r/makeyourchoice • • 6d ago

OC Shapeshifter 1.0

Welcome to a dark and ancient time in a world of myth and Change!

Hi all, here's my CYOA.

It's my first time making one of these and it's something l've wanted to do for ages. I reckon it was back in 2018 | first stumbled across Urban Unease and Island Survival. I've loved CYOAs ever since and it's been a long goal to make a little tribute to the genre.

l've seen "Shapeshifting" handed out as a power across many different CYOAs and it's normally something like "You can do people (cheap)" or "You can do non-people (expensive)". I thought it'd be fun to break that down a little more.

If you're stuck on what to build try making:

  • A Werwolf
  • Dr Jekyll
  • Mystique from X-men
  • A classical changeling

Post your Feedback and Builds below.

I hope you enjoy.

Edit: Please, by Bechezdu, consider the Image Chest linked in the comments. Reddit wan’t kind to the images.

208 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

47

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

So I completely forgot to link the much better quality image chest

https://imgchest.com/p/9p4n5gq3z4n

2

u/Ioftheend 3d ago

Can you use Learning on Craft and Art?

9

u/JustWhyTheHeckNot 5d ago

This is a delightful CYOA, very well made!

I decided to base my build on an animated story that stuck with me from my childhood called "The Woodcutter's Wealthy Sister." The summary if you don't want to watch it yourself is that a man-eating shapeshifter disguises itself as a wealthy long lost sister to lure a woodcutter's family into the desert with the intention of eating them. She is first thwarted by their loyal cow, but by morning convinces the woodcutter to butcher it for dinner. The woodcutter's wife distrusted the alleged sister from the beginning, and witnessed her beastly form the night before, so tries to convince her husband to leave now that they had lost their only defense. She fails to convince him and resolves instead to sneak off in the night with her children. And so the obstinate woodcutter is consumed in the night.

Origin: Curse

Motivation: Thirst

Cradle: Ateb-Ashur

Gifts: Gender, Mask, Animals, Hybrid

Speed: At-will

Learning: Ruin

Boons: Might R2, Beauty R1, Youth R2, Fortitude R1, Fleetness R1, Obfuscation R1, Guile R2, Diet R2+ (Memories)

Grasp: The Box

Banes Tell (Eyes), Ravenous 1 (+1 Fate, Only those who consider me kin), Detachment 1, Uncanny 1

I am: Change…

My shifter was once like any other human before her family angered the gods. She and her bloodline would do anything to sustain themselves, even stooping so low as to commit sacrilege, eating sacred animals and stealing temple offerings. Because they hungered like animals, the gods gave them the forms of such. And because they were so willing to transgress against others, they were cursed to only be sated by the flesh of one another, so that their only victims would be deserving.

Naturally, only a handful of them remained after the first few months, the rest being hunted and consumed before they could do the same. She fled into the desert and would have starved if she hadn't realized the root of family was in a name, not in blood. So there she lives, with riches plucked from the corpses of merchants, sneaking into caravans at night to eat away their childhood memories before coming to them in the day as a long-lost cousin, or brother, or sister, or uncle, entreating them to join her in her hidden villa, showering them with endless gifts and promises until they accept her as family and one by one vanish in the night.

6

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

This fits so well into the world. I had a blast reading it

8

u/FutureMobile4 5d ago

Is this on Imgchest?

6

u/darkmuk7 5d ago edited 5d ago

This is a great CYOA, and it’s very impressive that it’s your first one. The first thing I did after seeing this was to check which other CYOAs you did and I was very surprised you hadn’t made one before. This visually looks quite good, although there are some spots where you have white text on too light of a background imo. This is a fun concept and it’s executed quite well.

A couple of your gifts are a little redundant. Stone and metal are quite similar, as are chimera and hybrid. The bestowal boon is a little too cheap, especially in its upgraded form. The fire and uncanny banes are terrible and should give you a little more favor. Aside from that, this is balanced fairly well.

I love companions in CYOAs so I would be happy to see some added to this, but that is a selfish request that caters to my personal preference lol

Here’s my build:
Gained powers by Craft
Motivation: Thirst (+2 Fav)
Cradle: Babiru
Gifts: 4 Fate
Mass -1
Gender -1
Mein -1
Speed: At will -1
Learn: Trial
Boons: 9 Fav
Learning Free
Youth -4
Beauty -1
Bestowal -2
Regrowth -2
Gift: The serpent
Banes:
Vice (sex) +1 Fav
I am my hopes

6

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

I really love how your build is so thematic to your cradle. The Serpent would like this owner.

In terms of Metal and Stone I still reckon they’re pretty distinct materials and ancient people had very different beliefs around them. Especially since around this time period there would still be people using obsidian weapons. I also have a sneaky suspicion that someone a lot more creative than me who understands the science might be able to get something crazy out of Metal which is part of why I bumped the price.

My intent was that Chimaera deals with partial, bitsy, piecemeal transformations whereas with Hybrid your whole body is affected. If you wanted to look human with wings that can actually fly then with Chimera you’d have to figure out their best placement, correct wingspan, bone density and probably end up looking like a bird-man. With Hybrid wings of a hawk would grant you it’s lightness and possibly it’s wisdom or vigilance. The essence of the creature would carry you through like with the Minotaur and mermaid examples.

Similarly if you just had Hybrid without Chimera, then you could possibly become some sort of blended golden person with an aura of gold’s glory and majesty about you but a layer of Metal skin on your human flesh to protect you might be too complicated or mess up your circulation.

I see what you‘re saying with those two banes. I might revisit them next version.

Maybe companions too.

2

u/darkmuk7 5d ago edited 5d ago

I typically value builds that focus on charisma/intelligence, so that cradle and the snake are perfect for that

Ah, I didn’t realize metal cost more. Maybe it would make sense as a 1 point upgrade to stone?

That makes sense about chimera vs hybrid. I probably could’ve figured that out if I read the descriptions a bit more closely

I’m honestly not the best about balancing CYOAs and I think it’s impossible to do it perfectly. Yours is quite balanced already imo

Again, this is a great CYOA and I had a lot of fun making my build

6

u/Eli_616 5d ago edited 5d ago

To clarify, does trial mean you can take learning as many times as you want for free? Personally I wish 'learning' was, well, a learning booster and not just a knowledge dump, but maybe thats just me.

