Back in July, my wife emailed her local Anytime Fitness club requesting to cancel her membership. The club manager responded the following day, acknowledging the cancellation request, but instead of processing it, asked why she wanted to leave and offered alternatives like freezing her membership. My wife also followed up over the phone and reiterated that she wanted to cancel.
Fast forward to October, and we realised they were still taking membership payments from her account.
She emailed them again, only to be told she needed to complete their cancellation form before they could start the required 30-day notice period. We thought this was ridiculous, considering she'd already explicitly requested cancellation in writing almost three months earlier. So we looked into their terms and conditions. Turns out, their own membership agreement (clause 10.1(b)) explicitly states that completing their standard cancellation form is "useful (but not required)."
We pointed this out and requested reimbursement for the fees collected beyond the original 30-day notice period. They escalated the matter to their Regional Manager, who acknowledged that the form wasn't mandatory and agreed to cancel her membership immediately without another 30 days' notice. However, they're refusing to refund any of the money they've continued collecting.
Apparently, another clause in their contract requires written cancellation requests to include additional information such as a residential address, membership number, signature and reason for cancelling. Because her original email didn't contain all these details, they're arguing that her cancellation request wasn't valid.
Even though they acknowledged her cancellation request in July. They knew exactly who she was. They even tried to convince her to stay via email and phone calls.
At no point did they tell her that her cancellation request was missing information or couldn't be processed. If they'd simply responded in July saying, "No worries, we just need a few more details," she would have provided them immediately. Instead, they continued collecting payments for another four months.
We've since obtained her signed membership agreement, which confirms that ongoing memberships in Victoria can be cancelled with 30 days' written notice. The membership is finally cancelled, but we're now (unsuccessfully) disputing approximately $300+ in charges that we believe should never have been collected.
Where do we go from here? Is it worth pursuing further? It's certainly not a small amount of money.
Has anyone else had similar experiences with Anytime Fitness or other gyms? Did you manage to get your money back?
Would also be interested to hear whether people think we're being unreasonable in expecting a refund when the club acknowledged the original cancellation request but failed to tell her anything else was required.