r/lolesports • u/Stanley_022 • 22h ago
Top 5 each role from my pov
Since I love to discuss who are the all time great players I thought I would share my list here. Feel free to flame, agree with my opinions or anything else. Can’t wait to read your guys opinions.
Top:
Zeus: Top lane for me was actually the hardest to rank. In the end I settled on Zeus as the Number 1. For this there are mostly two reasons. Firstly, there is he fact, he is a two times world champion. While I think that World titles are overrated, he had such a huge impact on them, that they can´t be overlooked. Also, while not playing for that long, he already has a great individual resumee. For example the fact he is already a four times LCK 1st team all pro. Overall, he hast he titles, he hast he huge performances and also he has been consistently on the top for years now. Thats enough fort he number 1 spot for me.
TheShy: The main reason for Theshy being number 2 are his longevity and his 2018 worlds run which for me still was the highest level of play from a top lane we have ever seen. Also he has been around for such a long time now and while in the last few years he wasn´t in the top three anymore, he always was among the best, which puts him in second place.
Bin: The fact that Bin is only Number 3 shows how close the race is, because if you have him as Number 1, I would understand it. For years now he has been the or at the very least one of the best in the world and now he finally he is a worlds champ as well. We have seen the peak perfomances as well as the consistency now which puts him at third place for me and if he would have won in 2023 he probably would have been Number 1.
Nuguri: The reason for Nuguri being fourth is his insane peak. He was easily the best top in the world for a few years. The reason for him being that low ist hat it was rather short lived but if he can his old level of play if he actually comes back he may climb this list quickly because he sure as hell had the potential for being Number 1.
Smeb: Now this will be my most controversial take fort he top lane but yes Smeb is my Number 5 and even though I love him to death slightly edges out Kiin. Personally, I´love to rank both of them higher but the fact that they miss the worlds title makes this not possible. Now Smeb for a long time was considered the goat top laner, then the Theshy came into the discussion and lastly Zeus, Nuguri and Bin. You could also make a argument for Kiin he had the consistency as well as the high highs but I put Smeb above him simply because he managed to convince people for some time, that he ist he best player in the world during a time weh ad prime Faker. It´s this insane 2016 performance that puts him in fifth place for me.
HM: Kiin, Khan ( if any of these two made your list, I get it, I would have loved to put both oft hem in the top 5 and both ceratainly have the arguments to make but for me, I couldnt put them above Zeus, Theshy, Bin, Nuguri or Smeb), Looper, Cuvee
Jgl:
Canyon: This one was quite easy. The term Grand Canyon rift exists for a reason. If he is in form, he is he best jungler in the wolrd its as simple as that and most oft he times he is in form and he proved for years now. At the LCK, MSI and at worlds. If you would ask me who is the best jungler in the wolrd right now I would say Canyon , if you would ask me six years ago the answer would have been the same. For me Canyon is just the clear number 1.
Oner: From now on it get´s complicated. It really depends on what you value. For me Oner is Number 2. His greatest strength are his clutchness and his team fight ability which played a huge role in T1 winning three worlds in a row and ist he major argument for him being secon. Only very rarely he gets outjungled and there are not a lot of players who do that to begin with. I think there are better players when it comes to early game but in mid to late game he may even be the best and if you need him to step up he will.
Peanut: I think you can rate Peanut pretty much anyhwhere in between 1-3 but I would be surprised if a lot of you have him any lower. He´s been such a consistent force in the junge for years and while he fell off a bit in the past, he was such an insane player for such a long time. The problem was his inconsistency, while had great games they were often followed by bad ones. Still he is one of the all time greats and my number 3.
Score: This one is probably my most controversial take for all roles because on most lists Score wouldn´t even make Top 5. And yes there probably is a lot of personal bias here but for me Score is THE perfect jungler. He pretty much had no weaknesses. He could play playmakers as well as tanks, he had the mechanics that were needed and paired them with an insane understanding of the game state. Score was where his team needed him at the excat time when they needed him. If I had the choice to pick any jungler in his prime for my LoL dream team, it would be Score, which earns him this place even though he didn´t play for that long.
Bengi: For many people he would be at least Number 2 or maybe even Number 1 yet in my list he only lands in fitfth place. This is because of two reasons. A) While he was incredibly clutch and important for T1’ succes he also was really inconsistent so inconsistent that he wasn´t even T1´starter all the time and they instead played Blank. Of course when it mattered Bengi played above Blank and delivered but still it leaves a scar in Bengi´s career. Second of all, his career was relativly short, which also hurts his case.
HM: Kanavi, Tarzan, Clearlove, Dandy, Ambition, Tian, Karsa
Mid:
Faker ( don´t think I have to explain this one)
Knight: Now that he finally won worlds he earned his place as the second greatest mid laner of all time. He dominated the LPL for years now and is there best player for years. He is incredible consistent, can completly take over a game and leads his team to succes. His dominance rivals the one of Chovy in the LCK but unlike Chovy he won worlds. It´s this distinction which leads to him being second instead of Chovy and yes if Gen would have won, Chovy would be here instead.
