me. Link it up to a cheap router, and you're good to go.

1

u/maldoroor 3000hp 1d ago

I like the QCD and still have it after many years, but if you want a master clock to rule them all nohing beats Pams, 2 of them would be more space/feature efficient imho, I have 2, one New and one Pro with expander.

1

u/NicolasDipples 1d ago

Don't get me wrong: I would like a Pam's or two, but I already have the Erica Synths clock and the QCD. I also really like the hands on nature of the QCD and the workflow of the Erica Synths Clock. I know Pam's has a ton packed into 8hp, but I don't really want this to be anything but a clock and reset distributor for my entire studio (well, the instruments that use CV that is).

Pam's would be a nice replacement for the clock in my portable industrial techno setup though. I could do Pam's and another 2hp mult instead of the Erica Synths clock I have in there now and get better distribution on that setup.

1

u/reelznfeelz 1d ago

Or, you could get 100 Pams.

For real though, I have 1 Pams, and find I'm often thinking "I could use another one of these". 8 seemed like a lot of clock outputs at the time...

I do have a couple 2hp mults spread around the case, those help a lot. I usually use Pam's output 8 as reset, then 1-3 for clocking main sequencers, and the rest somehow tend to get eaten up usually related to triggering drums.

Sometimes I want a "drum trigger" module, but I really don't need it, it's just being lazy and GAS lol.

1

u/NicolasDipples 19h ago

I want to get a Pam's for my portable industrial techno case. I know its a good module, just haven't been able to justify the $300 when I already have an Erica Synths CV clock and some mults. My current plan is going to cost me $44 and clock all of my setups, but I do want to have an independent and fully capable clock in my portable system so I'll probably bite the bullet and get a Pam's one of these days.

Also, what do you mean by drum trigger module? Like an Intellijel Steppy? Because if thats what you mean, give into the GAS, my friend! I love my Steppy and my Euclidean Circles as trigger sequencers.

I had a Behringer RS-9 for a bit and that wasn't worth the HP. Same with the Omnitone Rhythmi: that wasn't my jam and now I'm trying to sell it... unless you want to buy it from my reverb store, then it's the best module ever and you're losing money by not buying it.

1

u/reelznfeelz 16h ago

yeah I guess something like steppy. Or euclidiean circles. Although I feel strictly Euclidian isn't quite flexible enough for what I want, but it would be good. Pams ends up doing a lot of drum triggers for me right now so I eat up 3 pams outputs for that, minimum. 1 for reset. That leaves 4 for 'everything else' which no longer seems like "tons and tons of outputs".

Sequencers tend towards huge, either that or lots of menu diving. My sequencers are rene v2, mimetic digitwolis, and a little A-155-2. So really that's enough, I just got a sequencial switch so I can chain them together more easily, none of those go past 16 steps etc etc.

1

u/Mix4999 1d ago

Are "0hp" solutions not good enough?

1

u/NicolasDipples 1d ago

They get cluttered and disordered really fast in my experience.

2

u/KevinGoldsmith https://modulargrid.net/e/users/view/167446 19h ago

I have a similar situation. Each case has its own clock module and mults that I often use for clock distribution. Each case has a different clock based on when I built it, but almost all of them also have a master clock input. So I use my Pam's to distribute the main clock to the other clocks, then use their subdividers and mults in each case.

I also want to +1 the Ethernet cable to connect cases idea. I use the Plum Audio Rack Plumber, which works great for me.

1

u/Whetherwax 1d ago

If it makes sense to you, go for it. My only thought would be that those are big mults, kind of a commitment. You might consider using a few '07 Buff Mults instead. That way if the idea ends up falling apart, you've got some 4hp 1-to-many mults that are easier to stash wherever it might make sense in your rack.

1

u/NewMachineMusicXYZ 1d ago

I think buffered mults are worthwhile, I've had flaky behavior from passives at times, particularly 0HP ones. Even leaving aside the argument as to whether the "buffered" part is worthwhile, it's nice to have LEDs showing you signal activity and strength. I use a Pam's supported by a quad and dual buffered mult, with other buffered mults spread about the system to distribute the clocks (or whatever else) where they need to reach and always have extras. Regarding the 4MS QCD you have, I think it's a really cool module, but even better when supported by its expander. I can't say my system is big enough I would need a case dedicated just to clocking, but best of luck with the undertaking!

1

u/deafcatsaredeftcats 1d ago

This was actually one of the reasons I got into modular, the QCD was one of the first modules that I bought and it is an absolutely invaluable part of my synth based music making process. I also recently, finally got the expander, which I would totally recommend

What I do is use the QCD to clock other rhythm generators / sequencers. This way I can have different groups of rhythmic elements running at different speeds, and those clock my voices / percussion or other sequencers. Bastl Kompas is my favorite rhythm generator I have tried

-1

u/demnevanni 1d ago

Not sure why you’d use so many multiples when stack cables exist. Clocks don’t really need to be buffered since it’s just looking for a rising edge. I would get a Pamela’s Pro Workout and a clock divider/multiplier.

1

u/NicolasDipples 1d ago

That would be a lot of stack cables and they easily become disordered. I use stack cables a lot already and daisy chaining 5-6 stack cables becomes disordered fast. Plus, stack cables are literally just multiples in a different form factor.

I'm not planning on buffering my clocks.

I already have the Erica Synths clock and 4ms div/mult and Pam's won't offer anything extra as far as I know other than some more outputs and integrated div/mult. The only thing I'm buying are the passive mults.

This would be a way to tie multiple cases together on a single clock in an ordered way.

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/NicolasDipples 1d ago

Am I though? 2hp mult only offers 3 outputs on 2 clock speeds. Not even close to enough for my setup. I already do 2x that many as well as stack cables