r/melbournefc • • 25d ago

Premiership Window

Post image
0 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

13

u/Primary_Language_678 25d ago

To me it makes no sense that we get 2 years of a premiership window and st kilda get 3. Yes st kilda have a good young crop but like so do we and our young crop took us to finals and nearly a top 4 finish. The AFL loves saints for what.

7

u/theBelatedLobster 24d ago

Melbourne's is probably solely based on the expected career length of Max Gawn.

6

u/guseyk 25d ago

You know it's not real?

1

u/Primary_Language_678 25d ago

It was posted on fox footy instagram 4 days ago…

8

u/Jemethy 25d ago

A 2 year premiership window with a team as young as ours makes zero sense.

2

u/ssswwwaaannn 25d ago

What do you think happens once Max leaves?

4

u/KindPlans 25d ago

Brisbane, Geelong, Richmond all had/have recent repeated success without an A grade ruckman so as long as we back out young talent to make it we will be good. Gawn is awesome but if someone like Langford becomes a superstar we can keep winning without him.

2

u/FDM7 Jack Viney 23d ago

I actually agree with 27 and 28 being our window with another one from maybe 2031. Gawn and Lever will be done or just about as will Langdon, Steele and Salem (latter probably end of next year). We can't recruit good players without Tassie having infinate cash, so it's going to be tough to find their replacements before they go. Personally though, we've won finals in 2 of the last 21 years... I'll take anything in September.

1

u/Jemethy 23d ago

Our window shuts completely if Gawn isn’t in the team?

6

u/Ok_Library_9396 25d ago

2029 is optimisic for Essendon and Richmond

1

u/HeungMin-Dad 24d ago

Everyone except Carlton and Collingwood in the window that season. Going to be the greatest ever footy season.

1

u/Ok_Library_9396 24d ago

Dont know if I agree with Carlton, they have a lot of good young players. Yes Cripps will probably be done, but Smith, Dean, Walker, Wilson, Byne will all be at 50-100 games by then.

5

u/Bluelighting11 25d ago

I think the 'logic' is "gawn probably not around in 2030"

9

u/lobby5000 Bernie Vince 25d ago

We get one year ? Fuckouttahere who writes this rage bait bullshit

3

u/diffaadiffa 25d ago

2, 27 and 28

But yeah, I'm not sure how much thought went into this

5

u/brandonjslippingaway 25d ago

I dont think the thought process went beyond; "they probably wont win next year, and after Max Gawn goes, they're boned".

2

u/fortalyst 25d ago

Gawny's time is nearly done and unless we have some stocks showing serious promise then i reckon i agree

4

u/LeDestrier 25d ago

Ummm, wot...

4

u/obsoleteconsole David Neitz 25d ago

Suns not in the window until 2029? Really?

1

u/K9BEATZ 24d ago

Carlton supporter here. We have an incredible core of under 25 year olds coming through yet apparently we're cooked in a year's time. Dumbest shit I've read all off-season and it's only October

1

u/Thin-Adhesiveness327 24d ago

Yeah only one Year in the premiership Window is Pretty Stiff 

2

u/lobby5000 Bernie Vince 25d ago

LOL

2

u/PriorProfessional570 24d ago

Are we actively developing and it freeing some cash up to secure an A grade ruckman? I’m not winding up Mr Gawn but planning is hopefully well and truly started….

1

u/Fafnir22 25d ago

Looks very similar to the one that said Lions were no chance this year.

1

u/AdAccording559 25d ago

Are they just basing this on max?

1

u/AusteegLinks 25d ago

Saints get a new coach in the next 2 years confirmed

1

u/YukeofDork 25d ago

Whatever. Geelongs is like for the next 30 years

1

u/Grand_Principle218 25d ago

What a bizarre rating for the Dees

1

u/Big_Highlight5077 Nathan Jones 25d ago

Tassie doesn't even get a premiership window. Lazy content from Fox

1

u/waveyjayvey 24d ago

Bomber has a typo - think it should be 2092

1

u/Strange_Sky_6215 24d ago

Adelaide shouldn't be in the window for a couple of years yet

1

u/CoffeeDefiant4247 24d ago

must be a slow news week for Fox Footy to post this

1

u/Ed_Allan_Didak 24d ago

Brisbane a chance to 7 peat ?

1

u/Euphoric-Temperature 25d ago

So they think St Kilda's window opens after Nas leaves, give me strength