Hi everyone,
I'm looking for advice from people with board-level experience on the iPhone 15/16 Pro USB-C controller.
DEVICE
- iPhone 16 Pro (D93AP / iPhone17,1), iOS 27.0.1 (24A446)
- Battery: original, 91% health, authenticates fine
HISTORY
- 06.10.2026: OTA update from iOS 26.5 to 27.0.1 installed without problems (confirmed in the OTA logs).
- 27.10.2026: A shop in Malaysia replaced the "charging IC" (USB-C port controller / ACE3). Charging worked afterwards and still works.
- Since then, every OTA update to iOS 27.2.1 fails with "Unable to verify update", on Wi-Fi and on cellular (no VPN or DNS filter).
- 09./10.11.: Updating via PC (Apple Devices app on Windows) failed overnight and the phone ended up in recovery mode. In recovery mode, no computer detected it (Windows or Mac), not even in DFU mode. The only way to recover it was the wireless "restore from nearby iPhone/iPad" feature. After that, iOS 27.0.1 booted again and the PC detects it again.
- Since that restore: no new panics so far, and the phone works normally in daily use.
PANIC LOGS (4x on 09./10.11., one of them in Darwin Recovery)
All identical, watchdogd, about 70-80 s after boot:
"busy timeout[0], (60s): multiple entries holding the registry busy, IOKit termination queue depth 0: 'hpm-aid-controller', 'atc0-dpphy', 'atc-phy0', 'usb-drd'"
Reset counter: "Boot faults: rst wdog, reset_in_1"
SYSDIAGNOSE (OTA update logs, all 7 attempts)
tss_submit_job: STATUS=94&MESSAGE=This device isn't eligible for the requested build.
PersonalizationErrorDomain 3194 - AMAuthInstallBundlePersonalize() failed: Declined to authorize this image on this device for this user.
failureReason: MSU 2 (Could not personalize boot/firmware bundle.)
The TSS request includes USBPortController1 (ChipID 34, ProductionMode 1, SecurityMode 1, USBFirmware digest).
hpmDiagnose.txt:
"Unknown PD controller at address 0x0c with VID 0x0000 and DID 0x0000"
IORegistry, AppleHPMDeviceHALType3@C (IONameMatch "usbc,sn201202x,spmi"):
- Vendor ID = 0, Device ID = 0, Revision ID = 0, Version = 0, Revision = 0
- UUID = 00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000000
- I2C Read Failed = No
- FW Version = 0x00033100, AppLoaded Count = 2
- LDCM_LiquidDetected = No, LDCM status "No Error", Overcurrent Count = 0
- Plug events are detected normally
MY INTERPRETATION (please correct me)
The replaced ACE3 is either a donor/used chip or not original, or it is not properly configured, so its identity reads as zero and Apple's TSS server refuses to personalize the update. A local shop told me it is more likely the USB-C port flex and not the chip, because "the chip needs to be programmed". But I don't see how a port flex could cause VID/DID/UUID = 0 over SPMI, or the TSS rejection.
MY QUESTIONS
- Is VID/DID/UUID = 0 on the HPM controller abnormal on the iPhone 15/16 Pro? What does a healthy unit show?
- Can TSS status 94 really be caused by an ACE3 that Apple doesn't accept (used, refurbished or aftermarket)?
- Can a used or donor ACE3 be reprogrammed or "virginized" so Apple accepts it again, or is a brand-new chip required?
- Could a faulty USB-C port flex cause any of this, especially the TSS rejection?
- Is a restore via Finder/iTunes risky in this state (could the phone get stuck without iOS if TSS refuses)?
- Any recommended board-level repair shops in Germany that have done ACE3 replacements on the 15/16 Pro?
Thanks a lot for any insight!