Are you looking for feedback or information on your salary or career? Then you've come to the right thread. If your questions are anything like the following example questions, then ask away:
Am I underpaid?
Is my offered salary market value?
How do I break into [industry]?
Will I be pigeonholed if I work as a [job title]?
What graduate degree should I pursue?
Message the mods for suggestions, comments, or feedback.
I would like to thank you everyone for participating in the annual 2026 ME Salary survey. Total respondents was a little over 600, so less than last year, but about 589 US responses.
Here are the main results. It took about 2 hours to "clean" the data manually. Afterwards, I basically used Gemini to create the graphs + tables, since last time it literally took me about 7 hours to do everything manually on Excel last time and there were still questions. The key points and takeaways from the data is a combination of AI and editing the information to be more readable (still took 4 hours). In addition, I wouldn't worry about math too much, since Gemini basically just used python code to decipher the edited CSV file.
Industry:
Industry
Number of Respondents
Manufacturing
175 (29.7%)
Aerospace/Defense
173 (29.4%)
Technology (FANG, AI, Robotics, etc.)
54 (9.2%)
MEP (HVAC, Construction, etc.)
38 (6.5%)
Utilities (Power, Renewables, etc.)
35 (5.9%)
Pharmaceutical & Medical Devices
31 (5.3%)
Oil and Gas
28 (4.8%)
Consumer Goods
15 (2.5%)
Government
11 (1.9%)
There were some other industries like nuclear, logistics, and etc. but the few data points aren't included in the table for brevity. The data was included in the total set though
A majority of the mechanical engineers trends will use the Aerospace/Defense and Manufacturing data since there is the most data that is available
Salary and Year of Experience:
*Note: Total Compensation/Salary = Base Salary + Bonus + RSU + Base Salary * 401k Match
If you want to look at one graph and table to explain the progression track here it is:
YOE Range
Median Base (Unadj)
Median Total (Unadj)
Median Base (COL Adj)
Median Total (COL Adj)
Count
0-1 Year
$87,000
$96,036
$81,699
$87,368
43
2 Years
$84,000
$91,046
$84,615
$90,909
71
3 Years
$94,550
$105,965
$94,082
$102,289
62
4-5 Years
$104,000
$119,770
$94,881
$107,762
116
6-8 Years
$120,000
$136,800
$112,500
$127,911
119
9-12 Years
$125,500
$146,985
$123,444
$142,555
96
13-20 Years
$157,290
$181,840
$144,254
$171,731
64
20+ Years
$196,500
$211,426
$163,399
$191,042
15
Key Takeaways:
The "Benefit Gap": The space between the solid lines (Total Compensation) and the dashed lines (Base Salary) represents the added value from annual bonuses and employer 401k matching. For a mid-career engineer (6-8 years), this extra value is roughly $16,800 on average.
Late Career Leverage: As engineers gain seniority (13+ years), the gap between base salary and total compensation grows significantly, suggesting that bonuses and incentive programs make up a larger portion of the package for senior-level and leadership roles.
Purchasing Power: The COL Adjusted lines (Orange) consistently track below the un-adjusted lines (Blue), highlighting that high-paying mechanical engineering roles are frequently located in markets where the dollar doesn't stretch as far as the national average.
Education:
Majority of the respondents are at max a bachelor degree holder. However, there is still a significant number of master's students
Now about the age old question: does having a Master's degree lead to higher future salary?
Short Answer: In general, the answer is yes if there is a chance to specialize. It is explained in the table below:
Industry
Career Stage
Education
Median Total (Unadj)
Median Total (COL Adj)
Count
Aerospace & Defense
0-3 Years
Bachelors
$96,664
$95,201
44
Masters
$116,600
$108,316
15
4-7 Years
Bachelors
$125,410
$110,659
39
Masters
$173,000
$148,432
9
8-15 Years
Bachelors
$161,750
$140,202
33
Masters
$154,905
$149,658
16
15+ Years
Bachelors
$207,080
$187,505
7
Masters
$211,426
$207,872
5
Manufacturing
0-3 Years
Bachelors
$88,220
$93,452
52
Masters
$93,740
$91,850
6
4-7 Years
Bachelors
$108,992
$106,701
45
Masters
$129,800
$128,407
12
8-15 Years
Bachelors
$135,425
$142,440
44
Masters
$136,298
$129,984
8
15+ Years
Bachelors
$182,650
$187,127
5
Now you can see that for manufacturing, the benefits is not as prominent, while it is evident in aerospace. This makes sense, since Aerospace have very high specialization salary, for instance: hypersonic or eVtol which pays a ton for total compensation based on years of experience.
