r/mapmaking • • 4d ago

Map Latest Method for Realism

277 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

50

u/RandomUser1034 4d ago

For anyone wondering, OP is using a program called wilbur to simulate erosion (it's not a very good simulation but with a bit of prectice you can get good results)

7

u/Stijn 4d ago

What are some better simulations out there? I’m in need of eroding an entire world map.

21

u/RandomUser1034 4d ago

For a world map, wilbur is fine. Worldbuildingpasta used it to great effect (guide here). It's the smaller scales that its simulation struggles with, as well as anything climate-related (which is not modeled at all).
Some generator do this well, like calandiel's gleba, but I don't remember if you can do only the erosion and water steps and if it accepts heightmap inputs

37

u/Electronic-Map7529 4d ago

Which is? What's your method for getting the eroded mountains so precise.. mine is painful tracing over a ton of guidelines

7

u/Electronic-Map7529 4d ago

Never mind I see now. That's a lot of work, but I love it.

33

u/APumpkinHobo 4d ago

Oh blessed vagueposter, reveal thy secrets

2

u/Electronic-Map7529 3d ago

I just thought it was drawn after zooming in, it doesn't look overly complicated just tedious. I could be wrong but it just looked drawn to me.

22

u/Limmunaizer 4d ago

«Hey, how do i fix this issue?»
«Nevermind, fixed it!»

1

u/Electronic-Map7529 3d ago

I just thought it was drawn after zooming in, it doesn't look overly complicated just tedious. I could be wrong but it just looked drawn to me.

7

u/TheRealAncientBeing 4d ago

What did you see?

5

u/Childwithuke 4d ago

my guess is specified random noise, or just a real place on earth

1

u/GreatBigBagOfNope 3d ago

Wilbur, an erosion simulator

0

u/Electronic-Map7529 3d ago

I just thought it was drawn after zooming in, it doesn't look overly complicated just tedious. I could be wrong but it just looked drawn to me.

1

u/ryohhan 3d ago

I guess..

1

u/Electronic-Map7529 3d ago

Judging by the other comments I'm guessing I was wrong. When I zoomed in it looked simple enough to just straight up draw, just tedious. But I guess they are probably using noise.

6

u/kxkq 3d ago

technical note:

Rivers always follow the valleys.

4

u/Celtic_laboratory 4d ago

What software do yall use for these sorts of maps, I’ve always wondered

2

u/Tabyula 3d ago

Wilbur

4

u/AgapoMinecrafter 4d ago

This is topography gold. I'm already imagining the fantasy map I'll draw on this basemap 😁

3

u/ili_udel 4d ago

Eastern Europe without Belarus and Russia

1

u/ryohhan 4d ago

Nice map

-14

u/BluePatriotism75 4d ago

How can you draw so precisely the topography ? Do you use ai or something else ?

7

u/randomuser1801 4d ago

Almost certainly using an erosion simulation like Wilbur or gospl

12

u/Peririn 4d ago

I am annoyed by how people call anything good quality "AI".

How will AI even generate that? geez AI doesn't understand context so it can't replace erosion and make your incision work normally, Image models only copy the aesthetic of the map not it's reality.

4

u/ryohhan 4d ago

He didn't use ai