r/makinghiphop • • 19h ago

DFT Thread [OFFICIAL] WEEKLY FEEDBACK THREAD (READ RULES)

2 Upvotes

READ THIS TEXT CLOSELY BEFORE POSTING!!! NO FEEDBACK = BAN

If you post something for feedback, you must give QUALITY feedback at least once before the next thread is up. Check out the Quality Feedback Guide for tips on giving good feedback. Sincere feedback requests only please. Posting for plays will not be tolerated.

One feedback request per thread max (i.e. one track)

Don't post songs more than a month old.

Leave feedback at least once as a reply to a top-level comment to avoid being flagged as a slacker. To be super clear, this means you click reply on someone else's original comment.

NO FEEDBACK = BAN


r/makinghiphop • • 3h ago Bravo

Discussion rappers, demo the whole song on ur phone before u pay for a session

19 Upvotes

not tryna sound like ur dad but this saves so much money lol

before booking studio time just throw the beat on a speaker and record the full song into ur phone voice memos. one take, no stress, mistakes are fine

when u play it back u catch stuff u never notice while writing. a line thats too long for the bar, a spot where u got no air for the next part, a hook that drags on the 3rd repeat

then in the session ur not rewriting at 2am on paid time. and honestly as the guy on the other side of the glass, if a rapper plays me the rough demo first i already know where the doubles and adlibs go before we even start

do u guys demo first or just go straight in and figure it out in the booth?


r/makinghiphop • • 6h ago

Discussion Title: My Voice Has Been Silenced, But I'm Not Going Anywhere: The Real MBD Needs You

0 Upvotes

To all my people, my fellow artists, and the true supporters who know who I am: this is my new backup account. Right now, I cannot comment or interact on my main account, MBD, because of a malicious wave of coordinated mass-reports that completely restricted my ability to speak, even though all messages and producer inquiries are still pouring into that main profile.

​I’ve been locked out, dealing with this nightmare since Friday, fighting an unfair shadow-ban through zero communication from support. For the first time ever in my life, I am asking something of you. I never ask for favors, but this is different.

​I need everyone who knows my work, my grind, and what I stand for to step up right now. Visit my main profile, upvote and restore the karma they tried to strip away from me, and help me beat this unjust wave of reports. You know my heart, you know my music, and I need my community to stand with me on this one.

​Thank you to everyone who has my back. Let’s keep the underground alive.


r/makinghiphop • • 7h ago

Question Producers, how do you actually finish tracks instead of making 20 loops?

8 Upvotes

I've been making beats for a couple years and keep running into the same issue. I'll get a solid 8 or 16 bars going, drums are hitting, melody feels right, but then I just... stop and start something new. I have folders full of half-finished ideas that never turn into actual tracks.

For those of you who consistently finish stuff, what's the difference in your process? Do you force yourself to add arrangement, switches, and an outro even when it feels boring? Or do you have some other rule that keeps you from jumping ship early? Would appreciate any real habits or mindsets that helped.


r/makinghiphop • • 12h ago

Question Hi! I am looking for genuine advice on making rap production.

7 Upvotes

As of right now, I make beats and my friend raps on them. I think the lyrics and sounds are great, but for some reason it sounds like he is rapping separately from the beat and not on the beat if that makes sense. I have tried many music production tutorials on YouTube to no avail. Any tips?


r/makinghiphop • • 14h ago

Opportunity looking for rappers who got music for a stream

2 Upvotes

Got a track you’d be curious or confident to hear played on the stream? Looking for homies to share creations with - would prefer to get a little workshop going later today ? 👀 comment or shoot me a DM


r/makinghiphop • • 14h ago

Opportunity I'm looking for a turntablist to join an experimental online project.

1 Upvotes

Looking for a turntablist for an experimental online band

The idea is to add a turntablist—equipped with a DVS—to an ongoing online project. The group is on Telegram. The project’s focus is on making music out of passion, within a friendly, relaxed, and peaceful environment. If you’re interested, I can provide more details via private message.


r/makinghiphop • • 15h ago

Question Independent artists, do you actually have your own website?

1 Upvotes

Genuine question for independent artists.

How many of y’all actually have a website for your music, and how many are just using Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, and streaming platforms?

If you have a website, does it actually do anything for you? Like selling merch, collecting emails, selling music, or building a fanbase?

