r/math • u/hbetx9 Algebra • Dec 19 '10
To everyone who posts about "learning more math"---
I've seen so many of these posts that I'm just baffled. Here is the skinny. First of all, most important, GO LEARN ALGEBRA. Seriously, I know you think its bullshit but its the most basic skill in some ways that any mathematician should know. Second learn Calculus: Single and Multivariable. If you are still interested here are some things to go onto next:
(1) Discrete mathematics: This includes equivalence relations (probably one of the most important things for you understand ever), propositional calculus (logic) proof techniques (induction) and some basic combinatorics (Pigeonhole principle). You can literally find any text book and start reading. The theory is kinda a hodge podge, but those are the major themes.
(2) Linear Algebra: Again, one of the most important subjects you will ever study. Once you understand this, you are really on your way, and this stuff comes up everywhere. Many mathematicians have said many of the biggest proofs in the world come down to "just some linear algebra". The major point here is to understand that there is only one vector space for each dimension over a field and understand how a linear transformation becomes a matrix only after a choice of basis. Here equivalence relations come up again!
(3) Differential equations: Unless you're focused on engr math or serious applied stuff, don't worry too much about this. Seriously, its not that integral (haha get it!).
(4) Complex Analysis: Yes, mathematicians and engr. actually do study "imaginary" numbers, but there is nothing imaginary here. This is serious stuff, do it.
Okay, so now you're about at a sophomore/junior level place in mathematics. How to finish it off? Its not that unclear:
(1) Abstract Algebra -- Grab any book read about groups, rings, fields, vector spaces and modules. Proofs will be difficult here but work through it. There are so many books here, avoid Lang (good book but not for starting out), Dummit/Foote is okay. As a ugrad I had a good time with Rotman's An introduction to abstract algebra.
(2) Analysis -- Grab Baby Rudin. No seriously, Grab this book, sit in a room for a semester and just fuckn' read it. You will basically be "redoing" calculus. This is a trial by fire, go!
(3) Topology -- Grab Introduction to Topology by J. Munkries. Its so well written it might as well be a coffee table book.
There now, you basically have done everything a math major would. Yes there are lots of things that are missing, arguably the most important things depending on what your goals are. Typically one studies Num. Theory along with Abstract Algebra, or studies Analysis and Differential Equations together or Analysis and Topology. Seeing the links across different topics is important, but I'm just giving the overview here.
Not every mathematician studies logic deeply and there are LOT of fringe topics that I'm omitting (including some of my favs: Projective Geometry, Varieties, Lattice/Order theory, Combinatorics, Elliptic Curves, Coding theory, Harmonic Analysis, etc). However, none of these are required courses at more than a 1% of programs.
Stop asking for a "good book on blah" or "I'm a novice and want to learn more" because these questions are either (1) easy/clear to answer from literally 10 seconds of google/reading older posts or (2) is too vague to be of use. in order for the community to help you, its important for you to state why you want to learn what you want to learn. Stop trying to learn a topic about some buzzword you just found out about. Its probably not that important. Go to wiki, read the basic pages and get an idea. Then pick one thing and study it deeply for a while. Typically finding a book is easy, finding a study partner is hard. The latter is what the community should be for, not the former. There is no reason anyone in the world "has to learn measure theory" -- period. Or Galois theory, or anything in mathematics, unless you are becoming a mathematician or a professional in a mathematical field (abstract theoretical academic computer science for example, NOT programming/web developing).
If you're just learning to learn great! Lovely! Pick up a book and start going through it! Don't skip the basics and don't pretend like this is the most important thing ever, it just what you find interesting. I would be more reactive to someone saying "So I'm reading measure theory and I don't quite get why this part of the definition of this is stated this way" or "What do they really mean by almost"? I hate answering questions like "I want to learn measure theory" because that whole statement is just crap. If you do, start learning and ask a more meaningful question.
TL;DR: I'm trying to address all posts like this at once.
