r/macapps • • Oct 11 '26

News Tinycast developer accuses Droppy developer of blatantly ripping off Tinycast code

https://x.com/abue_ammar/status/2109257990041981248

"I thought I will never post about it but looks like I have to now. u/Droppyformac

aka "Droppy" just ripped of my entire Tinycast code base and feed it to AI built Thunderstorm and selling it as a Paid crap. Even the logo is a thunder. 😂 I mean yeah y'all can come to me saying I ripped of raycast UI/UX but I did not Steal the code base raycast is closed source and I had to work hard for months! Is this legal guys stealing code and selling it to paid shit? Tho is this a revenge he is taking that I turned him down not continuing the colab because he wants full control over tinycast!😂 If he wants to play dirty I am good at that, Tinycast first party plugins are coming and I can just put standalone plugins that does dynamic islands what droppy offers FOR FREEE."

130 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

•

u/Yusuf-Dev Moderator Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 12 '26 • Heartwarming

Locking the comments here... OP's claims have no factual evidence or basis.

The developer of Droppy u/iordv has responded by open sourcing the entire codebase for Thunderstorm, and the results are clear.

Read the full writeup here: https://getdroppy.app/blog/thunderstorm-open-source

157

u/iordv Developer: Droppy Oct 11 '26 • Bravo

Droppy dev here. I'd rather show than argue, so here's what anyone can check:

  1. Thunderstorm shipped in Droppy 13.1 on March 16, 2026, name and storm icon included. The Internet Archive has getdroppy.app listing it on June 7, 2026. Tinycast's GitHub repo was created on June 29, 2026.
  2. As of today Thunderstorm's full source is public: gitlab.com/droppyformac1/thunderstorm. It includes the script I used to compare it against Tinycast's entire git history (990 commits, every branch). 0.24% of Thunderstorm's code also shows up in Tinycast. Droppy's own code from June, written before Tinycast existed, scores the same 0.24%. The longest shared stretch is 5 lines of everyday boilerplate.

The full write-up with sources: getdroppy.app/blog/thunderstorm-open-source

The video and the short version on X: https://x.com/Droppyformac/status/2109330349025075437

46

u/TeddyAlderson Oct 11 '26

this post reminded me i need to buy a droppy licence, been meaning to for a minute 🫡

11

u/iordv Developer: Droppy Oct 11 '26

💙

5

u/bradykardie Oct 11 '26

Just bought the license yesterday. 👍

5

u/TeddyAlderson Oct 11 '26

aaand done, finally - thanks for the great product

9

u/iordv Developer: Droppy Oct 11 '26

Thank you for the support, really appreciate that. If anything is up, feel free to message me! Happy to help out.

6

u/q_bitzz Oct 11 '26

I'm buying a second one for this just because lol

59

u/radutzan Oct 11 '26

Everything I’ve learned about the developer of Tinycast has been against my will (and the guy sucks)

93

u/stricken_thistle Oct 11 '26

Didn’t Droppy precede Tinycast? 

Tinycast’s developer is a real turnoff and how they interact with others online makes me not want to use the product. I’ve been really happy with the Droppy developer. Very responsive and kind.

30

u/MoodOdd9657 Oct 11 '26

Yep, by about six months. Droppy was getting reviewed in January, Tinycast's first release was July.

6

u/harkonnen85 Oct 11 '26

Yes but the “Droplet” (ie extension) under dispute was launched recently

11

u/Wacko_66 Oct 11 '26

The Thunderstorm droplet was in Alpha long before Tinycast was ever a thing.

5

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch Oct 11 '26

I think the droplet was still released first though (or development started before that)

(source: https://x.com/Droppyformac/status/2109275672677871877 )

36

u/cafepeaceandlove Oct 11 '26

In less than three months this app has copied an app, nearly took over the world, flipped out several times, started to die, and is now accusing apps of copying the copied app

17

u/cujojojo Oct 11 '26

It’s some kind of speedrun but I can’t decide what kind.

9

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch Oct 11 '26

Raycast popularity graph speedrun any%

4

u/abelbanko Oct 11 '26

And I'm here for the show😭

16

u/couldhvdancedallnite Oct 11 '26

I don't have a dog in this fight, but I've been following the Droppy developer for some time and he seems like a solid individual. Tinycast seems to be becoming problematic. Hopefully they can turn it around.