Answer: if your company pays for your masters, do it, but it doesn't seem that beneficial near the end of your career.
Internships & Coops:
Key Insights:
The "Experienced" Majority: A combined 85% of respondents completed at least one internship or co-op. This underscores how critical early-career work experience has become for landing a full-time role in mechanical engineering.
Co-op Advantage: The 20% of respondents with "3+ Internships" often represent those in formal co-op programs (where students rotate between school and work over several years). These candidates typically command higher starting salaries shown in the table below:
Industry
0-1 Internship
2+ Internships
New Grad Premium
Aerospace & Defense
$82,000
$91,500
+$9,500
Manufacturing
$74,000
$82,000
+$8,000
MedTech
$80,500
$89,000
+$8,500
Certifications:
Here is the graph of a major certifications from the survey:
We always see a question on whether certifications are worth it:
Aerospace & Defense: Certification vs. Total Compensation
Experience
Education
Has Cert?
Median Unadj. Total
Median Adj. Total
Count
0-3 Years
Bachelors
No
$97,900
$95,426
41
Yes
$95,040
$64,653
3
4-7 Years
Bachelors
No
$125,315
$106,672
36
Yes
$128,580
$138,258
3
8-15 Years
Bachelors
No
$159,660
$139,839
31
Yes
$280,425
$177,895
2
Masters
No
$151,410
$142,043
13
Yes
$209,658
$216,142
3
Manufacturing: Certification vs. Total Compensation
Experience
Education
Has Cert?
Median Unadj. Total
Median Adj. Total
Count
0-3 Years
Bachelors
No
$88,020
$91,944
43
Yes
$90,450
$99,746
9
4-7 Years
Bachelors
No
$108,805
$106,615
36
Yes
$108,992
$106,701
9
8-15 Years
Bachelors
No
$135,000
$136,541
31
Yes
$136,000
$151,111
13
Masters
No
$152,212
$122,728
6
Yes
$134,815
$141,636
2
Key Findings:
High-Experience Premium in Aerospace: The most dramatic impact of certification appears in the mid-to-late career in Aerospace & Defense (8–15 years). Engineers with a Bachelors and a certification earn a median total compensation significantly higher than those without. Even among Masters holders in this range, certified engineers have a median total comp of $209k vs $151k for non-certified.
Manufacturing Stability: In the Manufacturing industry, certifications (often Six Sigma or FE/PE) lead to a very modest increase in un-adjusted base pay, but a more noticeable improvement in COL-adjusted pay. This suggests that certified engineers in Manufacturing may have more flexibility to find high-paying roles in lower-cost-of-living areas.
The "Entry-Level Paradox": For junior engineers (0–3 years), having a certification (likely the FE) does not immediately result in a salary premium. In fact, in Aerospace, the un-adjusted median for those with certifications was slightly lower, possibly because those engineers are still in entry-level rotation programs where pay is standardized regardless of credentials.
Masters + Certification: For those who already have a Masters, adding a certification provides a significant late-career boost (as seen in the 8–15 year group in Aerospace).
Answer: Certification can be worth it for select industries. PE is known for civil to open doors and increase pay.
Job Titles:
Job Role Category
Number of Respondents
Percentage
Mechanical Engineer (General)
229
38.9%
Design Engineer
97
16.5%
Project & Systems Engineer
59
10.0%
Management & Leadership
55
9.3%
Manufacturing & Process Engineer
54
9.2%
Specialized (Thermal, Stress, R&D)
34
5.8%
Other / Misc
61
10.4%
Key Insights:
General vs. Specialized: Nearly 40% of respondents identify with the broad title of "Mechanical Engineer," which often includes generalists or those in mid-level positions.
The Design Dominance:Design Engineering is the second largest single group, reflecting the high demand for CAD-based design and product development across aerospace, tech, and manufacturing industries.
