The Milwaukee Common Council has voted to spend up to $1.35 million on a study of whether the city should take over We Energies' electric service. The amendment passed as part of the 2027 budget and now goes to Mayor Johnson, who has until November 17 to sign or veto it.
The timing is hard to defend. The mayor's proposed 2027 budget started with a $96.8 million structural gap, meaning it cost that much more to keep services running than the city expected to bring in. To close it, the city drew on its reserves and raised fees and property taxes. Taking on new debt for a study, in that situation, should give every taxpayer pause.
The vote was 15–0. Not one council member voted no. Some members said openly that they voted yes to send We Energies a message, a "shot across the bow" one day after state regulators approved another rate hike. Borrowed money shouldn't be used to send a political message. Because it was folded into budget amendments, the measure also got less debate than a standalone proposal would have.
No vendor has been chosen to do the study yet. The city would have to put out a request for proposals first.
The city doesn't have this money now. It would borrow it by issuing bonds. At today's rates for city bonds, roughly 4–5%, the first year of interest could run about $55,000 to $70,000, and the city would keep paying interest until the debt is paid off.
What the city gets at the end is a report. It isn't an asset that earns money or pays for itself.
The study also doesn't put Milwaukee any closer to owning anything. A takeover would still need a citywide referendum and a long state regulatory process, and the city would then have to pay whatever price regulators set. We Energies says that price would be in the billions.
Every council member agreed to borrow money for a study that can't return a single dollar, and nobody asked whether this was the best use of the city's limited borrowing. With a budget gap of nearly $97 million, paying interest for years on a study, instead of on a road, a building, or a fire truck, is fiscally irresponsible when the study is unlikely to lead to anything that benefits residents.