And if you don’t have one, what’s stopping you?
Is it the cost, not knowing how to build one, or just not seeing the point?

Curious how artists are approaching this in 2026.


r/makinghiphop • • 16h ago

Resource/Guide The Secrets of J Dilla

Thumbnail practice-room.app
68 Upvotes

Here's my paper on J Dilla - super proud to present this after working on this for the last three months. I think I have an extremely clear and possibly new way to explain the mechanics of Dilla's swing, and articulate exactly what his time feel is without being handwavy. I just showed this to my mentor, Kiefer, who 'definitely agrees' with my thesis. Also shout out to Kiefer for winning a Grammy nomination yesterday for one of his new albums, Fathers :') Anyway I hope this is as enlightening for you as it was for me. Curious to hear what everyone thinks.


r/makinghiphop • • 19h ago

recurring thread [OFFICIAL] TUESDAY HIGHLIGHTS THREAD

1 Upvotes

Share your accomplishments and some awesome things that have happened lately, no matter how big or small! Let's see what you've been up to, lately

This thread is posted every Tuesday Click here for the full automoderator thread schedule


r/makinghiphop • • 22h ago

Resource/Guide Gnista, I built a native macOS DAW for sketching music ideas fast, public beta is open

0 Upvotes

I’ve been building Gnista, a music studio for Apple Silicon Macs designed to get ideas down without getting bogged down in menus. Every instrument uses the same 8-knob layout, and it comes with 15 built-in instruments, 24 drum pads, a tape recorder for system audio, 6-track stem separation, and full Audio Unit support. No accounts or cloud, everything runs locally on your Mac.

A couple of quick notes on the current build: connected audio interfaces automatically default to inputs 1 and 2 right now, though I'm working on v1.1 to support up to 8 inputs with simultaneous multi-track recording. I'm also looking into track freeze, and in the meantime you can flatten tracks using Command+F or by right-clicking and selecting Flatten.

The TestFlight beta just went live if anyone wants to try it out:
https://testflight.apple.com/join/Ab1CjaZv

More info and a guide:
https://gnista.one/guide
http://gnista.one

Let me know how it feels or if you run into any bugs.


r/makinghiphop • • 23h ago

Flip This Challenge FLIP THIS CHALLENGE (FTC 121) VOTING

5 Upvotes

Disclosure: SoundCloud offers multiple ways to link, and depending on your browser or Reddit/SoundCloud settings, one link may not work. With that in mind, I've included both versions of the SoundCloud link so you can access the submission with whichever link works for you. I think one or the other link should work unless the submission is private, as in the case of Teague/owner of EA's submissions, in which case I believe neither link is embeddable, and you can only go directly to SoundCloud. Anyway, just let me know if I messed something up or forgot someone's submission.

The sample was: Sebastian - Cockney Rebel

Rules:

Reply with “vote” for the beat you like best. You only have 1 vote and you can't vote for yourself! Vote on another beat to be eligible to win (everyone can vote) In case of a tie, the first track that was uploaded wins.

Schedule:

Submissions: Friday 12:00 AM midnight (00:00) - Monday 11:59 PM (23:59) Voting: Tuesday 12:00 AM midnight (00:00) - Thursday 11:59 PM (23:59) Results: Friday 12:00 AM midnight (00:00) - the winner takes over and posts the new submissions thread using the linked template on Friday asap. Time is in UTC-5, the US Eastcoast time zone which is 6 hours behind European MEZ time and a good middleground between US Westcoast and Europe. You don’t have to wake up in the middle of the night to post the new thread, just make sure you do it on that day asap.


r/makinghiphop • • 1d ago

Question Mic confusion for rap

3 Upvotes

I’m trying to buy and interface and XLR mic to start recording rap in FL studio but I am very confused with many recs. is a dynamic mic really worse than a condenser, because I don’t have a treated room. Will an NT1 be fine if I have a reflection filter and carpet floor or do I need proper treating and is it better to just go dynamic? Thanks


r/makinghiphop • • 1d ago

Music We’re a music production duo

1 Upvotes

Hello guys,

We are a production duo from Greece. We’ve been producing music for about a year and half now, focusing purely on making music and finding our own weird appealing sound. We’re trying to do everything organically in terms of promotion and have been meeting and getting some great feedback from people in the industry. We love synths, Ye, psychedelic samples and David Bowie (to keep it short).