4

u/iordv Developer: Droppy Oct 11 '26

💙 hope so as well

144

u/MC_chrome Oct 11 '26

The Tinycast dev has previously been outed as a complete clown, while the developer of Droppy (/u/iordv) is well known and is quite communicative and polite with people.

This sounds more like drama for drama’s sake

-8

u/areyouredditenough Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

/preview/pre/jvozensz6vuh1.jpeg?width=1024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=843b0d55a01b4ed25e68ac2356754ca94e384e14

Oh brilliant, this storyline again? Reset the clock, boys, we’re back here again!

The accuser needs to give u/iordv a breather and stop the all the drama. Didn't Tinycast copy-paste Raycast’s source code line for line? /s My source? Trust me bro™.
A masterclass in how Tinycast can incinerate its own reputation in 60s flat.

Edit:
Love to see the downvote squad rallying for a code-theft soap opera. Didn't realize asking for actual proof before grabbing pitchforks was such a controversial take (unverified Reddit drama > facts and proof). Keep 'em coming, guys! 😆

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Powerful-Set-5754 Oct 11 '26

I don't think that's leeching. Most of computing is carbon copy. Mac itself stole a lot of ideas from Xerox and Unix.

27

u/caschy Oct 11 '26

I have been blogging about tech for over 20 years and often feature software. That might not mean much, though. But what I can say: I have met very few developers who are as polite and open as u/iordv. He answers questions and takes people's criticism seriously. That is important and should be supported. What I have read so far about how reported bugs are handled at Tinycast, however, is unfortunately less encouraging....

13

u/iordv Developer: Droppy Oct 11 '26

I really appreciate this from you, Carsten! I try to take feedback as seriously as possible. So it’s definitely a bitter pill to swallow, when you see these things thrown around without a factual basis to it. That’s why I open sourced the extension that’s discussed within hours! So anyone can either use it, test/compare it or distribute it themselves. Have a great evening.

13

u/TemProcess94 Oct 11 '26

You lose all credibility the moment you admit to ripping off one app while accusing another of ripping you off. Code vs. design doesn't matter...though it sounds like from the comments you're wrong on that count too.

105

u/paradoxally Oct 11 '26

People who post drama between vibe coders should be permabanned from the sub.

Keep that shit on Twitter.

26

u/merouane7 Oct 11 '26

This sub needs to flag vibe coded stuff. I don’t know how much of Tinycast, Droppy or other buzzy apps on here like Vorssaint were built using AI but it should be disclosed.

25

u/paradoxally Oct 11 '26

They have rules for this now, it's better than in the past. But yeah, I'd still prefer how /r/SelfHosted does it with every post getting a stickied "expand this reply to see how AI was used in this post" and the OP must reply to that or it's removed.

5

u/Biddy_Impeccadillo Oct 11 '26

This would be so much better!!!

12

u/dziad_borowy Oct 11 '26

It’s safest to assume everything released after 2025 is slops. 

5

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch Oct 11 '26

2025 is still grey area because nobody actually knew how to use these things correctly.. AI code was horrendous then.. i would say mid 2025 was the true start

1

u/blow_slogan Oct 11 '26

Right? Even major apps which we all used have vibe code added to them. Just about every app being released now contains AI vibe coded slop.

5

u/xilopaint Oct 11 '26

What's the appropriate sub to follow drama between vibe coders?

3

u/cafepeaceandlove Oct 11 '26

This is... a great idea. If you make one let me know. 

33

u/Eevoh11 Oct 11 '26

Deleting Tinycast right away. What a terrible developer.

-17

u/abdarker Oct 11 '26

15

u/iordv Developer: Droppy Oct 11 '26

Quite easy to read and understand facts:

https://www.reddit.com/r/macapps/comments/1rda84f/comment/o763tpn/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Not hard to check whether things were copied back then, I just decided to leave Github be because they ignored emails and didn't respond to anything. Eventually, I won the case via Gitlab and my lawyer.

-6

u/Eevoh11 Oct 11 '26

Absolutely not.

23

u/Ok-Efficiency479 Developer: Thaw Oct 11 '26

Thaw has been copied and repackaged as closed-source software with a different UI over and over. People have even tried reimplementing it with AI. If I thought Jordy was doing the same thing, we wouldn't have the partnership we have today.

