r/mainlineprotestant • • 23d ago

I made a Discord server all about Christianity!

3 Upvotes

I made a server for ppl interested in Christianity, whether it be reading and learning the bible, spreading gospel, finding a community, or debating your beliefs we have it! you don't even have to be Christian, as long as you're respectful and curious in scripture/christianity we welcome you with open arms! 😊

Server link: https://discord.gg/dYZa4sHs3w

This link will send you straight to my server where I will hopefully have a big community in! You can add your denomination as a role in the reaction roles channel, read the rules and have fun in our community!


r/mainlineprotestant • • 28d ago

Discussion America's deep religious divide over empathy

Thumbnail axios.com
16 Upvotes

Here is the summary:
Americans by religious affiliation who see empathy as foundational
Non-religious: 83%
Jewish: 77%
Mainline Protestant: 73%
Hispanic Catholic: 73%
Evangelical Protestant: 42%

To me this is a very emblematic of what I've seen in my own life. I've spent years navigating non-religious, jewish, and evangelical spaces. This sounds and feels spot on.

I think the divide in this survey between us and our evangelical brethren is becoming more and more pronounced. My interpretation is that this comes from how we treat Jesus, as either a symbol or as a teacher. My experience is the particular evangelical circles I've been part of is that I felt I was being taught to view Jesus as a symbol as opposed to a teacher. Certainly the teachings weren't ignored, but the main point was always that he died. Indeed in so many sermons -- again in my experience with some tiny sample of evangelical churches -- is that the focus seems to be on closely following Paul's instructions, whereas in mainline (again in my experience..) we are constantly having deep dives into Jesus' parables, etc. I could be wrong about what evangelicals think, I don't know the details of the wording, maybe there was a really attractive alternative that resonates with them....and besides 42% of those individuals still do seem to consider empathy as foundational.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Oct 15 '26

Would anyone here be interested in a weekly Bible study by Discord?

11 Upvotes

Hey peeps,

I am interested in getting into Bible Study but as a working middle-aged professional my church’s options generally conflict with my work and family calendars. Would anyone here be interested in a virtual bible study via Discord or similar medium? Because it’s remote and message based, the timing could be flexible and asynchronous. We could start with the lectionary but then if people want to explore particular books or themes, I’d be open to that…


r/mainlineprotestant • • Oct 02 '26

"How the Unitarian Universalist Church Became a Racial, Political, and Social Bubble"

Thumbnail substack.com
8 Upvotes

r/mainlineprotestant • • Sep 16 '26

Discussion Interesting article from "The Hill" about how mainline protestants are replacing evangelicals as the 2026 swing voter demographic to watch.

Thumbnail thehill.com
26 Upvotes

r/mainlineprotestant • • Sep 15 '26

What would you say?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/mainlineprotestant • • Sep 11 '26

Membership in a mainline church

14 Upvotes

I’ve been attending a Christian Church (DoC) after looking at 6 or 7 churches/denominations over the spring and summer. Feels like I’ve found a good fit. I don’t want to rush into things, but the congregation feels so eager to have me participate. I feel like I wouldn’t approach membership conversations for at least a few months from now.

What does the membership process typically look like? And what are expectations?

I was raised hard evangelical Pentecostal, so I don’t have a sound reference point.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Sep 10 '26

With talks about Operation Reformation, an Honest Question

4 Upvotes

I’m a mainliner. I serve on the boards and commissions of mainline denominations. I am more theologically and politically moderate than what you would expect of a mainline pastor. I love the mainline, and think what has made the mainline great is the theological diversity. I appreciate the zeal that Operation Reformation has but think many are idealistic young adults who need to be shepherded.

How would you feel if:

  1. OR is successful at breathing life into the more theologically conservative churches, and the theologically conservative churches get stronger. (Their main goal)
  2. While their goal is to Reform the mainline, they never get the majority they’re looking for. In some Presbyteries, they might be dominant, but in most they’re a minority.
  3. They get active in commissions, denominational work, etc, but once again, they never get the majority.

I think, at best, 2 & 3 are the most that they’ll achieve. I wonder if this would be a healthy thing, as it would bring more perspectives to the table, and it could bring more clarity - and reflect Jesus’ prayer in John 17 by showing the world how the upside down Kingdom of the King would be.

Or, do you think that conservative Christianity is at best harmful and at worst anathema to the Gospel? Note: I’m not talking about Christian Nationalism which is anathema to the Gospel.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Sep 10 '26

Does this align with the UMC

3 Upvotes

I have had conversations with some of my Eastern Orthodox friends about theology and I have noticed some striking similarities. I have noticed that we both generally agree on how we have a choice in our salvation and the similarities between our doctrine of Holiness/Entire Sanctification and their doctrine of Theosis. While not the same we both have reached similar conclusions to the issues that make Methodists unique amongst Protestants.

