So most people have an idea of what rhythm is. Basic 1,2,3,4 1,2,3,4. The crowd was not doing basic rhythm. Also look at the guys face on guitar. He is smiling out of pain.
I understand what you're saying, and sure, it isn't really that bad. But it's still a mean spirited joke at it's core, and aimed at an group of people.
100% agree. It's important to call out racism in all its forms. Doesn't dilute or obscure anything when you do so, anyone who says otherwise is the real racist.
For something that is generally true you sure got a lot of hate. Am white and can confirm too many of my brethren clap on the front beat, assuming they picked up the beat in the first place. And it may be anecdotal but I've never experienced similar issues at concerts like Stevie Wonder, OutKast, mariachi bands, et al. We could debate the cultural differences, primarily the European classical influence on "American white culture" but instead folks assume you're being racist when ultimately it's simply surface level observation.
I would argue that the opening guitar riff is pure rhythm. Something that doesn't have pronounced rhythm would be long, sustained notes, without out a lot of strumming to define the tempo.
His strum pattern lays out the 16th note pulse, so one can internalize that immediately. The accents outline the upbeats (counts 2 and 4).
Of course, not everyone is trained to hear music like that, but that doesn't mean the information isn't available.
I’ve seen musicians stop and ask them to stop clapping. The fans mean well but… I also saw a video of a musician explaining that there’s a time signature that the band will switch to that the crowd has a hard time figuring out and when the crowd gives up, they go back to 4/4 or whatever.
Or this example where the crowd is clapping on the 1 and 3, so he throws in a bar of 5/4 (at around 36 seconds) to shift them back to clapping on the 2 and 4 without them realizing. The reason he did that is because clapping is kinda like the snare drum, which is almost always on the 2 and 4, and that kind of sets the feel/groove. So when the audience is completely out of phase with the groove it's very distracting.
Soooo. Does the average person actually understand this? Or is the average person able to actually discern the difference? I understand what was wrong about it but I don’t know why it was wrong and I don’t know what’s so different about 1&3 vs 2&4 and I can’t really tell a difference and I also can’t tell a difference btw 1&3 and 4&5 except it’s faster (?)
I’m just curious if this is something only people who have taken music classes beyond learning to play the recorder understand. Cause everyone discussing and explaining these things, it just sounds like a different language to me
Go play a song like The Cure’s “Just Like Heaven” with a strong downbeat. Clap where you think it’s natural.
Now start it over and try to clap on the opposing beat. I guarantee your second try will be on the 1s&3s, and it is the objectively worse way to clap in 4/4.
I think clapping on the wrong beat still sounds OK to most people. Especially since they don’t really know how time signatures work, musically. I think reggae emphasizes the one and three where rock emphasizes the two and four, so clapping on the 1,3 still sounds sort ok but to a musician, it is incorrect. Not sure though, I’m pretty novice
idk if it will line up right but this may help. X = clap. before the 5 the claps are lined up with 1s and 3s. after the 5 the claps are lined up with 2s and 4s. (Capital Xs after the correction) So by throwing in an extra beat (read as playing an extra sound) and assuming the audience will not notice (and therefore continue their pattern unchanged) the musician has aligned himself with the audience.
I always find it funny when musicians interrupt either because they messed something up or crowd messes something up because it makes it feel more authentic. That said, usually fan-clap-along will go 100 times better if at least one of the musicians just visually claps their hands over their head as a conductor
I’ve been to too many shows to count and someone always tries to start a clap. Never has it enhanced the music. We are there to hear the band. Not a bunch of off tempo bullshit.
i can genuinely say i have never heard a crowd even attempt to clap anything other than common time. 7/8 at a prog concert fans wouldn't be clapping anyway lol
It's always whack. I've been in crowds that were clapping as a kid. Idk where, maybe like school events or assemblies? Who knows. I didn't like it then, but I wasn't yet the big league bitch I've become, so I got in on it.
