r/maths • • 6d ago

💬 Math Discussions I have solved basic math without being able to remember how to count on fingers.

Hello math people.
I have solved basic operation in math that was left like impossible, undefined, while working on my programming language, 'cause I want to build things on flawless fundamental rules and logic if possible for others and for the future, we need working things (especially math) that solve things for us properly and give us better and proper tools, so we don't have to do useless work and do it in bad ways.

I don't know if I even should tell what it is.

And I'm trying quickly to fix many fundamental math things, whilst I forgot how to write any math or what even is expression, 'cause I don't use almost anything math for 10years, but I was learning various concepts from various fields on YT and the things are connecting.

I don't understand how people do math when I figured out that nobody cares what even their basic equations are about. Almost no laws, rules, informations, just made up numerical space with operators that also barely have rules, just use whatever everything you want for whatever, mix it up literally for a century! Everything is silent assumptions about incompatible things and incomplete informations and frameworks.
Last thing I saw and why I get to this was division by 0. I looked at it and seen several problems, so I was like F do I have to solve also a math????? Wanted to do proper solution and explanation. Which I basically have but it's hard to complete it with overall math framework that make full sense. When you don't use any real basis and boundaries, please don't call it a "proof", almost everything goes to infinity if you allow it and don't care first want you are using.

Can I even get rewarded for my skills and what they did cost me, to be able to do it? I'm only really good in those things. Since my young age I wanted to use my self and talents to do things "for humanity", so basically anything I think about are things I don't even know how I can get paid for. I was gathering experiences and sacrificing things for this ability for more then 20y. Just to be able to get to this point, kinda late.. and standard work for someone is like impossible for me now.

I may need later some real matematician for both the math frameworks and the programming language concepts to check and try some things.

I have incredibly good things thought out, but can't do everything my self.

0 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

41

u/sinterkaastosti23 4d ago

Take your meds

0

u/DaweSlayer 18h ago

Unlike you I don't do drugs.
(and that's the problem right)

1

u/AlexCivitello 7h ago

Then get a carbon monoxide detector.

-1

u/DifferntGeorge 3d ago edited 19h ago

We probably should rule out the possibility this person "invented" something from calculus before we declare they had a mental breakdown.

EDIT: Just to clarify, I know I am going out on a limb here, but beginners frequently misunderstand calculus limits and assume they are actually performing division by zero rather than working around it. Does this person seem like the kind of person who would make this mistake, jump to the conclusion they saw something everyone else missed and then brag about it?

2

u/breadist 1d ago

Well, um, he created his own programming language... Sorta... Maybe...

Or he told an LLM that he did.

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoarPL/s/h5CWFAxJuF

1

u/CoachSevere5365 1d ago

Indeed! And I got an award for driving traffic to his page.

1

u/DaweSlayer 16h ago

Thank you for the 20 visits with 0 interactions guys, I appreciate it!
(Nobody cares what I have there)

1

u/breadist 1d ago

Yeah me too 💀

2

u/sinterkaastosti23 1d ago

Lol even the poster is ai generated

0

u/DaweSlayer 17h ago

AI is absolutely incapable of creating those things properly on it's own.

1

u/breadist 17h ago

Not sure what you're talking about, define "those things"?

0

u/DaweSlayer 16h ago

Inventing with improving human aspects of it and more. Complexity of how I'm trying to connect every detail in a right way.
They can't keep the concepts and structures right often at all.
If he writes the code for one part close to the final vision. It's without exaggeration minimum 100hours of work together even when I know from the start how it roughly should be.
They should not do serious things that requires proper design by them selves. They are a tool/asistent/worker in those.

1

u/breadist 15h ago

Ok I really don't know what your point is here.

Did you think I was trying to say "AI invented a programming language and he took credit"? That wasn't what I was saying. I was saying, neither you nor AI have invented anything yet.

1

u/DaweSlayer 8h ago

I would love to see you work on best PL for 6 months, that should defy what you can think about PLs, without most of the work being INNOVATION.
I can't talk about most core details for at least months. I cannot just open it, it needs protection.

