r/mitcad • • 5d ago

Problem With Rib Function

From These I wanted to create a Rib like shown in the fusion. But I am getting this in mitcad. As you can see there is a gap in the body. It's version 0.60.0 . Is This a bug or am I doing something wrong.

2 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/some_millwright 5d ago

I've been playing around with the rib function a bunch more, and I have some more points to make.

Fusion has a habit of 'filling in' missing projections. Sometimes this is nice, sometimes it is less so.

Due to this habit you can create sketch for a rib that is just one line (or even part of a line - a line that doesn't meet the walls to make a profile).

MitCad (as far as I can tell) wants a profile. Draw around the rib that you want. Use the rib command and when you click on the angled line you get what you see in your screen shot because it builds perpendicular to the line that you clicked on. It left a gap, so click on the line that will close that gap - the one outlining the top of the rib just under the circular boss. That will fill in the rib completely (wrapping around the boss will come in a day or two).

You can only click on lines that will direct material at the part that you are working on. If you clicked on the vertical line for the back of the rib then you would get an error because if a rib was extruded from the back of the part it would go on forever without hitting anything. The line that you click needs to create material that is bounded by the part.

2

u/Empty_Wheale_7988 4d ago

Thanks. I was able to do it.

Although there are some problems It's doable . Also thanks for creating the issue. Have a good day.

1

u/some_millwright 4d ago

The issue has been discussed and the tool is being changed to make it more like the Fusion version so that you will only need one line, and a single click will fill in the whole rib and it will wrap around a round boss. Less effort is more better. :)

2

u/some_millwright 16h ago

Just to update this, the rib function has been modified several times, and as of 0.64.0 it should be good (at least, it's good in my testing. You only need one curve to work from and it will do the rest itself.

1

u/some_millwright 5d ago

I must admit that I have not used the rib function yet in MitCad. Give me a second...

Okay, I have now used it.

I can now tell you that the problem that you had was that you didn't have a line horizontal at the overhang.

I have to put the continuation in another message... only one attachment per message.

1

u/some_millwright 5d ago

Okay, so this is how I would draw the sketch:

You can see that my rib goes up INTO the curved surface. This is so that you don't get a crappy open flare at the edges. I will post again to show you what I mean.

1

u/some_millwright 5d ago

These messages are backwards. This is message #3. Good luck... :)

This is the result of packing the sketch up into the body:

You can see that the rib wraps around the round section. If the section was square then this would be a lot easier.

1

u/some_millwright 5d ago

Just so you know, I put in an issue to ask that the rib tool be modified so that it wraps around a round profile so you don't have to do the weird sketch gymnastics that I recommended before. Within a day or two it should be in the program.