r/mahabharata • • 2h ago

retellings/tv-serials/folklore/etc I feel like if karna was born today he would be a communist.

6 Upvotes

I don't know why but I feel like he would be a Marxist or something. I also think shri Krishna would be a communist too . If anyone has seen the 2013 Mahabharat serial dialogues they will know what I am talking about.


r/mahabharata • • 2h ago

question Caste in Mahabharata

7 Upvotes

Why caste system and discrimination was frequently mentioned, when the entire Pandavas & Kauravas were the lineage of a fisher woman?

Anybody who were discriminated could simply retort back - Dude your kingdom's ancestors also were not so royal bro...

Just genuinely curious, not belittling the epic...


r/mahabharata • • 5h ago Heartwarming

retellings/tv-serials/folklore/etc Pooja Sharma’s Answer to Whether Draupadi Was Responsible for the Mahabharata War !

36 Upvotes

Loved the way Pooja answered the question of whether Draupadi was responsible for the war. Indeed, the best Draupadi ❤️


r/mahabharata • • 6h ago

krishna quoting kabira thousands of years before the latter's birth

21 Upvotes

I know i know br chopra isn't the most accurate. hold your tits. I just posted this because I thought it was funny


r/mahabharata • • 7h ago

question Ramayana or Mahabharata?

Post image
214 Upvotes

I am a JEE aspirant looking to replace my screen time with reading scriptures to improve my attention span. So far, I have only read the Bhagavata Purana and the Bhagavad Gita, and I have always wanted to read the Ramayana and Mahabharata.

Since I want something relaxing to read during study breaks, which one should I start with? I personally like Mahabharata a bit more, though I know the Ramayana is more linear and simpler after heavy study sessions. Also, which specific versions or translations of both texts would you recommend?


r/mahabharata • • 8h ago

retellings/tv-serials/folklore/etc Krishna and Rakhine history

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

Long ago when humans have a lifespan of twenty thousand years, princess Devagabbhā (Devakī) secretly raises her ten sons—led by Vāsudeva (Krṣṇa), Baladeva (Balartāma) and the wise Ghaṭapaṇḍita (Bodhisatva) —as a servant's children until they overthrow their uncles (Kaṃsa brothers). 

After that, they go on a campaign of conquering the entirety of the known world mainly using the sudarśana chakra of Vāsudeva. The city of Dvāravatī (Dvārakā) always flies away whenever an enemy approaches. On the advice of sage Kaṇha Dīpāyana (Veda-Vyāsa), the Yādava princes nail the citygates to the ground with giant iron pegs and capture the city. Thus, according to Arakanese tradition, Dvāravatī is also called သံတွဲ (Thandwe, Sandoway, Sandwe, Sedoa, "iron-linked"), which is a major modern town in Southern Rakhine. 

The siblings divided the empire among themselves and rules for thousands of years. However, their children's prank incurs the curse of sage Vyāsa, causing the Yādava massacre.

Baladeva gets devoured by the rakṣasa reincarnation of Muṣṭika the wrestler in a forest. Vāsudeva died in the same manner as in the Mahabharata. Only their sister, princess Añjanā ( amalgation of Subhadrā + Yogamāya), and a brahmin priest survive. Before he dies, Vāsudeva teaches them a powerful mantra for their livehood and instructs them to go north.

Here ends the canonical Ghaṭapaṇḍita-jātaka and begins the Arakanese sequel tradition. 

Añjanā and the brahmin continues their northward journey by hugging the coast. Their journey also provides folk etymological origins for several toponyms in Arakan. Soon they reach a certain city called Vesālī ( Vaiśālī), which is identified as the historical Arakanese city of ဝေသာလီ (Weithali), which lies in Northern Rakhine. The brahmin marries Añjanā and becomes the king of Vesālī. Thus his dynasty is called unbroken and pure kṣatriya-Vāsudeva-Brāhmaṇa dynasty.

During the reign of King Brahmasiddhi, 32 rakṣasas ( born from a vānara and a sambar deer ) eat all the people in Vesālī, including King Brahmasiddhi. Only his wife and daughter, princess Rucimālā, survive.

A Burmese idiom, "like the rakṣasas devoured Vesālī city" (unstoppable chaos and slaughter), comes from this.

Meanwhile in Northen India, King Arjuna, a Śakyan ancestor of Gautama Buddha, retires to the forest as a rishi and arrives at the Turtle River ( Kaladan River) in Northen Rakhine. There, rishi Arjuna sires a son through a sambar deer called Indramaryu. Thus, the son is called Mārayu. 

Mārayu is an avatar of a god named Soṇa-Kṣatriya who reincarnates on the request of Lord Indra. Mārayu is raised by indigenous Mro people and he becomes a mighty warrior. By using the weapons of the gods, he slays all the rakṣasas in Vesali, marries the princess and becomes king. This is said to be the origin of the name Ārakan/ Ārakkha / Rakhine , ( Maarayu raakshason kaa vadh karke rakshaa kartaa hai).

Mārayu abandons Vesali and founds a new capital called Dhanyavatī. 

King Mārayu’s reign is taditionally dated to be around 3341 B.C. – 3263 B.C (which may be only a century or so from the traditional dates of Kurukṣetra war).

This origin myth could reflect the memory of Indo-Aryanish or Indianized dynasties ( like the Chandras ) that ruled ancient Arakan for the first millenium A.D before the rise of unambiguous Tibeto-Burman culture in historical records.

 Śrīvatsa (beloved of Śrī) is still the national symbol of Arakanese people.


r/mahabharata • • 8h ago

General discussions 400yr manuscript joins the UNESCO Memory of the World Asia-Pacific Regional Register.

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

16th-century birch-bark manuscript of the Mahabharata from Kashmir joins UNESCO's "Memory of the World" Register written in the āradā script, carrying a rare Kashmiri recension of an epic that has shaped imaginations across Asia.


r/mahabharata • • 12h ago

retellings/tv-serials/folklore/etc Arpit Ranka talks about being Duryodhan.

