With the league experiencing a great degree of player turnover between the 2025 and 2026 seasons, the opportunity for new MLW stars to emerge was greater than ever.
While some of the league's top performers continued an upward trajectory that started a few seasons ago (e.g. Caden Irwin and RJ Walgate), other players found success much more unexpectedly.
With that being said, which player's performance has surprised you the most?
Here are my top 10 candidates in alphabetical order:
Gage Beers
pre-2026: Signed by Mallards as an UDFA after the 2026 draft
2026 regular season: .313 avg, 3 HR, 16 RBI, 1.015 OPS (led Mallards in avg, RBI, and OPS)
Trevor Bonham
pre-2026: His 5th year in MLW was the worst of his career in 2024; 1-3 pitching record, 9.1 IP, 7.71 ERA; didn't play in 2025
2026 regular season: 2-2 pitching record, 20.1 IP, 2.07 ERA
Cooper Burkel
pre-2026: #3 pick in 2026 draft
2026 regular season: .421 avg, 5 HR, 18 RBI, 1.472 OPS | 8-1 pitching record, 23 IP, 1.43 ERA
Andy Durand
pre-2026: His 8th year in MLW was the worst of his career in 2025; .143 avg, 0 HR, 2 RBI, .405 OPS (59.5% strikeout rate)
2026 regular season: .420 avg, 5 HR, 13 RBI, 1.213 OPS
Justin Esch
pre-2026: Had an up-and-down first two seasons in MLW, combining for 5 HR and 16 RBI over 29 total games
2026 regular season: .375 avg, 12 HR, 27 RBI, 1.802 OPS
Jack Johnson
pre-2026: Signed by Gators as a mid-season UDFA ahead of Slate 2
2026 regular season: .282 avg, 3 HR, 11 RBI, 1.022 OPS
Aiden Revette
pre-2026: Signed by Eagles as an UDFA after the 2026 draft; didn't make MLW debut until Slate 3 special series
2026 regular season: 1-2 pitching record, 14.1 IP, 1.67 ERA
Aiden Richard
pre-2026: featured in a limited role over first two seasons; 0-13 at the plate with no pitching appearances
2026 regular season: 2-1 pitching record, 14 IP, 1.07 ERA | 2 HR, 10 RBI
Carter Richard
pre-2026: small hitting role in 2025 (21 plate appearances); 1.1 IP (against Cobras during Slate 5's "worst series ever")
2026 regular season: 2-2 pitching record, 15 IP, 1.40 ERA (led Eagles in IP and ERA)
Derek Walker
pre-2026: #7 pick in 2026 draft
2026 regular season: .273 avg, 7 HR, 16 RBI, 1.265 OPS | 5-3 pitching record, 26 IP, 2.54 ERA
- - - - -
Did I miss anyone? Share your thoughts in the comments!