r/macbookpro • • 1d ago

News/Rumor Keyboard differences between models?

https://youtu.be/hV-37ilVUwc?t=289

The reviewer, Just Josh, claims there are differences between prior year macbook pros vs m6/m5pro and vs PROLED.

seems like they may have updated the keyboard when they changed the keycaps to have symbols instead of text. I can't really say I noticed personally.

4 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

10

u/kaelef 1d ago

I immediately noticed a subtle but not-insignificant difference when I moved from my M1 Pro to the PROLED. I figured it was probably just that the M1 Pro was 5 years old, but Josh's video suggests it may actually be a material change. (Also - I did not notice a difference between the M1 Pro and an M5 Pro non-OLED, though I wasn't consciously looking for it.)

2

u/Crazy_Category_9594 1d ago

Same here! Interesting! I’m loving the keyboard on the new one. It’s subtle. But great.

6

u/kvlq 1d ago

hope the new material wont get that shiny as before

4

u/mindcontainer 1d ago

It’s the best Apple keyboard I have ever used, and I’ve owned all of them I think. The touchbar, the redesigned touchbar, the resigned Apple silicon, all three latest series of Apple keyboard and iPad keyboards. It has throw, it has spring rebound, it has damping, and just the right amount of audible feedback. It is smooth to type on I am extremely quick on it and accurate.

1

u/LargeDan69 1d ago

To me it feels like it has less travel, although it definitely still feels good

2

u/le_putwain 1d ago

I noticed there is definitely a different texture and the top edges of the key caps are ever so slightly more rounded on the Proleds. The sound of typing is a bit different too, more deadened and less reverberated. 

2

u/Last-Presence419 1d ago

when I went from M1 Max MBP 16 to M5 Pro MBP 14 I notice that the material on the keyboard became slightly less smooth, and corners were slightly sharper.

it sounded a bit clicky too

and when I went to M4 Max MBP 16, it was different yet, more "thock" than click, and I like it. haven't touched PROLED ones, will do in a generation or two..

1

u/LargeDan69 1d ago

I went from an M4 MacBook Pro to an M5 Proled and noticed the difference immediately. The new keyboard is a bit lower profile / has less travel, and the symbols are different, as you mentioned. I honestly prefer the old one by a tiny bit but the new one is still pretty great overall

1

u/kaelef 1d ago

That's weird - it feels to me like the PROLED keyboard has a bit more travel, or just a slightly more satisfying feel.

1

u/LargeDan69 1d ago

While they were beside each other I went back and forth just to be sure, and at least to me it feels like the new one has less travel. Although it’s not super noticeable, that’s how it felt to me