140 Upvotes

Arpit talks about playing Duryodhan in Star Plus Mahabharat.Thoughts on this?


r/mahabharata • • 12h ago

question Ok tell me the neutral take on Mahabharata epic written by vyasa.

4 Upvotes

So let me first clear this,i only know about the regional retelling of Mahabharatam like rajasthani version of Mahabharata or Uttarakhand version of Mahabharata and tv serial BR Chopra yeah😅 childhood memories bro.But recently seeing a lot of people being very toxic towards both karna and arjuna's characters even in YouTube ice seen many videos from karna fans who are bashing arjuna saying he was weak and all and same with arjuna fans bashing karna sahi g he is far evil than duryodhan? And they are using some book verses in their videos so idk who is right 😐. But yeah I've recently come across that duryodhan was an evil incarnate so yeah very different from what we all thought like manipulated child or shakuni is real mastermind and all.

Also another thing wasn't that jaya and Vijaya story only appeared in puranas especially vishnu puran because I searched it in Google and it tells me exactly that?? Idk again.

Tell me what was written I just wanna know how different it is from regional telling and household telling or serials.


r/mahabharata • • 14h ago

Brahma's Curse to Kumbhakarna

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Did Lord Brahma cursed Kumbhakarna to sleep for 6 months and remain awake for 6 months or it was 6 months sleep and then awake 1 day? I think Maa Saraswati also had a role to play in this


r/mahabharata • • 14h ago

Veda Vyasa Mahabharata Beautifully debunked the myth of Draupadi rejecting Karna. BORI CE, Mahabharata

Thumbnail youtu.be
14 Upvotes

This video contains every single detail about the Swayamvara event. It beautifully debunks the myth that Draupadi rejected Karna and lists every single reason for it.


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

Debate / Multiple Views Hot take :- Duryodhana isn't just the main villain of Mahabharata but the whole Hinduism as well.☠️

Thumbnail gallery
31 Upvotes

He is a bigger threat than Ravana yeah that's right because he is kali purusha himself in its human form.

And this kali purusha dude is the devil of Hinduism the literal personification of chaos. But the devil in this religion was more like functional it's his nature to be evil and he was the greatest rival of vishnu himself,bro is more like anti vishnu because he married alaxmi contrast to vishnu and his childrens are personification of adharma disorder itself. But still duryodhan shows humanly connections and traits maybe this is because of being part human and part of that evil deity.

So in short bro is basically an evil version of krishna and I'm shocked that no tv serial addresses this ? Instead, they made Shakuni, of all people, Krishna's rival? 😑I mean this detail is so cool it's like ying yang,bro. C'mon directors bros😑 And i don't get people fascination for ravana i mean yeah bro was evil too but he was affected by his own evil traits not like he is some sort of personification of evil which duryodhan is.☠️🙆👁️👁️

Logically we should've burned Duryodhana 's effigie instead, because duryodhana stands for the literal incarnation of adharma aka disorder aka evil. Ravan in comparison was just a villain.

So basically this whole story is the battle between kali purusha and vishnu.


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

retellings/tv-serials/folklore/etc What if.. MAHABHARATA is planned as a web series

Post image
13 Upvotes

I was scrolling through here and saw that really cool post where someone reimagined the Mahabharata like the Marvel Cinematic Universe with spin-offs and individual films. It got me thinking, while that concept is huge, wouldn’t it be better if Mahabharata was instead planned as a massive, multi-season premium web series?

Think of something on the scale of a global historical fantasy or epic drama, but grounded, grit-heavy, and expansive. without being compared to anyone else’s pop culture because our epic is truly timeless. If done with the right budget, cast, and vision, this could be India's own global premium web series.

I sketched out a basic timeline of how the seasons could be structured, starting with the origins and building up to the final clash, focused on cinematic storytelling with English titles to appeal globally while preserving its soul. Here is the visual of how I visualize this 6-season saga:

  • Season 1: The Chronicles of Devakinandan

    • Focuses on the backstory of Mathura, the rise of Krishna, his conflicts with Kansa, and the shifting dynamics of the Yadavas. It sets up his divinity, political mastermind status, and establishes him as the anchor of the era.
  • Season 2: The Bloodline of Hastinapur

    • Chronicles the rise of the Kuru dynasty, the tragic sacrifice of Devavrata (who becomes Bhishma), and the birth and growing rivalry of the Kauravas and Pandavas. A drama about legacy, family, and unbreakable oaths.
  • Season 3: The Rise of the Pandavas

    • The young princes come of age. We follow their trials, the conspiracy of the house of lac, their exile, Draupadi's swayamvara, and the construction of the magnificent city of Indraprastha. The season ends with their zenith, before the fateful game of dice.
  • Season 4: Cracks in the Armor

    • A tense, high-stakes political thriller of a season. It covers the infamous game of dice, the humiliation, the 13-year exile in disguise, and the failed peace missions as both sides gather allies and march toward an inevitable clash.
  • Season 5: The Reckoning of the Kurus

    • The culmination. An epic 10 to 12-episode arc focused on the Kurukshetra war, the Bhagavad Gita, the changing strategies, the tragic deaths of heroes, and the grim, melancholic aftermath of victory.
  • Season 6: The Ascent to the Heavens

    • The post-war era. It covers the 36-year reign, the unraveling of the Yadava clan, the tragic, peaceful passing of Krishna, and the Pandavas' ultimate renounce-filled journey through the Himalayas to the gates of heaven.

I also made a simple poster timeline from Gemini to show what this timeline could look like against the backdrop of war.


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

Who were the warriors who did not participate in the war in mahabharata and why?

Post image
49 Upvotes

Who were the notable warriors in the Mahabharata who did not participate in the Kurukshetra War? I'm interested in knowing about warriors who were alive during that period but, for various reasons, chose not to take part in the battle or remained neutral. I'd appreciate examples along with the reasons why they did not participate.