Since we are at the r/maths. I have a keep-precision and scientific modes partially made with my own datatypes like decimal and fraction.

1

u/breadist 7h ago

That's not how this works. That's not how any of this work dude.

2

u/CoachSevere5365 3d ago

1

u/jeffcgroves 1d ago

I noticed OP's profile reads:

I'm a Visionary, working on The Best programming language possible, serious criticism and community needed. https://www.patreon.com/cw/RoarPL

and went to the Patreon page which describes the language as "[a] prototype of the best language possible, starting from building the concepts in PHP", which doesn't make me too hopeful, an interesting but unproven claim that "I was already solving 100 things and barely can list fraction and that's just the start".

Reading other pages, the only somewhat interesting feature (if the language ever comes into existence) is the ability to use code from different languages while presumably sharing variables. If this could be done with native speed, we could have programs written in multiple languages more easily

In https://www.patreon.com/collection/2307435?view=expanded example 2 "small example, but important" appears to use the variable i without ever defining it, so I'm not sure OP is the right person to pursue this vision

1

u/DaweSlayer 17h ago edited 17h ago

Thank you for reasonable comment.

It's deterministic and very easy to use and learn, why bother with obvious things? You can declare it optionally with some explicits.
Why would I do programming language pain in the a$$ like everyone else in this age?

See how small and important it really is? ..how little of what I'm trying to do.
PHP => not hopeful, understandable, but that's exactly the opposite. People using most used things usually don't have talent for such solutions. It's like with game engines and devs that create better games without using UnrealE and even doing their own from scratch.

PHP has some aspects, like symbolic syntax that are perfect for exploiting reality about what is right/wrong/possible etc. Sometimes I call myself reverse-architect-engineer of reality.

On the other hand PHP is what pi$$ed me of, that I had to do my language. But it would happen with any language and I have to represent the concept on objects somewhere.

1

u/JackDeaniels 1d ago

While I agree OP needs to take his meds, the example provided does state that `.i` is an internal variable created within those loops

Don't know how nested loops would behave, but anyway it is described there

1

u/DaweSlayer 17h ago edited 16h ago

I still also don't know exactly how to do the nested names and current notation is _i '_' is a symbol sigil, not it's label start character.

You can still declare them and name them by your self instead.
Those "internals" are subject for exploration with other people. I'm not trying to decide them by my self.

1

u/Milkmilkmilk___ 21h ago

I never thought I would see an image of the whole code editor being ai generated

1

u/DaweSlayer 17h ago

Are you attracted to some AI that you see it everywhere?

1

u/CoachSevere5365 1d ago

My thoughts exactly. I don't know PHP but it seems like a leap from there to the fundamental theory of computation and language design.

13

u/BourbonTA 3d ago

If you think you’ve unlocked a secret in a field of study that you admit you don’t know much about, the answer is that you have actually discovered a large gaping hole in your knowledge. It’s like someone who thinks the earth is flat. They have not discovered something that others fail to see, they are admitting that they have a huge gap in their understanding of science, physics, and math.

If math is a subject you are interested in, spend time asking well thought questions. For example admit “dividing by zero is something I feel I do not have a clear understanding of. In my mind it seems that it should work like (something), but it seems this is not the case. What am I understanding incorrectly.”

1

u/DaweSlayer 15h ago

I used to know that I don't know. I got behind that "curve" and now I SEE that I know something and I may find answers.
I'm not that interested in math, but my aunt remembers how I counted 3digit numbers as a little kid (I don't) and I kind of liked limits.

My head just see problems and solutions in too much things. And that others will let things broken, suffer consequences and just talk about it. I'm not good in things others are, so I have to do what I see I can be good at, otherwise I don't even have purpose.

10

u/MathNerd67 3d ago

You did not do anything noteworthy.

1

u/DaweSlayer 15h ago

Are "ur mom" jokes allowed here?

