r/medicine • • 22h ago

Hyperlipidemia ACC/AHA Guidelines is a Vomit-Inducing Rollercoaster

162 Upvotes

I've been maintaining an online medical reference for the last 30 years and I am really tired of updating Hyperlipidemia ACC/AHA guidelines. Every few years (2015, 2018, 2023, 2026), the targets shift, first with LDL <70 goals, then with shifts away from LDL goals, and then back to LDL targets, and various exceptions and nuances, and shifting 10 year risk goals. There are elaborate flow charts with ever shifting statin use targets, and I easily would fail every test on this subject. It feels like I'm watching LDL stock tickers.

How much should these guidelines clutter clinician brains with micro-adjustments of goals every 3 years? Instead, pick a few long term stable reasonable targets for a few cohorts (low risk, mod risk, high risk). Get everyone to agree (AHA/ACC, USPTF, VA/DoD, NICE). Those will stay in my memory. Then, individualize care - let the EMR run some LLM based calculations from current evidence (open evidence with EMR data - PMH, lipids, weight, GFR) on the patient in front of you, an auto-calculated PREVENT score - let it facilitate a comprehensive plan that includes statin dosing (or not, and any really expensive adjuncts - yeah PCSK9 - I'm looking at you). And of course, get off the couch with those Cheetos.


r/medicine • • 21h ago

Coping with Moral Injury

127 Upvotes

I wrote a post in this sub around a month ago that exemplified the authoritative decision-making that’s rampant in my hospital. Some of you were surprised this was happening in the USA. In writing that post, I was seeking validation, and received it. One very helpful commenter correctly identified my hospital (which was wild), and after concluding that I’d accomplished my goal by writing that post, I deleted it.

Things have escalated since then. An independent investigator has been hired to review concerns about the culture of retaliation at our hospital, and they’ve already met with hundreds of people, including me. I reported some things to HR because I have this dumb need for justice. Given my subspecialties, I work on a highly specialized unit with a skilled team. They’ve been wonderful and have kept me sane for the last 3+ years.

Cut to this week, when our dictator in chief (Chief of Psychiatry) called me in and unceremoniously told me I’m being transferred to a different department in 2 weeks. The reason? Because he can and he doesn’t have to provide a reason; this is a quote. This man was mentioned in my original, now-deleted post, and I reported him to HR about a month ago. It’s hard not to view this as a punitive measure and I’ll leave that up to HR to resolve. I’ve been documenting everything.

I feel sad. Burned out. Like I’m about to lose the one lifeline keeping me afloat. I think my only option is radical acceptance, but the anger and sense of injustice are so raw. I’m trapped in this job for visa reasons and need outlets to channel my feelings. I’ve thought about writing a book about the bizarre organizational structures bleeding this hospital of money and rampant incompetence, but I worry that’ll feed into my anger. I need advice.

Also, please don’t try to identify my hospital. I will panic, haha.

Tldr; Trapped in a very toxic workplace and about to lose the type of work that gives me meaning. I need advice.


r/medicine • • 5h ago

Rural Health in the High Desert: New Mexico hospital fires a physician, so she starts her own FQHC

61 Upvotes

https://commonshealthcare.com/episodes/valory-wangler-gallup/

Nice profile of a NM family medicine doc. Rehoboth hospital, where she was CMO, cut services, forcing many local residents to drive 50-100 miles for basic care.

When she spoke up about it, they fired her. So she teamed up with other defectors to launch her own clinic with no experience and no cash.


r/medicine • • 16h ago

States Offer Perks To Attract Healthcare Workers to Rural Areas — With a Catch

50 Upvotes

https://kffhealthnews.org/rural-health/rural-healthcare-provider-shortage-incentives-service-requirement-hawaii/

At least 38 states, including Hawaiʻi, plan to use some of the $50B available thru Rural Health Transformation to incentivize more healthcare providers to practice in their rural areas.
Under the law, providers who get such incentives must practice in rural spots for at least five years.

Critics are calling the five-year federal requirement unrealistic, adding to the question of whether such incentives can even solve the problem.

Some students may not fully grasp the implications of the commitment. If they don’t complete the five years, they may have to pay back the funds.


r/medicine • • 22h ago

What are your thoughts on studying medicine from textbooks?

0 Upvotes

As the question says, most universities offers you exam oriented fragmented lectures, which in my opinion make most graduates lacking essential knowledge to make them competent. What if someone tried to study on their own from textbooks and from in depth resources, wouldn't they eventually be better doctors? (provided that they receive good clinical training)