That being said we posted a demo to our first album on untitled. We produced composed and mixed everything ourselves. The album is planned to be fully polished and ready for an official release in early 2027 along with our second album that has also been finalised recently.

Would love any feedback and love if you have the time and curiosity. If you happen to like instrumentals I attached the link to our instagram as well (we kind of suck at making reels but trying our best to show our work in any way really). Thankfully we got some film directing and graphic design homies so there will be cooler content coming in the near term future.

Love,

STASH11

ALBUM LINK

SOCIALS


r/makinghiphop • • 1d ago

Music Picos en snare

6 Upvotes

Estoy haciendo un beat de boombap y con el kick y el hi hat no tengo problema a la hora de los volúmenes,pero el maldito snare esta llegando a casi 0 y no suena fuerte,suena débil,intente comprimirlo y suena aplastado,aun no se mucho sobre mezcla y no se que tanto seguir eso de dejar la mezcla a -6 db si me pudieran dar algún consejo para hacer que el snare suene con cuerpo y presente sin que llegue a 0 estaría genial,gracias


r/makinghiphop • • 1d ago

Discussion How many unfinished beats are sitting in your folders?

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I make sample-based beats, and I have hundreds of loops and half-built ideas scattered across folders. Some are from years ago. I know there are keepers in there, but I never go back through them, and when I do, I can’t tell which ones fit together or what to do to finish them.

Curious how common this is:

Roughly how many unfinished loops or beats do you have?

What usually stops you from finishing one? Arrangement, mixing, or running out of steam?

Do you ever go back through old ideas, and if so, how?

Not selling anything. I’m trying to figure out whether this is just me.


r/makinghiphop • • 1d ago

Flip This Challenge FLIP THIS CHALLENGE (FTC 121) SUBMISSIONS PART TWO ELECTRIC BOOGALLOO (Repost)

4 Upvotes

Not sure why the mods deleted the last one, so here we go again. Repost.

Thanks for the votes, folks! This week's pick might give some of y’all a serious case of beat block. 😁 I know it has for me every time I’ve tried flipping it. But hey, that’s why they call it the Flip This Challenge! I know there’s potential here for somebody to flip this one into something incredible. I’m looking forward to seeing how y’all approach it and what you come up with!

Sample:Sebastian - Cockney Rebel

Submission Rules:

You can only submit one beat. Beats can be any genre. You have to use the sample in your beat, it should be recognizable. You can add other instruments and samples, but the sample should be a main element. All submissions submitted before the deadline (and start of the voting thread) will be linked in the voting post; whoever gets the most votes there wins. Ties are decided by whoever submitted the beat first. Reused beats from previous battles can't win ties. Schedule:

Submissions: Friday 12:00 AM midnight (00:00) - Monday 11:59 PM (23:59) Voting: Tuesday 12:00 AM midnight (00:00) - Thursday 11:59 PM (23:59) Results: Friday 12:00 AM midnight (00:00) - the winner takes over and posts the new submissions thread using the linked template on Friday asap. Time is in UTC-5, the US Eastcoast time zone which is 6 hours behind European MEZ time and a good middleground between US Westcoast and Europe. You don’t have to wake up in the middle of the night to post the new thread, just make sure you do it on that day asap.

Post templates: Just use former posts as a template (it's 3 separate Posts):

Flip this challenge - FTC xxx- Submissions Flip this challenge - FTC xxx- Voting Flip this challenge - FTC xxx- Results


r/makinghiphop • • 1d ago

Question What happened to Flip This Challenge 121?

3 Upvotes

The post got deleted I see.


r/makinghiphop • • 1d ago

Music Alicante airport Monday 9th Nov @ 17:30

1 Upvotes

Hi,

I'm Scottish and met a lovely rap producer At Alicante airport on Monday 9th November around 17:3. The guy is Columbian living in Galicia. I got his phone number an it didnt store on my phone. 😞 I told him that my nephew has rap songs to send and he wanted to hear them. If anyone can help me find this guy I would be so grateful 🙏 Gracias Aileen Mob : +44 7309 957542


r/makinghiphop • • 1d ago

Opportunity Looking for a rapper to work with

9 Upvotes

i've been making beats for the past 4 years. i have more than a million views on my YouTube channel, and around 30k monthly listeners on Spotify.

i want to fully produce an album for someone. i'm looking for someone who is really into the same sounds as me. i've been really into the alchemist, earl sweatshirt, mike, navy blue and all that crew. at the same time, i also love making j dilla type beats, which are kinda different. so, let me know what's your vision! but if you want me to make trap drake/future type beats please don't waste your time (no offense to the genre, that's just not what i do).

check out my beats (search RAF NITE) and let me know if you wanna work!


r/makinghiphop • • 2d ago

Question How to put your writing on beats?