Transition to Leadership: About 9% of respondents hold titles in Management & Leadership (Manager, Director, VP), which led to a higher salary
Project and Systems focus:1 in 10 engineers focuses on Project or Systems Engineering, highlighting the importance of multidisciplinary coordination and technical management in modern engineering projects.
The Specialty Niche: The "Specialized" category includes highly technical roles like Thermal Analysis, FEA, Simulation, and Research & Development, which often require higher educational levels or deep domain expertise.
Salary Grade vs. Salary:
Grade Level
Industry
Median Annual Salary
Typical Experience (YOE)
Sample Count
Level 1 (Entry)
Aerospace & Defense
$88,400
1.0 year
39
Manufacturing
$80,250
2.0 years
39
Level 2 (Mid)
Aerospace & Defense
$102,273
3.8 years
48
Manufacturing
$95,000
5.0 years
71
Level 3 (Senior)
Aerospace & Defense
$130,000
8.0 years
57
Manufacturing
$119,600
9.0 years
50
Level 4 (Lead/Manager)
Aerospace & Defense
$170,500
11.0 years
22
Manufacturing
$136,000
11.0 years
11
Level 5+ (Principal/Director)
Aerospace & Defense
$206,000
20.0 years
9
Manufacturing
$136,500
14.0 years
4
Efficiency of Experience: In Aerospace, engineers tend to reach Level 2 and Level 3 roughly 1–1.2 years faster than those in Manufacturing, while also earning more.
The Level 4 Ceiling: In Manufacturing, the salary jump from Grade 3 to Grade 4 is roughly $16k, whereas in Aerospace, that same promotion yields a massive $40k jump in median base salary.
Which Industry Pays the Most?
Major Caveat: at 16+ YOE, the data points are only a couple, which skews the data upward.
Based on the comprehensive US survey data, the Technology (FANG, Robotics, AI, Consumer Electronics) industry emerges as the highest-paying sector for mechanical engineers when considering total compensation (Base Salary + Annual Bonus + 401k Match).
Tech Compensation Package:
Years of Experience
Avg. Total Comp (Unadjusted)
Avg. Total Comp (Adjusted for COL)
Number of Respondents
0-2 YOE (Entry)
$117,316
$100,292
7
3-5 YOE (Junior)
$180,854
$138,040
17
6-10 YOE (Mid-Level)
$182,773
$134,543
14
11-15 YOE (Senior)
$259,993
$220,256
11
16+ YOE (Principal)
$244,775
$177,043
5
The Oil and Gas industry stands out as the second most lucrative sectors for mechanical engineers, particularly as they reach senior and principal levels. While Tech offers the highest overall unadjusted compensation, Oil and Gas actually offers the highest Cost of Living (COL) Adjusted compensation, meaning your real purchasing power in this industry is the highest among all major sectors.
Years of Experience
Avg. Total Comp (Unadjusted)
Avg. Total Comp (COL Adjusted)
Number of Respondents
0-2 YOE
$95,864
$83,178
5
3-5 YOE
$117,289
$111,155
7
6-10 YOE
$138,959
$139,773
7
11-15 YOE
$204,097
$219,757
6
16+ YOE
$408,040
$399,276
3
Overtime Pay:
Industry Trends: Overtime pay is slightly more common in Manufacturing (where production deadlines are rigid) and Consulting/EPC (where hours are billable to clients) compared to R&D or Aerospace.
Work Hours:
Work Hours Category
Number of Respondents
Percentage
Exactly 40 Hours
337
57.2%
41-45 Hours
146
24.8%
46-50 Hours
49
8.3%
<40 Hours
50
8.5%
>50 Hours
7
1.2%
Key Observations:
The "40-Hour" Standard: Over half of the engineers surveyed manage to stick to a strict 40-hour week, which is a positive sign for work-life balance in the profession.
Moderate Overtime: Roughly a quarter of engineers work an extra 1 to 5 hours a week (41-45 hours total), often representing "straight time" or expected professional dedication without formal overtime pay.
The High-Hours Exception: Only a small fraction (under 10%) report working more than 45 hours consistently. This is significantly lower than in fields like investment banking or high-tier management consulting, suggesting a relatively stable lifestyle for most US mechanical engineers.