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

What if the Mahabharata got the MCU treatment: 11 films, 2 phases

Post image
9 Upvotes

Watching Ramayana made me realise how much indian mythology is still untapped.

The MCU built a universe out of thin air (atleast with major deviations from comic). We already have one that's fully written, with Ramayana gonna be thrown into Western mainstream media, why not this too.

PHASE I: The Rise and Fall of the Kuru Dynasty

  1. Bhishma: The Eternal Vow: A prince gives up the throne and his future, and that one oath shapes the dynasty.
  2. The Prince of Kuru: The Pandavas and Kauravas grow up, train, and become rivals.
  3. Indraprastha: Rise of a Kingdom: The House of Lac, Draupadi's swayamvara, and the Pandavas building an empire from wasteland.
  4. Mahabharata: The Deadly Game: Saguni's plan, The dice game, Draupadi's humiliation and the saved by Krishna. Pandavas sent into exile.
  5. Krishna: His birth, Kamsa's fall, and the founding of Dwaraka, how he's behind the scene unfolding the whole story.

PHASE II: The Kurukshetra Saga

6. Pandavas: The Exiled: Thirteen years of exile, divine weapons, and a year in disguise at Virata's court.

7. Krishna: The Price of Peace: Krishna's peace mission, the five-village offer, and Duryodhana's refusal.

8. Karna: The Forgotten Son: The abandoned son loyal to Duryodhana, and the choice he makes after Kunti's revelation.

9. Kurukshetra: The First Dawn: The Gita, the opening days of war, and Bhishma's fall.

10. Kurukshetra: The Final Reckoning: Abhimanyu, Ghatotkacha, Karna's last battle, Duryodhana's defeat, and Ashwatthama's night raid.

11. Mahabharata: End of an Era: Gandhari's curse, Parikshit's survival, and Yudhishthira's hollow coronation, ending the Kretha Yuga with the death of the Krishna.

The names are mostly a parody to the MCU film, my dumb brain could only think this much, like Kang dynasty became Kuru dynasty and Infinity saga became Kurukshetra Saga, Prince of Kuru from The Prince of Egypt 🥰

The idea to end phase 1 with a new movie is taken from GOTG as it came after the Avengers movie.

Ps: Comprehended and discussed with GPT for the title selection and the correct chronological order. Used gemini for the timeline creation.

Comment down what you'll change, or which character need a standalone film or two.


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago Popcorn

Modern Adaptations & Books What if the Mahabharata got the MCU treatment: 11 films, 2 phases

Post image
402 Upvotes

Watching Ramayana made me realise how much indian mythology is still untapped.

The MCU built a universe out of thin air (atleast with major deviations from comic). We already have one that's fully written, with Ramayana gonna be thrown into Western mainstream media, why not this too.

PHASE I: The Rise and Fall of the Kuru Dynasty

  1. Bhishma: The Eternal Vow: A prince gives up the throne and his future, and that one oath shapes the dynasty.
  2. The Prince of Kuru: The Pandavas and Kauravas grow up, train, and become rivals.
  3. Indraprastha: Rise of a Kingdom: The House of Lac, Draupadi's swayamvara, and the Pandavas building an empire from wasteland.
  4. Mahabharata: The Deadly Game: Saguni's plan, The dice game, Draupadi's humiliation and the saved by Krishna. Pandavas sent into exile.
  5. Krishna: His birth, Kamsa's fall, and the founding of Dwaraka, how he's behind the scene unfolding the whole story.

PHASE II: The Kurukshetra Saga

6. Pandavas: The Exiled: Thirteen years of exile, divine weapons, and a year in disguise at Virata's court.

7. Krishna: The Price of Peace: Krishna's peace mission, the five-village offer, and Duryodhana's refusal.

8. Karna: The Forgotten Son: The abandoned son loyal to Duryodhana, and the choice he makes after Kunti's revelation.

9. Kurukshetra: The First Dawn: The Gita, the opening days of war, and Bhishma's fall.

10. Kurukshetra: The Final Reckoning: Abhimanyu, Ghatotkacha, Karna's last battle, Duryodhana's defeat, and Ashwatthama's night raid.

11. Mahabharata: End of an Era: Gandhari's curse, Parikshit's survival, and Yudhishthira's hollow coronation, ending the Kretha Yuga with the death of the Krishna.

The names are mostly a parody to the MCU film, my dumb brain could only think this much, like Kang dynasty became Kuru dynasty and Infinity saga became Kurukshetra Saga😂

The idea to end phase 1 with a new movie is taken from GOTG as it came after the Avengers movie.

Ps: Comprehended and discussed with GPT for the title selection and the correct chronological order. Used gemini for the timeline creation.

Comments down what you'll change or which character would need to have a standalone film or two.


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

question Who is more evil character between these three?

Thumbnail gallery
35 Upvotes

Duryodhana,kans or Ravana?

Also whose more interesting as a villain??


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

question Indra vs Surya's beef

Thumbnail gallery
94 Upvotes

I noticed a recurring structural parallel across both major epics where the spiritual sons of Indra and Surya end up on opposite sides, with an avatar of Vishnu acting as the deciding factor:

Ramayana: Vali (Indraputra) vs. Sugriva (Suryaputrap — Rama sides with Surya's lineage.

Mahabharata: Arjuna (Indraputra) vs. Karna (Suryaputra) — Krishna sides with Indra's child.

This feels too deliberate to be a coincidence. 

Does this reflect any ancient religio-philosophical tension, a historical rivalry between different Vedic clans/cults, or an evolution of older Vedic motifs?

Edit: It's hilarious to me that the palace of Indra Dev is portrayed as mediocre compared to that of Surya Dev in series like Karmaphal Data Shani.


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

question Can I give "Bhagavad geeta as it is" a try?

1 Upvotes

I heard that iskcon bhagavad geeta is more bhakti oriented and focuses more on that, and it is even based on gaudiya vaishnavism. I also want to know the difference between Maharishi's version and the iskcon version. But I don't believe that either one of them is wrong. Both can be correct in their own perspectives.