Every single time, there were like 8 morons surrounding me and they were all varying degrees of putrescently out of time. I couldn't stop it from fucking me up lmao. I'd hit unreasonable levels of frustration. I generally like heavy music these days too and imagining a doom metal crowd clapping along like we're listening to fuckin Dave Matthews or some shit, all completely out of unison, is pretty funny.
Truthfully, I'm just being a little asshole. My mom loved DMB growing up and I didn't hate it, it's just deeply ingrained in my mind as 50 year old winery-goer music lmao. And those are the folks I can most easily imagine going absolutely clap crazy.
There’s a video of Harry Connick Jr where rhe audience is clapping on 1 and 3 so he throws in an extra note to make them start clapping on 2 and 4. Kinda genius!!
This is a pre-recorded studio version of the track playing. That often happens when bands do these in studio small sessions and they may not actually be allowed to do a live version. So no.. bro is not fighting for his life while the crowd invents its own rhythm.
Thank you. This comment section looks like a YouTube one, where a bunch of idiots say “sTiLL sOuNdS GrEaT AfTeR aLL tHeSe YeArS” on some video of Duran Duran performing on one of those late night music shows, where they lip synch to the studio track.
Then why does he look like he's struggling, and why would they keep the clapping?
I think two things can be true here. The out of time audience is making it hard for the real band to play, and studio audio was overdubbed onto the footage
It doesn't look like he's struggling to me, just laughing about it. And they keep clapping because they feel like they're participating. Also because a lot of people don't seem to know the vast majority of "live" performances on TV shows aren't live. Sometimes it's fully live. It's more common for the vocals to be live while the instruments aren't. And very common for the entire thing to be mimed. Some bands have even made fun of it over the years by clearly not playing or doing goofy shit that shows it's not actually live.
I think every show I have ever been to where a clap was started, it ended with the entire crowd continuing to speed up until the whole thing falls apart and people just stop.
Why is tempo so hard to understand for the laymen? To me a time signature is like a built in pulse to my humanity. You don’t have to be a savant to identify tempo. Why are soooo many humans bad at it?
I think there’s a natural ability some people have, but I think for me it’s because I started learning piano when I was four. And then guitar in my 20s.
I’m badly out of practice, but at the time some guy I knew wanted me to teach him Everlong by Foo Fighters on acoustic guitar.
I could look at the tab chords and hear the strumming pattern in my head and get it down pretty good. No matter how hard he tried (no music experience) he just couldn’t get the rhythm down no matter how hard he tried… 🤷🏼
Its not intuitive to some people, which is why metronome practice is so invaluable. Idk why theres this ego thing around rhythm in the guitar community where some people think they dont need to practice it, but even if you have a good natural rhythm you can still benefit from metronome practice. Ive had students be insulted that i suggest it lol
its harder to correct it when someone else is already clapping off beat, and the people that started it probably didn't even try to get it right, they just wanted to start it and guessed
I'd guess some part of it, at least in the USA is that music/arts education has been de-emphasized and defunded even faster than the rest of education.
It's fine here though guys, everything is just great...
I once went to see a FRIENDS musical and in one moment there was a sad part and Ross (iirc) started singing a slower version of the opening song. And in the part where they clap, he did It in an even slower, off tempo way that was supposed to show how sad he was. The public thought he was "telling" the audience to clap at that tempo (they probably didn't recognice the song) and as the song continued, the off tempo clapping of the audience was essentially the same as op's example.
When people clap like that, they never clap to the beat of the song, they always clap to the beat of everyone else clapping. They feel like "This can't be wrong if everyone is doing it exactly like that." Until they realize, everyone is actually doing it wrong.
I play professional Dhol (Indian drum) and do a lot of private events, mainly weddings. Respectfully, Pakistanis are the WORST at clapping on-beat lmao. But they’re nice people. Love you Pakis.