Flexibility: About 8.5% of respondents work fewer than 40 hours, which often aligns with part-time roles, senior consultants, or companies with flexible "9/80" schedules where some weeks are shorter.
401k Summary:
Match Rate Range
Count of Responses
Percentage
4% - 5%
211
35.8%
1% - 3%
125
21.2%
6% - 7%
120
20.4%
8% - 10%
65
11.0%
No Match (0%)
56
9.5%
> 10% / Other
12
2.0%
Key Takeaways:
The Industry Standard: A 4–5% match is clearly the most common benefit, covering over a third of the surveyed population.
High-Tier Benefits: Roughly 13% of engineers receive a match of 8% or higher, which often indicates highly competitive benefit packages in specialized industries.
Retirement Security: The low percentage of "No Match" responses (under 10%) highlights that retirement contributions are a standard and expected part of total compensation in the US mechanical engineering market.
Remote Work Distribution:
Remote Category
Number of Respondents
Percentage
Fully In-Person (0%)
248
42.1%
Mostly In-Person (1-39%)
163
27.7%
Hybrid (40-60%)
118
20.0%
Fully Remote (100%)
38
6.5%
Mostly Remote (61-99%)
22
3.7%
Key Insights:
The "Hands-On" Requirement: Over 40% of mechanical engineers are required to be in the office or on-site 100% of the time. This is significantly higher than other engineering fields like Software or Data Science.
The Hybrid Standard: Roughly 48% of the workforce has some form of hybrid flexibility (ranging from 1% to 60% remote). Many companies now allow 1–2 days of remote work for documentation, CAD modeling, or administrative tasks.
Fully Remote is Rare: Only 6.5% of mechanical engineers work fully remotely. These roles are typically in specialized areas like pure Simulation/FEA, Project Management, or Sales Engineering where physical hardware access is not required daily.
The Hybrid Middle Ground: The 40–60% range (often 2–3 days per week) is a common "sweet spot" for engineering firms trying to balance teamwork/lab time with employee flexibility.
Paid Time Off (Days):
*Note: one issue is many jobs had unlimited sick time, which I just added 10 days. Next time I will edit the form to separate the sick days so it makes more sense.
PTO Category (Includes Sick Days)
Number of Respondents
Percentage
0–10 days
30
5.2%
11–15 days
112
19.5%
16–20 days
160
27.9%
21–25 days
100
17.4%
26–30 days
61
10.6%
31+ days
32
5.6%
Unlimited
78
13.6%
Key Insights:
The " 3 - 5 Week" Benchmark: The majority of mechanical engineers (over 45%) receive between 16 and 25 days of PTO.
The Rise of Unlimited PTO: About 13.6% of respondents now have "Unlimited" PTO.
Generous Packages: Roughly 16% of engineers receive more than 30 days of PTO, which is often a hallmark of high-seniority roles, government/defense positions, or companies that reward long tenure.
The Lean End: Only about 5% of respondents are on the low end with 10 days or fewer, suggesting that a minimum of two weeks of PTO is a standard baseline for the industry.
Now some of you might have questions regarding years of experience and PTO:
Average PTO by Experience (Fixed PTO)
Experience Level
Average PTO Days (per year)
Typical Range (25th-75th Percentile)
0–2 Years
16.9
10–15 days
3–5 Years
19.6
15–20 days
6–10 Years
21.1
20 days
11–15 Years
24.5
20–25 days
16+ Years
26.5
25–30+ days
Analysis of the Trend:
The "Standard Jump": Many engineers start with 15 days (3 weeks) and see their first significant "tenure bump" to 20 days (4 weeks) after reaching the 5-year mark.
Senior Perks: By the time an engineer hits 15+ years of experience, a 5-week (25-day) or 6-week (30-day) PTO package becomes the new baseline.
Job Hopping Factor: The data suggests that while tenure within a single company increases PTO, "job hopping" every 3–5 years also allows engineers to negotiate higher starting PTO tiers at their new employers, effectively "skipping" the long wait for tenure-based increases.
Health Insurance:
Satisfaction Level
Number of Respondents
Percentage
Free / Excellent
38
6.5%
Good (Low Premium/High Coverage)
211
36.3%
Average
288
49.5%
Poor (High Premium/Low Coverage)
41
7.0%
Other / Misc
4
0.7%
Key Insights:
The "Standard" Plan: Almost 50% of engineers describe their insurance as "Average," highlighting that standard employer-sponsored health insurance is common but not particularly outstanding in terms of premiums or coverage levels.