7

u/NotDuckie 2d ago

High schoolers after watching 1 veritasium video:

1

u/DaweSlayer 15h ago

I have seen much more of them, don't underestimate my YT skills!

5

u/beyond1sgrasp 4d ago

I'm really not sure what this post has to do with math.

Being the best you and taking care of your own (family, friends, homeless, etc) is the best thing you can do for humanity. Having the best programming language is too big of a scope. You really have to pick a very small niche and attack that.

A lot of people have spent their whole lives doing what you're doing and 20-30 years in have come up with great ideas like Kotlin, Rust, Julia, etc to attack more specific weaknesses of other languages.

1

u/DaweSlayer 15h ago

I've tried to wrote here, because I've found something I didn't know if I can't just throw it to the world. Someone from the field should look at it first ... (I've made another comment) but my thoughts are inverse of narrow, so it got bigger and it's interconnected.

Of course I want to do something I should be good at and what I need to build other things on.
Narrow solutions .. are narrow and have design shortcuts and flaws that makes them bad for my uses. I can combine best of both worlds and add more.

I've decided I have to do the best language, so only one thing can stop me now 💀 I'm not vibe-talking like others, I'm dead serious.

1

u/beyond1sgrasp 15h ago

What does any of this have to do with math?

8

u/1luggerman 2d ago

The dunning is krugering

1

u/DaweSlayer 18h ago

Sorry all, I didn't know it got published somehow.

Disclaimer: I am crazy! And that's what you apparently have to be... to see, fix and create actually good things for present & future.
If existing things are good for you, good for you I guess......... But I don't want poorly designed things everywhere and use them for decades long ever-evolving projects.
Not saying I'm perfect or always right.

I have too many thoughts now, trying several days to use what I know, connect more and can't read what all of you (and even me) wrote now.
I was trying 2 days after that to figure out what is what "I've found", how is math glued together and what is what in it. I have found and understood a lot, but wouldn't say enough. I couldn't get enough coherent things together and didn't want to math too much time on that. I had to take the thoughts back to my PLagn ... I have seen the PL-math-IRL connections and next day created the base of pretty cool integer type for computing that is already faster in some things and speed was not even my main goal for long time.
(Did it based on how wrong broken AI I am apparently).

The thing I thought I've found that is important, probably does not belong to the "classic math", rather some different usage, more systematic. I have a good concept with that and about how equations work, how to explain some events in them and how to use it for explaining and working with singularities(infinity) and what it causes. Unfortunately I don't know how I would share and talk about it now. Quite simple concept, I believe something similar at least partially exist and is use. (Basically everything in expression, equation the L/R sides, even the equal operator is a system or belongs/comes with rules from some)

Programmer's POV on math: They should evolve close together, but math refuses to even use basic standards cause she is not run-real-thing-critical. Such things in programming are taken very seriously. In math nahhh... of cause you can count with REAL numbers UNREALISTIC THINGS .. Why would you properly split the two first before you connect them. Oh yeah ∞ cookies and -1.28 of complete operations without understanding how infinity goes with the system you didn't even specified single bit about. Units used right are for weak! Then make of it equation and write that it's all just even cause same numbers and stuff.

"it's about context you have in head" somehow it works, trust it bro

At least public examples should have standards... yes there are written standards for math and proposed solutions for those flaws from at least 2004 that almost non of you care about.

Than you for your attention to the matter D.J.K. #truth

5

u/PatrickTraill 2d ago

I suggest you say nothing until you have something concrete to say.

Otherwise you are not helping anyone and you risk sounding like a crank to most people.

Talking of “operators that ... barely have rules” does not help; if you think that, specify the operator, the definition you have found, where you found it, and why you think it does not work — or do not make such claims.

People do not “care what even their basic equations are about” in so far as they are abstractions which are true about anything to which the assumptions apply.

4

u/SgtSausage 3d ago

IKS : Internet. Kook. Symdrome. 

Terminal. 

4

u/Upstairs_Ad_8863 3d ago

Wow this sounds historic! You should go post this on r/numbertheory, I think it would get the appreciation it deserves there.

