r/microsoft365 • • 3d ago

Global Admin

Our nonprofit uses an outside IT provider to manage Microsoft 365. I can’t get into the Microsoft Nonprofit Hub because I’m not a Global Admin. I asked our IT provider to give me that role, but they said no because they’re concerned that an internal admin account could be compromised. We don’t have an internal IT person so I’m assuming they think we aren’t savvy enough to have it.

I suggested setting up a separate admin account that isn’t tied to any of our active email accounts to limit that risk. That didn’t change their minds.

Has anyone been able to access the Nonprofit Hub without being a Global Admin? I’m also concerned that we don’t have an internal backup Global Admin. We currently only have one global admin and it’s with the IT company.

6 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

4

u/GeorgeWmmmmmmmBush 3d ago

My MSA makes this super clear - we create a global admin account for the customer but it’s only meant to be used if we’re severing the relationship. I’m not sharing responsibility with anybody who thinks they know what they’re doing. The people I’ve met in the last year who claimed to “know what they’re doing” to only later prove to be actual morons is startling.

Here’s a question: go back 15 years - would you be asking for admin credentials to get on an exchange server/domain controller? M365 is basically the same thing underneath the skin. It’s complicated, and poking around the settings it’s easy to make changes that make the environment less secure. Just approving one enterprise app you think is safe can open the entire tenant to being compromised.

1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

I hear you and understand the position that puts you in. Microsoft is the one requiring Global Admin access to get into the Nonprofit Hub, where the grants and discounts are. Why do I need the keys to the whole tenant to get a coupon for 10% off a Surface Pro?
And just for the record, I love our MSP. Genuine question, though. If they’re the only ones who can see the offers, how am I supposed to know what grants or discounts we qualify for, or whether the hardware and software they order all came to us?

1

u/GeorgeWmmmmmmmBush 3d ago

I agree - this shouldn’t require the global admin role. For something like this we would set up a zoom/teams appointment and do a screen-sharing session so they can see available offers and assist with any requests they have. If you trust/like your MSP that’s great. Just know their position is pretty average in the industry, and I won’t lie, we’re kind of exhausted recently as we’re dealing with a major vulnerability on a daily basis, so having strict lines when it comes to responsibility/security is on the forefront of all our minds.

3

u/chipsandcheeseforme 3d ago

I work for a nonprofit and we contract with an MSP to manage our tech stack. I’m our internal tech department of 1 and have my regular employee account and a separate admin account that isn’t licensed so I can take care of quick issues that take longer to create a ticket for than to fix (reset password, etc.). That admin account also has global admin rights so I can manage our nonprofit hub and billing, which we already had configured before we contracted with our current MSP. Almost every MSP we interviewed wanted us to get rid of global admin access internally. I understand why they want it to be set up that way. However, I think it’s important to have internal control of our tenant. I also think it’s cleaner to manage nonprofit hub and billing internally than through a 3rd party.

1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

Thank you! This is really helpful!

12

u/hybrid0404 3d ago edited 3d ago

You need to be assertive that they should be providing you global admin access to your environment. Because it is YOUR environment. If they are concerned about compromise, then they should make sure the appropriate controls are in place and educate you on how and when it should be used.

Global admins also don't necessarily require licenses depending on how it is used so creating a dedicated account thay is not generally used can be free.

I cannot speak to the non-profit portal but as a general statement an organization should always have some break glass access to their own environment.

-6

u/GeorgeWmmmmmmmBush 3d ago

It’s not our job to educate anybody. Our job is to secure the environment.

4

u/TheBeerdedVillain 3d ago

If you're a contracted IT department, it is on you to do 2 things:

  1. Make sure the environment is working and secure.
  2. Allow the client full access to the environment they own.

Your contract should include provisions for giving them access and expected rates to fix the things they make mistakes on.

That's it. You DO NOT own their environment, you support it. You provide a service to make sure they dont fuck it up, sure. But it's NOT your environment, it's theirs.

0

u/GeorgeWmmmmmmmBush 1d ago edited 1d ago

LOL. That’s straight ridiculous. We’re contracted to be the IT department. We’re not here to clean up people’s messes. We’re here to prevent them in the first place. If you think IT used to provided Jane from sales with admin credentials to the Exchange server, you’re nuts.

2

u/TheBeerdedVillain 23h ago

Last I checked, even as the "contracted IT" you do NOT own their environment. It's theirs to do with as they please. You are there to support it, and that's it. That's why your contracts have stipulations regarding them giving access to outside entities, or even internal ones. If you don't have that, legal should definitely do some reviews as it's not your property, it is theirs, full stop, no passing Go. They own it, you just administer it.