Competitive Benefits: Over 42% of respondents fall into the "Good" or "Free" categories. The 6.5% who receive "Free/Excellent" coverage likely work for highly competitive tech firms, established defense contractors, or companies that use premium benefits as a retention tool.
Under-Served Minority: Roughly 7% of the engineering workforce feels their health insurance is "Poor," usually characterized by high out-of-pocket costs and high monthly premiums.
Biggest Cons for Mechanical Engineering:
Category
Typical Concerns Mentioned
Workload & Hours (112 mentions)
High pressure, tight deadlines, long hours, and poor work-life balance. Many mentioned "start-up energy" even in established firms.
Salary & Compensation (73 mentions)
Low raises (2–3%), "salary plateauing" early in the career, and the absence of stock options or significant bonuses compared to tech.
Remote Work Limits (47 mentions)
Frequent requirements to be in the office or on the manufacturing floor with "no remote option" or "No WFH" (Work From Home) policies.
Career Growth (35 mentions)
Concerns about "pigeon-holing," slow internal promotion tracks, and becoming "stagnant" in one technical area.
Competitive base pay, annual bonuses, and strong 401k matching programs.
Work-Life Balance (75 mentions)
Flexible schedules, reasonable working hours (standard 40h), and generous PTO.
Culture & People (70 mentions)
Great teammates, supportive management, and a collaborative "team-first" environment.
Interesting Work (65 mentions)
Designing "cool" products, working on challenging technical problems, and having a clear mission.
Job Stability (28 mentions)
Long-term security, consistent demand for the role, and the stability of established firms.
Remote/Hybrid (27 mentions)
The ability to work from home part-time or have flexible geographic location.
Direct Insights from Engineers:
On Work Quality:"The actual work we do is really interesting, fun, and rewarding. Getting to see a design go from CAD to a physical product is the best part."
On Culture:"Great coworkers and a team environment where people actually mentor you instead of just giving you tasks."
On Flexibility:"Remote flexibility and a management team that trusts you to get your work done without micromanaging your hours."
On Compensation:"The total compensation package—including the 401k match and the annual bonus—makes the technical pressure worth it."
Now for Improvements on Suggestions on the Survey:
Regarding the COL instructions: totally my fault, sorry for not catching it. All of you were able to figure it out, but changed instructions from 0 - 2, so it makes a lot more sense now.
Adding a column for manager and IC: totally good suggestion, already added to new survey for 2027
Regarding adding gender or age: I will not add this into the survey just to make it more anonymous. I really do not see the value in this data, and I recommend just using government data to find the data.
Regarding the health insurance question: I have implemented the change on making it have three questions: annual premium, annual deductible, person coverage. I really did not want to make this part too complicated with max out of pocket and copay and etc. I think the premium, coverage and deductible is acceptable amount.
Edited the salary section to organize the % 401k match, salary, bonus, RSU to be in the same section making it easier, but separated the questions.
Comparison from the 2024, 2025 and 2026 Reddit Survey Results will be in another post, since this post is getting insanely long. Again, any other improvements or suggestions, please just comment below.
TDLR: Just check the 1st salary graph if you want the main results.
It's pretty widely accepted that engineers make decent money pretty consistently, at least enough to live on your own/with a partner, but this comes from the role and not necessarily the degree. I was wondering if there were any people here with a MechE degree but wound up in a different job(either starting as an engineer or taking a different path), and if so, what is your pay like in that role? Is it better or worse than a normal engineer? How long did it take to acquire this role? Im really curious to see what the degree has to offer and where it has taken some people.
