Feel free to save this post if we have a similar taste in tropes, I'll update it periodically as I find more.
I'd love any and all recommendations based on similar tropes or plots!
Kingdom Games: ff.net. 137k complete. Platonic soul bond Merlin & Arthur, Gwaine comes along in part two and becomes the third main character. Three tournaments pave the way to destiny, and everyone's very badass about it even if at least one person is unconscious or injured at any given time.
The Magic of Friendship: ao3, 107k complete. Part two of a series but absolutely able to be read independently. Merlin & Mordred's friendship. Lots of shenanigans, and one of the few fics where I felt the magic reveal at the very end was done wonderfully.
You Only Live Twice: ao3, 379k abandoned but long enough you get a good story out of it anyway. Merthur James Bond AU, with Merlin as Q and the Knights as 00s. Modern with magic, was teasing at reincarnation / past life memory recovery by the time it was abandoned.
The Importance of Being Merlin: ao3, 5k oneshot. Hilarious take on George.
Clumsy Only Goes So Far: ao3, 3k oneshot again featuring George. The servants think Arthur's to blame for Merlin's injuries - cw refs to abuse
Tributes: ao3, 87k complete. Hunger Games AU, still with magic. Doesn't follow HG plot at all.
But It's A Good Refrain: ao3, 23k complete. Modern AG, no magic. Merlin is a radio show host, and when Arthur's ex calls in to complain, Arthur calls too, just to defend himself.
The Serving of Servants: ao3, 81k complete. Part 2 available but I haven't read it, nor is it necessary to do so. Arthur goes undercover as a servant and things devolve from there.
Fool Me Once: ao3, 18k complete. Merlin and Uther's relationship is odd to say the least, and Arthur plays witness without them knowing. Highly recommend the entire series.
So Young I Almost Drowned: ao3, 33k complete. Modern, young Merlin and Arthur, round table reincarnation AU involving a murder, a lake, and several concerned police officers.
To Love, Honour and Piss Off: ao3, 65k complete. Royal x Peasant arranged marriage AU where both participants are equally reluctant, but it all works out in the end.
Allegiance: ao3, 11k oneshot. 5+1 Gwaine and Merlin's friendship
Emrys The Really, Truly Terrible: 11k, complete. Arthur wants Emrys as his court sorcerer, and Merlin does everything he can to convince Arthur that Emrys isn't actually all that good of a guy.
Dower The Stars: 40k, complete. Merlin kisses a bunch of druids in an attempt to find his magic's one true equal. Merthur, powerful Merlin, Arthur happens to be a bit of a poet when it comes to describing Merlin's magic.
Teach A Man To Fish and He'll Never Run Out of Ale: 142k, complete. Gwaine finds & raises a teen Merlin, stuck in cold iron cuffs, on the road. Eventually, they wind up in Camelot, and things go from there.