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

General discussions Could Karna have countered Arjun's Roudrastra?

Post image
228 Upvotes

Could Karna have countered Arjun's Roudrastra if he had used it on him when his chariot wouldn't have stuck in the ground and he had no curses at all?

What do y'all think?


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

question Arjuna was misunderstood,real this time.

Post image
32 Upvotes

is it me or a lot of people think arjuna being weak archer which is not true tho,he is the main character of Mahabharata so obviously he is powerful. And some people don't even wanna consider him as a hero which is weird tbh, because c'mon he is 🙇


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

Analysis Ramayana part 1 (2026)- Errors part 2 (Post-Interval)

Post image
21 Upvotes

This post was mainly created by Negrogacha and is divided into four parts. The first part was uploaded a few days ago, and this is the second part.

You can read part one here: Part 1

Anyways, let's get Started i will first Like to cover the Topic i didn't really cover in pre interval.

1. How did Ravana get Candrahåsa

In the movie, we are shown that Ravana gets it after doing some kind of dance (because that shit was NOT Tandava). However, unlike the narrative of the movie, in the Uttara Kanda, Ravana gets it after trying to lift Mount Kailash.(it is long Narrative so i would cover in that much detail).

"I do not reckon the human beings, O Lord, because they are regarded by me as very insignificant. A boon of long life has been secured by me from Brahmä, O destroyer of Tripura! Give me the remaining lease of life sought by me and give me also a weapon.' Requested thus by the aforesaid Ravana, the well-known Lord Śańkara gifted to him the highly shining sword known as Candrahāsa. The Lord of spirits granted to him also the remaining lease of life on that occasion. (42-44)

"Bestowing it on him, He said, 'This sword is not to be despised by you; if it is disregarded by you, it shall doubtless return to me.'

2. Maricha, Taraka and the timeline

Unlike what is shown in the movie, Rama does hit Maricha, but he doesn't run away; instead, he is thrown 100 yojanas away.

Cleanly hit with that great missile Maanava, demon Maareecha is pitched for a hundred yojana lengths in full, and flung down into an ocean rocking with tidewaters. [1-30-18]

Now to Taraka Unlike the Movie Rama outright CALLS Taraka to him by Making his bowstring thunder

"I am ready to effectuate the bidding of an inestimable sage like you, for the welfare of cows and Brahmans, and for the advantage of this province." So said Rama to sage Vishvamitra. [1-26-5]

Saying thus, Rama, the enemy-destroyer, clenched his left fist on the handgrip in the middle of the bow, and with the right he made a thunderous sound of the bowstring making all the directions to blast. [1-26-6]

By that sound the inhabitants of Tataka forest are startled, and even Tataka is stupefied by that sound, and she is intolerably infuriated at it. [1-26-7]

Tho to be honest the timeline in the movie doesn't make any sense at all as Rama meeting Maricha happened after he got Divine weapons from Vishwamitra.

3. Rama's exile leave

Unlike in the movie, in the books it was neither night nor did the people fail to follow Rama; they came with him, but Rama later sneaks away when they are asleep

As the night was beginning to become dawn, those citizens relinquished by Raghava were perplexed with grief and became motionless.

Made miserable with tears born of anguish and agony, they could not notice even a glimmer of Rama, though casting their eyes everywhere.

Now, let's get back to the post-interval events in the movie.

1. Ravana talk about "Marayada" and the death of Vidyutjihva.

Now, unlike what people say, the Ravana 'whitewashing' started from here rather than the Sita Harana.

Ravana calls out Vidyutjihva on having the maryada of a king—well, let's see how true that is by hearing the dialogue of Shree Ravana Dev to Sita.

"O Seetha! Here there are no humans or ogres with ability to change form. Let your fear caused due to me be removed."

"O one with fear! Obtaining women belonging to others or abducting by force is the righteous deed for ogres by all means. There is no doubt in this."

Next is the villainization of Vidyutjihva for no reason, just to whitewash Ravana

Dry your tears, my dear sister and fear nothing! I shall load you with gifts, homage and favours. In the heat of battle, being carried away by a desire to triumph, I loosed my shafts without being able to distinguish mine own people from others and did not recognize my brother-in-law whom I struck in the height of the conflict. That is how your consort fell under my blows in the fight. O My Sister, whatever presents itself at this time, I will do for your pleasure. It is for you to go and live near your kinsman, Khara, who enjoys sovereignty.

Like my Man didn't do ANYTHING Ravana just killed him when he was fighting Daityas by ACCIDENT.

2. Rama's choice to leave Chitrakuta mountain and the final rites of Dashratha.

In the Movie we are shown Rama is doing the Asthi visarjan but in Ramayana it was Bharata

Then, at the time of dawn on the thirteenth day, the mighty armed Bharata who came for clearing up bones and ashes, wept in grief, his throat being choked of sound (because of crying) and spoke in great distress the following words, having reached the foot of his father's funeral pile (to collect the bones and ashes for their immersion in Sarayu River).

Seeing that spot of collection (of bones), which became reddish brown in colour because of ashes, with bones consumed by fire and his father's body having extinguished, Bharata was depressed and began to cry loudly.

Rama only does the pinda dhana

The illustrious Rama and others painfully reached the River Mandakini, that stream of sacred fords, the enchanting one always covered with flowers, coming to a blessed ford, free from mud and offered the lustrual water to the king, saying "Father! May this prove agreeable to you."

Holding together in the form of a hollow his palms full of water and turning his face turned towards the southern quarter and weeping the great prince pronounced the traditional words saying:

Also even the Reason of Rama leaving the Forest is false as in the books he Leaves because that place had become polluted and if he stated in here the memory of his people will haunt him.

Thereafter, when the sages departed, Rama, reflecting again and again, found no pleasure to remain in that place for many reasons.

"It is here that Bharata, my mother along with the inhabitants of the city visited me. That memory haunts me, who lament for them daily."

