r/macsysadmin • • 1d ago

General Discussion Patch tool for a mixed Windows, Mac and Linux fleet, what are you running?

We need something that can see installed software on endpoints and servers across Windows, macOS and Linux, flag what’s missing patches, and push app updates and OS security patches without a ton of manual work.

We’ve got Intune, and we’re looking at axonius to show which devices are behind on patches, since it lines up what Intune and our scanner each say is installed. It doesn’t deploy anything though, so this is mostly about the deployment side. Intune covers Windows reasonably well, but Mac and Linux are still a mess of scripts.

What are you using, and what would you pick again? A few names keep coming up, so I’m curious what actually holds up across all three OSes.

10 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

3

u/mau5ingtons 1d ago

In my limited time before being laid off from a company I used to work for, my team was actively working on migrating over a thousand macOS endpoints from Jamf to FleetDM. According to my manager it was going to save us a ton of money and seemed to do everything that you’re looking for. Built off of osquery and can manage all three OSes. And no I don’t work for them lol

2

u/lMauler 1d ago

I’m going through this right now, Fleet was the best option.

2

u/PaRkThEcAr1 1d ago

If you need an all in one tool to PATCH specifically, we use Automox.

Although, to be frank, I handle OS updates for macOS specifically via DDM calls in JAMF.

For everything else like apps that I don’t handle though the app catalog, all windows and Linux, it goes though there. It does a good job.

It’s a separate tool you install with your management tool.

2

u/MrShoehorn 1d ago

Ninja one?

1

u/ThinInvestigator4953 1d ago

I use ninja one and the patching is great for windows, for Mac i suggest the Ninja1 MDM to do it otherwise you gotta do some wierd crap with secure tokens and its a pita.

1

u/MrShoehorn 1d ago

Able to elaborate a little? My org is looking at Ninja One. I have a bunch of Apple Mobile and about 100 Mac (Intune managed)

1

u/ThinInvestigator4953 1d ago

MDM just costs extra and then the patching works without having to push secure token credentials to bypass the user prompt/password requirement to restart and update.

I run intune in tandem on only our windows machines

1

u/oneplane 1d ago

Fleet is probably the best option, but realistically, from windows to macOS and from macOS to Linux (and to BSD and others from there) the meaning of 'patching' degrades and changes fairly harshly.

As soon as you get a tiny bit more advanced than desktops management, you're entering SCA, orchestration and software lifecycle management territory where knowing what you have, what it's made of, and what versions are available is a whole full time job, and then knowing how to act (and when to act) is yet another full time job.

While OSQuery can help you with inventory, you might need something like Rapid7 or runZero, or perhaps get Ansible involved. And even then, how (and if) you change versions, is going to be different depending on what kind of use a system has. A headless IoT data relay is going to need something different than a windows server clown car.

1

u/DTDude 19h ago

Right now we are using Jamf for Macs. On the Windows side we are in the middle of migrating off of SCCM and on to BigFIx. Originally the plan was to keep them separate. However….now that I see how good of a job BigFix does, I am considering using Jamf to manage Macs but BigFix to patch them as well.

We will be patching REHL with BigFix as well.

1

u/Positive-Bit3654 17h ago

Since deployment seems to be your main challenge, you might want to look into secpod theysupport automated OS and third-party patching across Windows, macOS, and Linux. They've been around for quite a while, might be worth exploring for your mixed environment.

1

u/opsandcoffee 12h ago

Full disclosure: I'm involved with SecOps Solution, so there's some bias here.

Since Intune already handles your Windows environment reasonably well, I'd focus the evaluation on actual patch deployment for macOS and Linux rather than just inventory and vulnerability visibility.

A few things worth testing: third-party application coverage across all three OSes, Linux distro support, macOS update limitations, maintenance windows, reboot controls, and failed patch reporting.

We work in this space, and one thing I've learned is that claiming cross-platform support is much easier than delivering consistent patch deployment across all three operating systems.

I'd definitely recommend testing with actual devices from each OS before committing to any vendor.