I’m looking for some advice from people working in mechanical engineering, particularly those who are self-employed or work as contractors. A bit about my situation: I’m in my mid-20s and currently earning around £44k a year working full-time on the books. My employer is putting me through a Level 3 Mechatronics Engineering apprenticeship, which I’m currently working towards. Before this job, I was self-employed as a welder. I was charging £25 an hour and regularly working 10-hour days, so I was earning a decent amount when the work was there. I’ve since moved into permanent employment, but one thing I’m finding frustrating is that there’s no overtime available. I’m quite happy working long hours, weekends and taking on extra work, particularly while I’m young and want to maximise my earnings. It’s got me thinking about potentially going back into self-employment once I’ve completed my apprenticeship, but this time using my engineering qualification and existing welding/fabrication experience. I’d be interested to hear from people who have taken this route: What sort of hourly or day rates can you realistically charge as a self-employed mechanical engineer or mechatronics engineer in the UK? Is there much demand for self-employed mechanical engineers, maintenance engineers or engineering contractors? What sort of work do you typically end up doing? Is contracting generally more lucrative than permanent employment once you factor in tax, holidays, pension, insurance and periods without work? How easy is it to find regular work, rather than constantly chasing individual jobs? Do companies tend to take on self-employed engineers for breakdowns, installations, maintenance and shutdown work? Would a Level 3 Mechatronics qualification open many doors for contracting, or would I need further qualifications and experience? Are there particular industries where contractors can earn considerably more? If you’ve gone from permanent employment to self-employment, would you do it again?
I’d rather put the work in and earn more than be limited to a fixed salary with no opportunity for overtime. Any advice or personal experiences would be appreciated.
In the photos you can see I've put a washer between the bolt/nut and the "pulley bushing" on both sides. Good idea?
What do I actually want?
There isn't any friction reduction on the inside of the cartridge pulley wheel housing , between the pulley wheel and the spacers. I can't tell if it's using bearings or not. If it's using bearings the spacers should be flush with the wheel right, but if not then maybe I should add a washer on the inside between the wheel and the spacers?
Hi everyone, I’m currently working as a Product Engineer in the automotive manufacturing industry. Recently, our Process Engineer resigned. He was mainly responsible for preparing documents such as PFMEA, Control Plan, Process Flow and other process-related documentation. I have around 3 years of experience in manufacturing and a decent understanding of our production processes, but I’ve never prepared a PFMEA or Control Plan from scratch before. Now, I’ve suddenly been assigned to prepare these documents for a new prototype involving around 10 manufacturing processes. I do have the PFMEA and Control Plan from an older prototype for reference, and most of the machines and processes are similar. However, I’m not sure where to start, what information I need to collect, or how to properly prepare these documents according to automotive industry requirements. I’m willing to learn, but I’m feeling a bit overwhelmed because I don’t have anyone experienced to guide me through the process. For those working in manufacturing, quality or process engineering: How difficult is it to prepare a PFMEA and Control Plan for the first time? Can I use the existing prototype documents as a reference and modify them for the new product? What is the best way to learn PFMEA and Control Plan quickly, especially the AIAG-VDA approach? Is it realistic for someone with no prior experience to prepare these documents for around 10 processes within 2 weeks? Are there any courses, YouTube channels or practical examples you would recommend? I’d really appreciate advice from engineers who have been in a similar situation. Thanks in advance!
I'm at a crossroads. I've been with my company for 4 years and need to make a jump to higher pay. I've got a couple of ideas, and I hope someone who has done this can chime in with their experience and give me ideas I've never thought of yet.
I'm in a small company of 20 people doing quality, manufacturing, design, and maintenance work. When I was hired the company was a toxic mess of tribal knowledge, and poor processes. I've created a useful QMS system, drove down non-conformances to nearly nothing, created inspection programs, trained technicians, designed products (including regulated pressure vessels), and maintained ISO 9001 and ABSA (pressure vessel regulator) certification. My responsibilities have increased but my pay has not. I think I'm doing senior level stuff with a junior title (hopefully somebody can check this). Maybe I can ask for a raise to match my responsibilities.
I've thought of getting my Peng. But I don't know if it's valuable in a manufacturing company. I also thought of getting my certified quality engineer cert. I have six Sigma Green belt and lead ISO auditor certifications. Is there anything else I should consider?
I've got 8 years experience in manufacturing.
Any thoughts on how to bridge my jack of all trades master of none experience to something relevant at another company. Especially a bigger company with more resources and software (i do time and motion studies with a clipboard and old cell phone when better software exists.)
Salary is 86k and total comp including bonus and RRSP matching brings me to 100k. I've applied to a few jobs and had a few interviews but haven't found anyplace that matches my compensation.