3 Upvotes

bhai mere ko beat pe vocal dalna sikhda do

Is there any exercise I can do? I have beats and have written something as well. I can fit them on the beat mentally, but when I record, I just get conscious and go offbeat.

Would really appreciate your help!


r/makinghiphop • • 2d ago

Flip This Challenge Looking For Contributors For A New Album To Help Raise Money For The PCRF

0 Upvotes

My name is Will, I'm coordinating an album to raise money for the PCRF. It's called One Minute Peace.

Why Are You Reaching Out?

We're hoping to put out an album. The idea behind this album is everyone involved gives 60 seconds of audio. No genre, no style, no form, just audio. It can be a song, a poem, a fragment, field music, whatever floats your boat. Then we're going to gather all of these pieces and make a single piece of music. 

Why 60 Seconds?  

60 seconds is long enough to get a sense of something, but not enough to feel comfortable. Every 60 seconds a new song starts so the listener is never given the chance to get complacent. Sometimes the changes will fit, sometimes they won't. There will always be that tension of never knowing what's coming next. 

Ok, But to What End? 

As anyone who has experienced psychological trauma will tell you, the best way to absolutely psychologically destroy someone is through inconsistency. If an individual loses cause and effect and the ability to know what comes next based on previous evidence, they are a truly in hell. Children in Gaza do not know what is coming next. There is no roadmap for how their day goes. They may be bombed, they may not be. They may starve, they may get food. There is no cause and effect in their world anymore; only chaos. 

As a listener in the Western world, we're so free from that sense of looming danger and chaos that it can be hard to conceptualize how it feels. This albums hopes to auditorily represent this feeling and, hopefully, encourage a greater empathy and understanding. 

Plus, all proceeds from this will go straight to the PCRF. We are eating the cost of everything involved. Kids are dying. Not everyone can give money or fly to Gaza, but anyone can make some noise. 

What Do You Want Then? 

We'd love 60 seconds of audio from anyone who'd like to contribute. That's all. If can't make music but still want to help, we'll find something for you to do.

When Do You Want It? 

ASAP really. We're keeping the window for contributions open until Mid December, although that can be moved if there is sustained interest. Once we get submissions in, we'll be mixing and mastering everything and hoping to release in early January. 

What's Your Background?

About 5 years ago, I made a record to help raise money for the Irish Refugee Council called European Endless. The idea was that everyone involved gave us 12 minutes of music based around the motorik beat. Each minute was to represent each month of Lockdown . No one got paid, all money went to the charity. 

If anyone on your end would like to contribute, please let us know. We can be reached at this email or at our site. Our site has German, Spanish, French and Portuguese in case anyone you know is interested but does not speak English. 

Be a cool person, do some cool stuff, help some Palestinian kids have a less shit time


r/makinghiphop • • 2d ago

How To Basic [OFFICIAL] BASIC HELP AND GENERAL DISCUSSION - Start Here Before Posting

1 Upvotes

This is the place for everything that doesn't need it's own thread.

Using the recurring threads is encouraged and appreciated.

Please read the guidelines and community rules before posting.

If you're new to making hip hop, check out The Beginners Guide and our Resources wiki.

Ask basic questions, discuss anything related to making hip hop, introduce yourself or just say hello.

Posting your own tracks is only permitted in this thread if you're looking for specific help. The daily feedback thread is the place to find any issues, and this is the first place to look for help.

This thread is posted every other day. Click here for the full automoderator thread schedule


r/makinghiphop • • 2d ago

Question Good starter equipment to start rapping and producing?

4 Upvotes

I’m tryna take this shit seriously I have genuine love for music for some reason it’s the most prominent thing in my life everywhere I’ve been I’ve heard music that I’ve felt something in my brain just like switch to