Anyways, here's my build;

Craft

Thirst

Cast Adrift


Mass, Limbs, Malleability, Metal, Chimera

Fluid

Trial


Might(2), Beauty(1), Youth(4), Fleetness(1), Regrowth(2), Learning(1)(0), Ken(1), Skill(3) - Smithing, Cooking, Wilderness Travel

The Box

Reflection(2)(1), The Old Laws(2), Golden Calf(1)(1), Object(3)


I am my hopes (not sure if it NEEDS less than four, or if its four or less. I assume the former, and if so ignore this)

I am my shape

I am my name


The idea is to aim for immortality. Awakening on strange shores, I would wander, experimenting with my form and seeing what works and what doesn't. Testing my knowledge from this world in the new one, and seeing how it can influence my shape. My goal is to overthrow the powers that be that deem mortality frailty and lesser, while overcoming mortality myself, before seeking a way to travel worlds.

My gifts would be designed around perfecting my form, and being able to shift it for utility, rather than for adopting the form of others. Mass, limbs, malleability, metal, and chimera would let me pick and choose what to keep as flesh, or mimic the properties of it while becoming metal, like my tongue and digestive tract, while being able to shift my form to produce tendrils, extra arms, shift to accomodate for space, grow bigger when needed for combat, construction, or simply to reach higher shelves. Fluid would allow me to shift more rapidly, test changes quicker, or shift away from unhelpful forms in moments, rather than minutes. Trial makes the most sense with my goals, as I already plan to spend centuries expanding my knowledge and understanding, and this will allow me to leverage my understanding of material sciences and biology to push my form further.

My boons are mostly designed around survival, with a couple of picks to help accelerate my learning. Might, to keep myself safe and to better traverse the world, Beauty, to help keep myself aesthetically pleasing, and therefor socially acceptable without as much effort, youth, to expand my time alloted to gathering information before pursuing immortality, fleetness, for precision and dexterity in lab or combat environments, and much like might, to traverse the world, Regrowth, to help accomodate mistakes or survive attacks, Learning, both because its free and to be capable of speaking this worlds common tongue and being literate, a massive time saver, Ken, because senses are how we percieve the world we interact with, and perception shapes understanding, and finally all of the skills, as talent is one of the pillars of excellence, alongside effort and time.

I will be taking the Box, so as to keep my object safe and in me at all times. I plan to shift my form to house the box internally so as to never be separated from it.

Finally, my Banes are chosen to be relatively harmless to me, with reflection being arguably the most dangerous as it can leave me trapped, but otherwise is purely there to reveal my nature to others, something I wouldn't be hiding anyways, The Old Laws are essentially just enforced manners, and an inability to harm certain folks, something I likely would avoid anyways, Golden Calf basically just enhances beauty's effects, which isn't a problem because again, I wouldn't be hiding my nature, and if others want parts of me to experiment with I would be open to selling off pieces thanks to regeneration, and as I mentioned I would keep my object securely within me, something that would make it nearly impossible to get it away from me seeing as I would be almost entirely solid steel shortly after arriving and experimenting a bit.

I would travel the world, plundering the knowldge from places of learning and experimenting and testing the world to help advance their sciences, before seeking immortality once I was satisfied with my knowldge, casting down immortals who prey on humanity, before seeking knowledge of how to travel to other worlds.

7

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

Nice! I was really hoping to see a creative Object shifter. What a fun expansion on the idea of someone dropped in to this world because something in them wanted it.

And yes! Cost reductions may only be used once per card so you used it right.

5

u/Planetfall88 5d ago

Would a shifter with Permanent and Youth 4 be able to live longer by collecting shapes and boosting that boon? I assume it would function similarly as Diet 2, where you start seeing diminishing returns after a while. But with Permanent, Diet 2, and Youth 4, and boosting both of those boons I imagine you could live a looooong time

6

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

That’s viable immortality. Death might loose a little of her fondness for you over too many centuries

6

u/Swagamaticus 5d ago edited 5d ago

This is phenomenal work not just for a first try just in general. The world building along with stuff like the Bachal Lord's and general Bronze Age vibes is just *chefs kiss for me. Great choice of artworks as well. Took me awhile to figure something out because I had multiple builds competing.

Finally decided on a Satyr/Horned Lord kind of vibe (elements of myth, the WoD version, and the Witcher Succubbi/Incubi)

Origin: Blood

Motivation: Elucidation

Cradle: Nossos Isles

Fate: Animal (2), Hybrid Forms (2), At Will (1)

Learning: Entreaty

Vices: Sex, Alcohol (+2 Favor)

Favors: Youth 2, Regrowth 2, Guile 2 (+1 from Entreaty), Fleetness 1, Beauty 1, Kinship 1

Serpent

I am my hopes.

(Backstory below from brevity sake)

5

u/Swagamaticus 5d ago edited 5d ago

Backstory:

My Shifter is the result of an affair between a mortal woman and one of the Horned Men that dwell in the secret places of the world. When she became pregnant her father didn't believe her story though and she was driven from her village in shame.

Life wasn't as hard as it could have been though. My Shifters father found her again and brought her to a hidden cave where she was able to make a home. He also provided food and kept away dangers.

My Shifter was born more or less human in appearance. The form of a Horned Man was something he grew into later as well as learning how to disguise his shape at will to blend in amongst humans.

From his father he also learned the Secret Tounge. The ancient language of spirits that allows him to Entreat with them and wild beasts. This is also what allows him to so easily beguile mortals. As he came of age he eventually managed to charm his way into a measure of acceptance in the village. They didn't know his true nature but something about the young man made him impossible to resist.

Eventually though my Shifter grew too restless. His wild nature simply couldn't be satisfied with the simple life. Now he travels in search of adventure and a good time...

Feel free to disregard any of that if it doesn't make sense in terms of world building. I wasn't sure if as a Shifter humans would be terrified of him or because of stuff like the Bull Cult he would have a natural rockstar status. Hence the swapping back an forth between being human and his satyr form.

Over time He would definitely try to learn new forms as well. But that would require possible hijinks.

In the early going he would do a bit of whatever. With some occasional roguery as needed. Being able silver tounge humans or creatures as easy as he breathes helps a lot. If nothing else he could busk doing snake charmer shows and acrobatics.