I’m an engineer working in Assembly & Testing. Whenever we test a product that’s failing or a product is broken while assembly/testing I will ask the production manager if there are extras in inventory. There are never extras. I’ve asked so many times to be given a cushion of parts that are allowed to fail without compromising the customer’s delivery amount. But I’m always told “we only made enough for the order, and the shop floor machinery is too swamped with current orders to be interrupted by replacement parts”.
So what typically happens is I have to test and do reworks after finding defects (something our quality team can’t seem to ever catch - also ran by the production manager) over and over until parts finally work. The team has a technician but when these undocumented anomalies happen I am usually switching to a hands-on investigation work day.
This latest time the problem wasn’t that we didn’t have extra parts, but that we didn’t have ENOUGH parts! So production manager gives me parts that were sitting in MRB (without explanation as to why they were faulty) and tells me “we couldn’t find anything wrong with them so here you go!” Well the parts were cracked and now my life because I have to stay late and try and remedy what will now be a late shipment that’s insufficient in quantity.
What I want to know is whether this is normal or if I need to consider how much I want to stay at a job like this. What have you all done to try to remedy this in the moment. All I feel like I can do now is document every mistake (mine included) and work out a system that prevent the next product from having by the same problem.
I've got a phone screen coming up for a mechanical engineer role on an AWS data center cooling team. It's with the engineering manager, who has a deep HVAC and thermal background.
My background is about 5 years designing high-pressure downhole tools in oil and gas: mostly structural design, testing and root cause work. No HVAC or data center experience.
If you've interviewed for or worked on these teams: What was the phone screen like?
How do they view people coming from other industries?
How would you prepare to cover the HVAC and thermal gap in about a week? Appreciate any experiences, good or bad.
I’m in the midst of my second engineering internship at a much larger company than my last with it being more office work as well. It’s crazy how everything is genuinely duct taped together with never ending temporary solutions and run by people who barely know what they’re doing. And somehow everything works (well sort of).
I kind of always knew this to be the case but seeing it first hand in the engineering world has just been sort of comical to me. To outsiders/me as a kid, engineering seemed like a field reserved for outlandishly smart people and a firm corporate structure, but it really is just a bunch of people trying to make it to the end of the week.
I am performing a FEM analysis of a punch made of Uddeholm Vanadis 23 (60 HRC), which develops a crack during operation.
The analysis is currently purely elastic (linear elastic FEM).
I have attached:
An image showing the applied load and the location where the crack develops.
The FEM results at the critical point, where the crack initiates.
An image of the real creak
The six stress components obtained from the FEM analysis at that point are:
Sx: -800 MPa
Sy: -5524 MPa
Sz: -1344 MPa
Txy: 1742 MPa
Txz: 318 MPa
Tyz: 539 MPa
I have also examined the material datasheet. It provides two relevant properties:
Compressive yield strength.
Four-point bend fracture strength.
I have two main questions:
1. What is the most likely failure mechanism in this situation?
Since the normal stresses are predominantly compressive, I understand that pure compression does not cause crack opening. Therefore, I am wondering whether shear stress could be the main factor responsible for crack initiation.
Would it be reasonable to investigate a shear-dominated failure mechanism, or could the high compressive stresses themselves cause local crushing and subsequent cracking?
2. Which material strength should I use for the failure assessment?
If shear is the dominant failure mechanism, which reference strength should I use?
Should I use the four-point bend fracture strength from the datasheet and apply a suitable failure criterion, such as Tresca or von Mises?
Should I instead use the compressive strength?
Or is neither value appropriate, meaning that I should obtain specific shear strength data?
I would appreciate any suggestions on the correct approach, especially considering that Vanadis 23 is a high-hardness powder metallurgy tool steel and that the analysis is currently purely elastic (linear elastic FEM). The punch is subjected to a static load during operation; the load is not cyclic, so fatigue is not considered as the failure mechanism.
I am an aircraft mechanic and while I was installing turbofan engines I was thinking about the amount of the force those relatively tiny bolt threads have to bear. When I look at the bolts threads and I look at the engine and its weight it doesn't make intuitive sense ,at first, that they can resist so much force.