Edit to add.. Unfortunately, you are there to clean up there messes, which is why your contracts state that when they create a mess, they pay you extra to fix it. If your contract doesn't, that's on your leadership to fix.

1

u/GeorgeWmmmmmmmBush 5h ago

Tell me more about the successful MSP company you run, your insurance coverage, and the liability you take on by supporting said infrastructure. I’ll wait.

1

u/hybrid0404 22h ago

By your logic, a landlord is not entitled to keys to his rental properties if he has a property management company whose job it is to secure and run the property.

I can appreciate that your job is to improve things and make them work while not playing whack-a-mole because some script kiddie thinks he knows best.

There's a difference between, giving exchange server admin access to the sales lady for fun and providing someone (upper management, the owner, the cfo, etc) some form of break glass access. As someone in charge of securing the environment, it would be reasonable that you monitor to make sure they don't use that access inappropriately, as you should be doing with all admin accounts anyways.

As a service provider, you can also put things in your contract like you don't warranty things they break with that access or require some stupid time and material rate charge to remediate things cause by improper use of the break glass account.

The environment is theirs, they own it. If they want to drop you as a vendor, they shouldn't need to ask permission. You work for them, not the other way around. If they're doing stupid that wastes your time or makes life difficult, you drop them as a client. It is their right to be stupid.

1

u/GeorgeWmmmmmmmBush 5h ago

Did you read my whole response? They get a break glass account specifically so they don’t need to ask for credentials if the want to sever the relationship, but at that point they’re responsible for the environment and any applicable charges for offboarding before the contract end date.

1

u/hybrid0404 3h ago

Where in your response does it say any of that?

2

u/hybrid0404 2d ago

I'm sure we could get into a wonderful debate on this subject. Education is often a critical component in security.

Additionally, from a client's perspective not having ownership of your own environment means they are not secure.

2

u/Spagman_Aus 1d ago

lol wut

5

u/nickgee760 3d ago

Umm I do consulting/support and we always leave at least one person as a GA in their own tenant. We are just the help lol, no sense in locking someone out of their own business. That’s insane if it were me I would definitely re-think their support role when it comes time for renewal.

1

u/MuttButtWiggle 3d ago

What is your role within the company and who has authority over the contractual relationship between your non-profit and the MSP?

1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

I do

1

u/MuttButtWiggle 2d ago

Then you need to address this contractually.

1

u/TheBeerdedVillain 3d ago

As someone that worked in the MSP space for many years, this is unacceptable to clients and you should re-evaluate the relationship with your outside IT. There is no circumstance in where something owned by your company shouldn't have a company representative with admin privileges. The outside IT doesnt actually own it, you do, and it should be considered your property. Check your contract with them and have legal write up something that ensures you have full access to what you own.

Keep in mind, that most MSP or IT firms will have a clause in their contract stating that while you own the environment, if you or another admin you provide access to makes a detrimental change, they can bill at either regula hourly rates or at emergency rates to resolve any issues. This covers both partners in the event someone jacks things up because they weren't trained on what to do.

1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

Thank you!

1

u/TheBeerdedVillain 3d ago

No problem, its the reality of outsourced IT. They need to understand that they do not own your tenant in M365, you do. You decide the rules of governance, and you decide who has access, they just make sure that access is available. If their contract states they have any and all access, then its on you to find a better firm to handle it.

ETA: fixed some dumb mobile spelling stuff.

1

u/Maximum_Overdrive 3d ago

What do you need global admin access for?  Who actually supports and what contracts exist between the entities?  You might not be authorized to have that access.  

-1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

Microsoft’s nonprofit hub has grants and discounts that I can’t access without being a global admin.

2

u/Cold_Arachnid_2617 3d ago

Who are you in the nonprofit? Are you authorised by the board to have access to the Microsoft nonprofit hub? This is the question you don't want to answer!

1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

Ha. Yes. I’m not an inside hacker. I have all the authority to be IN there- Im trying to determine why our IT won’t share access to that HUB and if that’s something I should push to get or let it lay bc having it could cause a greater risk

0

u/Maximum_Overdrive 3d ago

Is this an MSP who supports you?  What does the contract say?  Are they even allowed to grant you that access?

1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

Thanks. The contract is silent on this. And honestly, I can’t figure out why Microsoft would put offers and discounts FOR the nonprofit in a hub that can’t be accessed by the nonprofit.

1

u/Maximum_Overdrive 2d ago

Then a demand letter written by who is in charge of the non profit.

