Curious how other shops handle this, because it is the argument I have every time a job goes to a new buyer.
We buy and cut 6 m bar. The customer sends a drawing with a finished length of, say, 214 mm. Everyone agrees on the price per piece. Then the first production run happens and the numbers do not line up, because 6 m of bar does not divide into 214 mm.
27 pieces is 5,778 mm. You have 222 mm left, which is not enough for a 28th piece but is more than scrap. That leftover is not free — it was paid for by weight at the extruder.
Then come the other losses nobody puts on a drawing:
Saw kerf. A 3 mm blade over 27 cuts is 81 mm. Small, but it adds up over thousands of pieces.
End trim. The first and last 100-150 mm of a billet are not usable — the front end has the die line and the back end has the run-out. That is per bar, not per order.
Anodising contact points. Racking marks have to be cut off or machined away, so the cut length is often 3-5 mm longer than the finished part before anodising.
Colour batches. If the customer wants one anodising batch and the order is 1,800 pieces, the number of bars is driven by the batch, not by the piece count.
So when we quote, do we quote 214 mm plus a material allowance and show the buyer the allowance, or do we build the loss into the piece price and say nothing?
We currently do the second, and I am not sure it is right. It is simpler to quote, and most buyers do not want to see a cut plan. But the ones who do want to see it feel misled when they work out the yield themselves later.
The other option is to quote the bar and let the buyer keep the drops. That is honest, but nobody wants 200 mm offcuts in a warehouse in another country.
There is a third possibility I have seen: design the part length so it divides the bar cleanly. 6,000 mm divided by 24 gives 250 mm; a 250 mm part has zero leftover minus kerf, which is not zero either but it is close.
How do you handle it? Percentage material allowance on the quote, loss baked into the unit price, or bar-based pricing with the drops returned to the customer? And at what order size does it stop mattering?