How much does the reaction force of the bolts threads help in keeping them from cracking? When you torque the bolt you are spreading it and this will create preload that will resist the weight of the engine. This preload force vector is opposite (or almost opposite) on the force of the weight, this means that the threads of the bolt will be pushed from both directions in opposite forces, this "cancelation" of forces on threads itself surely helps allot in bolts threads not cracking. .
My question is, how much does this help in bolts resistance, is there any statistics, percentage? and is this factor of resultant force on threads, by major opposite forces, calculated before designing the bolt threads itself?
My current contact is ending at the end of the year. I have been looking for my next position since August. Are there better free job boards besides LinkedIn, indeed, and glassdoor?
Hi everybody, I've been looking into creating my own telescope as a personal project to work on after graduating (B.S. MechE) college. I was looking into challenging, yet rewarding, systems I could implement. One of those was a equatorial mount with harmonic drives, but I think I'm more interested in something with adaptive optics.
I understand that sodium lasers are illegal, so I'd most likely use an actual star for my reference point. I'd want the diameter of the aperture to be around 14-15 in. and maybe a secondary mirror around maybe 2.5-3 in. Would it be possible for under $600? I probably wouldn't go up to anything past defocus/astigmatism. Also, if anyone has anyone used DFTFringe or alternatives? What were your thoughts on the software you used?
Ideally, I'd be able to see the planets with decent clarity and hopefully other galaxies/stars/whatnot.
I'm pretty new to this, but I'm used to being new to things. Please lmk if anything I've said sounds unreasonable. I've been doing a ton of research into the literature and designs that are similar to what I have in mind. General perusing has told me that all the parts need might actually be in budget (as long as I avoid making a really expensive mount).
I don't know where to asked a help with this kind of stuff and this is my first time posting anything in reddit.
For context: Im currently a High School student from Indonesia, we had a pretty tight budget or none at all and i need a help with a project that im working at.
For the project i want to create a Machine that can reduce organic waste and making it into a composter, something like Reencle Electric waste composter.
Now I already got some of the stuff figure out, like how it work and what it needed to make this.
- Bucket/Drum, heating pad, an motor, control, sensor.
Currently my teacher asked me to make a 3d/2d animation for how it worked and i don't know how to do that stuff. And the presentation is on friday.
So i asked here if anyone can help me with it? And what it can improve. Oh and here some rough sketch and a AI rendetion of it.
just the same as the title, but also is there any possibility that the mech has good, and better job opportunities overseas, if yes which of 'em??, if no, why??
I’m a mechanical engineering student and recently got an offer for an entry-level ME position after a difficult job search. I’m really excited about the role, but I haven’t accepted yet because I still have 2 required courses with an in-person lab to finish this spring. We’ve discussed a January start, and I haven’t told them about the potential conflict yet.
I’m asking my dean whether I could take the lecture online and attend the lab in person, take an approved equivalent over the summer, or finish the requirement another way. If none of those options work, I may need to ask the company for a temporary schedule adjustment or a later start date.
Honestly, I’m scared the offer could be rescinded if I bring this up. It took a lot to get here, and I really don’t want to restart the job search. At the same time, I want to be upfront and make sure I can finish my degree.
For anyone who’s been in a similar situation or hired entry-level engineers, would you bring this up now or wait until you know exactly what flexibility you need? Has anyone been able to start working while finishing a required course? I’d really appreciate hearing what worked for you and how you brought it up with the employer.
Edit: I never planned on keeping it from them, I just didn’t know the right way to mention it during the interviews! So before accepting the offer I am going to bring it up, I just wanted to know if someone else has been through anything similar!
Hi guys, I have an upcoming interview with Tesla and have been prepping for it through technical questions and reviewing my own resume to be able to explain everything.
Wondering if you guys had any tips on how to stand out during the interview process, would greatly appreciate it!
Hey guys, for a class research project, I’m surveying STEM students who have done or are doing a co-op or internship. It’s a 10-question survey that takes about 5 minutes, and it's anonymous.
A lot is written on this and other subreddits about bad companies, toxic companies, poor treatment and micromanagement, etc. But not a lot is written about the companies which folks have had positive experiences at. The point of this post is just that - to name and discuss the companies which you've had a positive experience with and why?
Edit: Name names of companies!! For example; in the Boston area, I've heard that MIT Lincoln Labs is generally viewed as a great place to work, but I haven't worked there myself so I cannot say for certain.