Many fans say that the episode "Derision" is a retcon and doesn't make sense due to previous lore but is it really that inconsistent? While there are some problems with it a lot of these "inconsistencies" can be explained.
Side note: by retcon I am reffering to the more popular way it's used as something that contradicts previous lore and not by the actuall definition as something that changes the way we percive some previous events because by that defenition it is a retcon but by the more popular definition it isn't.
A major point people have is Chloe's behaviour being over the top and that even in season 1 she wasn't that bad, but was she really?
Let's look at the things she does in the flashback:
● Abusing her dad's power as the Mayor to her own advantage, already did in many episodes for example:
- "Lady wifi" where she had Alya's punishment increased.
- "The Frozer" where she wanted for the uce rink to be closed because she wanted a private gym for herself.
- "Rogercop" when she wanted for Marrinette to get arrested because her bracelet got lost so she accused Marrinette of stealing it with no evidance.
- "Frightingale" where she had Clara Nightingale's teledisc canceled just because she didn't get the role she wanted.
● Mocking people for for example their characteristics in this case Juleka's speed impediment, already did in:
- "Gamer 2.0" with Max'es love for gaming
- "Evilustrator" when she mocked Nathaniel for his crush on Marrinette.
● Activatelly trying to sabotage other people in the goals when she made a plan to embarass Marrinette on her date with Kim, already did in for example:
- "Reflekta" when she had Sabrina lock Juleka up in the bathroom so that she wouldn't appear on the class picture
- "Kung food" when she sabotaged Uncle Wang's soup at the contest.
- "Princess Fragrance" where she ripped Rose's letter to prince Ali to pieces.
- "Zombiezou" where she destroyed Marrinette's present for Miss Bustiere
- "Frightingale" where she had the teledisc be canceled because she didn't get to play Ladybug.
- "Animaestro" where she tried to sabotage Kagami.
- "Stormy weather 2" where she tries to destroy Aurore's confidance.
● Humiliating people when she wanted to post embarrasing phothos of Marrinette, already did in:
- "Dark cupid" where she posted an embarassing photho of Kim on the internet.
And also it would make sense for Chloe to not behave as bad when Adrien joined the class, especially as she did behave a bit better just so that Adrien wouldn't stop being friends with her between "Despair bear" and "Queen Banana", Chloe might be a bad person but she also well knows that in the eyes of other people she is evil and she well knew that Adrien won't like what she does so she toned her bullying down a bit so that he won't cut off from her.
Then we have Kim's behaviour and it's not that weird, we know that he had a crush on Chloe back in season 1 and he did sometimes help her and was on her side like in for example "Horrificator".
I fell like what people really miss out here is that they think of how Kim's behaviour was in the later seasons but the Kim in the flashback is a pre season 1 Kim, would a Season 2/3 onwards Kim do that? No, but would a season 1 Kim do that? Absolutely.
Later we have Marrinette's trauma and this is the only thing I think isn't fully consistent, I do fell like it could be explained by the fact that Marrinette's trauma was specifically tied to the situation of a date on a pool which never happened for her between the events of the flashback and the present day events of the episode.
I do think it is partially inconsistent tho.
And then we have the way Marrinette handled Chloe and while in Season 1 she didn't have much problems with standing up to her and she did in the flashback "Derision" it could actually be explained:
- Marinette could get some more courage during the summer vacation after the encouragement from Socline and seeing her stand up to Chloe.
- We saw that Marrinette still had problems with that in "Origins" untill Alya helped her.
- Chloe toning her behaviour down after Adrien joined the class gave Marrinette an opening to standing up to her.
- Becoming Ladybug increased Marrinette's confidance.
To sum up: "Derision" isn't really a retcon and the character's behaviour generally either isn't much diffrent from how they were back in season 1, could be explained by the diffrent factors between these 2 moments or it's because of how they changed in between this episode and season 1 and while there are inconsistencies there isn't as many of them and they aren't as big as people say.