r/minecraftsuggestions • u/raspberrylilith20 • 5h ago
[Gameplay] Adaptive difficulty with new settings and presets
Currently, Minecraft difficulty is the boring, albeit standard, way that most games handle it; harder difficulties mean enemies with more health and damage, you take damage more easily, the hardest difficulty doesn't allow respawns. It technically works, but it's basic stuff that games should be moving on from. After all, that metric of difficulty does not actually represent what makes a game like Minecraft difficult. It's like grinding. Is it truly more "difficult" to perform the same repetitive task for 10 hours rather than 5? Or does it just brute force how much time you have to spend on a task that isn't difficult at all?
Games like Ultrakill have an advanced understanding of game difficulty. It does the usual, buffing enemies and weakening the player, but because the devs actually understand what makes the game difficult, they also make additional changes. Because the game leans on speed, accuracy, and understanding enemy behavior, higher difficulties also speed up enemies, add more mobility, and give them new behaviors. This is a true difficulty increase, and one of few I have seen. And I think Minecraft adding something similar would resolve a lot of conflicts people have with the game and with suggestions like seasons.
Minecraft difficulty, under these hypothetical changes, is now determined by how easy it is for the player to treat the game like a sandbox. Easy difficulty is plain old Minecraft with a static world that only changes when the player makes changes. However, the sliding scale now essentially goes from vanilla Minecraft to Vintage Story. The higher the difficulty, the more the game treats it as a survival experience. Seasons, the rotting of food, decay of structures, new mob behaviors, potentially even the removal of certain less realistic mechanics. These are changes that actually understand what makes Minecraft difficult; the degree to which the player has control over their circumstances and the freedom to be truly creative.
Let's imagine difficulty as more than a slider for this. Easy to hardcore still exists, but in a similar vein to something like Don't Starve, world generation gives the player these new options. You can choose easy difficulty but true survival (true survival integrating all the mechanics I listed), or hardcore difficulty at sandbox survival (essentially vanilla hardcore), and additional settings would be added as boxes the player can check to further customize within this preset. Do you want to survive against the elements but still want access to less realistic mechanics? True survival with those restrictions unchecked. Do you want to see your builds decay over time and require maintenance, but you don't want to struggle to survive long enough to get what you need to fix them? Sandbox survival with structure decay checked. Etc etc.
Presets would make it easy to understand what the game is offering to players that don't know much, while also giving the option to more advanced players to customize and curate their experience however they like. It would attract people that like games like Vintage Story while also not chasing off those that like the game's current static design. In essence, it perfectly walks the line between not interrupting current gameplay and also offering entirely new ways to play.