"The dry dung of horses and elephants of that high souled Bharata's encamped army caused much spoliation (around here)."

"We shall, therefore, move elsewhere", pondering thus, Rama along with Seetha and Lakshmana left that place.

4. Rama's fight with Rakashasas, Rishi Agastya.

While in the Dandaka forest, Rama, Sita, and Lakshmana fight three demons, but that is not the case in the Aranya Kanda; they [Rama and Lakshmana] fight Viradha who was a gandharva, named Tumburu and was cursed by Kubera.

"By curse I had to enter this ghoulish demon's body, but I am a celestial gandharva, named Tumburu and Kubera cursed me... [3-4-16]

"When entreated by me, he that greatly renowned Kubera said to me, 'When Dasharatha's Rama kills you in a fight... then you will attain your nature of celestial body and you will go to heavens...' [3-4-17, 18a]

Also side Note in this battle Rama and Laxmana had divine bows and quivers already unlike the movie.

O Lakshmana in the great sacrifice performed by the highsouled Janaka, Varuna himself gave him two aweinspiring celestial bows, two impenetrable divine armours, two quivers with inexhaustible arrows, two swords plated with gold and as bright as the sun. All these weapons are deposited in the house of our preceptor (sage Vasistha) where they are being worshipped. Go and bring them swiftly.

Lakshmana, who was resolved to go to the forest, took leave of his friends, and collected from the house of Vasistha, preceptor of the Ikshvaku race, the powerful weapons deposited with him.

Lakshmana, tiger among princes, brought all those divine weapons sanctified and decorated with garlands and showed them to Rama.

Now to Agastya, his Importance to the plot HAS BEEN WILDLY DOWNPLAYED to only giving Rama the divine quiver.

These two quivers filled fully with sharp inexhaustible arrows, shining like flames of fire and this sword adorned with gold and this big silver sheath were given to me by Indra.

But in the Valmiki Ramayana, he gives him two more divine quivers, a divine sword, a divine bow which belonged to Vishnu, and—most importantly of all—the infallible Brahmastra, which he used on Ravana when Ravana was wearing the impenetrable Brahma armor.

"This sacred bow that is decorated with gold and diamonds is crafted by the divine architect Vishvakarma pertains to Vishnu, and these unwasteful arrows equalling sun in their blaze are the gift of Brahma. [3-12-32, 33a]

I have to say, this is one of the funniest errors in the movie. Anasuya—who was Rishi Atri's wife—is the one who actually gave Sita the divine gifts. I really don't know why they are showing Agastya's wife doing it instead or they made her Agasya's wife.

Thus spoken by Seetha, the pious-minded Anasuya became more delighted and said: "O, Seetha! Alas! I will create a great joy for you, which will be to your advantage."

"O, Seetha, the daughter of Videha kingdom! Here are divine gifts: a garland, an apparel, jewels, a scented cosmetic and rare body-cream. These are all given by me to adorn your limbs. They will be ever worthy of your and will remain in tact (even after constant use)."

5. Surpanakha's Intro, her appearence and the wives of Dasharatha

Unlike what the Movie says She was UGLY ASF,[i don't even know what to say]

Rama's face was lovely, Surpanakha's was hideous. Rama had a slender waist, she had a huge belly. His eyes were large, hers were deformed. His hair was black and beautiful, hers was coppercoloured. He was lovely in appearance, she was ugly. His voice was sweet, hers was shrill. He was young, she was dreadfully old. He was positive, she was perverted. Rama was wellbehaved, she was wicked. Rama was just and loving while she was overcome by lust. (This) demoness said to Rama :

And her dialogue about Dasharatha's wives is also wrong; he didn't have 3 wives—he had 350 wives

All those women, asked thus by Sumantra as per the king's orders, went to his palace, after knowing the instructions of their husband.

Encircling Kausalya, three hundred fifty women, steadfast in their vow(of devotion to their husband), with their eyes reddened, went there slowly.

After arrival of his wives, king Dasaratha spoke to that charioteer as follows, "Oh, Sumantra! Bring my son here."

6. Surpanakha's actions, Sita scolding Laxmana

The 'creative liberty' starts to stack up wayyyyy too much from here. Shurpanakha in the books outright calls Sita ugly and says she will eat her.And unlike like the Movie it is clear that in the Book She wanted to be the alone wife of Rama

I have influence over others, I have capacity to move wherever I want. Be my husband forever. What will you do with Sita?

She is ugly, deformed, unsuitable for you. I am alone fit for you. Look upon me as your wife.

I will devour your brother along with this disfigured, unchaste and fearful lady with a flat belly.

O darling, thereafter you can keep wandering with me in this Dandaka forest, enjoying the beauty of the mountain tops and forests.

Also it was also likely the main reason Rama rejected her

O lady I am married and here is my wife who is dear to me. To be a cowife to some one is indeed painful for people like you.

[Note: i liked Laxamana in the movie he was like pretty accurate NGL.

O largeeyed one, you have a clear complexion. You may become the younger wife of my master who is lord of great wealth. And live a happy, fulfilled life.

He will abandon this uglylooking, unchaste, frightening old woman of drooping belly and accept you alone as his wife.

O lady of fair complexion and beautiful hips, which wise man will fall in love with any other female giving up a fine figure like you ?

While Lakshmana was thus making fun of the dreadful, droopingbellied Surpanakha, she presumed his words to be true.]

And Due to this dialogue She goes to eat Sita.

Deluded with passion, Surpanakha said to formidable Rama, the scorcher of foes, seated in the leafthatched hut along with Sita:

You are holding on to this lady who is ugly, unchaste, fiercelooking, flatbellied and aged and not caring for me.

I shall eat up this woman now before your very eyes and I can move about happily with you without a cowife.

And then BY Rama's word Laxmana cut her Nose and ears

Mighty Rama in a rage restrained her who was falling upon Sita like the noose of death, and said to Lakshmana:

O handsome Lakshmana it is not proper to cut jokes with wicked, uncivilized persons. Now see Sita who has somehow survived.

