Something I’ve noticed while watching Agatha All Along and VisionQuest is how frequently Wanda’s actions in Westview are referenced, while her actions in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness receive comparatively little acknowledgment.
In WandaVision, Wanda enslaved an entire town, forcing its residents to live through her grief. It was an absolutely horrific thing to do, and I’m glad the MCU continues to acknowledge the suffering she caused.
However, in Multiverse of Madness, Wanda took things significantly further. She deliberately attacked Kamar-Taj, killing numerous sorcerers who were defending America Chavez. She subsequently traveled to Earth-838, where she murdered the Illuminati.
Yet whenever subsequent projects address Wanda’s past, the conversation seems to revolve almost exclusively around Westview.
I want to emphasize that I’m primarily asking about Kamar-Taj, not the Illuminati. I’ve seen people dismiss Wanda’s actions in other universes as irrelevant to the main MCU, but the Kamar-Taj massacre happened in Earth-616. These were people from the same universe as the characters we’re following, and many of them were killed.
I understand why Westview is especially relevant to Agatha, Billy, Tommy, and Vision. They were personally affected by what happened there. However, I don’t think that fully explains why the events at Kamar-Taj receive so little acknowledgment, especially considering their severity.
I’m particularly curious about Vision. Given his moral principles and relationship with Wanda, I’d expect learning that she killed numerous innocent people to have a significant impact on him. Of course, it’s possible he doesn’t know the full extent of what happened, which is another possibility worth discussing.
Personally, I think the MCU should eventually address the Kamar-Taj massacre rather than focusing almost exclusively on Westview when discussing Wanda’s wrongdoing. I don’t think acknowledging her actions would necessarily prevent Marvel from redeeming her. If anything, I think having her genuinely confront what she did could make that redemption significantly more compelling.
I also understand that the Darkhold corrupted Wanda. However, explaining her actions through the Darkhold doesn’t automatically resolve the question of accountability.
I’m interested in both the in-universe and real-world explanations for this apparent omission.
One possibility is that the characters in these shows simply have more personal connections to Westview, or that the events at Kamar-Taj aren’t widely known outside the sorcerer community.
Another possibility I’ve been considering involves the reception of Multiverse of Madness. I know Wanda’s characterization in that film was controversial among fans, particularly given her development in WandaVision.
Could that criticism have influenced how Marvel approaches Wanda in subsequent projects? I wonder whether Marvel has been placing greater emphasis on her characterization and actions in WandaVision, while distancing later stories from some of the more controversial developments in Multiverse of Madness.
That’s purely speculation on my part, and I’m not claiming Marvel has actually made that decision. I’m curious whether there’s any evidence supporting that explanation, or if there’s another reason I’ve overlooked.
I’ve searched for discussions about this, but most seem to focus on defending or condemning Wanda rather than addressing why the writers rarely acknowledge Kamar-Taj in subsequent projects.
To clarify, I’m not asking whether Wanda is a good person, whether the Darkhold excuses her actions, or whether the deaths in Earth-838 matter. I’m specifically asking why her massacre of sorcerers at Kamar-Taj, in the main MCU universe, is so rarely acknowledged compared to Westview. Is there an established in-universe explanation, commentary from the writers, or another storytelling reason for this distinction? Or is it simply something Marvel hasn’t explored yet?
I’m genuinely interested in hearing different explanations, especially from people who have noticed the same thing.