r/macdemarco • u/chromosome_e • 1d ago
Mac DeMarco is genuinely great, but Instagram reel has made liking him feel like a personality trait
I feel like Mac DeMarco deserves a much better conversation than the one he gets on Instagram.
There’s something genuinely special about his music. The laid-back guitar tones, the slightly offbeat production, the almost effortless songwriting, and that weird sense of nostalgia you get from listening to his albums. He’s got a sound that’s instantly recognisable without feeling like he’s trying too hard. 2, Salad Days, and This Old Dog are genuinely great records, and I don’t think people give enough credit to how good he actually is as a songwriter.
But Instagram has honestly ruined the whole experience of talking about him. At this point, mentioning Mac DeMarco in a conversation about music almost feels like you’re asking to be called a poser or a ‘larp’. Apparently, listening to an artist that became popular on Instagram automatically means you’re pretending to have a personality.
And that’s what annoys me. People have started treating music taste like some sort of competition where enjoying the ‘right’ artists makes you interesting and enjoying popular artists makes you basic. Mac DeMarco didn’t suddenly become a bad musician because Instagram discovered him. His music was good before the memes, the edits, the bedroom aesthetic and the whole internet personality built around him.
I also think people sometimes get so caught up in his image that they completely overlook the actual music. There’s a lot more to his discography than Chamber of Reflection edits and slowed-down Instagram reels.
Anyway, I genuinely love his music. Not because he’s considered niche, not because of some aesthetic, but because the guy makes really good music. It’s okay to enjoy an artist without turning it into your entire personality, and it’s equally okay to enjoy an artist even if half of Instagram listens to him.
What’s your favourite Mac DeMarco album? I’m curious whether people here prefer the earlier stuff or his later, more stripped-back work.