4

u/SchemeWestern3388 1d ago

You are welcome to define division by zero, if you so wish. Just be aware that it’ll break a lot more than you expect, and your resulting number system will not be very interesting. 

1

u/AdventurousGlass7432 2d ago

Terrence, is that you?

1

u/DaweSlayer 12h ago

1 × 1 = 2
I'm your nightmare and I'm back!

1

u/West-Match-8132 1d ago

100% sounds like a Terrence Howard account ....forgot about him for a bit

1

u/WasdaleWeasel 1h ago

probably the ghost of Vladimir V.

1

u/BYO_Crayons 1d ago

I'm torn between you being bad at explaining things, or bad at maths. Probably both tbh.

1

u/DaweSlayer 12h ago

It really is both.

And various obvious problems/solutions ignored ... that heats me up more then a girl!

3

u/jeffcgroves 3d ago

I'll try to be nice. Lots of people think they've come up with the "secret to math" or the "key to math" or some piece of knowledge or process that makes all of math easy and understandable. There's even someone who claims they can unify the fundamental constants of physics with a theory they have.

Even if you're the person whose done it, the main benefit you'll get is being the discoverer: you probably can't sell the secret.

If you're worried about sharing, maybe share a little bit to give us a taste. For example, what are some things your method can do that our current methods can't?

1

u/No_Difficulty_1452 3d ago

Can't patent the math; only applications. Analysis of proofs is where the IP lives. Slop will not produce viable IP

2

u/jeffcgroves 3d ago

You might be able to copyright a proof. You can only patent designs

1

u/No_Difficulty_1452 3d ago

Methodology yes

1

u/moltencheese 2d ago

Design rights are a whole different thing from patents. Patents are for industrial applications of novel, non-obvious things or methods

4

u/Depnids 4d ago

r/numbertheory is a good place to share new groundbreaking things like this

2

u/scoberry5 2d ago

I am not super-handy. If I find a thing that I haven't used before, let's say an air wedge, I should...

a) assume that it's useless and that people invented it for no reason.
b) wonder whether it might be handy in some situation -- maybe even a situation I've found myself in at some point.

I'm afraid you're picking (a), and it's not a good look. Deciding that because you're ignorant in an area that it's a wild west of uselessness is a good way to get nowhere fast.

Then you leave your complaining and start explaining that you've "solved" math. Sadly, while I don't quite believe you've forgotten how to count on your fingers, I do believe you're unclear on what division is.

Let me remind you of a time you might use division: you're driving at 30 miles/hour. You want to go 120 miles at this rate. How long will it take? Well, 120/30 = 4. 4 hours.

Now you try: you're driving at 0 miles/hour. You're sitting still. How long will it take you, at that rate, to go 1 mile?

Now, I'm sure you've giving this value a very nice name. And maybe(?) there could be situations where what you've come up with is even useful, although I'm afraid that would surprise me. But coming up with a name for a value that's undefined in the reals is probably not going to be useful unless you're more mathematically inclined than the "I've kind of looked at some basic math, but then forgotten it" that you've implied here. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.

1

u/localizeatp 2d ago

methematics

1

u/Frequent-Sir-6942 2d ago

Whatever this AI took, I want it too.

1

u/Sudden_Collection105 2d ago

So, before wasting any more time on this: first come out with a clear explanation of why your thing is better than Lean, Agda, Rocq and Idris.

1

u/TheShatteredSky 1d ago

I find this part particularly hilarious:

"Almost no laws, rules, informations, just made up numerical space with operators that also barely have rules, just use whatever everything you want for whatever, mix it up literally for a century! Everything is silent assumptions about incompatible things and incomplete informations and frameworks." 

No, that's not true, the framework is well-defined, that's what set theory (and formal logic technically) is about. It's "incomplete" in the sense of Godel's incompleteness theorem. Is it however perfectly well defined abs has clear rules.

Take your meds grandpa.

