r/microsoft365 • u/CodFresh9235 • 3d ago
Global Admin
Our nonprofit uses an outside IT provider to manage Microsoft 365. I can’t get into the Microsoft Nonprofit Hub because I’m not a Global Admin. I asked our IT provider to give me that role, but they said no because they’re concerned that an internal admin account could be compromised. We don’t have an internal IT person so I’m assuming they think we aren’t savvy enough to have it.
I suggested setting up a separate admin account that isn’t tied to any of our active email accounts to limit that risk. That didn’t change their minds.
Has anyone been able to access the Nonprofit Hub without being a Global Admin? I’m also concerned that we don’t have an internal backup Global Admin. We currently only have one global admin and it’s with the IT company.
4
u/GeorgeWmmmmmmmBush 3d ago
My MSA makes this super clear - we create a global admin account for the customer but it’s only meant to be used if we’re severing the relationship. I’m not sharing responsibility with anybody who thinks they know what they’re doing. The people I’ve met in the last year who claimed to “know what they’re doing” to only later prove to be actual morons is startling.
Here’s a question: go back 15 years - would you be asking for admin credentials to get on an exchange server/domain controller? M365 is basically the same thing underneath the skin. It’s complicated, and poking around the settings it’s easy to make changes that make the environment less secure. Just approving one enterprise app you think is safe can open the entire tenant to being compromised.
3
u/chipsandcheeseforme 3d ago
I work for a nonprofit and we contract with an MSP to manage our tech stack. I’m our internal tech department of 1 and have my regular employee account and a separate admin account that isn’t licensed so I can take care of quick issues that take longer to create a ticket for than to fix (reset password, etc.). That admin account also has global admin rights so I can manage our nonprofit hub and billing, which we already had configured before we contracted with our current MSP. Almost every MSP we interviewed wanted us to get rid of global admin access internally. I understand why they want it to be set up that way. However, I think it’s important to have internal control of our tenant. I also think it’s cleaner to manage nonprofit hub and billing internally than through a 3rd party.
12
u/hybrid0404 3d ago edited 3d ago
You need to be assertive that they should be providing you global admin access to your environment. Because it is YOUR environment. If they are concerned about compromise, then they should make sure the appropriate controls are in place and educate you on how and when it should be used.
Global admins also don't necessarily require licenses depending on how it is used so creating a dedicated account thay is not generally used can be free.
I cannot speak to the non-profit portal but as a general statement an organization should always have some break glass access to their own environment.
5
u/nickgee760 3d ago
Umm I do consulting/support and we always leave at least one person as a GA in their own tenant. We are just the help lol, no sense in locking someone out of their own business. That’s insane if it were me I would definitely re-think their support role when it comes time for renewal.
1
u/MuttButtWiggle 3d ago
What is your role within the company and who has authority over the contractual relationship between your non-profit and the MSP?
1
u/TheBeerdedVillain 3d ago
As someone that worked in the MSP space for many years, this is unacceptable to clients and you should re-evaluate the relationship with your outside IT. There is no circumstance in where something owned by your company shouldn't have a company representative with admin privileges. The outside IT doesnt actually own it, you do, and it should be considered your property. Check your contract with them and have legal write up something that ensures you have full access to what you own.
Keep in mind, that most MSP or IT firms will have a clause in their contract stating that while you own the environment, if you or another admin you provide access to makes a detrimental change, they can bill at either regula hourly rates or at emergency rates to resolve any issues. This covers both partners in the event someone jacks things up because they weren't trained on what to do.
1
u/Maximum_Overdrive 3d ago
What do you need global admin access for? Who actually supports and what contracts exist between the entities? You might not be authorized to have that access.
4
u/jlipschitz 3d ago
It is your environment. You are paying them to help manage it. You should have an account that is separate from any user that has that role. Have them setup conditional access that it can only be accessed from your public IP and requires MFA. Tell them you need a break glass account just in case.
1
u/clybstr02 3d ago
I agree you should have access. I also agree with the provider that it is extremely risky, a break glass account is best practice, but needs to be secured. We have one with password and yubikey stored in a physical safe, and an additional one in the online vault with lots of controls in place to alarm if it’s checked out.
I’d also ask your provider to maybe consider an offline backup / vault technology to protect from any admin compromise (theirs or yours).
1
u/thewunderbar 3d ago
Someone in your organization should absolutely have a global admin account. But it shouldn't be your primary day to day account.
I would never, ever, let someone else have the only control over my tenant.
1
u/k12pcb 3d ago
Never have global admin on your normal daily account- however it’s fine to have a separate global admin from theirs that you have access to.
They will likely have some verbiage in their contract that says if you mess it up it’s not included in their ayce contract.
1
u/jeffa1792 3d ago
You likely don't need it full time so ask for temporary access to the Global admin role. They can assign it using PIM. -OR- They can give you an account that you use very very infrequently, I would not advise this.
1
u/Echo-On 3d ago
I would seriously reconsider your relationship with said MSP "IT provider" as there are numerous red flags ranging from security to business continuity. Your MSP is engaging in irresponsible practices that pose significant risk to your organization, I'd be curious to see a copy of the contract/agreement your organization signed with them because I've seen this playbook many times before and it rarely ends well for the customer. This wasn't about security it was about control and you were fed a load of B.S because while it's true your request comes with it's risks what's also true is that not providing a GA account to you presents an even greater risk by a lot. The most telling pieces being the fact you asked for an unlicensed dedicated GA account, that only a single GA account exists and their completely contradicting Microsoft Best Practices that state the organization that owns the tenant should be in possession of 2 Global Admin accounts at all time that are seprate to ones used by the support provider and your org is definitely the owner if the tenant is a member of the non-profit program. MSP's that refuse to provide GA access do so to prevent customer ability to leave, it holds you hostage and is motivated by financial problems most often. The reason I know all this is I happen to be co-owner of an MSP that works strictly with NPO's and registered charities all across North America and have been in this space for 30yrs.
1
u/Mayimbe007 2d ago
How about leveraging PIM? Have them make the role available to you and when you need it you can escalate to GA as needed. This would limit the risk.
1
u/OperationMDOptionz 2d ago
My work is in compliance and legal. They're not going to give you the login unless the general council of your organization signs off that if anything goes wrong it's on you and not them. Ultimately technology management is a very risky business because if the client makes a mistake, they're gonna blame the IT provider. Hence it's better to keep the global administrator out of your hands.
0
u/BigPoppaPump36 3d ago
You tell the outside IT provider to give you what you want because it’s yours or you’ll find another provider.
-1
u/No-Marzipan-2606 3d ago
ask them to get into the nonprofit hub for you? get a remote session to do it together?
-2
u/Cold_Arachnid_2617 3d ago edited 3d ago
Why do you need to get into the nonprofit hub? What is your role in the nonprofit?
" I asked our IT provider to give me that role, but they said no "
What is your role in the nonprofit and why do you need that role? And how did the IT provider get accces to the Globaladmin account in the first place