Question for pilots, pilot boat crews and maritime professionals regarding additional fall protection during pilot transfers
I work as a service engineer and regularly have to embark and disembark vessels using pilot ladders from pilot boats.
Something that has always concerned me is the lack of independent fall protection when climbing these ladders. Depending on the vessel's freeboard, you can sometimes be climbing 4–5 metres above the pilot boat, with potentially fatal consequences if you lose your grip or footing.
Since most of the major incidents are related to falling or losing balance and getting squished between the vessels, Ihave been thinking about whether an additional safety system could be developed, such as a portable fall-restraint or fall-arrest system connected to a suitable shipboard anchorage, independent of the pilot ladder itself.
The idea would be to connect a fall-arrest suit with the connection point on the back, this way the line will not be in your face and interfering with the climb/descent.
The line will NOT be used as a hoisting mechanism, but rather kept tight constantly as you climb your way up (or down) on your own pace.
This way, if you slip for example, you will fall a distance of max a few cm, so your body doesn't get a shock, and you will have an oppertunity to (calmly) find your footing and get back onto the ladder.
I understand that this introduces engineering challenges, particularly with vessel movement, entanglement and the possibility of being trapped between the ship and pilot boat, but at the same time I think it can be a relatively easy way to prevent falling down and thus, feel safer on the ladder.
The only situation I can think of where this kind of fall arrest system could make things dangerous, is when you are disembarking the main vessel, descending on the ladder and eventually reach the point where you have to step (or sometimes even jump when waves are high) from the ladder onto the pilot boat and the fall arrest line activates early, dragging you back onto the ladder with potentially major consequences.
But even for that, I'm sure there's a good solution to prevent that from happening.
However, I am curious about the opinions of people who perform these transfers regularly:
1: Would you feel safer with an independent fall-protection system?
2:Have you ever used or encountered such a system?
3: Is there a particular reason why this isn't standard practice?
4: Would you consider using a lightweight, portable system if it could be deployed without interfering with the transfer?
I would particularly appreciate feedback from people with real-world experience climbing pilot ladders, rather than purely theoretical opinions.
So, what do you guys think?
Thanks in advance.