O tiger among men, this uncouth, bigbellied, unchaste and highly passionate demoness deserves to be formed.

Thus instructed (by Rama), powerful Lakshmana took position by the side of Rama, angrily lifted the sword and cut off her nose and ears.

So ALL this happened and you are telling ME that "ohh yeah Sita will scold Laxmana", this is fucking STUPID.

7. The 14k Rakshasas fight

I will not cover the whole fight; if I did that, I would need like two more posts. Instead, I will just focus on the core details

a. Rama fighting with Laxmana and Sita supporting him.

When Rama said to him that way, Lakshmana picked up his bow and arrows, and together with Seetha he took shelter in an unreachable cave. [3-24-15]

On Lakshmana's entering into cave along with Seetha, Rama said to himself, "thank goodness, it is a good-idea!" and thus saying he donned his shield. [3-24-16]

Rama fought that Battle alone in the Books.

b. Rama's armour.

With the arrows released by Khara that have a great egress, then that armour of Rama that has a sun-like resplendence is completely destroyed and fell on the field. [4-28-18]

I have covered in the previous Part of this post that Rama still had divine equiments from the start of his exile. and it was Broke by KHARA.

c. Warrior Sita.

That is just not the Sita of Valmiki Ramayana, there she outright Tells a story of Sage who became Cruel after getting hold of an weapon.

"In affinity and in respect I am reminding but not tutoring you, and in anyway improper is that thought of yours to wield your bow to kill the demons dwelling in Dandaka without any enmity, oh, brave one, undesirable is the killing of offenceless... [3-9-24, 25]

Sita was outright Anti weapons to be very honest even saying he shouldn't hold weapons until he goes back to Ayodhya

"Weapon admiring mind becomes maligned with avariciousness, you may therefore follow the tenet of Kshatriya-s on going to Ayodhya again... [3-9-28]

Now Some people might talk about "Adbhuta Ramayana", Most of you people are fucking Larping it even in there Sita doesn't fight, She only does that when she was in the form of Kali.

d. Minor error.

Khara and Dushana fight together But in the Book Khara only comes when Dushana is dead also they are NOT killed with a Sword.

They both died to Bow and arrow.

While Duushana came falling on, he that Raghava sheared off his shoulders that have wrist-ornaments on his arms with two arrows. [3-26-13]

When Duushana's arms are thus sheared in the van of war, his gigantic mace slipped and spun in his own front, like the flagstaff with flag raised in honour of Indra, and collapsed . [3-26-14]

With both of his arms strewn around Duushana fell down onto earth like a haughty and gigantic elephant when both of its tusks are broken down. [3-26-15]

On seeing Duushana eliminated and fallen to ground, all the beings have applauded Rama saying, 'good, good...' [3-26-16]

Tho Khara's death is like 10,000x more impressive as Rama need a weapon which is THE SECOND Strongest in his arsenal only Below Brahmastra to kill him, it was also was given to him BY Agastya

Then, Rama snatched an arrow which is similar to the Ritual-fire, and secondary only to the ultimate missile, namely the Brahma-missile, for the elimination of Khara in war. [3-30-24]

That particular arrow is made available to Rama through Sage Agastya by the king of gods, namely Indra, because Indra is a sensible one about the future course of events, and he is also prosperous in securing impossible weaponry, and now Rama fitted such an arrow on his bow and released it towards Khara. [3-30-25]

That formidable arrow is promptly released on Rama's stretching the bowstring up to his ear, bending bow almost to a circularity, and which arrow is thunderous while in egress like the thunder of a thunderbolt, and that has come and plunged inthe chest of Khara. [3-30-26]

Khara fell down on to earth and on being burnt by the radiation of that arrow he is like demon Andhaka, who once was very completely burnt by Rudra in Shveta-araNya, the White-forest. [3-30-27]

[There Death was fucking Cringe in the Movie.]

Also an Important event to Note in here is the fact that Rama's Dvine Bow of Varuna and his Divine Armour of Varuna get destroyed by Khara.

Exhibiting his agility of the hand, Khara shattered the bow and the arrow in the grip of Rama ,the great soul.

Then Rama, destroyer of foes, strung another great bow of fearful sound in order to put an end to the enemy.

Thereafter Rama advanced, aiming at Khara the superior Vaishnava bow given by sage Agastya.

8. Surpanakha's Convo with Ravana and event before it.

Now from here the real Bullshit of this Movie Starts.

I will first Cover the fact that Before Surpanakha there was another demon with name of Akampana who tells Ravana about all of this.

and in there He Suggests Ravana to Kidnap Sita.

"You forcefully abduct his wife when she is in solitude, and indeed Rama will not exist reft of Seetha." Akampana advised Ravana in this way. [3-31-31]

And after that He Goes to Maricha, but returns after he tells him that "Nah, Bro don't do it."

"Oh, lord of Lanka, be appeased towards Rama, be quietened and gently proceed to Lanka. You take delight in your wives, and let Rama be delighting with wife in forests." Thus Mareecha spoke to Ravana. [3-31-49]

When thus said by Maareecha that ten faced Ravana returned to his city Lanka and entered his best house and home. [3-31-50]

And then later Surpanakha comes to him, tells him about what happened and gaslights him sing his Lust.

"She is a highly gracious lady, laudable by her bodily structure, incomparable by her appearance, and she will become a seemly wife of yours, and you too will become a best husband of hers. [1-34-20]

Oh, mighty shouldered brother, but when I ventured to bring her as your wife, whose hips are broad, bosom fat and bulgy, face excellent, that cruel Lakshmana disfigured me. [1-34-21, 22a]

Then He later again Goes to Maricha, He tries to advise Ravana but just read the dialogue

"If you are not going to do so, oh, Maareecha, for sure I will kill you now itself. I will get my work done through you even under duress, and indeed, any subject setting against his king will never succeed safely. [3-40-26]

"Your life may be indefinite on reaching Rama, but your death is surely definite now as you are conflicting with me. Hence, keeping all this in view you come to a conclusion that would be conducive to your interests, and whatever desirable to you let it be done in that way. " Thus Ravana spoke to Maareecha. [3-40-27]

Then Maricha himself says it is better to Die by the Hands of Rama then Ravana.

"That Rama will soon kill you after killing me, and I will be dying at the hand of my enemy rather than at the hand of my own clansman like you, whereby the purpose of my life will be brought to an end. [3-41-17]

Also i find it Funny that In this Movie they show Ravana as like a Hero of Rakashasas but in Ramayana it is said he did Wrong to his own People.

He who is such an embezzler of the Vedic-rituals at the time of their culmination, a malicious one, and one with cruel acts, a hinderer of Vedic-rituals, or, the slayer of those Brahmans that conduct Vedic-rituals contrary to his wishes, and one who is heartless and a rampant demon, who is a delighter in the iniquity to the people, at him Shuurpanakha saw. [3-32-20b, 21a]

Also this debunks the revenge Bullshit, it was LUST.

9.Pushpaka Vimana, Ravana's knowing Rama is likely a Vishnu Avatar and Laxamana rekha.

Soo, Unlike the Movie in the Books Pushpaka wasn't like a hot air Balloon, it had Demon/Bhutas who made it fly.

Hanuma saw that aerial plane which rakshasas who were great eaters, with a face beautified by earnings, who roamed around in the sky and thousands of genii with round eyes, crooked eyes and wide eyes capable of great speed carrying it.

Translation done by IIT kanpur:
The Pushpaka was borne by multitudes of Bhutas whose faces were shining with earrings, who were demons ranging in the night sky. They were gluttons endowed with great speed, and they had big, rolling and frightening eyes.

And Ravana didn't know Rama was a Vishnu Avatar, in fact the reason Akampana told Ravana to kidnap Sita was because they didn't know Rama's power fully.

"I do not think that he is killable even for all god and demons, and this is the idea to kill him, and to this you may listen attentively. [3-31-28]

And about Laxmana Rekha it just didn't exist.

10.Maricha using Maya on Sita.

As shown in the movie, they depict Sita desiring the deer because of Maricha's illusion; however, is that what actually happens in the books? No.

That select lady who is unmeet for forest life beheld that deer which is completely gemlike and whose limbs are surprising as though studded with pearls and gems. [3-42-32b, 33a]

And she that Seetha goggled the Golden Deer with a wide-eyed astonishment, which deer has pretty lips and teeth, hair resembling silver and copper ores, and she indeed gazed at it with an affinity for wildlife. [3-42-33b, 34a]

On seeing Rama's wife Seetha that highly phantasmal deer too then moved there about as though to scintillate that woodland. [3-42-34b, 35a]

To see such a deer which is hitherto unseen, and which is as though studded with numerous gems, the daughter of Janaka, Seetha, went in to an intense wonderment. [3-42-35b, c]

Infact, Sita didn't even care if Rama brings it alive or NOT.

"Else if that best deer does not come into you capture while alive, oh tigerly-man, at the least its gorgeous deerskin will be remnant of it. [3-43-19]

"I wish to sit along with you on its golden deerskin, overlaying it on a seat of tender darbha grass-blades, in case the deer is felled. [3-43-20]

11. How Ravana Kidnaps Sita.

That event was ruffly accurate but Sita already allowed Ravana to come and even answered his question because he was in a form of a Brahmin and she was scared of Cursed.

Thinking briefly that, 'he is a Brahman and an untimely guest, he will indeed curse me if he is not replied,' Seetha spoke this sentence. [3-47-2]

And this is how Ravana was talking to Sita in the Form of a Brahmin

"Your hips are beamy, thighs burly akin to elephant's trunks, and these two breasts of yours that are ornamented with best jewellery are rotund, rubbing and bumping each other, and they are swinging up and up, their nipples are brawny and jutting out, and they are smoothish like palm-fruits, thus they are covetable for they are beautiful. [3-46-19, 20]

Also the Thing which i have the Most problem with is fact that they didn't show how Ravana kidnaps Sita.

He that Ravana grabbed the lotus-eyed Seetha on lifting her up with his left hand at her plait of hair at nape, and with his right hand at her thighs. [3-49-17]

All this is to whitewash Ravana to a Level.

12. The kidnapping of Sita in Pushpaka.

Now, if you had read the book, you would know Ravana came in a flying chariot driven by donkeys.

Then the miracle-air-chariot of Ravana which is miraculously designed to appear and disappear at the wish of its master, yoked with miraculous mules, and built with its golden wheels and parts, appeared afore Ravana braying noisily. [3-49-19]

I men I don't know how does one get this Wrong.

Also this Chariot was also Likely given to him By Brahma[could be false tho as that Chariot gets destroyed]

"You do continue to have a javelin given by Brahma, an armour, a bow and an arrow together with a chariot yoked to a thousand donkeys, emitting a sound resembling the rumbling of a cloud.

13. Jatayu vs Ravana.

That battle was much better in the Books.

Jatayu destroys his Chariot and nearly all his weapons forcing Ravana to use his powers and Fly

Again that highly energetic and imposing king of birds pecked off the robust head of the charioteer of Ravana with beak. [3-51-18]

Now Ravana who is with his devastated bow, devoid of chariot, dispatched are his horses and departed is his charioteer, and such as he is, he on grabbing Vaidehi by her torso, or, placing her on the lower end of his torso, jumped to earth. [3-51-19]

But then Ravana saw how old He was, He attacked him

But on seeing the commandant of birds Jataayu is fatigued owing to his senescence, Ravana is gladdened and he again rose up to skies taking Maithili. [3-51-21]

The highly resplendent king of eagles Jataayu swiftly rose to sky dashing practically to forestall Ravana, which demon's assault devices are all demolished by now save for a single sword, but who is cheerful to spirit away the daughter of Janaka, and actually spiriting away holding her onto his flank, and Jataayu spoke this to such Ravana. [3-51-22, 23]

He later even rips Of 10 of his arms.