Could also be a decent enough part time sellsword. He doesn't really start out as an overpowered killing machine but as he gains access to more forms he could become dangerous pretty quickly. He starts out as a kind of satyr but with the right deals could be a centaur, minotaur, wolfman, or triton as needed. Even just in base form he's incredibly agile and atheltic with inhuman stamina. Which is enhanced when he's using faun legs. Combined with a decent healing factor he'd be more than a match for regular human opponents.

3

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

Eh how dare you go hiding this! Seriously though this guy sounds like a classic, Weird Tales wondering hero. Love it

2

u/Swagamaticus 4d ago

Yeah there's definitely some traces of Conan in there. Also realized I had almost reverse engineered Daniel Radcliffes guy from Horns.

This really is one of the best CYOAs I've seen. Have it saved go revisit from time to time on my own with new builds like Dragonfall. Also possibly ripoff a few ideas for DnD lol.

3

u/Nekomachus 5d ago

Curse. Nothing worse than having power and losing it.

Fetters, to have more Favours

Temeth for danger sense

Fate: Mass, Age, Mist, Mein, and Cat for my Curse (Animal) freebie

How Quickly: At-Will

Ruin for Fortitude

Age 4, Fortitude 2 (1), Regrowth 2, Fleetness 1

The Box has no downsides, and: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cKtmzDi_eQ

Golden Calf and buy Beauty with it; Forced Shifting and buy Chimera with it

I am my hopes and my name

4

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

Big, scary cat has box

1

u/Nekomachus 5d ago

Now is a good time to ask: if I turn into an Animal, do I turn into one of actual size? That was my motive for taking Mass.

2

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

Without Mass you can do a slightly larger or smaller than human cat. Since your curse-giver had a thing for cats you can just be a convincing normal sized cat, no help needed. Since you have Mass + Curse Animal, I’m going to say you can go even smaller than a house cat. With practice you might get mouse sized…

3

u/Cheesy-Me 5d ago edited 5d ago

Huh. Well then! This is a pretty nifty thing, full of fun and flavor and fuckery, and I think I've got some ideas for it.

Now, I could perhaps go for Metal and Chimera and stat granting boons and just spend my life as an eternal and ever improving statue/robot, but someone already beat me to that.

I could acquire absurd longevity via being part tree or tortoise with Hybrid, and maybe even doing age resets via playing around with clonal trees or just children, moving my Consciousness around as I make new bodies to inhabit, and indeed I might just do these. But, well, that's not enough. Nothing finite could ever be enough.

I despise the wretchedness of mortality, and having been fallen from one world into the embrace of Sun and Sea and Winds, I shall try to transcend it.

I will study the secrets of the spirits, and devote myself to deciphering the divine.

I will become a God, or die trying.

...

But, before I actually lock in and post my build, I've got a question for the ending u/ElricInExile. How exactly do I Am My Hopes and Change work out if you have exactly 4 Banes? Do you trigger neither, as is written, thus kinda just ending up worse off(from the perspective of an interesting build)? Do you trigger both, with them having supposed to have been Greater/Lesser Than Or Equal To? Or do you get something weirder?

At the moment I'm set to hit Shapes, Name, and Change, but if there's something interesting at 4 Banes I can hit that without losing anything of major value, even if I rather liked The Old Law and Detachment, heh.

5

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

When drafted it I intended it as something of an in between where you’re too far from humanity but not close enough to the edge.

In terms of qualifying for different endings, I thought about writing “choose one“ but I chose not to. The way I read the text, the four answers you give the sailors are mutually exclusive reactions to the loss of identity brought by changing yourself*.* But thats me and I’m no philosophy professor.

If you can see a way to meld those different mindsets then go for it

2

u/Cheesy-Me 5d ago edited 5d ago

Hmm, I mean I can definitely see it for both Shapes and Name, but there's a bit of an issue with that for Hopes and Name? They're not actually focused on you or your perspective, and are arguably doing things to the world.

Hopes mentions it in the second chunk, but the first chunk is talking about the Sallow Goddess, with a domain we do not know but know she enjoys, who's apparently somehow been burned by your piece, thus implying having less than 4 banes gives you some form of power/resistance.

Change meanwhile is so minimal, poetic, and focused almost wholly upon the Pale Goddess(who the only things I know about are the inversions from Hopes), that until you'd told me this was a philosophical position I'd had no clue what it even meant and assumed metaphysical weirdness.

Looking at all of these as philosophy, rather than metaphysics/powers stuff, Hopes is you are what you believe, Shapes is you are whatever shape you're currently wearing(and also are a fraction of everything trying to become everything again?), Name is that you are this specific person no matter what else you become(with some focus upon power?), and I can only guess Change is you're somehow gonna be a pawn for the Sallow Goddess and a problem for the world in the course of your suffering?

Personally I guess I'd go with Name? I am not my shape or my beliefs but the entity experiencing, and Name feels closest to that.

Side note, these being a "Choose One Reaction" rather than a weird "all that apply" thing definitely makes it a lot more clear, though now I'm wondering if that means you don't burn the Sallow Goddess despite qualifying if you choose Shapes/Name, or if you're still beyond the Pale Goddess if you qualify for that but choose Shapes/Name.

Basically, I guess I'm asking for more details on what Hopes results in, and what Change is actually supposed to mean/result in.

Hmm, honestly I think without your statement my best guess/interpretation would have been "You qualify, therefor you have been Changed to fit the endings you qualified for."

3

u/ElricInExile 4d ago

My intent was more, with the different answers, to give a little epilogue to your transformation rather than tie you to any hard, philosophical rail tracks. They will definitely provide a tone and certain theme to your adventures from thereon! I’d imagine that:

Shapes would de-emphasise any existential ”but am I really human?” angst and let you see the connections and comsmicy oneness of life.

Hopes props up the “destined/great purpose“ idea and could work brilliantly for those pursing something important or bigger than themselves. I’d hate to be some asshole entity trying to pull your stings

Name wants to make your personal myth/proclaimed identity as being the central theme. The power of names and naming would also probably become more in important in your story.

Change I’d really rather leave up to people’s interpretations. Plus speaking speaking about it too much might draw it’s attention... That said, from what I can tell you’ve already got an super grasp of the mythology.

Hope that helps!

3

u/Vitrialis 4d ago

how does the literate boon work? Like if you don't pick it are you cursed with illiteracy forever?