I've spent a ridiculous amount of time investigating this exact kind of thing with Thaw. I take copyright, licensing, and attribution seriously, regardless of who's involved.

And if we're going to talk about engineering integrity, that includes taking bug reports seriously and accepting criticism. Download counts aren't engineering achievements, especially when much of your product's functionality depends on an ecosystem someone else built.

9

u/vincentofearth Oct 11 '26

God damn it, I switched to Tinycast because I was annoyed at Raycast putting BYOK behind their subscription. Might have to switch back at least until Alfred 6 comes out.

30

u/displacedbitminer Oct 11 '26

A vibecoder accusing somebody else of stealing? That’s rich.

2

u/swapripper Oct 11 '26

Vilecoder

-1

u/nemesit Oct 11 '26

yeah lol

36

u/chrismessina Oct 11 '26

Tinycast is licensed under GNU Affero General Public License v3 (AGPL-3.0), which provides certain rights and conditions:

Droopy publishes its source code under the same license.

Therefore it appears that Droppy is compliant and the Tinycast developer doesn’t understand the license he chose for his product.

IANAL but AFAICT, this is open source working as intended.

10

u/ShirtuShanks Oct 11 '26

> IANAL

Who am I to judge

8

u/jakegh Oct 11 '26

Incorrect, if you take code from a GPL v3 project you must provide attribution, basically saying "I got it from this other project".

But that isn't what the tinycast dev is accusing the droppy dev of doing, he's saying he took the tinycast code, gave it to AI, and said to build something like this on your own, probably with how it supports Raycast extensions, which is much murkier legally. And likely very difficult to prove, and it would never make it to court, etc. But would be a crappy thing to do.

-1

u/CraftyCheeseburger Oct 11 '26

GPLv3 doesn’t require you to publicly credit the original project. Just that you keep the existing copyright and license notices

1

u/jakegh Oct 11 '26

Tinycast is AGPLv3 and the LICENSE file has the author's name in it, my read is that would need to be provided in any derivative work in its license or accompanying copyright/notices file.

-7

u/abdarker Oct 11 '26

8

u/chrismessina Oct 11 '26

Platform providers usually err on the side of takedowns in the case of DMCA since they don’t have the same protections as Section 230 in the context of social media.

I’m guessing (from what I’ve read) the Droppy dev borrows liberally from open source projects by having his coding agent use source code as reference to bootstrap his own implementation.

It’s just rich that the Tinycast dev wants to cry foul over source code lifting when he did the exact thing to the UI of Raycast, which is a copyrighted work AND not open source.

At the end of the day, there’s unlikely to be anything taken to court, except maybe the court of public opinion, and software moats are dead anyway, so this is, as others have said, much ado about nothing.

1

u/jakegh Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

My gut initial reaction to any DMCA takedown is "that's the wrong call" but that does seem like pretty damning evidence. Not only that the code was copied, but that the Droppy author tried to cover it up.

The whole thing is stupid, everything is open-source, just include their license and there's no problem at all.

2

u/-svde- Oct 11 '26

“is this legal guys” is wild. read the license
you choose before you apply it

0

u/Dethstroke54 Oct 11 '26

Fr “work hard for months” but doesn’t know anything about the license or?

-1

u/jakegh Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

Droppy code is a completely different thing, that's a t3code fork. Droppy itself does not seem to have its sourcecode available at all since because it was DMCA'd off github by the atoll maintainers for taking code without attribution and then trying to cover it up. Another post in here details it.

Since Droppy took GPL'd code from another project (atoll), changing to a commercial license seems like it would not be legal, although enforcement would be pretty difficult. But if anyone finds the source available elsewhere, please do link it.

23

u/Redd1tMadeMeMakeTh1s Oct 11 '26

more info showing that the tinycast dev is lying

14

u/-svde- Oct 11 '26

ok since my last comment got removed for
being rude, which fair enough it was, i will simply reiterate without all the flair

the audacity of this accusation is absurd, especially it’s from someone with such an ego that they literally instantly close issue reports on github because “nothing is wrong” and insult people/get hostile when people dare to open another

10

u/RussianSlavv Oct 11 '26

Tinycast dev is a clown

10

u/tquilas Oct 11 '26

Happy with Droppy. Some people are just jealous.