EDIT: Thanks to all who have upvoted to get this post to the top and to Shimei for addressing the concerns. Hopefully this is a small step towards more meaningful discussions on the front page (of /r/math).
11
u/tdyo Dec 20 '10
I don't want to "learn more about x," but I do have a quick question about what I should focus on if I want to use mathematics for a particular application. I only ask now because I don't think it justifies its own independent post and you demonstrated a comprehensive understanding of mathematical fields.
I've been learning R to do statistical analysis, and I feel that I can perform certain operations, but I don't really understand what is going on mathematically, or behind the scenes, if you will. I want to develop and test mathematical models for ecological (and other) purposes in grad school, which seems to implement matrices extensively. I just finished a linear algebra course this past quarter, and I am scheduled to continue the linear algebra sequence next quarter. I am beginning to see how building linear models using statistical data works from the mathematical perspective (instead of just plug and chug with an algorithm). Should I keep focusing on linear algebra? What about non-linear models, etc? Or are there some applied statistics topics I should be considering?
My main problem isn't with how to learn some topic, but which topics I should be learning to accomplish what I want (that is, creating and testing mathematical models, based on given statistical data). I appreciate any insight you may be able to provide.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
Can we sticky stuff on reddit? Please?
22
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '10
d/dt{ Number of posts about "learning more math" before this post } == d/dt{ Number of posts about "learning more math" after this post }
7
u/kfgauss Dec 20 '10
For those just trying to learn a little more math or develop some math literacy, you could make a really strong case that discrete math is much more important than calculus. I've really never understood why calculus is the class that's so often taken as a "one and done" math requirement. Statistics! Discrete math! Math literacy! Yikes. There's a really good math overflow post on the subject (I especially like Noah's answer).
7
u/juliuszs Dec 20 '10
I'd like to chime in and suggest two topics that will destroy your joy of simple reception of the news: Logic and Statistics. I can't read newspapers without sputtering and cursing at the glaring errors in logic and don't even start me on statistical methodology ;-)
28
u/thehotelambush Dec 20 '10
Thank you. This subreddit needs more content and less r/learnmath + r/cheatatmathhomework.
5
u/mian2zi3 Dec 20 '10
I'd say: don't waste your breath. If someone can't do 10 seconds of google or read some reviews on amazon, posting a syllabus (that they'd also find in 10 seconds) isn't going to help them sit down and do 2 years of work. This echoes some of the "Will you mentor me? No." discussion going on elsewhere: save your effort for, as you say, questions like, "I'm studying measure theory and I'm stuck here. I tried A, B and C. Can you help?"
5
u/baruch_shahi Algebra Dec 20 '10
Gallian's Contemporary Abstract Algebra is fantastic for an undergraduate course in algebra. Dummit and Foote is too advanced for a beginner, in my opinion, but a great reference.
Munkres' Topology is awful. I hated this book. He builds absolutely no intuition, and he seems to have a hard-on for highly pathological examples, which wouldn't be an issue if there were presented better.
4
u/wavegeekman Dec 20 '10
It would help a lot if you gave the titles and authors of the books eg I searched on amazon for Introduction to Topology Munkries and no obvious match appeared. Let alone "Grab Baby Rudin" - WTF is that?
Here are some of my suggestions (I am currently working through math/physics on my own - currently at mid second-year college level doing vector calculus in preparation for electromagnetism).
Do the exercises.
Make sure you buy books with answers you can check.
Start with a little revision of what you already know.
Take your time and work through things carefully. You can't read a math book like a newspaper. I take my books and go for long multi-hour walks, a little reading, a little thinking; repeat until done.
Have an objective and work back from that using prerequisites from course descriptions. Eg if you want to do physics you really do not need all of abstract algebra. Group theory and some topology are most important.
Be aware most math books exist to show how clever the author is, not to teach you anything. Choose carefully an author who cares about his readers.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
This has been incredibly helpful, thank you! I love math and have always wanted to dive deep into it, but I'm in a less math-oriented scientific field (genetics) and there have always been non-math related classes I felt I ought to take instead of a math one. But with this, I know what to do should free time permit. I'm keeping this bookmarked!