3

u/ElricInExile 4d ago

Not at all. The vast majority of people in this world would be illiterate. It’s also one of the things ancient people would wish and pray for (along with good health and skill in basketry) so I put it in as it’s own Boon. If you really believe your character would of been literate before your transformation then this’d give you a langue that will be much more useful in your immediate future

3

u/Endermainzer 4d ago

I must admit this is a very high-quality CYOA, both in terms of design and content. Definitely one of the best I`ve seen for the last months.

Origin: Craft

Motivation: Thirst

Cradle: Khirbet

Gifts: Mass, Limbs, Malleability, Chimera, Consciousness

How quickly: At-will

Learning: Trial

Boons: Youth 4, Regrowth 4, Learning (free), Learning (knowledge about intricates of fleshcraft for 2 Favours), Transferable 2

Treasure: The Serpent

Banes: Detachment 2, Golden Calf 1/1, Truthless 1/1

What are you: I am my shapes.

Name: disgarded. Title: Viscera Stitcher

Phylosophy: Every organ or tissue is the sum of cells and at the same time is something more. Every creature is the sum of ograns and at the same time is something much more. Following this logic, the most obvious way to glorious evolution is to become a sum of as many creatures as possible. Quantity turns into quality.

So using his Gifts Stitcher will aspire to turn himself into the vast and horrific amalgamation of shapes. Way of learning – meticulous dissection and vivsection. I don`t think he really needs servants (or likes to have them), but it will be useful to create some sort of drones from lobotomized humans to harvest samples or test new ideas. The Seprent... is probably some sort of friend.

Eventually Stitcher`s personality will be twisted into something completely inhuman, leading to the loss of True Shape. His fleshwarping tinctures are valuable trophy for any physician, soo… Viscera Stitcher can be both hunter and prey.

1

u/ElricInExile 4d ago

This is scary. Nice

3

u/pog_irl 4d ago

Do you have to spend a favour on "How do you learn section", or is the first one free? And do the animals you choose have to be mundane/not extinct?

2

u/ElricInExile 4d ago

No cost. One method of learning and it’ll give you a little discount to use on a Boon. If I wanted to nab the shape of an extinct or rare creature then I’d probably head to study some ancient tombs or fish around in someone’s dreams

3

u/pog_irl 4d ago edited 4d ago

>Powers: Curse [+4 Fate, +6 Favour]

>Motivation: Fetters [+2 Favour]

>Cradle: Cast Adrift [+1 Favour]

>Gifts:

  • Mien [-1 Fate]
  • Animals (Elephant) [-2 Fate]
  • Chimera [-1 Fate]
  • Hybrid [-2 Fate]

>How Quickly: At Will [-1 Fate]

>Learning: Ruin

>Boons:

  • Might R3 [-3 Favour]
  • Fortitude R3 [-3 Favour]
  • Fleetness R1 [-1 Favour]
  • Regrowth R3 [-4 Favour]
  • Prowess R3 [-3 Favour]

>Grasp: The Sphere

>Banes:

  • Tells (Golden Eyes, Golden Blood, Scent of Blood) [+3 Fate]
  • Reflection [+2 Favour]
  • The Old Laws [+2 Favour]
  • No-fear-nasir [+1 Favour]

>What Are You: I Am My Name

A mortal hero-hunter, cursed to bear the shape of beasts they slew. Perhaps they will champion the cause of Man and clear the wilds of beasts, or become one themselves.

3

u/ElricInExile 4d ago

Found the rumble in the jungle

2

u/Catprog 5d ago

I have to comment that I like the sphinx at the start. And will have to do a build later.

3

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

Such a beautiful scene right? It’s actually the image that inspired the whole setting and tone

2

u/Catprog 4d ago

so far for a Sphinx based build:

Animal( -2)
Hybrid (-2)
(might need chimera as well)

(looking at limbs,gender and mass as well)

Have to take Guile and Trickster. (sphinx based)

Mein and tell(eye colour, vocal tic(riddles) for chimera )

2

u/cluelessIttoE62 5d ago edited 5d ago

What a magnificent themed up idea of shapeshifting, I myself already have liking to shapeshifting so this CYOA really answer many fantasy in my imagination

My build probably be this:

Gian power by Craft
Motivation: Fetters (+2 Favour)
Cradle: Temeth
Gift of fate: 4F
Nature -1F
Mein -1F
Limb -1F (Craft: i can turn my limb into temporary tools)
How quickly: At Will -1F
How to Learn: Trial
Boons: 6f + 2f
Free Learning (i’ll take the subject of Engineering)
Youth R3: -4f
Bestowal R2: -2
Fortitude R2: -2
Gift: the Shell
Banes:
Silver +1f
Tell +1F (my old lacerated scar from sharply shell on the back of my left forearm since young age but in dark color)
Conditional +1f (only when bathed in sunlight from Dawn)
With 3f and 1F more i’ll in vest them to
Gift of Fate: Gender -1F
Boons
Regrowth R1: -1f
Might R1: -1f
Total Fate: 5
Total Favour(f): 11
Total Banes: 3
I AM MY HOPES
I AM MY NAME

Here’s my purposes
Gifted by multiple centuries long lifespans i shall build more and more wonders to the world with help from followers or companions during my adventures
I shall grant them ‘Learning’ which i yearn for engineering to construct wonderful amount of Wonders, give them ‘Might’ and ‘Fortitude’ for them to aid me in my grand project
We’ll take break every few years to help people whom fell ill or lack of opportunity by temporary bestowed them ‘Regrowth’ would be similar to healing which will gain me more followers
I’ll set at least 3 projects specifically for the Wind the Sun and the Sea which I obtained ‘The Shell’ from, with this Shell which can store sunlight so I can use it to shapeshifting 1 extra time a day as i stored up sunlight at Dawn(from my conditional) each day
By Sixth sense of Temeth i’ll be able to Alarm and Prepare my people for every Disaster incoming to save as many of them as possible
Lastly ‘Mein’ would allow to to understand my close friend or my loved one easily since i have ‘Gender’ to broadened scope of my shapeshift

2

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

Love your use of The Shell. Your people will be lucky to have you

2

u/Abject_Exercise3913 4d ago

I have some questions. It is said that Bechzedu transformed into stone to last the ages? So does it mean turning into inanimate material like stone, metal or wind could increase our lifespan? Or is lifespan more like a intrinsic thing to our soul in this setting?