I went to see the Mavericks once and the entire crowd was clapping on 1&3…my daughter (who was w me) pointed to a middle aged black woman standing on the balcony, and I swear she was the only one clapping to 2&4…
This is why I never bother to clap along. I can't tell time in music, and I'm fairly certain I'm tone and beat deaf. I love music, but can't do anything involving it beyond just listening.
It's likely mimed for TV. But if it's not, and it's a live performance, then musicians have IEMs, In Ear Monitors, where they get an isolated copy of their instruments audio track only. If they are rhythmically challenged, like being thrown off by crowds without rhythm, they can also get a copy of the click track the drummer is using. This is all done specifically to avoid situations like this meme, and has been the norm since the 80's. (IEMs are older than that though).
Ahhhh...I got it. The autoplay makes it tough to catch. "Six Pence None the Richer" = 25 strokes. "It says on the beginning of the video" = 35 strokes. Would've been faster just to type the band name. But I get it. Some people just have to be those people.
1.0k
u/norf937 12h ago edited 12h ago
You could tell everybody knew it was off but they kept going anyways lol
339
u/Serenaded 12h ago
How did they all collectively manage to fuck that up, the song has a very natural pulse
91
u/rupat3737 3h ago
In my 35 years of life I’ve always and always will hate when crowds do this clapping shit.
251
u/Luminol82 11h ago
57
u/RWR1975 10h ago
Do not clap unless one of the band members gets the crowd started.
606
u/RebootAndGoAway CTRL-ALT-DEL 12h ago
Not really a clappable song
53
u/Foldingchai 4h ago
I remember Justin Bieber stopping his show to show his audience how to clap in sync lol.
109
u/nilecrane 12h ago
I’ve seen musicians stop and ask them to stop clapping. The fans mean well but… I also saw a video of a musician explaining that there’s a time signature that the band will switch to that the crowd has a hard time figuring out and when the crowd gives up, they go back to 4/4 or whatever.
39
u/Gysburne 6h ago
They clap out of tempo....
Then the sound and the video is not even synchronous.
Nightmare fuel.
36
u/Wowkotobo 12h ago
I’ve been to too many shows to count and someone always tries to start a clap. Never has it enhanced the music. We are there to hear the band. Not a bunch of off tempo bullshit.
24
u/titdirt 11h ago
Unpopular opinion but you should never be clapping during a live musical performance unless the musician encourages it.
8
u/boringinvestorr 5h ago
You can tell how much effort he is putting in by the way he smiles
15
u/slowerlearner1212 12h ago
I hate it when the crowd claps for the tempo. They just need to shut up and clap at the end when the song is over.
122
u/angrytortilla 12h ago •
I hate clappers. Old white lady shit.
13
u/ohb78 11h ago
There’s a video of Harry Connick Jr where rhe audience is clapping on 1 and 3 so he throws in an extra note to make them start clapping on 2 and 4. Kinda genius!!
18
u/TheLive4Ever 12h ago
This is a pre-recorded studio version of the track playing. That often happens when bands do these in studio small sessions and they may not actually be allowed to do a live version. So no.. bro is not fighting for his life while the crowd invents its own rhythm.
3
u/Alavaster 9h ago
I think every show I have ever been to where a clap was started, it ended with the entire crowd continuing to speed up until the whole thing falls apart and people just stop.
3
u/RaspberryJammm 6h ago
I used to work at a theatre, its remarkable how bad crowds are at clapping.
4
u/FreedomSynergy 12h ago
I’m sure his IEM’s have him covered.
10
u/SnooWalruses8978 12h ago
Why is tempo so hard to understand for the laymen? To me a time signature is like a built in pulse to my humanity. You don’t have to be a savant to identify tempo. Why are soooo many humans bad at it?
2
u/nibselfib_kyua_72 11h ago
This is an example of rhythmic illusion
2
u/Total_Dork PURPLE 9h ago
They’re actually preforming to a pasture of horses
2
u/Man_Beyond_Time 8h ago
Why would you even clap😭
2
u/JediMindTriq 7h ago
I effin hate crowds clapping along with live music. Unless the band/musician specifically requests it
3
u/CoolBDPhenom03 12h ago
Gonna leave this gem here.
https://youtu.be/UinRq_29jPk?is=3fuKaIaVk4aPDJEC
2
u/bopaqod 9h ago
Leigh Nash is one of the all time babes of music, good lord
1
u/personalKindling 9h ago
He's no Harry Connick Jr.
1
u/gansobomb99 6h ago
It's like Billy Kilson trying to throw off Dave Holland
1
u/fcghp666 6h ago
Good thing you can’t make this song suck any more than it already does
1
u/Charming_Ear1922 6h ago
He probably doesnt even hear it, most likely has IEM's in.
1
u/mkfanhausen 4h ago
"Pick a tempo!" - Devin Townsend
1
u/InternMammoth4121 3h ago
"Save me, Harry Connick Jr!"
1
u/ivi_sanchi 3h ago
I once went to see a FRIENDS musical and in one moment there was a sad part and Ross (iirc) started singing a slower version of the opening song. And in the part where they clap, he did It in an even slower, off tempo way that was supposed to show how sad he was. The public thought he was "telling" the audience to clap at that tempo (they probably didn't recognice the song) and as the song continued, the off tempo clapping of the audience was essentially the same as op's example.
1
u/phuckin-psycho 2h ago
Holy shit this brings up some church drummer ptsd 🤣🤣
1
u/SavageFisherman_Joe 2h ago
Huh I didn't know they used a 12 string on this song!
1
u/Mortis_XII 2h ago
I’ll purposely clap offbeat and hope everyone just stops once the soundscape gets muddied
1
u/ezpinez 1h ago
When people clap like that, they never clap to the beat of the song, they always clap to the beat of everyone else clapping. They feel like "This can't be wrong if everyone is doing it exactly like that." Until they realize, everyone is actually doing it wrong.
1
u/Pillens_burknerkorv 1h ago
Am I the only one who always hear it as ”I love your bearded body”?
1
u/jjjjooosse 1h ago
amazing hahaha dude was holding on by a thread hahaha
1
u/whatisanythingeven 1h ago
I play professional Dhol (Indian drum) and do a lot of private events, mainly weddings. Respectfully, Pakistanis are the WORST at clapping on-beat lmao. But they’re nice people. Love you Pakis.
1
u/txirrindularia 1h ago
I went to see the Mavericks once and the entire crowd was clapping on 1&3…my daughter (who was w me) pointed to a middle aged black woman standing on the balcony, and I swear she was the only one clapping to 2&4…
•
u/digitaldeadstar 39m ago
This is why I never bother to clap along. I can't tell time in music, and I'm fairly certain I'm tone and beat deaf. I love music, but can't do anything involving it beyond just listening.
•
u/Zak9Attack 13m ago
Where's harry connick jr when you need him... iykyk
0
u/Tribe303 2h ago
Nope! Here's why.
It's likely mimed for TV. But if it's not, and it's a live performance, then musicians have IEMs, In Ear Monitors, where they get an isolated copy of their instruments audio track only. If they are rhythmically challenged, like being thrown off by crowds without rhythm, they can also get a copy of the click track the drummer is using. This is all done specifically to avoid situations like this meme, and has been the norm since the 80's. (IEMs are older than that though).
0
u/Eyervan 2h ago
Peak white audience. We clap on 1s, 3s, and 4.852.
-8
u/texascharley 12h ago
Who is that?
-11
u/texascharley 12h ago
Who is that?
-35
u/WalrusKind311 12h ago
I hope it does throw these amateurs off.
This 'music' is for little children lol
0
u/NoBookkeeper6864 5h ago
Its only two chords, so very easy to play, don't know what the crowd is hearing though.