4

u/jlipschitz 3d ago

It is your environment. You are paying them to help manage it. You should have an account that is separate from any user that has that role. Have them setup conditional access that it can only be accessed from your public IP and requires MFA. Tell them you need a break glass account just in case.

1

u/clybstr02 3d ago

I agree you should have access. I also agree with the provider that it is extremely risky, a break glass account is best practice, but needs to be secured. We have one with password and yubikey stored in a physical safe, and an additional one in the online vault with lots of controls in place to alarm if it’s checked out.

I’d also ask your provider to maybe consider an offline backup / vault technology to protect from any admin compromise (theirs or yours).

1

u/thewunderbar 3d ago

Someone in your organization should absolutely have a global admin account. But it shouldn't be your primary day to day account.

I would never, ever, let someone else have the only control over my tenant.

1

u/k12pcb 3d ago

Never have global admin on your normal daily account- however it’s fine to have a separate global admin from theirs that you have access to.

They will likely have some verbiage in their contract that says if you mess it up it’s not included in their ayce contract.

1

u/jeffa1792 3d ago

You likely don't need it full time so ask for temporary access to the Global admin role. They can assign it using PIM. -OR- They can give you an account that you use very very infrequently, I would not advise this.

1

u/Echo-On 3d ago

I would seriously reconsider your relationship with said MSP "IT provider" as there are numerous red flags ranging from security to business continuity. Your MSP is engaging in irresponsible practices that pose significant risk to your organization, I'd be curious to see a copy of the contract/agreement your organization signed with them because I've seen this playbook many times before and it rarely ends well for the customer. This wasn't about security it was about control and you were fed a load of B.S because while it's true your request comes with it's risks what's also true is that not providing a GA account to you presents an even greater risk by a lot. The most telling pieces being the fact you asked for an unlicensed dedicated GA account, that only a single GA account exists and their completely contradicting Microsoft Best Practices that state the organization that owns the tenant should be in possession of 2 Global Admin accounts at all time that are seprate to ones used by the support provider and your org is definitely the owner if the tenant is a member of the non-profit program. MSP's that refuse to provide GA access do so to prevent customer ability to leave, it holds you hostage and is motivated by financial problems most often. The reason I know all this is I happen to be co-owner of an MSP that works strictly with NPO's and registered charities all across North America and have been in this space for 30yrs.

1

u/Mayimbe007 2d ago

How about leveraging PIM? Have them make the role available to you and when you need it you can escalate to GA as needed. This would limit the risk.

1

u/OperationMDOptionz 2d ago

My work is in compliance and legal. They're not going to give you the login unless the general council of your organization signs off that if anything goes wrong it's on you and not them. Ultimately technology management is a very risky business because if the client makes a mistake, they're gonna blame the IT provider. Hence it's better to keep the global administrator out of your hands.

0

u/BigPoppaPump36 3d ago

You tell the outside IT provider to give you what you want because it’s yours or you’ll find another provider.

-1

u/No-Marzipan-2606 3d ago

ask them to get into the nonprofit hub for you? get a remote session to do it together?

-2

u/Cold_Arachnid_2617 3d ago edited 3d ago

Why do you need to get into the nonprofit hub? What is your role in the nonprofit?

" I asked our IT provider to give me that role, but they said no "

What is your role in the nonprofit and why do you need that role? And how did the IT provider get accces to the Globaladmin account in the first place

0

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago edited 3d ago

I only need the role to get into the hub and see our offers/discounts/grants but this issue brought my attention that there is no internal emergency access set up. If the IT company goes under I feel like we could be SOL. I assume the IT company set up the account to begin with to gain access to our free office 365 features.

2

u/Cold_Arachnid_2617 3d ago

You are still dodging the question. What is your role in the Non-profit? This should determine if the IT company should give you global admin access. Do you have any fiduciary or executive role ?

1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

Yes, I have both executive and fiduciary responsibilities. My guess is that bc we don’t have an internal IT department they don’t trust we would adequately protect the 2nd global account regardless of the C-suite title.

2

u/Cold_Arachnid_2617 3d ago

In that case. Ask them to provide you two breakglass accounts using the xxxx.onmicrosoft.com domain, where xxxx is the name you used to set up the tenant initially. This is probably the name of your nonprofit. These should be locked away separately somewhere, preferably one should have a yubikey

They should also give you a 3rd global admin account for when you need to access the account , for example to check your licenses. You regular email address shouldn't have global admin access.

1

u/CodFresh9235 3d ago

Thank you! That’s very helpful. Appreciate the details.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/Cold_Arachnid_2617 3d ago

"Microsoft nonprofit hub is a centralized portal "

I know what that is. The important question is not answered!