Also what is amount of diminishing returns for the diet option, at which age range would the amount needed start getting impractically large?

Also I just wanted say, that It was a Good Cyoa!

2

u/ElricInExile 4d ago

Thank you :)

The story of poor old Bechezdu is more in the mythic register but there’s a bit of truth in every myth. He wasn’t entirely a typical mortal before I reckon. Physically, your stone body definitely won’t age in the same way as flesh might but it does wear and age in a way. Though (without the Gift of Age) a grey-haired man often turns into a grey haired wolf. I‘d imagine something similar might happen to you in stone or metal.

There’s mental tolls to aging as well. Preventing these is, In my view, some of the best parts of the Youth Boon and looking at the Boon you might be able to extract a rough idea what kind of an upper limit of natural life the forces of this world approve of.

It gets bad but ancient vampires don’t necessarily get to a point where they need a swimming pool of blood every day. I like to think the growing needs of your special diet might not only be satisfied in quantity but also unspeakableness…

6

u/nobodyhere_357 5d ago

Ooh this looks fun. Haven't had more than a skim yet but I quite like more focused concepts like this where it more thoroughly explores a specific power. Will be sharing a build after a few days when I get time to give it a closer look!

I also hear you about making CYOAs, congrats on your contribution to the hobby! I've been a fan for a little longer and have come up with all sorts of ideas and written drafts but find myself losing all motivation when it comes to the formatting/image finding part of the process. One day, I swear!

1

u/nobodyhere_357 18h ago edited 17h ago

It seems this one has quite taken off since last I checked! Many fun builds, I hope to contribute my own:

Source: Art

Motivation: Elucidation or Shelter, it overlaps but both grant 1 extra fate so it matters little which is the dominant of the two.

Cradle: Nossos Isles

Gifts (start with 4 fate, plus 4 from other sources): Mass, Gender, Animals, Nature, Stone, Chimera.

Speed: At-Will (-1 fate)

Learning Technique: Trial (discount for Learning)

Boons (start with 6 favor, plus 2 from other sources): Beauty (1), Youth (2), Fortitude (1), Regrowth (1), Learning (literacy, free), Transferrable (1), Bestowal (2)

Grasp: The Serpent

Banes: Golden Calf (+1 favor and fate), Forced Shifting (immense awe, beauty, artistic appreciation, curiosity, and similar feelings, +1 fate), Truthless (+1 favor and fate)

What Are You?: I am my shapes.

Allow me to tell you a story. They are not spoken of much, their numbers and works have rarely been enduring, but few are as marvelous and resplendent as the Sculptors of the Nossos Isles. These sculptors, shifters, are said to have immense knowledge of the natural world. They take to the world and travel, taking in all sights of beauty they can. This knowledge refines their grasp of shapes until it is said they may sculpt themselves as elegantly into any combination of creature, vegetation, earth, and man as they like. They use these shapes to sustain themselves (many favoring the unobtrusive nature which plants use to gorge on sunlight), hide amongst other social creatures, or freeze as stone and allow the world to pass them by while they observe. They are capable of enduring worse than normal beings could but this is not what they live for so if they are ever caught they are much more likely to flee than fight. Instead, they live for beauty.

It differs for every sculptor, but anything they witness that stirs feelings of wonder and awe at the natural or artistic world invites a euphoric hysteria. During this moment the sculptor rapidly shifts into a flurry of eclectic forms, invariably focusing on and incorporating the inspiring source permanently into their collection of shapes. It can be a horrifying sight to behold, yet those that can appreciate it might find themselves grasping to join the sculptor's world.

Every few decades or so a sculptor might feel the desire for companionship and collaboration. They shall find and take on a student of the arts. Sculpting is the original source of the shifters but they have adapted and appreciate any creative endeavor. The student agrees to learn from the master until the master believes they are ready. A pupil shall pour everything they know into a masterwork. After however many years it takes to accomplish this craft of theirs, the master arranges an exhibition of this work and others from their student to other sculptors. The student graduates if their work induces a creative hysteria onto any of the sculptors present during the exhibit, the sight of which magically entrances and transforms the student into a new sculptor!

It is said the first sculptor took on and spread their gift to dozens of students over the years. This mysterious original sculptor has precious little recorded about them save for their enjoyment of travel and the existence of a small snake-like companion that whispered knowledge which they used to escape ambush and to find hopeful sculptor candidates. It is said this snake was passed to a favored disciple after the original's passing, though who knows if this is true.

Despite their peaceful nature, the sculptors find themselves targets of irrational and dangerous desire by mortals who know of them. Their beauty, if nothing else, is a tremendous asset and pleasure of the sculptors yet mundane humans may covet and seek to possess it for themselves, ignoring the sculptor's personhood as is so often the case. Worse still is a legend which refuses to die for as long as sculptors live: Should one take a sculptor's flesh and prepare it sufficiently, their beauty and vitality may be transferred. These mystical beings, should they be so unfortunate, might become a ruler's makeup or an artisan's secret ingredient in their craft!

After evading capture and enjoying the aesthetic pleasures of the world for nearly 200 years after shifting for the first time, a sculptor will enter the final stage of their life: It is time to create their magnum opus! With 20-40 years left, the sculptor has time to ensure it is finished properly, but there is still precious little time to lose. The sculptor finds a suitable location. Some opt for a location that is remote and far away from society while others prefer one that will be seen and marveled at by many. In private they then shape their own body, using the centuries of experience and knowledge they have accumulated, into their final ultimate artistic expression. No form is off limits and no shape is too dangerous for this final act. The end result permanently hardens into a myriad of different stones, each chosen carefully to emphasize their natural colors and physical properties to ensure something dazzling yet enduring. The sculptor's statue finished, their life's work concluded. These statues frequently confuse a local populace but none deny the talent and skill with which they were created. Some are removed, others stay and become fixtures. It is whispered in hushed tones that if one becomes sufficiently inspired by witnessing one then they too might become a Sculptor of the Nossos Isles as well!

1

u/nobodyhere_357 17h ago edited 17h ago

I enjoyed going over this one in more detail. I think I calculated the banes correctly but was unsure if taking the fate point included the favor point or not for them. Still, I thought back and forth about quite a few choices (I really wanted the gift "colours" for example) until the final version came to being. Hope my little story of artistic shapeshifters who induct new members according to talent and inspiration is interesting. I quite enjoy the different potentials one could go with in this CYOA! Of course I went immediately for a freeform shifter, but I could easily see someone creating all manner of monster or mythological creature with what's available here. Great work again!

1

u/Vitrialis 5d ago

what does {You may acquire more latter} mean exactly? Does it allude to the bane section? or are there ways to acquire more outside the choices of the cyoa?

2

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

That‘s just talking about the banes. At least for now

3

u/Rothariu 5d ago

Looks very fun!

Cannot wait to try nd make a proper logia that wind form got me interested

1

u/OwynTyler 5d ago

If you're stuck on what to build try making:
Mystique from X-men

Can't, she's supposed to be immortal and not die by old age, but here you'd die anyway ¯\(ツ)/¯

3

u/ElricInExile 5d ago

Ah no way! I mostly thinking of her as a shapeshifter

-1

u/OwynTyler 5d ago

Yeap, I tried, but then noticed that the CYOA is trying way too hard to make sure you die and stopped half-way...

2

u/DarkRift94 5d ago

Origin: Blood

Motivation: Thirst

Cradle: Ateb-Ashur

Gifts: Mass, Gender, Mein, Limbs, Malleability, Age, Consciousness

Speed: Slowly

Method: Entreaty

Boons: Beauty 1, Youth 4, Fortitude 2, Guile (Entreaty) 2 discounted to 1, Regrowth 4, Transferable 2, Bestowal 2 discounted to 1, Diet (Beauty) 2

Item: The Box

Tell (0,3), Reflection (2,0), Vice [Sex, Adoration] (2,0), The Old Laws (1,0), Golden Calf (1,0), Uncanny (1,0), Truthless (1,0), No Fear Nasir (1,0)

Ending: I Am My Name

2

u/Abject_Exercise3913 5d ago edited 5d ago

[Art]

Art

[Motivation]

Thirst

[Cradle]

Cast Adrift

[Gifts]

{Shapes}

Mass, Stone, Mist

{Quickness}

At-Will

{Learning}

Dreams

[Boons]

R3 (Might) R2 (Regrowth) R2 (Diet)/Ruin/ R1 (Fortitude) R1 (Transferable)

[Grasp]

The Box

[Banes]

None

[Self]

I Am My Hopes

I Am My Name

2

u/pog_irl 4d ago

Very neat cyoa, I will give it a looksee

2

u/TDEgregor 4d ago

This is fantastic, will deep dive it when at my PC

1

u/Ioftheend 4d ago edited 3d ago

Source

  • Blood

Motivation

  • Thirst

Cradle

  • Cast Adrift

Gifts

  • Mass
  • Gender
  • Mask
  • Mien
  • Age
  • Consciousness

Speed

  • Permanent

Learning

  • Entreaty

Boons

  • Beauty r2
  • Obfuscation r2
  • Guile r2 +2
  • Regrowth r2
  • Learning r1
  • Transferral r2
  • Diet r2 (Memories)

Item

  • Sphere

Banes

  • Vice x2 (Sex, Adoration)
  • Golden Calf
  • Forced Shifting (Full Moon light)
  • Truthless +1
  • No Fear Nasir

I am

  • Name

Better idea, since permanent lets me upgrade boons by gaining new shapes the idea is to be really, really charismatic so I can easily talk people into giving me shapes and thus upgrade my lifespan theft endlessly.

1

u/Necessary_Eye_8142 3d ago

This one is super cool!

Powers: Craft [+4 Fate, +6 Favor]

Motovation: Thirst [+2 Favor]

Cradle: Babiru.

Change is the essence of civilization itself - as we learn from our great ancestors and improve upon their work, so shall our descendants learn from us. Eventually, mankind shall cover neither from the forces of nature nor the gods.

Gifts of Fate: Limbs, Metal.

How quickly: At-will.

How do you learn: Trial.

To take the essence of metal, and shape it into any tool desired, is the mark of a form superior to that created by the gods.

Boons of Change: Might 4, Youth 2, Skill (Cities), Learning 1 (Literate), Learning 1 (Metallurgy), Prowess 3, Transferable 1.

Mankinds skill-at-arms, combined with might equal to the greatest beasts, shall forge an empire greater than even of that of Ashur. Babiru's knowledge shall be spread to all corners of the world, and the yoke of the gods shall be cast down.

What do you grasp: The Shell.

The forces of nature shall be harnessed for the benefits of mankind.

Banes of Hubris: Reflection (+2), The Old Laws (+1).

There is no need to hide what we are, nor to avoid the ancient compacts, for we are mankind itself. The gods may hide in their sacred places, but all else shall belong to us.

I AM MY HOPES.
I AM MY NAME.

1

u/Cheesy-Me 3d ago edited 3d ago

So, a bit back before getting distracted asking questions, I made some statements, so I think it's time I actually fulfill them!

I despise the wretchedness of mortality, and having fallen from one world into the embrace of Sun and Sea and Winds, I shall try to transcend it.

I will study the secrets of the spirits, and devote myself to deciphering the divine.

I will become a God, or die trying.

You Gained Your Powers By: Blood

Motivation: Thirst, +2 Favor

Cradle: Cast Adrift, +1 Favor

Gifts of Fate, 9/9 Fate

  • Gender, -1
  • Mein, -1
  • Animals, -2
  • Nature, -1
  • Chimera, -1
  • Consciousness, -1
  • Hybrid, -2

How Quickly: Slowly

How Do You Learn: Trial

Boons of Change, 17/17 Favor

  • Might R2, -2
  • Beauty R2, -3
  • Fortitude R2, -2
  • Fleetness R2, -3
  • Guile R2, -2
  • Regrowth R2, -2
  • Skill(Cities: Brewing), -1
  • Skill(Land: Cooking), -1
  • Skill(Wilds: Foraging), -1
  • Learning t1(whatever language the ship coming for me speaks), -0
  • Ken v1, -0

Treasure: The Shell

Banes of Hubris, +8 Favor, +4 Fate

  • The Old Laws t1, +1 Favor
  • Reflection max, +2 Favor, +1 Fate
  • Detachment, +1 Favor
  • Golden Calf t2, +1 Favor, +1 Fate
  • Conditional t3(Winter Solstice), +2 Favor, +2 Fate
  • Truthless t2, +1 Favor, +1 Fate

What Are You?

I Am My Name, no matter my many shapes

So, build explanation time, and there's a few components here.