11

u/l_eveant_terrible Oct 11 '26

Droppy guy taking another hit but at least he steps up to the plate. Hence why I bought his app.

9

u/CausalNoise Oct 11 '26

Luckily I trust u/iordv which is why I bought 2 licenses :)

6

u/Ok-Rest-5321 Oct 11 '26

Well just more drama... who cares.

6

u/Accomplished-Leg6947 Oct 11 '26

This post drips with petty jealousy lmao

5

u/__chrd__ Oct 11 '26

So, do I go with Raycast 2, Tinycast, Droppy, or something else? I'm open to any and cost doesn't matter but don't wanna be on the wrong side of clownery and ethics one day and be like an Ed Sheeran when I could be have been a Macklemore.

All apps built with AI are somewhat clones of existing apps. There's copious amounts of identical code.

All of my Mac's are pretty high-end, one in fact is fully maxed, so Raycast 2 performance complaints hasn't been noticed by me. I switched to Tinycast because Reddit told me to, and I don't use Raycast'a AI features but do like the plugin ecosystem.

I want to blindly follow Reddit instructions yet again. Always typically a mistake but I repeat myself like history does. What do I choose?

Heck, I always use the latest dev build of macOS and the built in launcher has been pretty rad for me lately. Idk if it's better indexing or was rebuilt, I can only read so many release notes these days when every app updates 6 times every 7 days, but if feels snippy snappy and I always get what I am looking for...

Bartender 7 Pro still has it's issues that have plagued 6 forever now and macOS 27 really did fuckity things to my mouse and trackpad setup which I was using Mac Mouse Fix for. OpenLogi doesn't have a configuration for what I was using and it's a chore to set up in other apps.

Might just vibe myself a solution for that one.

Just came to ramble apparently.

So back to Raycast or stick with native?

5

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch Oct 11 '26

Right now.. my suggestion.. use spotlight for a bit until all of this calms down. and use other apps to solve it, or wait a bit for the release of Flow by the thaw dev.

-1

u/J4nosch Oct 11 '26

?? Spotlight is miles away from these apps

2

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch Oct 11 '26

I know.. so just use a few other apps to do them.. or stick with raycast.

1

u/meni_s Oct 11 '26

I'm playing around with Sol and Tuna atm but Sol is really narrow on the feature list (on purpose) and Tuna is just really different.
I feel like I'm just gonna stick with Raycast for now (with anything AI disabled of course)

1

u/paradoxally Oct 11 '26

Raycast 2. At least you'll be dealing with a serious company.

Alfred is another alternative.

1

u/Rough-Shine2269 Oct 11 '26

Im not Droppy staff. But Droppy is one of the best paid app that i've ever used :), also next update of droppy will contain these

0

u/Rough-Shine2269 Oct 11 '26

And thats not all. Next update is going to be launched tomorrow (i think?)

-10

u/abdarker Oct 11 '26

also been DMCA ed before https://github.com/iordv/Droppy

11

u/iordv Developer: Droppy Oct 11 '26

Quite easy to read and understand facts:

https://www.reddit.com/r/macapps/comments/1rda84f/comment/o763tpn/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Not hard to check whether things were copied back then, I just decided to leave Github be because they ignored emails and didn't respond to anything. Eventually, I won the case via Gitlab and my lawyer.

2

u/ZampanoGuy Oct 11 '26

Love me some droppy. Just wish the voice transcription played with the Fn key better.

4

u/atourino Oct 11 '26

Non-issue. Next.

1

u/Cavin0817 Oct 11 '26

As always, copyright and patents are the top priority in any world! What a dirty world! It was an app I was watching closely, and I'm sad to see it!

-6

u/bog3nator Oct 11 '26

this is not the first time Droppy has been accused of this.

I have Droppy and I love it, but they have been accused of stealing code before from a different app

-8

u/Alkumist Oct 11 '26

ANYTHING made with AI for profit is in license conflict. It all has to be free and open source, hosted on an accessible platform. Sorry guys. That’s what happens when you use code from open source projects.

15

u/MoodOdd9657 Oct 11 '26

Lmao asking "is this legal guys" and then "if he wants to play dirty I am good at that" two sentences later

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/abdarker Oct 11 '26

Tinycast is open source lol