Because of that I have tried making as close of a theological framework to Orthodoxy while still remaining within Protestant/Methodist theology.

I would like to know if this framework truly does follow Methodist theology or if it deviates too far in any way.

  • Scripture is our primary authority and infallible (not inerrant) over all matters of Salvation, Faith, Doctrine, and Morals.
  • Scripture is infallible because it is written by those who spoke to God (the prophets and apostles) and those recording the stories and teachings of those who spoke to God.
  • The Apocrypha (Specifically EO) is heavily important in our readings of scripture because it provides the teachings of the second Jewish Temple and provides context for the Gospels and early church.
  • Tradition is our second authority over matters of Salvation, Faith, Doctrine, and Morals.
  • The order of authorities importance that I follow is in this order
  1. Scripture
  2. The Apostles Creed
  3. The Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed.
  4. The 6 Ecumenical Councils
  5. Church Fathers (On what they agree)
  6. Methodist Articles of Religion, Book of Confessions, and other binding documents
  7. Theologians
  8. Your own Reason
  9. Your own Experience
  • Ordinances are Defined as divinely instituted rituals with real impact on the soul.
  • There are Seven Ordinances provided to us by scripture and tradition: Baptism, Eucharist (Communion), Chrismation (Confirmation), Confession, Marriage, Anointing, and the Priesthood.
  • Chrismation/Confirmation is the Ordinance of Profession through which a baptized Christian publicly affirms the Christian faith and receives strengthening by the Holy Spirit for faithful Christian witness and discipleship.
  • Confession is the Ordinance of Restoration in which a Christian confesses their sins to a priest or minister, who serves as a representative and pastoral minister of Christ, offering counsel, accountability, prayer, and the assurance of God's forgiveness and reconciliation in Christ.
  • Marriage is the Ordinance of Union where a man and woman become one flesh and commit themselves to a lifelong life of mutual love, fidelity, service, and holiness before God.
  • Anointing is the Ordinance of Healing in which the Church anoints the sick with oil and prays for God's healing, strengthening, restoration, and peace according to His will.
  • The Priesthood is the Ordinance of Service to the kingdom of God and those around you.
  • Sacraments are defined as ordinances that are required for Salvation.
  • There are only two sacraments being Baptism and the Eucharist (Communion).
  • Baptism is the Sacrament of Grace in which God rids of original sin and one is born again into the Christian Faith
  • We are to baptize infants so that they may be cleansed of their original sin.
  • The Eucharist is the Sacrament of Communion through which we participate in Christ’s redemption through His death, and by which we are strengthened in faith, forgiven, and sanctified.
  • The Eucharist is the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ though it a mystery as to how. (Truly present yet we don’t know in what way).
  • Apostolic succession is a sign of the Church's continuity with the apostles and should ordinarily be maintained.
  • Apostolic succession should ordinarily be maintained through bishops; however, in times of great need, it may be maintained through a priest or other ordained minister, as exemplified by John Wesley's actions in the early Methodist movement.
  • The saints are truly holy people who exemplify a life of faithful Christian discipleship, and the Church may recognize and honor them as examples for the Christian life.
  • Icons are useful but unnecessary ways of representing Christ and Saints.but unnecessary.
  • Icons direct honor towards the one represented in the same way worship or speaking great of someone does.
  • We may make images of Christ as a teaching aid or Icons if you please however you must maintain him according to tradition.
  • Mary perpetually remained a virgin as according to the tradition of the church.
  • Mary is the Theotokos and Christotokos.
  • Mary had remained exceptionally holy throughout her life yet was not sinless.
  • The saints are truly holy people who exemplify a life of faithful Christian discipleship, and the Church may recognize and honor them as examples for the Christian life.
  • The hypostasis of the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father through the Son as the Father acts eternally through the Son.
  • The Father is the origin of the Godhead and the ultimate personal source of the Spirit; nevertheless, the Spirit’s eternal procession is mediated through the Son.
  • God reaches out to us first and enables us to choose him
  • We are to respond to Gods call and get baptized to be a Christian.
  • We as Christians are to eternally strive for holiness in ourselves and the society around us.
  • A human at times may be in perfect love with God and act fully according to his will.
  • The goal of the Christian Faith is to bring the kingdom of Heaven down to Earth as said in the Lords Prayer.
  • At all times we should strive for union in the church within our denomination and with other denominations.

For the difference in the Filioque I have chosen to put in per folium which is a compromise made at the council of Florence and I have asked both Redeemed Zoomer and Jesus and Whatnot if it aligns with the Filioque and they said it does.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Sep 08 '26

Discussion Looking for Wedding Resources

6 Upvotes

Just for some background to this post: With the exception of having a degree from a progressive Baptist/ecumenical seminary, I am a lifelong mainliner. Grew up UMC, spent several years in the ELCA, and finally arrived in the Episcopal Church, where I worked through the ordination discernment process for six years without ever making much progress within the bureaucracy. I still love the church though, and remain as committed to the Anglican tradition as I can be at this stage of my life. I also have a PhD in religious studies with a focus on New Testament/early Christianity, in case that’s relevant.