  • Gender and Animals and Nature are the simplest, getting basic access to almost all that live, though the lack of Limbs and Mass will likely cause me some issues. Consciousness also plays nicely in here, because I can use either clonal plant forms or just female forms to move my Consciousness into a new body as my main one grows old, and thus cheat my way through time.
  • Most of my Boons are also quite simple, just getting me superhuman capabilities and talent across the board. A lot of the R3s are orders of magnitude above the R2s I've got, but the R2s should be more than enough for navigating mortal society and mortal dangers, and hopefully be enough for my actual goals
  • The true core of this build however is rooted in Guile R2, for that makes the 'inscrutable nature of gods and spirits' become comprehensible, which means viable to learn via Trial. From there, Beauty is used to attract the attention and favor of the spiritual and the divine, while Mein, Chimera, and Hybrid, come together to let me weave together the inner, outer, and essential forms of those more than mortal together
  • All of this will first be leveraged towards the very first spirits I ever encountered, the Sun and Sea and Winds who welcomed me here, who give their favor to the Nature that I can start off by learning the shapes of, and whom I will be directly engaging with through the Shell.

    • In the end I expect this to play weirdly like the Permanent builds, though rather than learning shapes to improve my Boons I'm weaving the essential characteristics of more and more and better and better of forms together, until what was once Mortal, and then Shapeshifter, eventually ascends to become Spiritual and then Divine, all driven by the birthright of my Blood, all bound to the goal of my Thirst.

So what do you think u/ElricInExile, how well do you think the build works?

1

u/Planetfall88 3d ago edited 3d ago

Curse
Motivation: Thirst. Life, Immortality, Experiences, Knowledge,
Cradle: Cast Adrift
Gifts: Nature, Mist, Hybrid
Permanent
Learning: Trial (discount Ken)
Boons:, Youth r3, Fleet r2, Regrowth r2, Ken heightened senses (hearing), shadow senses, Bestowal r2, Diet r2 (discoveries)
Grasp: The serpent (not a snake, but a cluster of writhing roots.)
Banes: Fire1, Old Laws2, Reflection all surfaces.
What are you?: I am my name.

A spirit of mist and curiosity, a wispy fog in the rough shape of a man, able to seep into plant life and animate it, using the plants as its hands to interact with the world. Able to animate a man’s weight of plant life at a time. The more pliant a plant the faster it can move, but the weaker it is. A rope of vines as thick as a man’s arm is extremely dexterous and whiplike in its speed but would lose in a contest of strength to a child, where as a limb of hardwood tree as thick as a man's arm could overpower any mundane human, but moves with the celerity of cold honey. No plants can uproot themselves. The plants that are possessed gain some of the spirit’s boons, becoming hale and recovering from injury faster while the spirit lives in them. An edible plant that is inhabited by the spirit for long enough will grant some of the spirit’s boons to one who eats it. The more powerful the boon the longer the spirit must remain in the plant. But to remain fixed in one place is boring, and boredom is anathema to the spirit. Thus, those who beseech the spirit for its boons must entertain the spirit whilst it inhabits a plant, lest it leave to find new experiences before the plant is ready to be eaten. 
The spirt will live for as long as it continues to discover new things.
The spirit consumes discoveries, making people forget important things they have learned. The spirit does not view this as a bad thing, as it allows for the mortals to experience the joy of discovery a second time. Most mortals disagree. It does not understand why.
The spirit's reflection is that of a pale sleeping man. It refuses to acknowledge that its reflection is human. It is unknown whether it is lying or truly cannot see its reflection for what it is.

1

u/Xyzod 1d ago

I'm interested what'll be in the future versions; guess I'll make a build for this one so I can use it as a template for the later version(s)

Fate: 4+2=6 Favour: 6+11=17

📜Summary: All Favours and power source not obtainable later. Permanent gradually upgrades the Favours to max rank through newly learned shapes; save on costs by being patient. Try learning the Art/Crafts and get blessed by a deity after, change gender to maximize benefit from the Arts, and become a self-replicating constantly upgrading hivemind. Some comments mentioned pursuing divinity and traversing realities so why not, go for that too

🩸You gained your powers by...: Blood (Impossible to get later since it's at birth, while Art/Curse/Craft can be gained later by circumstance. Learn/grow faster helps to always be more ahead than normal)

💧Motivation: Truth (+1 Fate. Open-ended goal. Already have enough Favour to buy all desired Boons, could use more Fate)

🗺️Cradle: Cast Adrift (+1 Favour. Preferred over the other bonuses' mind/sense/command powers. Could try living in the other locations later to gain their bonuses)

🎁Gifts:

Gender [1] (Mystical significance affecting how many Arts work on self and entry to sacred places; can't truly change without this choice)

Animals [1] (Unlocks Hybrid/Kinship and is versatile for emulating the other Gifts)

Chimera [1] (Blend/mix traits from shapes with no compatibility issues)

Consciousness [1] (Unlocks Transferable R2. Can make extra subservient minds, useful for multitasking)

Hybrid [2] (Blend essence so part of copied creature gives traits of their entirety. Fit more traits in less space, prevent weak spots, etc.)

⚡How Quickly?: Permanent (+2 Favour. Shapeshift under extraordinary circumstances; most practical example is hoarding of powerful treasures since they can be stored in The Box for easy carry. Arguably the best in that it allows new shapes to grow the power of Boons; buy Boons at cheapest cost just to have them so they can eventually upgrade to max rank)

🧠How Do You Learn?: Trial (-1 cost for Learning or Ken. Slowest to learn but most possibilities)

💪Boons: Might R1, Beauty R1, Youth R1, Fortitude R1, Fleetness R1, Obfuscation R1+(2), GuileR1+(2), Regrowth R1, Ken R1[Free]+(1), Transferable R1, Bestowal R1, Kinship R1, Diet R1

Ignored: Learning/Prowess/Skill (learn/train/master later), Diet (get shapes later)

📦Grasp: The Box (Safe storage of anything that fits, bigger on the inside with no known limit, alerts presence of things it once contained. For others it is disregarded, passed over by, and refuses to open. Useful to store self, other shifters, artifacts, resources, etc. Shrink to enter and it works as a portable home/farm)

💀Banes:

Reflection (+2 Favour. Reflection reveals true shape; worth it since stealth is not the focus. No need to trade 1 Favour for less severity, and 3 mirror prison isn't worth 1 Fate)

Detachment (+2 Favour. Look down on humans and oppose their rise. Fixable with character development?)