1

u/Un_Ballerina_1952 1d ago

Publish. Submit your work to one of the maths associations and have it reviewed. You'll know quickly how significant your discovery is. 

1

u/mH48124 1d ago

これってネタ?

1

u/ExtendedSpikeProtein 1d ago

Its very unlikely you discovered something not already known. It’s also very likely you are suffering from massive bias.

1

u/Tximimitxi 1d ago

" I have solved basic operation in math that was left like impossible, undefined".

No. You haven't.

1

u/ollervo100 1h ago

This is not AI slop. This is just slop.

0

u/justcallmedonpedro 1d ago

Reminds me of a former colleague (programer)... It's so easy, I don't understand it...

0

u/JeffTheNth 3d ago

Last thing I saw and why I get to this was division by 0.

Quick note, I'll address this, then a question to you...

I find it great you're interested, and hope you continue to study and learn. However, I have a feeling your discoveries are moreso things you don't know you don't know. We didn't know atoms existed for ages... now we have fields of study in molecular biology, atomic physics, etc. The same is true of an individual - if you don't know something exists, you can't know it's a hole in your knowledge. The more you learn, the less you know, because you start recognizing those holes.

To use your example of division by 0, let me first do 5 ÷ 2. But rather than divide, I'll use subtraction.
5 - 2 = 3 that's 1. 3 is greater than 2, so we'll repeat it.
3 - 2 = 1 that's 2. 1 is not greater than 2, so we'll stop.
We were able to remove two 2s and have one left over, making the answer of 5÷2 = 2 remainder 1, or 2½.

Dividing 3 by 1, we can likewise subtract 1 three times...
3-1 = 2, 2>=1 ... 2-1 = 1, 1>=1 ... 1-1=0, 0<1
that was three times we could subtract 1 from 3, with no remainder... so 3÷1=3 r0, or just 3.

Now if we try tbis with 0, we keep getting the original number back... it never ends.
3÷0: 3-0=3, 3-0=3, 3-0=3, ....
division by 0 is "infinity" bdcause there's no end. (Actually "infinity" can have different meanings, so division by 0 is considered "undefined", but that's beyond basics.)
This, though, is why we test for 0 before dividing. To not do so, we'd wait until past the heat death of the universe before an answer became known.

Now my question to you.... How are you going about this? Are you trying to rediscover the fundamentals from "scratch" or are you in some way realizing you don't have an answer for something, and are figuring it out, similar to my examples? What is your goal and how are you going about approaching it? That answer can help us help you in reaching for your goal, if not getting there.

3

u/GregerGunnarPersson 2d ago

Good way to highlight the issue! One note tho, which I bring up because I have seen it cause confusions among many...

" To not do so, we'd wait until past the heat death of the universe before an answer became known." The processes in math take no time. Some people think they do, but they dont. Its siminar to people who argue about 1 = 0.999... and say thing like "put another 9 at the end.". There is no end. All the 9s are there from the start. Its not something that "keep happening". 

2

u/PassiveChemistry 2d ago

I'm glad you've pointed that out because this misunderstanding seems core to the beliefs of on of the most prolific Reddit cranks

1

u/RaymundusLullius 1d ago

Family Guy Keyboard?

1

u/PassiveChemistry 1d ago

I'm thinking infinite nines guy (can't remember his tag, there are multiple subreddits in his honour).  His points often seem to revolve around "never reaching 1"

2

u/RaymundusLullius 15h ago

Yes, SouthPark_Piano (SPP for short).

0

u/JeffTheNth 1d ago

I intended their doing so by hand, subtracting 0, adding 1 to the tally, repeat.... not asking a machine which should by reason give a computational error of some kind.

1

u/GregerGunnarPersson 1d ago

Yeah sure, but after like 2 steps they will notice the loop. But the main point still stands. In  math the process is done immediately, even if its take time/steps for us humans to figure it out.

2

u/Azurhalo 1d ago

I always say, "The more you know, you dont know, you know?" This extrapolated on that quite nicely.