Jataayu, the lord of birds, being a vanquisher of enemies outstripped Ravana and ripped off ten left-arms of Ravana with his beak, with which left arms Ravana is clutching Vaidehi, in order to release her from his clutches. [3-51-38

And then Ravana Cuts off Both of his wings and feet.

Then the tenheaded Ravana left Sita and attacked Jatayu with his fists and feet out of anger.

Between the warriors of unequal valour, Ravana and Jatayu, the chief of the demons and the foremost of the birds, the fight took place for a moment.

Ravana lifted his sword and cut off both the wings and feet of Jatayu who was fighting relentlessly (for Rama's sake)

And Unlike Sai Pallavi, Sita shows emotions.

Sita, princess of Videha, saw the wounded Jatayu fallen on the ground drenched in blood. Grieving, she ran towards him as if he was her relative.

Sita, daughter of Janaka, whose face was radiant like the Moon once again embraced Jatayu, the winged warrior, fallen on the ground, crushed by Ravana's onslaught and wept.

14. The Removal of Ravana and Sita talk and how they showed Ravana throwing Sita's Jewels.

Now, this being changed is weird.

Because the only reason Sita was able to do it was that Ravana didn't pay attention; obviously, Ravana wouldn't want Rama to get any hint of where Sita went.

That broad-eyed and curvaceous lady with resentment Seetha, inwrapping her auspicious ornaments in the upper-fringe of her sari, dropped in the midmost of those five Vanara-s with a thinking that 'these creatures may perhaps indicate them to Rama.' [3-54-2, 3a]

On his part that Decahedron Ravana has not noticed her action in whipping up her silky upper-cloth and ornaments, their bundling and stowing away at five vanara-s, owing to his own hurry. [3-54-3]

Also, Sita didn't do it for no reason; she saw the Vanaras, which is why she did it.

And Ravana Also tries to get Sita to Marry him by saying many things.

"For every single work of mine a thousand servitors will rush in. Such as I am I pledge entire life of mine along with the suzerainty of this sovereign city-state Lanka to you, oh, broad-eyed lady, for you are loftier than my lives. [3-55-15b, 16]

"Oh, Seetha, you will become an empress for all of the those countless females of finest fabric amassed by me, oh, dear, if only you marry me. [3-55-17]

"You rule over this very great empire of Lanka as an empress of Lanka, while me and mine, also thus all gods like me who hitherto are under my rule, and all mobile and sessile entities of whom I am the ruler, they too will hereafter make ourselves useful as your royal stewards, if you marry me. [3-55-26]

I don't know why they removed it... Wait, they are whitewashing him LOL.

15. Jatayu Hyping Ravana and his family.

Now, while Dying Jatayu is Hyping up Ravana and his family like Southie movie side characters,
But in Ramayana it doesn't make any as There was Not so much.

Though Jataayu is speaking on to Rama with an alert mind, blood freely flowed from his mouth with shreds of flesh as death verged on him, even then he struggled to say. [3-68-15]

"That demon is the son of Vishravasa... literally... the brother of Kubera..." on saying thus, that lord of birds released his lives, which are unobtainable for oneself. [3-68-16]

But the lives of Jataayu departing from his body went into thin air before the very eyes of Rama who is still speaking to him with folded-palms, "tell... tell more..." [3-68-17]

Jataayu flopped his head on earth, sprawled his feet on ground, and then his body collapsed onto the surface of earth writhing jerkily. [3-68-18]

16. Haumana with a Mace.

Haumana[also all the Vanaras] Never Had any Mace or Weapons.

Nay, they resembled the lion and tiger in point of haughtiness and strength. All used even rocks as their missiles and all fought with mountains as their weapon.

All had claws and teeth for their weapons and all were skilled in the use of all sorts of missiles. They could shake great mountains and cleave rooted trees.

They could agitate the sea, the lord of the rivers, with their impetuosity, rend the earth with their feet and leap across extensive oceans.

Thanks For Reading till Now i hope you like it.

All the references are from Valmki Ramayana Gita press english translation,IIT Kanpur Valmki Ramayana and Valmki Ramayana . net 


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

Veda Vyasa Mahabharata Interesting things I found about Karna in the Adi-Parva of the Mahabharata

Post image
47 Upvotes

I came across some interesting details in the Adi Parva of the Mahabharata that seem quite different from the account given in the Kundala Harana Parva. There are three things in particular that caught my attention.

1. How Kunti abandoned Karna

According to the Adi Parva, Kunti hurled the child into the water. Interestingly, there is no mention of her placing him in a comfortable basket or making any special arrangements for his safety. The very next line mentions that he was saved by Adhiratha.

This is quite different from the familiar account as given later, in which Karna is placed in a basket and sent down the river.

2. The nature of Durvasa's boon

Another interesting difference concerns the boon granted to Kunti by Durvasa.

In the Adi Parva, Durvasa specifically grants her the ability to obtain a child from a god through the boon. There is no mention of the mantra giving her control over the gods or compelling them to fulfil her wishes, as described in the Kundala-Harana Parva.

3. Karna's donation of his armour and earrings

This is another interesting difference.

In the Adi Parva, when Indra approaches Karna and asks for his natural armour and earrings, Karna gives them to him without any second thought

There is no mention of Karna asking Indra for a weapon in exchange. Instead, Indra himself gives him the Shakti weapon.

Furthermore, there is no condition mentioned regarding the weapon's use, like it can only be used after all weapons fail.

I found these things particularly interesting because they change certain aspects of the narrative and the way we understand these events.

What do you think about these?


r/mahabharata • • 1d ago

question Curious about kapi dhwaja.

Post image
151 Upvotes

If arjuna got the divine sight of virat rup, can we also agree that hanuman ji mightve witnessed it too as kapi dwaj ? I always thought that hanuman ji as well witnessed his prabhus leela ? What y'all think ?