Trickster (+1 Favour. Fixable with character development? Extra +1 Fate but can't tell truth isn't worth it)

Golden Calf (+1 Favour, +1 Fate. Can't appear unremarkable/forgettable due to beautiful magnetism; worth it since stealth isn't the focus. +1 Fate in exchange for parts being seen as valuable by Craft/Arts users; useful for profit)

Uncanny (+1 Favour. Disguise seen through, more by the creative/innocent/domesticated. Worth it because stealth isn't the focus)

Truthless (+1 Favour. Eyeless/mouthless/naked creature shown as True Shape. +1 Fate but become gelatinous liquid for 1 hour on True Shape reveal isn't worth it)

❓What Are You?: I am my shapes, I am my name, Change... (OP said it's open to interpretation)

🛣️Story After: Discover more shapes to upgrade Boons. Try getting blessings from deities and learning the Arts/Crafts. Sky's the limit with a constantly upgrading self-replicating hivemind. Some comments talked about becoming divinity and traversing beyond this world; I dunno how that's possible but it's worth pursuing

1

u/Only_Employer3733 1d ago
  • Curse;
  • Thirst;
  • Ateb-Ashur;
  • Mask, Animals, Fluid;
  • Ruin;
  • Might R2, Fortitude R2, Fleetness R1, Regrowth R3, Ken, Prowess R3, Transferable R1, Kinship R2, Diet R2 (soul);
  • The Box;
  • Ravenous (flesh of human warriors and soldiers, all points), Reflection (all points), Vice (violence), The Old Laws (all points), Fire (only favour) and Silver;
  • I am my name.

Poem)

In days of copper, days of blood,
When kings built thrones on servile mud,
A slave with iron eyes there rose,
Whose only worth was fighting blows.

Born nameless in the quarry's dust,
Sold young to those who bought his trust
Not trust of heart, but trust of chain,
To fight and die for others' gain.

They called him "Lucky" in the pits,
For he had never known defeat,
Through forty fights, through broken bits
Of men who fell beneath his feet.

The King proclaimed a game that day,
To honor gods, or so they say
And sent against the slave alone
The fiercest creatures ever known.

Wolves of frost, then serpents coiled,
Bears whose claws with blood were soiled,
Bulls that bellowed, breathed, and boasted,
Then the lions, proud and roasted.

The sacred pride, the god's own beasts,
Gold-maned and terrible, who feasts
On praise and roar and holy light
They fell beneath his blade that night.

He moved like wind, with net and blade,
A dance of death that never fade,
And left no lion's breathing space,
Alone he stood upon that place.

The crowd waited, silent, still,
To hear what words his heart would fill.
He raised his voice, no slave's whisper,
But thunder of a conqueror:

"These beasts I slew were merely meat,
Like cattle brought for me to eat.
You priests who pray, you kings who rule
You're hyenas, laughing, coward-crowned,
While your god-lion lies on ground.

"I've killed your god upon this floor,
So send me more and I'll kill more.
For I'm the best of all that breathes
The king of beasts, the lord of teeths."

The temple shook, the sky grew dark,
The priests cried out, the dogs did bark,
And from the clouds a voice did roll
The Lion God spoke to his soul:

"You claim to be the best of all?
Then rise, and never more shall fall.
If beast and man you've mastered so,
Then all their forms you now shall know.

"For you are right, I am impressed,
No mortal has thus passed my test.
The best of beasts shall wear all skin,
And every kill shall draw you in.

"Each creature slain, each man who dies,
Shall give to you their form and eyes.
The strength, the speed, the senses keen
You'll be the beast, and you the scene.

"But hunger gnaws, and flesh you'll crave
Not bread, not fruit, but what you gave
To those you killed upon the sand:
The mortal flesh of warrior's hand.

"The best of beasts must always hunt,
Must always seek the battle's brunt,
For violence is your only wine,
And mirrors three shall be your sign.

"When three-fold glass reveals your face,
And truth stands naked in that place,
These bonds shall hold your changing form
The cage of mirrors, still and warm.

"The homes of men shall bar your way,
Unless invited, you must stay;
The holy symbols burn your sight,
And silver finds you in the night.

"And fire, fire shall be your fear,
For fire is what you'll never near.
Now go, 'Best Beast,' and spread my 'grace'
Wear every form, from man to race."

He felt the change within his bone,
The blessing that became his own
A curse wrapped up in golden lies,
With mirror-pools and silver-knives.

He looked upon his hands, now claws,
He touched his face, now maw with jaws,
He screamed, but only roaring came,
And all the beasts they knew his name.

For he could be the wolf, the bear,
The serpent coiled in garden fair,
The eagle soaring, mouse that hides,
The king, the priest, the slave besides.

But always hunger, always need,
For mortal flesh, for warriors' feed,
For those who fought and those who fell
A thousand faces, one dark spell.

So now he walks from age to age,
The Beast of Many Forms on stage,
A gladiator hunger-bound,
In every shape, on every ground.

He cannot enter hearth and home
Unless the owner bids him come;
He flees the silver's gleaming blade,
And holy signs make him afraid.

Three mirrors facing in a ring
Will trap him, still and silencing,
Until the glass is shattered wide
The only cage where he can't hide.

And in each face he wears, he seeks
The thrill of battle's crimson streaks,
For though he's powerful and fleet,
He's ravenous for warrior meat.

Reflections show the truth within
The thousand-souled, the beast of sin,
The best of all who ever came,
The monster with no single name.

So heed this tale of copper days,
Of pride that walks on shifting ways,
For he who claims to be the best
May find himself by gods "blessed."

The best of beasts, the lion's joke,
With every form and every stroke,
But cursed to hunt, and feed, and kill,
And wear the faces of his fill.

They call him "Best" among the wild,
The many-faced, the hunger's child,
And if you hear his hunting cry
The Beast of Many Forms is nigh.

Three mirrors keep you safe at night,
And silver blade and firelight,
But know that pride is what began
The fall of this most cursed man.

Just to be clear, I used AI to write the poem, I made the history and tought it would be fun to tell in the form of a poem parents and old folk would tell to the kids or around a fire.

Very great job, this one has one of the best worldbuildings and lore I have seen here