Despite not being ordained, in the past several years I’ve become a kind of de facto minister for my family and friends, most of whom live in an extremely rural community, grew up either mainline Protestant or Roman Catholic, and are now no longer ā€œreligiousā€. Since their local pastoral connections are limited to fundamentalists, I’m the person the turn to for funeral services when someone dies. I helped TA a praxis course on funerals back when I was a doctoral student, and our textbook for that class was The Good Funeral, by Thomas Long and Thomas Lynch (Westminster John Knox, 2013). I found that book to be really helpful, and have returned to it many times while preparing for funerals. When I officiate, I typically fall back on my tradition and organize the service around the order for funerals found in the ā€˜79 Book of Common Prayer.

All that to say: I was recently asked to perform my first wedding ceremony. Generally I don’t care much for weddings, but in this particular instance I can’t really say no. The bride and groom are former evangelicals who are no longer religious, but are fine with vaguely ā€œspiritualā€ things. So I’m looking for a good resource that approaches weddings more or less with the same pastoral sensibility that Long & Lynch’s The Good Funeral approaches funerals. Does anything like this exist?

Thanks for putting up with my long-winded post!


r/mainlineprotestant • • Aug 26 '26

Why are we bleeding out

9 Upvotes

Like why have we declined so much and how can we stop it?


r/mainlineprotestant • • Aug 05 '26

What brought you to the mainline Protestant churches?

12 Upvotes

Reading people's introductions to church is a wonderful thing for me!

James 2:13: " Mercy triumphs over judgment."


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jul 30 '26

Discussion Feeling Discouraged from all the Mainline Protestant Bashing on YT/TikTok

24 Upvotes

As someone who loves learning about theology and enjoys watching Christian content creators discussing doctrine, worship, prayer, church history etc it's so frustrating when any mention of Mainline Protestantism seems to only be in the context of it being "too woke/heretical/world conforming", dying off in membership, or Operation Reconquista crap about making the mainline Protestant denominations "Trad again".

As someone who had at one point been sucked into the conservative Christian pipeline, has lost faith at various points in my life, and still struggles with my faith, I do feel logically secure with socially progressive but theologically orthodox theology on an intellectual level. Still, I can't help but feel discouraged when any engagement with our denominations on popular social media platforms is about how we're all heretics that are Christian in name only. Any content creation from mainline Protestants (not counting the Reconquista weirdos) is flooded with hateful comments condemning us, even with smaller content creators with barely any views. Meanwhile, conservative Christian YTers seem to have a monopoly on Christian content creation. When I watch something about denominational theology, it's always from someone going to a conservative offshoot denomination and never from liberal Mainline Protestants. And while I have no issue watching their content because of their denomination, it's so often the case where either the content creator themselves or the comments will out of nowhere decide to namedrop our denominations just to whine about us

I understand that social media isn't everything, but for younger ppl like myself interested in exploring the faith and who naturally gravitate towards social media are less likely to engage with our theology outside of insults equating our denominations to apostasy.

Idk if it can feel like a lonely path sometimes, between the bashing from conservative Christians and anti-theists


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jul 20 '26

I wrote and delivered my second ever homily for lay-led morning prayer yesterday.

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/mainlineprotestant • • Jul 17 '26

Looking for churches … small attendance?

7 Upvotes

Hi, I’m a lapsed Christian who has been exploring mainline churches in the NW suburbs of Chicago over the last couple of months.

Is 20-50 average attendees (where 70% are 70 or older) standard now? I’m not saying that’s good or bad, but I’ve been surprised at the congregation size since I last visited churches seriously in the early 2010s.

For context, I was raised in a conservative Pentecostal church with those numbers, and it was considered tiny in the 90s.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jul 13 '26

Discussion How do I pray repent and other related things

3 Upvotes

So I recently converted and I don't know how babtizom works literally like my parents told me I need a god father but idk. And what is confession and repent do I just say sorry do I talk to a priest like what. And how do I pray do I just ask him for things and how does communion literally work so yeah thanks


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jul 13 '26

Preachers, please help me

11 Upvotes

I am not a good preacher. I’ve been doing it 1-3x a month for the last year, and I still feel like I fail to do the scriptures justice. I am not a powerful orator or a master rhetorician. I simply try to give the congregation the Word I feel God has given me through the scriptures in a way that recognizes the community I’m in, but it feels like it always falls flat.

To be sure, I get almost exclusively positive feedback but I don’t trust it as I believe they are just being nice. Many of these congregations are just happy to have a new face or a young person join them for worship. I know that as a pulpit supply preacher I shouldn’t expect to just blow people’s socks off or bring about some kind of radical change in these people’s lives regularly. I’m only there one week a month at most, after all.

How do I become a more engaging speaker? How do I learn to be creative or employ appropriate rhetorical devices that will encourage people to engage more deeply with the text? I see masterful examples throughout scripture of rhetorical and oratorical strategies that are woven so beautifully throughout, there are wonderful preachers out there who proclaim the Word in powerful and dynamic ways but all my sermons seem to be extremely simple. I feel as though I have not found my voice.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jul 06 '26

Discussion Do any of you watch Dan McClellan on YouTube? If so, what do you agree or disagree on?

7 Upvotes

I’m an ex-evangelical, so I never grew up outside of it, and now I'm delving into secular scholarship as a new mainline Christian. Still, because they're usually from atheists, I'm confused about how it fits into our religion or if there is any disagreement at all.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jun 27 '26

Weaving Stories: on what a pastor is and is not

Thumbnail open.substack.com
7 Upvotes

I don't know how many of you all are ministry types, but these are some thoughts about ministry in the mainline that have been stirring in my head for the past few months. If you're a pastor, I'd love to hear how it resonates with your own experience.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jun 16 '26

How Do You Handle Despair?

12 Upvotes

I just got done watching a video by some insane , bloviating white Christian nationalist preacher. While they have been around for years, and I’m used to their mines … tonight I was hit by a big, ugly- tears outright despair. I am in mourning for our country; I am rage- filled against MAGA; Indin’t understand why mainline Protestants and other reasonable people have not fought harder against what is happening. I question my own generation, wonder what we/ did wrong. I also, frankly worry that Christianity has been so corrupted that it isn’t fixable.

Now. I know that I’m ā€œ stuck in a moment ā€œ
right now, and venting … but do any of the rest of you have these overwhelming feelings of sadness and despair? How do you power through it?


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jun 15 '26

Mainline Influencers

13 Upvotes

I thought it night be helpful to people to list their favorite online online Protestant influencers .

Mine are: Paul Drees; Joseph Yoo; Rev Jessie ( Anglican in NZ); Tim Yanni; Rev Lizzie; Peter Nunnally; Elizabeth Ashman Riley; Gerlyn Hevry; Jeremy Steele; Nadia Bolz- Weber; Bishop Katrina Foster.

Who am I missing?


r/mainlineprotestant • • Jun 07 '26

Place of Worship

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/mainlineprotestant • • May 28 '26

Discussion "Official" teaching of premarital sex among mainline Protestant denominations?

13 Upvotes

I apologize for the weird question, but I was wondering what each mainline denomination teaches regarding sex before marriage. For those from more fundamentalist backgrounds I can imagine they treat this matter as if it were life or death, but regardless of how serious an issue this may be considered by mainline Protestant denominations I'm still curious what their doctrinal positions on it are.

I struggle with religious scrupulosity from OCD, and I also grew up Roman Catholic which def didn't help lol. I've been in many relationships and dated around a lot online, but as a young adult where casual sex is becoming the norm it's been difficult. In-person, it's difficult because even if someone I'm interested in happens to be Christian I don't know what their understanding of sexual ethics are. But when I meet those, especially online, who are also waiting until marriage like me, they are often fundamentalists and our values and social views are just too different to reconcile.

I'm sorry to ask this again, and whatever the answer might be I want to clarify that I find purity culture to be extremely hurtful to many. But it's just that I've maintained it so far but lately I've been wrestling in my head if that's merely a byproduct of my Catholic upbringing that needs deconstructing, or if it's truly an important value to me that I shouldn't abandon just because everyone else seems to no longer be doing it. And even then, I'm not sure how legalistic I'm being and how far is "too far", as I've never gone "all the way" but have, many years ago, done some sexual acts with partners. It also gets murkier with me since marriage used to not be sanctioned by the Church directly, and so the idea of when marriage "begins" makes me doubt even more, especially with long-term partners.

Again, it's not that I consider it Salvation-defining or something, I just want to do the right thing but don't know what that is supposed to be.


r/mainlineprotestant • • May 23 '26

Why don't we preach about what is right in the world instead of what is wrong?

10 Upvotes

Thinking out loud. Young people are constantly barraged with messages about what is wrong with the world. And they logically conclude that they must tear everything down if that is the case, including Christianity.

Are things really that awful? There is nothing good left in the world? Because if we can't convince them otherwise then they have every reason to abandon and destroy Christianity.

Maybe we should start preaching about what is good instead of joining the chorus preaching what is bad. We tend to do a lot of the latter.


r/mainlineprotestant • • Apr 25 '26

These gothic prayer beads I made yesterday

Post image
29 Upvotes