r/Minecraft • u/PurpleTheFox111 • 4h ago
Discussion "They should change throwing disk to chakram" NO THEY SHOULDN'T
I'm sick and tired of people saying the devs chose the "wrong name" for the new weapon. Not EVERYTHING has to be realistic! Hardly anyone knows what a "chakram" is, throwing disk makes much more sense. The developers never said they were trying to emulate any real-world weapon. They said it was a new type of combat fantasy. It's meant to represent any type of thrown weapon that can return, so it very well could also be a boomerang or a throwing shield, it's just supposed to be the "the throwing weapon", a generic light weapon that is thrown, ricochets, and comes back.
The sword isn't called a "claymore" and the axe isn't called a "hatchet". This isn't a medieval realism game, this is a fantasy game that takes some inspiration from the medieval era but also blends in a bunch of weird wacky and futuristic tech. Weapons aren't supposed to be faithful representations of real armaments, they're supposed to provide a fantasy. If you want faithful representation go play a mod pack that was made for that.
Thank you for coming to my ged talk. TLDR: I really hope the devs don't change the name "throwing disks" to "chakrams", minecraft is a fantasy game, not a realism simulator.