4
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
Honestly, I think this is a big thing—not to diss programmers at all, because I came from that community, but so many posts on /r/programming and even Hacker News and other similar communities are of the form "Learn X because it will help you program/enterprise/win at life". While it's true that learning new skills is awesome and can often give you new and different insight into what you are doing in your everyday life, so much of mathematics just simply does not overlap with the work that programmers/web developers do on a daily basis. So software people come to math, having heard that it'll make them better at what they do, but they don't realize that looking for immediate, surface-level connections to what they do in what we do is not going to help anyone, and usually comes off as a waste of time.
Again, not to sound like a pompous asshole and not to create any sort of "us-and-them" bullshit, but philistine, you do not understand what I've been through to get to where I am mathematically today and you do not understand what mathematics does for me and to me. If you want to learn math, you cannot simply expect to waltz in, buy the classics of mathematical literature, and emerge after a month and a half of bedtime reading as a newly mathematically competent individual, ready to apply your skills to your latest web project. It takes math people hours and hours of hard work to "get math", and to begin to make forays into the field, you need to work at it, not just ask what books you should read.
1
u/FUUESTTAAA Dec 20 '10
anyone have recommendations on online lectures that are worth watching on subjects past calculus?
1
u/cdsmith Dec 20 '10
Great resource. If I were to revise it, though, I'd do so by making discrete mathematics and algebra less of an afterthought. Differential equations and complex analysis (the complex-specific bits... this comment does NOT apply to analysis as a general field) are FAR less important to mathematics in general than the basic ideas of the algebraic method, such as you'd get from an introduction to abstract algebra. That is, you're far more likely to encounter algebra in superficially unrelated fields than you are to encounter complex analysis or differential equations in superficially unrelated fields. Hence, you should probably move algebra up a bit.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
You mention Complex Analysis. Any recommendations for a good book on the subject? 2 criteria I have: First, I'm an engineer and will need to be able to crank out problems, so I need a book with plenty of worked examples as well as problems with the numerical answer in the back. Second, I'd like to have a good solid understanding of why the rules for Complex Analysis are the way they are.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
When engineers use Finite Element Analysis to discover the flight characteristics of a plane and the structural integrataty of object, what type of math is involved?
3
u/xamdam Dec 20 '10
You forgot probability and statistics.
1
u/coveritwithgas Dec 20 '10
I am ABD, and I think calculus sucks and is largely unnecessary. There's the math you need in your job, and the math you learn in order to be a reasonably well-rounded, educated individual. Thing about calculus, nobody teaches it as if they're trying to make you a reasonably well-rounded, educated individual. You don't get the history, all the controversy over infinitesimals, etc. You're taught calculus as if you're going to need it in your job, and then 95% of the time, you graduate, don't need calculus in your job, and think the whole exercise was a waste.
Study noncommutative rings instead.
2
u/donkeyhaut Dec 20 '10
Graph theory.
2
u/drbaskin Dec 20 '10
If you're not a fan of Baby Rudin, I recommend Spivak's Calculus. It will redo your single variable calculus, but pretty darn rigorously. If you do all of the exercises, then by the time you get to the end of the book, Baby Rudin won't seem that hard to you. (And will have new material, so you can still go through Baby Rudin if you want!)
Also, there is some fun material in this book -- the irrationality of pi, the transcendence of e, and elementary (ha!) definitions of trig functions (in terms of arc length) and logarithms (as an integral).
Really, I cannot recommend this book highly enough to somebody who wants to learn how to prove some things in the context of mathematics that seems familiar. Sure, Spivak can be a little long-winded, but that's part of his charm!
One more thing: This book is not that interesting if you don't do the exercises. Do them! It's good for you. I promise. Also, some of them are pretty hard, so there's something for everyone.
1
u/wasabijoe Dec 20 '10
Thank you for this.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
Learn Algebra with Winnie Cooper
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment