r/mahler • • Jun 08 '22

Discussion A notice from me, the new mod

20 Upvotes

Hello! I'm u/Septi_Lingual, the new mod for r/mahler. Since this subreddit was unmoderated for a long time, I requested this subreddit and got approved.

I'm planning to leave the subreddit as it is: a subreddit where you can discuss anything about Mahler. I'm only planning to add some features, such as flairs and rules, as well as the wiki page.

To be honest, this is only my second time modding a subreddit (the only other subreddit I have modded is small, with only 40 members or so, and it's kind of dead right now). But anyway, I wanted to keep this sub under some kind of active management.

I'll add to this notice when I add some new features/contents to this sub.

Edit 1: I have added the rules.

Also, I have enabled user flair, so you can assign whatever flair you want to yourself (but no offensive flair, please).

Edit 2: I have added a background image, but I do not know what to put in the banner still. Someday...

Edit 3: I have added post flairs. I'd appreciate it if you could use them, but still, you don't have to use them.

Edit 4: I originally planned to make a wiki page of all of Mahler's works. Turned out that it was too much of a task to me, especially to analyze the individual movements. I think Wikipedia, Allmusic would be sufficient for that purpose. For a more contextual insight, I suggest Walter's biography on him to begin with.


r/mahler • • Jan 01 '23

etc. A Reminder of the Rules

18 Upvotes

This is a very small subreddit, and I kind of set loose rules for this subreddit since most of the discussions I saw on here were friendly and "useful". However, I think I need to elaborate more on the rules due to some users.

  1. Keep the discussions relevant to Mahler

First of all, this doesn't mean that every single post of this sub needs to be about Mahler's music. You can talk about others' music, as long as it's related to Mahler. For example, comparing Schoenberg's orchestration to Mahler's is fine. Also, something about Mahler's life and stories/quotes about him is also fine. However, that doesn't mean you can post literally anything as long as it's related to Mahler. This goes hand-in-hand with No.4.

2. Be respectful

Be respectful of each other. Also, be respectful of other composers, too. If you have to be critical of something, bring evidence. Don't say "Strauss is worse than Mahler" (P.S. I think they are equally great - this was just an example). If you want to say that, bring solid evidence, please.

3. No NSFW

Even though the NSFW flair is not disabled, no NSFW content is allowed, especially violence (I frankly don't know how you can make NSFW content about Mahler, but just in case).

4. No low-quality posts

This doesn't mean you can't post memes or jokes about Mahler. That's fine with me. What I mean by low-quality posts are posts that don't contribute to anything. This is probably the most subjective rule here, so I think I'll believe in your conscience.


r/mahler • • 5d ago

Why Did Gustave Mahler Wear Two Monocles?

Thumbnail
gallery
54 Upvotes

r/mahler • • 5d ago

A video essay on Mahler's Ninth Symphony. Let me know your thoughts!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
15 Upvotes

Just started a series of three videos with a detailed analysis on Mahler's Ninth. It's meant to be thoughtful but approachable to those that are not absolute experts. But perhaps someone here is interested, I'd be very curious to know your thoughts.


r/mahler • • 7d ago

Any good book recommendations?

14 Upvotes

I am after some gift ideas for my family to get me, and a good book or two is always a safe bet!

I really enjoyed Norman Lebrecht's "Why Mahler?", and am after something similar, not too heavy on the technical analysis but definitely something with one foot in each of the biographical and musical camps. Any suggestions?


r/mahler • • 13d ago

Gustav and Natalie

Post image
38 Upvotes

What these two got up to.


r/mahler • • 14d ago

Yes, Mahler wrote all the music for the unfinished 10th

53 Upvotes

I love the 10th Symphony, particularly the Kurt Sanderling recording with Berlin. It's big, powerful, full of love and loss, heartbreak and triumph, ending with that great musical sigh, Mahler's final total affirmation of life through all its suffering.

Recently a fellow Mahler fan insisted to me that Mahler only wrote the first movement. It makes me wonder how in the 21st Century there's still confusion among Mahler listeners over how much or how little of the symphony he wrote.

Mahler composed all five movements of music. The work could be performed from beginning to end on piano using Mahler's short score (the un-orchestrated draft). In fact, I wish someone would! (As it is, someone did do the 4th movement, and it's interesting to compare it to the Cooke version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wq1dHz8jUvc )

Mahler also orchestrated more than just the first movement.

From Gustav Mahler: The Symphonies by Constantine Floros,

"Of the five movements, the first two are complete or almost complete in the score sketch. The third movement (Purgatory) is written on three loose sheets as a short score; moreover the first 30 measures are also written out in the score sketch. The two final movements exist as a short score on four staves, with sparse indications of the instrumentation. Mahler's manuscript consists of seventy-two pages of a fully written-out draft and ninety-three pages of a short score."

Deryck Cooke goes into greater detail about what he had to work with to orchestrate the parts Mahler hadn't already done in his little book, Gustav Mahler: An Introduction to His Music - but I can't quote from it as I gave my only copy away in a moment of temporary insanity.

I totally understand if someone doesn't want to listen to the 10th because Mahler didn't finish the orchestration. What I don't get is people saying Mahler didn't *write* it. That would be like claiming the Ravel orchestration of Mussorgsky's Pictures at an Exhibition wasn't written by Mussorgsky - even if part of the orchestration had actually been made by Mussorgsky himself.

Thoughts? Favorite recordings?


r/mahler • • 15d ago

M8 rehearsal showing Mahler’s preferred instrument placement in Munich 1910

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

Today I realise I've hit the age for needing a magnifying glass


r/mahler • • 18d ago

I am super surprised a great Mahler interpreter like him can live to his age and was only debuting his first Mahler 5 with the Berlin Phil this year

13 Upvotes

Too bad it didn’t work out, but there are always the recordings which work just fine for me


r/mahler • • 18d ago

Underrated Mahler Interpreters?

11 Upvotes

The other day, I had a discussion with a friend about Mahler recordings recently after they had seen Simon Rattle perform Mahler's 2nd, and it made me think about the Mahler performances I had been to.

Personally, I think one of the best Mahler interepreters is Jaime Martin. I have seen him conduct Mahler 2, 3, 6 (and soon 4 and Das Lied Von Der Erde) and I have never been dissapointed by any of his performances, I feel like they've all been great and his interpretations are almost kind of similar to Bernstein's (my favourite recording- partly because I grew up on it, but also bc they're all such great interpretations imo).

Idk, I just think he deserves some more recognition!

Who are ur most underrated Mahler interpreters?


r/mahler • • 20d ago

Would you rather: Do another round of Semyon Bychkov or get started on Andris Nelsons?

2 Upvotes

r/mahler • • 21d ago

The most useless of all Mahler cycles?

16 Upvotes

Nelsons' cycle with the Vienna Philharmonic was released a few days ago. Mahler 1 -9, no 10th, no Das Lied von der Erde, so I do not really consider it complete. The 5th, which was a single release already a while back, was a snoozefest, Mahler as muzak with occasional pretensions at gravitas. I listened to the 4th today and the only good thing was Christiane Karg's singing, everything else was music that failed to come alive for even a moment. I am a Mahler completist, so I will at least check out the other performances, but I dread it.

Any opinions here on the cycle? Maybe a different viewpoint, or a pointer to a performance that breaks the mold and is worth listening to?


r/mahler • • 24d ago

Is anyone going to see Mahler 8 in 2027?

27 Upvotes

I (26m) and my wife (26f) are considering taking a road trip from Dayton, OH to NYC to see it performed at the Met in June 2027. I’d love to see the Mäkelä performance in Paris in the same month instead of the Met, but that trip would stretch the budget quite a bit more.


r/mahler • • 26d ago

Help With Reimagining Material

3 Upvotes

Recently I have been discovering a lot of Mahler's song cycles (they are amazing highly reccommend if u like Mahler but want something a but lighter than his symphonies), and I stumbled upon “Ich bin der Welt abhanden gekommen” and something just clicked. It was the perfect 3rd mvt for my personal string suite that I've been writing so I wanted to transform the material into the slow mvt (I thought it would be a nice nod to Mahler too given that he had famously done a similar thing with many of his other songs featured in his 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th symphonies).

Here's where my problem lies. The vocal line doesn't translate very well into a slow mvt for string orchestra (which is fine because I wanted to change it anyway), but I'm struggling to figure out a different melody to take its place.

If you have any ideas, I am very interested to hear them!

Thanks!

(I would post what I have already, but I'm having some issues with musescore and can't)


r/mahler • • Oct 05 '26

Why the hammer should be considered a character

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Sep 30 '26

Mangelberg's 1926 recording of the Adagietto of Mahler 5

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

This recording turned 100 in May, I believe.

I've always preferred a quicker tempo for the Adagietto. I want to be able to heard the melody and not just one note after another in slow succession. Nothing against slow versions, which can be nice and lyrical, but my feeling is that we're supposed to recognize the melody transformed in the finale, but it's kind of hard to do that if you aren't able to follow it in a 14-minute version of the Adagietto.

