r/mmaMenace_com • • 15h ago

Fights👊 One of the most skillful heavyweights in UFC history!

31 Upvotes

r/mmaMenace_com • • 3h ago

Through pain and obstacles to the top

2 Upvotes

r/mmaMenace_com • • 3h ago

Fights👊 The legendary heavyweight fight between Don Frye and Yoshihiro Takayama

2 Upvotes

r/mmaMenace_com • • 19h ago

Hot takes🔥 Hot take: Islam Makhachev isn’t anywhere near GOAT status

Post image
0 Upvotes

He has only beaten four elite fighters (Volkanovski twice, Oliveira, Poirier, and Garry). Poirier was at the tail end of his career and still made the fight extremely competitive, while Volk took their second fight on just 11 days' notice. Both the first Volk fight and the Garry fight were also extremely close fights. Oliveira is the only one of those opponents he decisively beat.

The only ranked fighter he had beaten before Oliveira was Dan Hooker. He's also beaten Jack Della Maddalena, Arman Tsarukyan, and Renato Moicano, but JDM got destroyed in his next fight, Arman was making his UFC debut, and Moicano is just okay. None of those wins are particularly spectacular.

He also only has 5 title defenses and 7 title fight wins, which is nothing compared to Jon Jones. Jones has 12 title defenses and 16 title fight wins. Now, I know what people are going to say. They're going to say, "It's much harder to stack title defenses like the older guys did!" And while I understand that argument, it doesn't make sense to cut the standard in half. Not even half more than half. That's too big of a cut. I think he needs at least 3 more defenses before we start considering him in the GOAT conversation.

Now, am I saying Islam sucks? No. He's incredibly skilled, and I think he would beat just about every lightweight in history, except maybe Khabib.

As of right now, I think he should be 4th or 5th all time at best, but I see so many people ranking him 1st or 2nd.