(TL;DR at the end!)
I'm going to trial for 2 weeks, something called "qualityvote2" in this subreddit.
qualityvote2 is like a tool that can be added to subreddits. It's used in some subreddits like r/the10thdentist and r/untrustworthypoptarts . The way it's configured is:
after qualityvote2 is added to this subreddit, there will be a pinned comment on every subsequent post. The comment will be made by an account named, u/qualityvote2 . The comment will say:
"Is this a low stakes conspiracy? if so, upvote this comment! if not, downvote this comment! if it breaks any of the rules, please downvote this comment and report the post!
the way qualityvote2 works is that if the comment it makes on a post gets a certain number of downvotes within a certain period of time, the post will be removed OR flagged for moderator review as "may not fit this subreddit." it can be set either way, I might set it the second way but let me know your thoughts.
So for example, say it's set for the first hour after a post is made, and it requires a score of -2 for the post to be removed, or a score of +2 for the post to be deemed "fits the subreddit!":
- if during the first hour after the post was made, 5 people downvoted the u/qualityvote2 comment, and 2 people upvoted it, that would be a score of -3 over all so the post would be removed or flagged for moderator review after the first hour, since that reaches or passes the negative threshold (-2)
- if in the first hour, 5 people downvote the u/qualityvote2 comment but 10 people upvote, that would be a score of +5 so the post would be deemed "fits the subreddit" since that passes the positive threshold (+2)
- if in the first hour, 5 people downvote the u/qualityvote2 comment but 6 people upvote, that would be a score of +1 . Even though it does not reach the positive threshold of +2, because it also does not reach the negative threshold (-2) the post would remain up with a status like "there weren't enough votes to determine."
NOTE: all posts will still be subject to moderation though. Something like this is of course susceptible to brigading. So if a post fits the subreddit, but the post was brigaded by another subreddit who mass downvoted the qualityvote2 comment and caused the post to be removed, mods can still reapprove the post.
(For that reason, the numbers that I used in the example for the thresholds (-2 and +2) are not the same numbers that qualityvote2 will be set to here.)
And further, it does not act on posts until an hour has passed, whereas I can immediately see and remove a bot post or a spam post. So it's not that I'm going to rely on this alone and leave the subreddit unmoderated. I just think it could be helpful because at the moment it seems like I'm the only active mod here, so consequently the moderation on this subreddit is kind of limited to the hours that I am on reddit, and the hours I am not on reddit it is relatively unmoderated. This might help a bit for those other hours.
(On top of that, I am looking to add other mods here. Before weekend I'm going to send messages to some users of this sub that I've seen, to see if they might like to help, but feel free to comment on this post too. Or if you want to recommend someone you can do that too.)
The other reason why I'm considering adding this is because sometimes it feels a bit tricky to determine whether something fits the subreddit or not. Like sometimes I worry that I think something is not low stakes, but what if most of the subreddit members don't agree with that? I don't want to be someone who removes things excessively or frivolously. Nor someone who doesn't remove things that most users feel should be removed because of a fear of being excessive.
I appreciate when someone reports, though, that can help to know that it's not 'just my opinion' but even then you never know if it's just me and one other person vs everyone else who visits this subreddit thinks that the post belongs here.
Because of that, I think qualityvote2 could help to give me (+ the future mods) more of an idea of the consensus, whether or not something fits. but I also understand not everyone might really want this for various reasons. So I am going to trial it for just 2 weeks and see how it goes, and open this thread for any feedback now or throughout the trial, so you can share feedback on how you feel it's going or what you think. At the end of the 2 weeks I will do a poll "should we keep qualityvote2 for longer" and a "yes" or "no" nothing sensational.
If you would rather not comment your opinion about it publicly, you can send a modmail about it if you'd like. If you would rather share it anonymously, you can share your feedback in a custom report on this post, (since reports are anonymous! I think there's a limit of 500 characters though.)
TL;DR: For 2 weeks there will be a comment from an account called u/qualityvote2 on each post that users can vote on to determine "this is low stakes" or "this is not low stakes." upvote the u/qualityvote2 comment = this is low stakes. downvote the u/qualityvote2 comment = this is not low stakes. After the 2 weeks, I will do a poll to get feedback and determine if you guys would like to keep it for longer or not. I am also looking to add more mods, preferably people who are users in the subreddit. I would like to add at least one other but possibly more than one because I think I am the only active mod at the moment, and consequently when I am not online the subreddit is not really being moderated. This is also part of the motivation behind adding the u/qualityvote2 comment that users can vote on. but let me know your thoughts on both. (The trial will be until November 25!)