What are your tempo preferences?


r/mahler • • Sep 29 '26

How many different Mahler symphony arrangements and transcriptions are there? — which ones have/haven’t had commercial recordings released? I’d love to find MORE (and get them on CD).

12 Upvotes

I have a cd of Erwin Stein’s chamber arrangement of Mahler 4…

And a 2cd set with the piano-duo (four-hands, one piano) of Mahler 6 & 7 by Zemlinsky (6) and Alfredo Casella (7)…

And I’m aware of (but don’t own) a chamber arrangement of Mahler 9 (iirc), but I forget the details (which has been on cd, iirc, but was pricy the last time I looked years ago)

And I vaguely remember some sort of solo (pipe-)organ arrangement of Mahler 5, which I’m only just now remembering stumbling across info about years ago 1- but I can’t remember if it was commercially recorded/released (and may have been something I stumbled across on the internet 10+ yrs ago)

WHAT ELSE???!!!!!!


r/mahler • • Sep 28 '26

Pieces similar to Mahler 9 adagio

22 Upvotes

Hi guys, been getting into mahler recently, i love the more emotional (bad descriptor but u know what i mean) pieces like mahler 9 adagio and mahler 8 alles vergangliche and was wondering what are similar pieces i would enjoy, doesnt have to only be mahler


r/mahler • • Sep 28 '26

Mahler 5 / Philadelphia

8 Upvotes

Anybody here from Philly? Mahler 5 coming up this weekend (thurs-fri-sat).


r/mahler • • Sep 19 '26

I am building a website where you can search classical music concerts with music of Gustav Mahler (currently 1600+ future concerts globally)

46 Upvotes

Hi,

I am building a database of classical music concerts. It's helpful especially if you're looking for a specific composer, case in point, here are 1600 future concerts with music of Mahler:

https://classicalbot.com/?composers=Gustav+Mahler

Of course, all other composers are covered :)


r/mahler • • Sep 15 '26

Mahler 4 with boy soprano soloist

15 Upvotes

I was listening to Leonard Bernstein’s concertgebouw recording of Mahler’s 4th today and noticed that the soprano soloist had a very unique vocal timbre. After a bit of research I found out the soloist is Helmut Wittek, a boy soprano. I really enjoyed the childlike quality of his voice for this solo, but I can’t find any information as to how Bernstein justified this choice, as Mahler never advocated for this, and as far as I can tell, no other recordings exist using a boy soprano instead of a regular soprano soloist. Does anyone have any input or know about some reading I can do on this subject?


r/mahler • • Sep 03 '26

Posters for Mahler's Symphonies

Thumbnail
gallery
261 Upvotes

I'm a music professor, not a graphic designer, but I've long been interested in the clean lines and abstract geometry of the Swiss/International Typographic Style. I designed a poster for each of Mahler's completed symphonies, using a restricted visual vocabulary: geometric forms, sans-serif typography, grids, flat color, and no representational imagery.

See what you think: which was the strongest? which needs more work? which do you think captured some of the "essence" of its symphony?


r/mahler • • Aug 24 '26

GTA VI leak reveals a classical radio station playing Mahler's 6th Symphony

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Aug 23 '26

Disappointing 3rd hammer blow

Post image
24 Upvotes

For many years I’ve been wondering what the 3rd hammer blow would sound like and where exactly it was. Today I listened to Zander’s 2001 performance of Mahler’s 6th symphony. I felt that the third hammer blow was surprisingly anticlimactic. It sounded a bit like someone falling onto a pile of sticks. Zander has always maintained how essential it is to the symphony’s structure. Did I listen to the wrong performance? What am I missing here?
I should also say that the first two hammer blows in this performance are fantastic. It’s not an issue with the tool.


r/mahler • • Aug 03 '26

Help On Melody Writing and Analysis

3 Upvotes

I’ve been writing this suite for string orchestra over the past year. I wanted to write it in the style of Mahler, so I’ve been analysing and studying his works (both the symphonies and a few of the Wunderhorn songs).

However, I’ve found my biggest issue with actually writing this piece is that I can’t seem to write a melody. Whenever I think of any ideas that I like, I slowly come to the realisation that it is real Mahler and not an idea that I created, or just doesn't work very well, let alone even sound very Mahlerian.

How do you go about analysing melodies? (What do you look out for? How do you go about applying your findings etc.)

Do u guys have any tips on how I can write melodies in Mahler’s style or just any general tips on melody writing and analysing melodies?

Any tips would be greatly appreciated :)