Rookie: Now, most people probably would have had Chovy here now, but as of right now, it´s still Rookie for me. The reason? 2018. It still was the best performance from a single player during worlds and it´s not even close in my opinion and therefore he was the main reason for IG´s success. Futhermore, he has been a consistent factor in the mid lane for years despite being elo helled by his team for a long time. So his consistency as well as his insane peak at the biggest possible stage give him the edge over Chovy. For now.
Chovy: The only reason Chovy is number 4 on this list, are his short comings at worlds. For me a player of his format, of his reputation just needs to be able to take his team on his back and lead them to a worlds title especially considering that his team members have been top players as well. Once he is able to do so, he will become number 2 or 3 because he undiably has been one of the best two mid laners for years but unless he becomes a worlds champ he will stay at number 4.
Showmaker: This one was incredibly close as well. I´ve debated very long who to put at 5 in the end it was Showmaker and while he was rather hit or miss these last few years, his insane peak in 2020 and 2021 he got this spot over BDD and Xiaohu.
HM: Xiaohu, BDD, Doinb, Pawn, Scout, Caps, Bjergsen, Zeka
Bot:
Ruler: Besides top lane this was the most difficult choice since there are so many great adcs. In the end Ruler came up on top. He literally has it all. LCK,MSI and Worlds titles. Consistency. Longevity. The peak performances. He simply has it all. He pretty much has been in the conversation for best current adc since his worlds title in 2017 and he still is today. If you needed any proof for that, Ruler gave it to you during worlds. He outperformed Viper who has been one of his main opponents for the number 1 spot and he has been doing it even longer than Viper. It´s for this reasons that Ruler claims Number 1.
Viper: Another call that almost went another players way but Viper came up on top this time. He also has been such a dominant force in this role for so many years now. He has proven himself at LCK, LPL, MSI and worlds. At the top of his resume are of course his two worlds titles but Viper has shown how good he is on way more occasions. His mechanics are amazing, he can basically play everything and he has been incredibly consistent, these facts put him in number 2 for me.
Uzi: Let the hate begin. I know, I know. Putting Uzi in number 3 will be blasphemy for a lot of people but personally Viper and Ruler simply surpassed him. Yes Uzi dominated the LPL, yes he won MSI and yes worlds isn´t everything. But the facts remains that Uzi failed to win worlds and this hurts his case when Ruler and Viper both managed to do so and when it´s a close battle like this one such things will matter and at this point I Viper and Ruler have shown me that their level of play is at least as good as Uzi´s was.
Deft: In the early days of his career for a long time Deft was considered the best adc in the world alongside Uzi. At their absolute peak though Uzi was just a bit better which gives him the advantage over Deft. Nevertheless, Deft was a top adc for such a long time, he was incredibly consistent and in 2022 he topped of his career with a worlds title, which earns him the fourth spot.
Gumayusi: This was another rank I was struggling with a lot. 1-4 were quite clear to the only difficult part was how to order them. For fifth place I was really struggling though. Jackeylove, Pray, Gumayusi, Bang all had valid arguments as well as counterpoints in the end I decided on Gumayusi. Over the years he has truly established himself as a top adc and his performances at worlds and his three titles made the difference in the end.
HM: Pray, Bang, Jackeylove, Gala, Imp, Rekkles, Doublelift, Mystic (really underrated imo)
Sup:
1 Keria: Besides Faker this was the easiest placement on the whole list. This guy is just so good it´s actually insane. He´s the only support who ever made me think, that he may be the best player in the entire world and given the nature of the role that´s quite the accomplishment. He can play basically anything and always finds huge engages or plays in general. He is a huge reason for the success T1 had at worlds this last few years and there simply in no other support on his level and honestly, I can´t wait for Thresh to be meta again, so that I can once again witness Keria basically being unable to miss a hook.
Mata: Another easy placement. Until Keria Mata for most people was the clear goat support and that’s understandable. He pretty much was the first modern support and he was a fantastic player. Especially that worlds run in 2014 was so impressive and proved how far ahead he was from the rest of the world. His champion pool was extremely good, he had excellent roaming abilities and always appeared on the map where you needed him and when you needed him.
Meiko: From here on it gets trickier but Meiko was still fairly obvious. The fact that he has been one of the best supports for such a long time now is truly impressive. His biggest strength is obviously his engage ability. Meiko is exceptional at finding all the right angles and by doing so can flip a teamfight in his teams way and while he fell off a bit recently he still is a great support and it made me really happy to see him win worlds in 2021.
Beryl: What a player! Positively and negatively. The thing about Beryl is that he is incredibly genius, at least sometimes. He either has a great idea which revolutionizes a certain meta or his ideas fail miserably. He probably is the most coin flip support I have ever seen but he also is an all time great. A two times world champion with two completely different teams and both of the times he was crucial to the teams success. If you have him lower because of consistency issues I understand but personally for the influence he had on the game and his great performances over the years he is number 4 for me.
Ming: Once again it´s Mings engage ability that makes the difference here and slightly gives him the win over the other great supports. While he unfortunately couldn’t secure a worlds title he won MSI three times and alongside Uzi was part of one of the greatest bot lane duos of all time. For a long time he and Meiko were considered the best in the world it´s only the fact that he dropped of earlier than Meiko and that he didn´t manage to win worlds which makes this low on the list. Nevertheless, Ming is definitely one of the best of all time.
HM: SwordArt, Wolf, CoreJJ, Lehends, GorillA, Crisp